10 Terrible Episodes In Otherwise Awesome TV Shows
Even the greatest shows have their off-days.
No TV show is perfect, and even those series which seem to boast an improbably high batting average of quality episodes aren't beyond at least one dud.
Given that most TV series are collaborated upon by dozens of writers, directors, producers, and studio heads - not to mention a huge ensemble cast - it's little surprise that things don't always work out perfectly, even if the best TV shows impressively make it an absolute rarity.
Though these 10 TV shows have all received heaps of critical acclaim over the years, each has been guilty of releasing a single episode which actually passes for genuinely terrible.
Whether a result of production issues, budgetary constraints, or an ambitious writer simply getting in over their head, these episodes serve as minor smudges on the records of shows that were otherwise shockingly consistent for the most part.
While some fans might be able to embrace these episodes for their off-the-wall "eccentricity" - if we're being kind - they absolutely stick out in shows that were so great at hitting the mark (almost) every time...
10. "Shades Of Gray" - Star Trek: The Next Generation
The first two seasons of Star Trek: The Next Generation had their fair share of not-great episodes, to be fair, but just a single one which dared to be a truly worthless insult to the audience.
The second season's finale, "Shades of Gray," was the only clip show episode across TNG's seven seasons, and was devised after previous episodes in the season had run over-budget.
Writer Maurice Hurley, who himself called the episode a "piece of s**t," wrote a frame narrative involving Riker (Jonathan Frakes) being forced to relive pivotal moments during his time on the Enterprise in order to fight off an alien infection.
Even for the standards of clip shows, it's howlingly lazy stuff, with the wraparound scenes all being shot in just three days, serving as an embarrassingly flimsy segue to various choice clips from the first two seasons.
It may well be one of the worst season finales to any mainstream TV show in history, though thankfully TNG rebounded with its hugely improved third season.
9. "Fire + Water" - Lost
Though Lost maintained an enticingly weird clip all the way through to its divisive finale, there are a couple of mediocre entries among the bunch which saw the show spinning its wheels and refusing to move things forward.
And then there's the season two episode "Fire + Water."
Focused largely on Charlie (Dominic Monaghan), the episode offers up some limp, melodramatic flashbacks to Charlie's fraught relationship with his addict brother and the infamously embarrassing shoot for the DriveSHAFT diaper commercial.
On the island, Charlie witnesses some pretentious and absurd visions, before attempting to baptize Claire's (Emilie de Ravin) baby Aaron, and getting punched out by Locke (Terry O'Quinn) for his trouble.
Worse than a mere holding pattern episode, Fire + Water's attempt at "character development" falls totally flat while depicting Charlie at his most utterly insufferable.
8. "The Waldo Moment" - Black Mirror
Though Black Mirror has maintained a fair consistency across its run, there is one clear standout as the show's worst.
Season two's "That Waldo Moment" follows a despondent comedian (Daniel Rigby) who voices a popular animated bear, Waldo, and ultimately enters a by-election as Waldo to become a member of parliament.
Despite many noting the episode's relevance following Donald Trump's successful Presidential campaign, it's also the most on-the-nose and off-base Black Mirror episode, taking shallow, simplistic, and worse of all unfunny pot-shots at populist politics.
The episode's rushed ending, in which the comedian's life is quickly ruined, was particularly criticised, placing a not-convincing-enough capper on an episode that lacked the satirical flair or conceptual cleverness to be worthy of the Black Mirror name. A rare misstep for the great Charlie Brooker.
7. "Jakovasaurs" - South Park
Unlike every other episode on this list, the all-time worst episode across South Park's staggering 23 seasons is kinda-sorta on purpose.
The season three episode "Jakovausaurs" aired less than a month after the release of Star Wars: The Phantom Menace and was designed to parody the film's much-maligned comic relief character Jar Jar Binks.
The episode sees the boys run into the titular human-duck-thing, an over-designed abomination with an extremely annoying, grating voice - not unlike Jar Jar.
While it's clear that Matt Stone and Trey Parker were venting their own frustrations with The Phantom Menace and tapping into a cultural vein of rage, the irritation factor of the Jakovasaur was never outweighed by the comic merit, of which there was precious little.
Sure, Jakovasaur is extremely irritating just like Jar Jar, but where are the laughs? As a whole the episode just assaults the viewer with its message, which while perhaps the point, makes for the most insufferable and skippable episode of the entire series.
6. "Christopher" - The Sopranos
The Sopranos is one of the most instrumental shows in breaking down the wall between TV and film, the influence of which continues to be felt two decades later.
But even this prestige behemoth wasn't above a single clunker, as evidenced by the season four episode "Christopher," focused on Silvio (Steven Van Zandt), Patsy (Dan Grimald), and Artie (John Ventimiglia) confronting a group of Native Americans protesting the Columbus Day parade.
Though it's not an inherently terrible concept, the script - penned by Christopher Moltisanti actor himself, Michael Imperioli - is so hilariously on-the-nose and lacking in subtlety as to be embarrassing.
Everything the characters say sounds more like Talking Points than naturalistic dialogue, and it surely doesn't help that Silvio's focal role was originally meant for Paulie (Tony Sirico), but was switched-up due to Sirico being out of commission for the season's first half after back surgery.
As a result, it's no mere coincidence that Silvio's behaviour seems a touch out of character and would be far better-suited to the more fiery Paulie.
While hardly unwatchable, it's certainly the most tiresome hour of an otherwise astounding TV monolith.
5. "Beer Bad" - Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Though Buffy was never averse to indulging its goofier sensibilities every now and then, the season four episode "Beer Bad" was one step too far, basically serving as a supernatural PSA against binge drinking.
Xander (Nicholas Brendon) starts working at a local bar thanks to a fake ID, leading him and Buffy (Sarah Michelle Gellar) to discover that the owner is brewing beer which turns the patrons into Neanderthals.
Its messaging is laid on incredibly thickly, yet lacks that wink-wink camp factor which could've turned it into a genuine cult classic rather than an embarrassing abomination.
Though Joss Whedon acknowledged that the episode makes "a lot of people groan," he still concedes that it "has some lovely stuff in it." Most of the fanbase would beg to differ, Joss.
4. "Frank's Brother" - It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia
Considering it's the longest-running live-action comedy series in American TV history, it's impressive how consistent It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia has been across its fourteen seasons to date.
Yet season seven's "Frank's Brother" is the single exception that proves the rule, in which the gang are paid a visit by Frank's (Danny DeVito) older brother Gino (the late, great Jon Polito).
Despite game work from DeVito and Polito, this breaks the first sitcom rule: it just isn't funny.
The majority of the gang are barely in the episode, and the generally low-effort, no-wit approach to humour makes it feel as though the script was hashed out on a cocktail napkin the night before filming.
The closest thing the show's ever had to a flat-out dud, Frank's Brother is the single episode you absolutely must skip on repeat watchthroughs.
3. "Tea Leaves" - Mad Men
Like The Sopranos, Mad Men is a premium drama show with few notable lows and many, many landmark highs. By far its weakest episode is "Tea Leaves," which it brings us no joy to say was directed by none other than Don Draper himself, Jon Hamm.
But the issues aren't so much with Hamm's direction as they are the episode's script, which focuses on reintroducing Don's ex-wife Betty (January Jones) to the narrative, depicted here as both depressed and overweight.
You won't find any Mad Men subplots more universally maligned than "Fat Betty," which saw its silly genesis here by way of some embarrassingly bad prosthetic effects.
The storyline only exists because Jones became pregnant between the show's fourth and fifth season, and creator Matthew Weiner apparently saw no other way to have Betty in the show without Jones donning a fat suit and performance-encroaching makeup.
Though the more office-centric stuff isn't bad here, it's entirely overshadowed by the uncharacteristic splash of goofiness that Fat Betty brings with her.
2. "Chapter Seven: The Lost Sister" - Stranger Things
Ask any Stranger Things fan what the show's single bad episode is and invariably everyone will answer back with three words: "The Lost Sister."
The seventh episode of the sci-fi mystery show's second season takes a surprise detour from the main story, as Eleven (Millie Bobby Brown) heads to Chicago and meets Kali aka Eight (Linnea Berthelsen), a fellow unwilling experiment from Hawkins Lab.
Beyond the episode substituting the nostalgic style the series is known for in favour of a grimdark glimpse of the Windy City, The Lost Sister absolutely reeks of a backdoor pilot, with many fans believing the Duffer Brothers were testing the waters for a Kali spin-off series.
Despite the Duffers denying this claim, the episode sticks out like a sore thumb, bringing the central narrative grinding to a halt and taking a breather that nobody really asked for.
Ripping Eleven away from everything she and the audience knows was a risk that absolutely didn't pay off, and given the widespread disdain for the episode, it's unlikely we'll see any similar "experiments" anytime soon.
1. "The Farm" - The Office
Though The Office's best years were long behind it when it neared the end of its run, nothing quite says network desperation like one of the show's final-ever episodes, "The Farm."
The episode focuses on Dwight (Rainn Wilson) as he attends his aunt's funeral at Schrute Farms, and effectively serves as a backdoor pilot to a proposed Dwight spin-off set to fill The Office's slot when it wrapped up its run a mere two months later.
But Frasier this wasn't, as The Farm was widely reviled by critics and fans alike, who in addition to feeling that the episode was too blatantly angling for its own series order, also found it painfully unfunny.
Above all else, it proved that Dwight is far more effective as a supporting character than a protagonist, and once Michael Scott (Steve Carell) took his leave, The Office was really just running out the clock.