10 Star Trek: The Original Series Episodes That Were Almost Made
What could have been for the Original Star Trek...
When Star Trek finished its original run on NBC on June 3, 1969, there had been seventy-nine episodes ("and thirty good ones," at least according to Philip J. Fry). But not every story conceived for the show made its way to the screen — often for good reason.
As with all art, there is inevitably a good deal of intrigue for fans in what could have been. And from the scrap-heap of partially developed stories and episode concepts emerge a pack of interesting behind-the-scenes stories of the episodes that didn't come to be and why they were scrapped...
10. “Shol”
Darlene Hartman was a New Orleans-based writer who got her foot in the door on Star Trek by submitting four spec scripts, the last of which was called "Shun-Daki.” Story editor D.C. Fontana felt that script, which featured Spock in a ritual duel and references to his father, infringed upon "Amok Time" and "Journey to Babel."
Furthermore, she believed it would take a page one rewrite (i.e. a complete rewrite from beginning to end) to be shootable. Associate producer Bob Justman had reservations, too, writing, "We have a lot of talk - we don't have enough physical conflict, or peril."
Nonetheless, Gene Roddenberry saw something in Hartman, telling producer Gene L. Coon, “I'm of the opinion that she is one of these rare examples of unsolicited manuscript writers who is worth some time and attention.” He invited her to pitch the show, and she submitted five story premises. Those were rejected, too, but Roddenberry stuck with Hartman, finally writing a story “springboard” with Gene Coon for her to turn into an outline.
As Hartman’s outline begins, a landing party beams down to a verdant planet and discovers a small colony of artists. Industry and agriculture seem alien to them; their every need is provided by something called Shol.
Kirk asks where they can find Shol, but the natives shrug, telling him, “When he wants you, you will know.” Soon thereafter, Uhura and Sulu turn up dead. “They joined Shol,” says one of the natives. After investigation, the crew discovers that the ecology of the planet is in complete balance, and the natives are in perfect health. There are also no elders among them.
Searching for Shol, McCoy and Scotty call Kirk with excitement — they have found him! By the time Kirk arrives, however, McCoy and Scotty are dead, too. Kirk is filled with rage, and sets off with a phaser to put an end to Shol. As Kirk is about to fire at Shol, who appears as a being of pure light, Spock knocks the phaser from his hand. Shol is not a malevolent alien, but the collected consciousness of thousands of beings — including the dead Enterprise crew.
Spock believes they can get them back if he, too, joins Shol. Spock’s scheme is risky, but it works, and he returns to life along with Uhura, Sulu, Scotty, and McCoy. All are overwhelmed by the experience, even Spock, who is “badly shaken, moved as he has never been moved before, and trembling visibly.” None of them can adequately describe their experience. As Kirk leaves, a native gives him a gift: "a bit of white marble, done faultlessly in the form of an apple, forever inedible."
Gene Coon rewrote Hartman’s outline, adding a subplot about McCoy having a nervous breakdown, and then sent Hartman off to write the script. She turned in two drafts, neither of which solved the story’s fundamental problem, which D.C. Fontana put best, writing, “has anyone noticed that Captain Kirk blunders around (a) at first only receiving information and (b) making a jerk of himself in the second half?”
When combined with the story’s similarities to the “The Apple,” which had already been filmed, it was decided to junk the script, rather than waste time on yet another rewrite. Hartman ended her association with Star Trek without a produced credit.
9. “From The First Day To The Last”
Story editor John D.F. Black and producer Gene Roddenberry had a contentious relationship. Roddenberry had promised Black he would not rewrite the experienced freelancers working on Star Trek, but he did rewrite them, often heavily.
Things got worse when Roddenberry, without telling Black, did a complete rewrite of Black’s own script for “The Naked Time.” Black left the show when his thirteen episode commitment was up, with “The Naked Time” as his only writing credit.
Black’s name can be found on a second script for the series, however, that was not produced. When it became clear that the production was lagging behind schedule and there was a risk of missing an airdate on NBC, a plan was hatched to write an “envelope” that would allow the series to repurpose its first pilot episode (which had a different cast, with the exception of Leonard Nimoy as Mr. Spock) into a two-parter. Black called his version “From The First Day To The Last.”
Black’s script features many of the same ideas that would be recycled by Roddenberry when he took his own stab at the two-parter, which he called “The Menagerie.” The framing story takes place in a hearing room where much of the time is spent watching Star Trek’s first pilot episode.
The issue at hand is whether a heavily-injured Captain Pike will be able to return to Talos IV (like in the finished episode, there’s a Starfleet regulation in place forbidding anyone from returning to that planet). And a late episode twist is that the officer presiding over the hearing turns out to be a Talosian illusion.
There are key differences, however. Spock does not steal the Enterprise to help his former Captain, and as a result, he is not subject to a court martial. Instead, he asks Kirk for help getting Pike to Talos IV, and the hearing is called to discuss whether or not this request may be granted.
In this version, Commander Jermaine presides over the hearing, and before he is revealed to be a Talosian in disguise, we learn that he wrote the very regulation that forbids travel to Talos IV. The hearing is resolved much sooner than in the filmed version, which leaves time for a scene where Spock escorts his former Captain to the bridge and shows him his upgraded workstation, as well as time for Kirk to beam down to Talos IV and watch Captain Pike return to the Talosians and Vina.
Black felt his contributions to the script entitled him to half the writing credit. Roddenberry disagreed, and the script went to arbitration. The WGA sided with Roddenberry, who ended up with the full “written by” credit on the two-parter, and all the residuals that came with it.
8. “Japan Triumphant”
When Gene L. Coon was given an early release from his contract during season two, he agreed to write for Star Trek on a freelance basis, subject to his availability. For the third season, he was given six story assignments. Coon, who made his reputation as a lightning-fast writer, managed to turn in four story outlines.
For two, he handled the script as well, and all four became episodes that season (“Spock’s Brain,” “Spectre of the Gun,” “Wink of an Eye,” and “Let That Be Your Last Battlefield”). However, due to a commitment to produce the series It Takes A Thief, his availability ran out before he could write the remaining two (“One Million, B.C.” and “Japan Triumphant”) and they were abandoned.
No record has emerged to date regarding “One Million, BC,” but we know more about “Japan Triumphant,” which was considered as a potential story idea as far back as the first season. Roddenberry included a short “springboard” for the story as part of a memo written to Coon on December 5, 1966:
This is another parallel Earth story we might consider...quite briefly it's the story of USA 1967 with Japan having quickly won the war in 1943. A sort of comedy show, emphasizing George Takei, with the Japanese “running” America but now hating every moment of it, feeling ashamed, and a “defeated” America enjoying every moment of having these “imported victors” actually doing all the hard work for everyone.
Happily, at least in this writer’s estimation, this one never made it to the screen.
7. “Shore Leave II”
In 1968, Ted Sturgeon was a well-known writer of literary science fiction with two popular Star Trek episodes to his name: “Shore Leave” and “Amok Time.” Among the show’s staff, however, he had a reputation for blowing deadlines and ignoring budgetary constraints.
His third effort for the show (to be discussed later) resulted in a final draft script that was deemed unfilmable and junked. Nonetheless, the staff gave him one more try at the beginning of the third season, which carried a working title of “Shore Leave II.”
Most sources claim this outline was a direct sequel to Sturgeon’s earlier “Shore Leave,” while others claim it was rewritten into the animated episode “Once Upon a Planet.” Neither of these claims are true. Sturgeon’s outline (even at 33 pages, it’s a stretch to call it a story) is an episodic tale set on the planet “Lackaday” (no, really).
Many incidents occur while the crew are on shore leave. Chekov gets robbed by a pickpocket. Sulu loses money in a shell game. Kirk gets into a fistfight. The crew meets a large many “with a big ugly head and scar” called... “Ol’ Gorilla Grillo.” And on and on.
Bob Justman read Sturgeon's outline, and promptly fired off a memo to the show’s new producer, Fred Freiberger, that was brief and to the point:
In my opinion, there are only a few minor things lacking in this submission. And those are:
1. Story
2. Peril
3. Conflict
4. Believable characterizations.
Already warned by Roddenberry that Sturgeon had a penchant for turning in work late, Freiberger didn’t wait for a revision. He cut off the story, and ended Sturgeon’s association with Star Trek.
6. “The Joy Machine”
Ted Sturgeon’s third Star Trek effort began life as an outline called “The Root of Evil,” which was about a Federation planet that has cut off all contact with the outside world. The inhabitants are all hooked up to a “payday” machine that rewards labor with a feeling of pure ecstasy — and as a result, all everyone does on the planet is work any way they can, as hard as they can.
Interestingly, Sturgeon’s initial outline made Uhura its central character, pushing Kirk, Spock, and McCoy to the sidelines. Gene Roddenberry, however, told Gene Coon to de-emphasize Uhura’s importance. “Ted should keep in mind,” wrote Roddenberry, “that our real money is Kirk, Spock and McCoy.”
Sturgeon obliged and reconceived the story, now titled “The Joy Machine,” with Kirk as the central character. In the original version, Uhura reconnected with her old flame, Danny, on the planet surface. In the revised version, it is Kirk who reconnects with his old flame Dannie. It’s the kind of change that would have made Nichelle Nichols livid — had she found out, and had the episode been made.
Sturgeon started work on the script in June of 1967 and then toiled on it for months, finally delivering a revised teleplay in November. Bob Justman liked the overall idea, calling it “marvelous,” but found the execution lacking “logical construction, correct characterizations, and believability.” He suggested holding it until the third season, when someone other than Sturgeon could rewrite the entire thing from scratch.
That’s exactly what happened. In the fall of 1968, producer Fred Freiberger brought in Meyer Dolinsky (writer of “Plato’s Stepchildren”) to bring his own take to the material, but it wasn’t enough to push the episode over the finish line. After Dolinsky delivered his first draft in late October of 1968, “The Joy Machine” was abandoned.
Almost twenty years later, however, Ted Sturgeon’s story was realized — sort of. Science fiction author James E. Gunn, who had been a friend of Sturgeon’s, adapted the abandoned story material into a Star Trek novel, which was published on September 1, 1996.
5. “BEM”
Pitched for the show’s third season by “The Trouble with Tribbles” scribe David Gerrold, the premise was that an annoying, practical-joking, non-human alien joins the Enterprise crew on an adventure and seeks to test their mettle. BEM (a play on the acronym for Bug-Eyed Monster) is a colony creature with parts which can detach and act independently.
In fact, Gerrold provided concept drawings for how the creature might look and a costume might be built. After a very different and very plot-thin outline was submitted, Roddenberry suggested pairing Gerrold with "a good practical TV writer" to see if they could make it work as a script. But third season producer Frieberger chose not to, cutting it off after Gerrold turned in a revised story outline that was equally paper-thin.
(A few years later Gerrold dusted off this concept for the animated version of Star Trek, but that episode is a lot different than what Gerrold pitched back in 1968, especially after Roddenberry inserted a godlike alien entity into the proceedings. Interestingly, the animated show ought to have been able to portray BEM even more alien in appearance than Gerrold suggested, but he ended up looking blandly anthropomorphic.)
4. “Joanna”
At the end of the show’s first season, Dorothy Fontana began revising the Star Trek writer-director guide. She took the opportunity to speak to all of the actors about their characters, and after chatting with DeForest Kelley, she updated his character’s description:
Dr. McCoy is 45 years of age, was married once...something of a mystery that ended unhappily in a divorce. He has a daughter, “Joanna”, who is 20 and in training as a nurse. McCoy has provided for her, hears from her as often as inter-galactic mail permits, but his duty aboard the starship keeps them apart.
We will meet her some day in an episode and find Joanna lovely, bright and intelligent...very much to Jim Kirk’s liking. We will suspect that it was the bitterness of this marriage and divorce which turned McCoy to the Space Service.
Fontana initially turned to actor and writer Gary Clarke to develop this idea into an episode for the second season, but a story outline never materialized. Later that year, Fontana asked to develop the story herself, but Roddenberry said no, telling producer John Meredyth Lucas, “there is really not sufficient story in the premise.”
Not one to let a good idea die, Fontana pitched the story again for the third season, and this time got the go-ahead to write it. Her outline begins with a group of “23rd Century Flower Children” beaming aboard the Enterprise. One of them turns to McCoy and says, “Hi, Dad.” She's Joanna McCoy (Fontana suggests Nancy Sinatra or Bobbie Gentry as possible casting choices).
Joanna is part of a small band that follows a young man named Sevrin. They're devoted to peace and brotherhood, though Fontana notes, "They are not dirty, no drugs or hallucinogenics [sic], [and] no mentions of ‘hippies’ will be made in reference to them.” They have come aboard the Enterprise after accidentally wrecking their ship, and tell Kirk they are in search of a mythical planet called “Nirvana.” Eventually, they take over the Enterprise and find the planet, but it isn’t what they expected...
If all of this sounds familiar, it’s because the story was reconceived and filmed as “The Way To Eden.” There’s one critical difference, however: the episode, as filmed, doesn’t have McCoy’s daughter in it.
After turning in her story outline, Fontana met with the show’s new producer, Fred Freiberger, who felt that McCoy wasn’t old enough to have a 21-year old daughter. Having already been burned by Freiberger’s rewrite of her teleplay for “The Enterprise Incident,” Fontana recognized it was time to move on, and walked away from Star Trek.
Joanna would be mentioned on the animated Star Trek show made a few years later, but she never appeared on screen. When it came time to assign credit, Fontana took her name off of “The Way To Eden,” using the pseudonym “Michael Richards” instead.
3. “He Walked Among Us”
Shortly after turning in his final draft of “The Doomsday Machine,” Norman Spinrad got a second assignment — a prime directive story called “He Walked Among Us,” about a pre-industrial civilization that has been contaminated by a notorious “psycho-sociologist” named Dr. Theodore Bayne. Spinrad has claimed that the character was written with Milton Berle in mind, but it should be noted that at least one draft describes the character of Bayne as “obviously a Negro from Earth.”
In Spinrad’s outline, when Bayne crash landed on the planet Jugal fifteen years prior, the natives began to revere him as a god. Rather than correct this misconception, he used it as “chance to establish his ideal society and vindicate his theories.” Kirk is aghast at this blatant violation of the prime directive. Making matters worse for him, Bayne isn’t willing to leave. The story’s fundamental dilemma is how Kirk will remove Bayne from Jugal without violating the prime directive or further contaminating the planet’s society.
“Are we doing too many ‘god’ stories?” asked D.C. Fontana in a memo to her boss, Gene L. Coon (that season alone, they had “The Apple,” “The Changeling,” and “Who Mourns for Adonais?”). After Spinrad turned in a second draft outline, Fontana advised Coon, "There is no real jeopardy to Kirk and the others...There are no genuine, valid problems for Kirk." She suggested a rewrite.
When Spinrad turned in his first draft teleplay, associate producer Bob Justman didn’t mince any words:
No doubt you will remember that I made a statement about Norman Spinrad evidencing definite signs of becoming a highly skilled television writer. I would like to retract that opinion....This teleplay is very sloppy.
Fontana agreed with Justman. “In general,” she wrote, “there are too many people, not enough action, indecision and no assertiveness on the part of Kirk, and dreadful dialogue.”
There was another problem with the script, too. Spinrad had been hired to write a planet show using the existing backlot and bring it in on budget. Instead, he delivered what Justman saw as a budgetary nightmare. Justman wrote to Coon:
The amount of extras and bits and wardrobe and special silver wigs at several hundred dollars apiece 'begs explanation'! I am very glad that the representatives of Gulf Western do not examine or first draft teleplays.
Hoping to salvage the effort, Coon fired off a lengthy memo dictating all the changes the staff needed from Spinrad when he rewrote the teleplay. Regarding the dialogue, he told Spinrad, “Remember that this is [being] written to be spoken not to be read.” It was one of the kinder things he said in his memo, which did not sugarcoat things.
Spinrad delivered his second draft teleplay a month later. Wrote D.C. Fontana, “It is a poor structure, badly characterized, and with unspeakable dialogue.” She went on to eviscerate the first 20 pages of the script, and then concluded:
Just because I didn't say much about Pages 20 through 44, and 44 through 65 doesn't mean I like them. This is a dull script, except for several flurries of contrived action. Kirk stands around examining his navel...
Coon did his own rewrite of the script, but then he left the show. When producer John Meredyth Lucas took over, Roddenberry sent him a memo about the latest draft of the script:
Perhaps most of all, the thing we've missed most all along on every version of this script by various writers, is a theme or premise. What is this story about? What statement are we making? Recommend you and Dorothy and I sit down together on this one, toss some ideas back and forth, see what happens.
In the end, rather than tossing together some ideas, they tossed out the whole script.
2. "Tomorrow The Universe"
Paul Schneider was a television veteran who wrote “Balance of Terror” and “The Squire of Gothos,” two classics from Star Trek’s first season. But even pros have their off-days, and his third script for the series, “Tomorrow the Universe,” was an unmitigated disaster. Producer Bob Justman didn’t mince any words when he read it, calling it “undoubtedly a new low for professional writers.” It was not produced.
In the story, the inhabitants of the planet Spurlos have transformed their society into a spitting image of Nazi Germany, complete with swastikas, tiger tanks, sieg hails, and even Adolf Hitler. It seems that several years before Kirk and company’s visit, another Federation starship was accidentally destroyed there, leaving behind a set of damaged historical tapes (conveniently, they stop in 1941) and a sole survivor: a power hungry half-Vulcan woman named Speen.
If all that sounds vaguely familiar, you’re probably thinking of “Patterns of Force,” a similar tale of a Nazi planet written by John Meredyth Lucas for Star Trek’s second season. When Schneider caught wind of the episode, he filed an arbitration claim with the Writer’s Guild, feeling his work had been used without credit, but the Guild sided against him. Once the matter was settled, Schneider sent a note of apology to Gene Roddenberry, but it’s obvious he still held a grudge. On a copy of the script in his personal papers, a note appended by Schneider reads, “my original 1st draft (unproduced, but later copied without giving me credit).”
1. "Portrait In Black And White"
Lightning did not strike twice for Barry Trivers, who wrote the memorable “The Conscience of the King” for Star Trek’s first season. His sophomore effort was this proposed episode in which the Enterprise visits another “planet of hats” — on this one the hats they’re wearing are American Civil War caps — but the “twist” on this world is its blacks enslaving whites.
Kirk is captured as a runaway but nothing much happens and no points are made other than the obvious one that slavery is bad. No kidding. NBC wasn’t having any of it and said “hell no,” not even approving the story outline to go to script. But Roddenberry had Trivers to do a first draft anyway, but that was as terrible as his two story outlines. Trivers doesn’t deserve all the blame for this one, though. Gene Roddenberry came up with the noxious story premise, which he called “Kongo,” as part of his initial pitch for the series in 1964.
Many sources claim Trek’s heavy-handed “Let That Be Your Last Battlefield” was an evolution of this story, but the two are nothing alike, and “Battlefield” is arguably better, which gives you an idea how wretched a “Portrait” this was.
Mad Men seems to have been poking fun at this in its fifth season episode, “Christmas Waltz,” when a character in that 1960s-set show wrote a script for Star Trek called “The Negron Complex,” which sounds suspiciously like “Portrait.”