10 Star Trek Twists You Never Saw Coming
This entire article was written whilst still inside Luther Sloan’s mind.
When it comes to writing a good story, some follow T’Hain of Vulcan to dictate the action through the characters, and others just make it up as they go along for those "unexpected plot twists". You may want to rely on a Muse Eternal for your sudden reversals, or, if you’re out of ideas to surprise your audience, simply add a moustache and change the name to Marseille.
Star Trek has provided us with countless moments we never expected: twists and turns that upended the plot, left us desperately awaiting the next episode, changed a character or characters forever, and even transformed entire lore. Most of these revelations have ultimately proven for the better of the episode or the series, and the fact that the audience (the vast majority, at least) did not anticipate them is testament to the skill of the writers. It is that carefully-crafted touch of the unforeseeable that keeps us on our toes.
Very occasionally, however, the reason for a twist’s unpredictability is the trivial irrationality of an anti-climax. You didn’t see that one coming because you’re asking, 'why on Earth would I have seen that one coming?' Some of these moments will also be discussed here. Looking at you, 'The Burn'!
And, of course, avoiding major plot points is all the more difficult in the social media age. That there are spoilers ahead in this article almost goes without saying.
10. The Odo Origination
As unexpected twists go, we could have talked about the de-cloaking of Starfleet’s first ever warship at the start of the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode The Search Part I, and left things there. This "little surprise for the Dominion" is, of course, the Defiant. The reveal was certainly a surprise for the audience, more used to the runabouts and the Treaty of Algeron. There is more to this two-parter, however.
Odo’s search for his origins forms a large part of seasons one and two of DS9. Both the character and the audience had little to go on. The scientist Doctor Pol, who discovered Odo floating in Bajoran space, didn’t recognise that the "shapeless viscous mass of fluid" was sentient at first, and it took time for Odo even to realise he could shapeshift. We get a few hints as to Odo’s beginnings in season two, such as when DNA similar to his is discovered on a seemingly abandoned planet in the Gamma Quadrant.
When Odo finally finds out where he really comes from in The Search Part II of season three, it comes quite a shock. Odo is actually a member of an alien race called The Founders, who created and lead the Dominion, holding 'solids' in low-esteem. The DS9 Series Bible entry for the character stated that "[Odo] is certain that justice is an integral part of [his species]". The truth couldn’t have been more different, and Odo is left estranged from his warmongering people until the very last episode of the series.
A certain Michael Eddington was also introduced in The Search Part I...
9. The Valjean Incarnation
When Lieutenant Commander Michael Eddington was introduced in season three of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, he was intended to be a rather by-the-book Starfleet security officer, and thorn in the side of Odo – not especially likeable, but not entirely detestable either. At that stage, the writers and producers hadn’t decided on a particular arc for the character. Over the episodes, the dynamic between him and Sisko would be favoured over that of his adversarial relationship with Odo.
Apparently, before the big reveal of the character’s alternate allegiances, viewers were convinced Eddington was a changeling – even more so after the episode The Adversary, during which a Founder takes control of the Defiant and nearly starts a war. It was decided at this point to make Eddington a leading member of the Maquis. This twist then came in the episode For the Cause when the character defects from Starfleet definitively, taking some industrial replicators along for the ride.
Eddington actor Ken Marshall was reportedly surprised (but pleased) by this turn-of-events, only finding out when reading the script of For the Cause. Fans were equally as shocked, having warmed to the character in season four with episodes such as Our Man Bashir.
The storyline is then wrapped up in season five of DS9, as Eddington places himself in the role of protagonist Valjean, relentlessly pursued by the vindictive Sisko as Javert.
8. The Seska Retaliation
The Star Trek: Voyager season three episode Worst Case Scenario begins with a faux-twist. The cold-open ends with the reveal that Chakotay is planning a mutiny. Dun dun duuuuun!
It does feel a little strange that Chakotay would have waited almost three years to express his 'grievances,' to such an extent that a more informed audience would have been dubious. There are other clues that things aren’t as they appear, like the fact that Janeway is wearing her hair up in a bun (although they changed that so often that it might have just been 'hairstyle of the week').
Nonetheless, you might not have realised this was all photons and forcefields until you were told as such. Indeed, the first 18 minutes or so of the episode take place entirely in the holodeck, 10 of which you would have been left only with questions about this supposed maquis rebellion.
This isn’t the main surprise of the episode, however. When the crew demand an ending to "Insurrection Alpha," Tuvok and Paris return to the holodeck to get writing. They find that the long-dead Seska has, rather literally, beaten them to the punch. Before her departure, she had found the program and rewritten it to cause all kinds of havoc should anyone reopen the narrative parameters file. Clearly no one saw that one coming! Tuvok and Paris are trapped on the holodeck and subjected to Seska’s torturous whims until they, along with Captain Janeway, manage to write a happier ending.
7. The Lorca Elucidation
Season One of Discovery was notably more sombre than we had come to expect for Star Trek. A lot of this darker tone came from the top: Captain Gabriel Lorca. There was a reason for this. Lorca was, in fact, from the Mirror Universe and had taken over the life (and perhaps taken the life) of his Prime counterpart. Sure, some fans spotted this a mile off, but many were left wondering until the last moment.
The big reveal didn’t come until the twelfth episode of the season, Vaulting Ambition, but it had been telegraphed throughout. There was his relationship with Michael Burnham, recruiting her from prison after saving her life, and doting on her from then on. It turned out Lorca had had a more…intimate relationship with mirror Burnham.
Lorca equally seemed to have a few gaps in his memory regarding his past with Admiral Cornwell, and she noticed a change in his personality. He slept with a phaser under his pillow, and, at the same time, we see a triangular scar on his back (from an agonizer). Lorca’s un-Starfleet approach to all-things is also as glaring as his sensitivity to light.
The actor, Jason Isaacs, delighted in the duplicity of the role. When asked by Entertainment Weekly what the twist meant for Prime Lorca’s fate, he jokingly replied (almost in character), "I’ve lied to all of the press constantly since the very first day […]. So why would you believe anything I say now?"
6. The Borg Pacification
Season Two of Star Trek: Picard opened and ended with the Borg. In later episodes we are given the twist that The Borg, or rather Doctor Jurati and the Confederation timeline Queen’s version of it (nicknamed the 'Borgati' by viewers), will be peaceful and respect the "uniqueness of their members". People must agree to be assimilated from now on. Good luck with that! What would the recruitment even be like? 'We are the Borgati. Please carefully read our Terms & Conditions and consult a healthcare professional before attending one of our assimilation open-days. Closed on Tuesdays.'
In the finale, the Jurati-Borg are even given provisional membership of the Federation. Who could have foreseen this twist for any version of the Borg? Also, what’s the deal with the gigantic transwarp conduit? Is it the work of the Borg of the Prime Universe? What did Jurati/Queen get up to in the intervening years, and where? We are left with a lot of questions.
Season three of Picard, we are told, will take place about two years after the events of season two, and will focus on the main cast of The Next Generation. With Alison Pill, who plays Jurati, having confirmed that she is not returning, it seems unlikely we will be getting any answers about the Borg twist.
Non, rien de rien…
5. The Kelpien Cauterisation
It turned out that cause of the utterly devastating, galactic event of the 31st century, 'The Burn,' which wiped out every ship with an active warp core, killed whatever the collective noun is for that many people, and pretty much saw the collapse of the Federation, was ONE angry Kelpien with a bizarre connection to dilithium. If you saw that one coming, please use your powers for good. And, to quote the TrekCulture podcast on the matter, "is that it?" What’s Kelpien for 'Are you taking the piss?'
We were teased about 'The Burn' nearly all season-flippin’-three long of Star Trek: Discovery. Michael BURN-ham was pretty much obsessed from the moment Booker told her about it, and the audience was rather intrigued too. As is fun for fans, multiple theories as to its cause started to emerge including a link to Omega, an accident caused by Burnham’s suit, a tie-in with The Next Generation episode Force of Nature, extradimensional manipulations via the mysterious music, the return of Lazarus from The Original Series, the Borg, the temporal cold war and so on. As far out as some might have been, all bar none were far better than the actual explanation.
Plot twists like this are impossible to predict for all the wrong reasons: the baffling and maddening anti-climax. The shock comes from the natural desire to avoid one’s own disappointment.
4. The Freeman Fabrication
The season two finale of Star Trek: Lower Decks gives us high stakes and a lot of action. It begins as the crew of the Cerritos are accompanying the Archimedes on a first contact mission with the Lapeerians. We also learn that Captain Freeman has earnt a promotion, and will no doubt have to transfer without her senior staff. Later, when the Archimedes is disabled by a solar flare, the entire crew of the Cerritos pull together to save it from collision with the Lapeerian planet.
Seeing how well the crew handled the crisis situation, Freeman realises that she was mistaken to pursue the promotion, and that the Cerritos is her home. When a team from Starfleet command arrive, the Captain is expecting to have to politely decline the transfer, therefore. Instead, we are given the highly unexpected, jaw-dropping moment of Freeman’s arrest for the destruction of Pakled Planet in collusion with a group of Klingons. She was innocent, of course, but still!
The scene in which Freeman walks down the corridor in handcuffs, surrounded by the shocked faces of her crew who were all ready to cheer her on, is actually quite moving, and it leaves us waiting for season three with bated breath. This was such a good cliff-hanger ending that it was marked by the first 'To be continued…' since season four of Star Trek: Enterprise.
3. The Romulan Revelation
The Romulans have been used as a surprise reveal in various episodes across several of the Star Trek series. The first, and undoubtedly still the best, is, somewhat naturally, their introduction in The Original Series episode Balance of Terror. When the Enterprise viewscreen flickers into focus, and the Romulan commander turns around into full view, we see that he looks eerily like a Vulcan. The bridge is stunned into silence, and the camera closes in on the face of the equally baffled Spock.
No one in Starfleet or the Federation had seen a Romulan before this point, and Spock hypothesises that they are indeed related to the Vulcans. Used quite sparingly in the rest of TOS, the Romulans notably returned in the 'we’re back' twist of The Next Generation episode The Neutral Zone. A frequent foe from that point on, the audience is treated to many an unexpected Romulan plot twist. Spock appears to defect to Romulus, but is actually working on reunification, Troi wakes up as a Romulan, and who could forget the reveal of Sela!
There are also a few unforeseen shock moments with the Romulans in Star Trek: Enterprise. At the very end of the season four Syrrannite arc, it is revealed to the audience that 'Vulcan' officer Talok, who has been working with the duplicitous head of the Vulcan High Command, is in fact a Romulan. He states that, despite the pair’s failure, reunification is "only a matter of time". Not long after, we find out that the Romulans are behind the attacks of the holographically-enhanced drone ship.
2. The Bashir Substitution
In the fourteenth episode of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine’s fifth season, we find out that Doctor Bashir is being held prisoner in a Dominion internment camp. Moreover, he is still wearing the older, Voyager-style uniform. But wait, hasn’t he been on the Station this whole time? That’s right, the Bashir on Deep Space Nine is a changeling! The puzzled look on Worf and Garak’s faces is a mirror for the audience.
Inasmuch as we never saw this twist coming, it appears that the writers and producers had a little trouble with the continuity of the revelation, having to clarify a few issues after the fact. For the captured Bashir to appear in the older-style uniform, the switch with the changeling must have reasonably taken place before the switch to the new uniforms in the episode Rapture of the same season. If so, this would mean that the changeling version of Bashir performed complex neurosurgery on Captain Sisko and delivered the O’Briens’ baby, all the while taking part in social activities and completely duping everyone on Deep Space Nine. In retrospect, there are also some potential problems with the in-world timing of the interim events.
Furthermore, according to the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Companion, Bashir actor Alexander Siddig was unaware of the changeling twist "until the last minute" and, hence, had not played the character any differently in the previous episodes. He was as surprised as the rest of us!
1. The Holographic Recursion
In the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode Ship in a Bottle, Moriarty returns and appears to do the impossible: he leaves the holodeck by sheer willpower alone (his "cogito, ergo sum"). Data later discovers, however, through some left-handed, Holmesian deduction that he, Picard, and Barclay are still on the holodeck. They are, in fact, stuck in a simulation of the Enterprise-D created by the sinister Moriarty, who has also taken control of the real Enterprise.
Eventually, the trapped crewmembers manage to program the holodeck within the holodeck to trick Moriarty into thinking he is transporting out to the real world. As producer Brannon Braga put it, this is "a twisty turny complex mystery" of an episode.
If you couldn’t follow all the ins-and-outs of this play within a play within a bubble of technobabble, then neither could those who worked on the episode. Reportedly, the TNG staff kept track only with the aid of diagrams that they drew during breaks in filming.
Nevertheless, the fact that Moriarty’s transubstantiation is a trick, and that our trio had never actually left the holodeck, is hinted at before it is revealed. For example, there are no external shots shown of the Enterprise-D until the very end of the episode. This is a method often used to indicate that events are happening in the holodeck or inside the mind of a character.
Watch Next
Star Trek: Where No Quiz Has Gone Before