10 Stupidest Decisions Made By Characters On The Walking Dead
Win a gunfight with a pair of scissors? Sounds legit.
The Walking Dead at it's core is a show centred around a range of characters having to survive a zombie apocalypse. So as you might expect, a good portion of the show is dedicated to how the survivors choose to live their day to day lives, having to dodge threats from both the living and the dead.
The thing is, some of the choices the characters make are so baffling, you wonder how anyone is still left standing.
Sure, it would be a pretty boring show if everybody breezed through the apocalypse, but there is a certain level of idiocy this lot seem to display, just so the writers can stretch out the plot even further.
We see the cast navigate a whole range of issues with complicated methods that normally gets them through by the skin of their teeth, only for another character to ruin everything with one stupid decision.
Even worse, sometimes the whole group contributes to these ridiculous moments. It can really ruin your immersion in the show, as you're sat there scratching your head on just how anyone could make so many consecutive mistakes, yet still survive several years into the apocalypse.
These are the most standout stupid decisions made by characters on The Walking Dead.
10. Bringing Randall Back To The Farm
Bringing Randall back to the farm was just one of many strange choices the characters made throughout the show's slow second season.
While it did provide a good catalyst for Rick and Shane's drifting relationship to deteriorate even further, you do have to wonder what was going through the group's mind when they decided to save Randall and bring him home with them.
Randall was a part of a group that had just tried to kill Rick, Hershel and Glenn, and he took a few shots at the trio himself. He then proceeded to fall off of a roof and impale his leg on an iron fence.
With walkers surrounding the group, it would've made more sense for Rick to put Randall out of his misery and kill him out of mercy. Instead, they rip his leg off of the fence and take him home.
While Rick's intentions may of been admirable, you've got to remember that once Randall was bought back to the farm, he was left in a barn in the dark, blindfolded and regularly beaten and interrogated by Shane and Daryl. It's hardly like Rick saved him from a fate worse than death. By the end of his time on the show, Randall gets his neck snapped and is left to turn.
He probably would've preferred been put out of his misery on that fence.
9. The Group Never Had A Rendezvous Point After The Prison Siege
To give credit to Rick and the group, they probably didn't expect The Governor to ever return to the prison, let alone with a small militia that even included a tank. All things considered, the group did pretty well with the whole ordeal, Hershel being the only main cast member to die in the battle.
Unfortunately however, the prison fell and everyone was forced to hit the road.
In the chaos of the battle there wasn't exactly much time for everyone to group up and leave together, meaning everyone split off into small groups. But you have to wonder, why didn't the group have a rendezvous point? Sure they might not have expected an attack from a tank, but it's incredibly naive of the group to think that the prison would never fall.
Having a place to meet up in a worst case scenario seems like something you'd figure out pretty early on.
How about Hershel's farm? Or the supermarket from the fourth season's premiere? Anywhere the group can just stay for a few days at most to re-group before moving on is all they needed. Instead they had no back up plan in place, and all ended up walking into the Terminus trap. Nice one.
8. The Walker In The Well
The walker in the well from the second season of the show is quite memorable due to how gross and disgusting it's design was. He was one of the first 'unique' walkers to feature on the show, and presented the group with a difficult task. How do they get him out of the well so that they can start using it again?
Their idea to hoist him out with rope wasn't awful, but sending Glenn down to tie it round him was stupidly dangerous and of course it backfired, almost killing Glenn. The well walker then proceeds to spilt in half as they try to lift him out, leading to his bottom half and a majority of his insides to splash back into the well. It was all for nothing.
But the thing is, it was always for nothing.
That water was always going to be contaminated anyway, as the walker had been sloshing about down there for some time already. It just really wasn't worth all the hassle the group went through to deal with it. It did make for a good laugh for audiences, though.
7. Morgan Holds Owen Prisoner
When we first started getting teases that Morgan would be returning to the show throughout season five, fans were understandably really excited to see what he would bring to the table.
After all, he was one of the first characters Rick ever met, and Lennie James is a fantastic actor who was sure to bring his all to the character. The last we saw of Morgan he was unstable and dangerous, so mixing him with the people of Alexandria was sure to be interesting.
Instead the writers decided to make Morgan a bit of a frustrating character, who refused to kill in any circumstance.
The problem was we were now six seasons in, and the moral discussion about rights and wrongs of killing people had gotten old. So when Morgan refused to kill Owen, a member of the raider group called The Wolves, it was just annoying to watch as he put the whole group at risk.
Because Morgan didn't just spare Owen, he actually kept him hidden in Alexandria as a secret prisoner, enlisting Denise to help tend to his wounds. This ultimately lead to Owen actually taking Denise hostage. While Denise was able to survive unscathed, you have to wonder how Morgan justified putting every resident's life at risk, all because he didn't want to kill a raider.
6. Lori Crashes A Car On An Empty Road
It's easy to forgot now that we're at the end of the tenth season of the show, but back in the day Lori was easily the most hated character on the show.
Her affair with Shane, her shoddy parenting skills and general attacking of every one of Rick's decisions made her quite a difficult character to love. However her worst moment has to come during season 2, where she somehow managed to crash her car on an empty road.
It's worth rewinding a bit here. Lori decides to go look for Rick by herself, as he hasn't returned from going to get Hershel. She tells no one that she's planning on leaving, including her eight year old son, and decides to hit the road on her lonesome.
She then decides to check the map while driving and accidentally hits a walker which leads to her crashing the vehicle. The thing is, even after hitting the walker she seems to have pretty good control of the car, only to freak out and swerve instead.
So not only has Lori just crashed her car, but no one knows where she even is. All she has been able to achieve is delaying any help Rick could possibly need, as Shane has to figure out where she's gone.
5. Andrea Shoots Daryl
As mentioned earlier, the second season of the show was rife with poor choices and questionable logic from almost every character in the group.
Andrea was not exempt, and while she would go on to make a series of mistakes that lead to her own death in the third season, nothing quite tops the time she almost killed Daryl.
Having had a more than rough experience in the forest looking for Sophia, Daryl returned to the farm looking like a walker. Having spotted him from afar, Andrea prepares to shoot him but is stopped by Shane and Rick, who insist on dealing with themselves.
After all, Rick doesn't want to cause any problems with Hershel, who at this point doesn't want any walkers to be killed on his farm. Andrea, desperate to prove herself decides to take the shot anyway.
Luckily for Daryl it only grazes his head, but you have to wonder what Andrea was thinking. It was a waste of a bullet, she could've easily accidentally hit Rick or Shane and the sound of the gunshot will attract more walkers. Taking the shot was nothing more than an attempt to show off that hilariously backfired.
4. Beth Tries To Kill Dawn
The hospital arc of season five is really quite unpopular due to the pointlessness of it all, seeing the group come back to Atlanta just to find and rescue Beth. On the very cusp of doing so, Beth ruins everything by trying to stab Dawn and ending up getting shot through the head, making the last three episodes feel like a big waste of time.
Watching the scene where Beth dies will leave you speechless. What was Beth even thinking? There are two groups of people both with guns aimed at each other, and you think it's a good idea to try and stab one of the leaders while you're in the middle of it all?
It was always going to backfire. What makes it worse is the fact Beth tried to do it with a small pair of scissors. It might've worked if she went for Dawn's neck or something, but she stabs her in the chest?
Beth's death was tragic and a real low point for Maggie and Daryl, but really there's no one else to blame but Beth herself. The group could've always come back to save Noah another time.
3. The Group Never Mention The CDC To Anyone
The first major change from the comics was making the group visit the CDC in hopes of finding some answers regarding the virus, and possibly even some form of vaccine or cure.
Sadly, the group found out the depressing truth: There is no cure, there is no one working on one, and there is nothing left but the those surviving on their own.
This is a huge revelation that is never bought up again past the second season, which has to be one of the most infuriating things the show ever did. This issue first cropped up in the third season, where Andrea helps Milton conduct experiments on the dead to see if they retain any of their old selves, despite the fact she knows they do not.
Instead, she just lets Milton hopelessly work away.
Even worse is during season five, when the group meet Eugene and co, and are told he needs to get to Washington to work on a cure. The group are a little bit skeptical, but ultimately believe him.
But why? They were told by Dr. Jenner that the US Government had fallen, so some random man with a mullet shouldn't be able to trick them so easy. At least mention the fact you were at the CDC... maybe that would be useful for Eugene to know??
2. Rick Sacrifices Himself
Rick's exit from the show left a bad taste in viewers mouths for a number of reasons, but even the reasoning behind his fake death is stupid.
Of all the ways to have him leave, the writers decided that he should sacrifice himself and somehow survive a huge fireball with nothing but a few scratches and bruises. The thing is, he didn't even have to sacrifice himself.
Yes, the bridge was being used by a horde of walkers that would definitely cause problems for all the communities. But we saw in season six that if a group can coordinate well enough, they can take on a horde quite efficiently.
This time round there may have been more walkers, but you also had several communities at your disposal that could've easily coordinated to figure things out.
Obviously Rick was in a pretty poor state and already hallucinating, but almost everyone had arrived and was ready to help Rick out. So his decision to shoot the conveniently placed TNT to destroy the bridge has to be one of the stupidest decisions Rick ever made on the show.
Not the worst, though. That goes to...
1. Rick Doesn't Tell Everyone They're Infected
The end of season one left viewers with a mystery as Dr. Jenner whispered something into Rick's ear just before he fled from the CDC, leaving Rick looking absolutely lost for words.
Many theorised that perhaps Jenner had found out Lori was pregnant through the testing he had done, but this turned out to be wrong. Instead Jenner had told Rick that everyone was infected, no matter how you die you would return as a walker.
Rick then decided to hold onto this information for the entirety of season two, even though it's crucial information that the whole group deserves to know.
Instead Rick keeps this secret until the final episode of season two, likely because the writers wanted to draw out the mystery and the second season on another bombshell.
Rick's justification is awful, stating that he wasn't sure if it was true and he didn't think it made a difference. Of course it made a difference!
Had one of the group died while Rick was away, that person could've reanimated without anyone knowing, then killing someone else! It has been one of the worst displays of leadership that Rick has during the entire show.
It's honestly surprising the group even continued to follow Rick after such a betrayal of trust.
Watch Next
The Walking Dead Quiz: True Or False?