10 Things Hannibal Does Better Than The Movies

Phenomenal casting, spectacle and horror, fine dining... and the greatest interpretation of Hannibal Lecter?

For years, Hannibal the Cannibal was synonymous with Anthony Hopkins. He delivered a dark, chilling, Oscar-winning performance in Silence Of The Lambs. While there might have been a little bit more ham to his performance in Hannibal, Hopkins to continued to mesmerise audiences. Frankly it was impossible to imagine anyone else playing the role - forget Hannibal Rising - and so the idea of a television reboot seemed an unnecessary cash in. How wrong we were: over the last two years Bryan Fuller has delivered the best show on television. Oh you might argue that Game Of Thrones wears that crown but Hannibal is the only show currently airing where not a single moment is wasted. Every performance is sublime; every shot is beautifully crafted; every episode delivers something so entirely unexpected that even readers of Thomas Harris's novels can only guess where the show will take us next. SIlence Of The Lambs is a stunning movie, no one can deny that. Its sequel and prequel are also great, even if they don't match the heights of Hopkins' first film as Hannibal, but incredibly, unexpectedly, the TV show is even better. Bryan Fuller has taken this world, these rich characters and pushed further than the movies ever could. Most surprising of all, Hopkins may have found himself bettered by the mesmerising performance of Mads Mikkelsen. Not convinced yet? Read on to see exactly what Hannibal does better than the movies...

10. Fine Dining

Silence Of The Lambs may have had the infamous line "I ate his liver with some fava beans and a nice chianti" but we never got to see Hannibal Lecter enjoy his predilections when it came to fine dining. Hannibal offered more, particular the riveting final scene where Lecter cooked a piece of a still-living Paul Krendler's brain and fed it back to him. But the nature of all the Hannibal Lecter films (imprisoned or on the run) meant that we never saw him in his element, mixing human organs with fine cuisine. As a prequel series, Hannibal has milked this opportunity perfectly. In most cases, we don't even know what the 'meat is, we just see the end result, served up as an exquisite-looking dish. Hannibal Lecter's dinner parties have become some of the dark and twisted highlights of the show; seeing our heroes unwittingly consume human flesh is stomach churning and only added to the suspense of when Lecter would finally get caught. Of course, the way season two ended, Lecter's fine dining might be at an end. Which is a terrible shame. That food looked amazing and even knowing what the ingredients were, just ask yourself...didn't it still look delicious?

9. Hannibal Treats The Audience As Intelligent Beings

The difference between the TV show and the films is that the films need broad audiences to be successful. There has to be an element of simplifying the story to make sure that it is accessible to a large variety of audience types. That being said, the Hannibal Lecter movies - Silence Of The Lambs in particular - go to great effort to treat the subject matter of Thomas Harris's with the respect they deserve. Which was probably why the oscars, while greatly deserved, were a surprise win for a film that went with a dark subject matter mainstream audiences were't used to. Hannibal struggles with the ratings partly because of the subject matter and the way it is presented isn't as accessible to wider audiences. But it is a better show for it. Recently we ran an article looking at TV shows that don't treat audiences like idiots and we listed Hannibal as number one. It is easy to see why: the dialogue assumes the audience has a knowledge of the psychological discussions. The FBI don't state the obvious when they complete their investigations; they are reasoned and knowledgeable. The audience has to pay attention, focus on the finer details and remember what has come before. But the pay off a week - or several weeks - down the line is immense, as the gripping season two finale proved. Hannibal treats the audience as intelligent beings and refuses to dumb down the dialogue and plot to appease the masses. That makes this show very special indeed.

8. An Intelligent, Skilled And Capable FBI Unit

What really stands out in Hannibal is that it isn't just the lead hero that is clever, skilled and intelligent. If anything, Will Graham is one of the most flawed characters on the show. Sure Dr Alana Bloom may have been clueless to her mentor and boyfriend's antics, but the rest of the FBI unit aren't idiots. They have the skills, knowledge and intuition to follow the clues on the cases they investigate. Interestingly the revelation that Hannibal was a serial killer who had been feeding his friends human meat wasn't a cliffhanger in the final episode of season two. It was a slow build up as Will, then Jack and finally Alana began to piece the clues together before it all came to a head in that bloody confrontation. In the movies, the FBI agents were less noticeable. Jack Crawford was presented well in Silence Of The Lambs and Scott Glenn delivered a strong performance but the other characters never made the same impact as Hannibal, Clarice or Will. In the show every one in the FBI unit has depth, personality and skill. Jack Crawford is a much more powerful character, central to the events taking place rather than just reacting to them. He balances reason with his desire to engage Will's skills to help solve his cases. As for Angela, it was no surprise that she pieced the clues of Hannibal's true nature well ahead of the season two conclusion, even if that led to her tragic death. Of course, Hannibal is the master of deception and it was only right that he ran rings around the FBI for so long. That is what makes him such a great villain.

7. Hannibal Isn't Afraid To Play With The Source Material To Its Advantage

The films understandably stuck fairly closely to the novels from which they were adapted. Wheras the TV show has an artistic licence to take elements from the Thomas Harris's books and shape them into something that follows the general narrative of Hannibal's history while still keeping the series unpredictable and fresh. It also isn't afraid to shake things up - like supposedly killing Silence Of The Lamb's Doctor Chilton long before that novel's events have appeared in the show and changing Freddie Lound's gender. Freddie's aggressive nature is much more interesting as a woman. She might be easily dismissed, but there is a greater sense of vulnerability to her too. Like Clarice she is willing put herself in danger to solve the mystery and is far more likely to engage with characters like Abigail Hobbs compared to a similarly domineering male figure. We've already had a pre-deformed Mason Verger in season two, next year we're going to see Inspector Pazzi from the Novel Hannibal, Hannibal's aunt Lady Murasaki from Hannibal Rising and Francis Dollarhyde of Red Dragon. It is an exciting time for the show as it moves beyond the Red-Dragon prequel setting into the novels themselves. Book purists might not like it, but the show has already proven itself in its ability to take Hannibal and Will in an innovating new direction. Going for the jugular of Red Dragon will be the point when it really shines over the films. Of course ratings are always an issue for this show. But if we get to season four, Bryan Fuller gets to try his hand at Silence Of The Lambs and that is an exciting prospect indeed.

6. A Sense Of Spectacle

In the ninth episode of season one, Trou Normand, we opened on a totem pole on a beach. It was a moment that was so utterly extreme it took a few minutes to register what we were looking at. The totem pole was made up of dead bodies, It was something so bold we couldn't really believe it was happening. It was that sense of horrific spectacle that makers the show stand out from the movies. It€™s not just the level of horror that the show masters (more on that next) but the sheer spectacle in the way it is presented. The series is filled with bold, dramatic imagery that hooks the audience and pulls them into this world. The movies made a great effort to capture the big moments from the books but the TV series goes further, mixing realism with epic moments that stick in our minds forever. We all remember the moment in Silence Of The Lambs where the FBI discover the warden strung up in Hannibal's cage as part of his escape, That was a big set piece in one movie. Hannibal the TV show does that every week.

5. Horror To The Extreme

In the second episode of season two, Sakizuki, the victim wakes up sewn into a murial of human bodies. What follows is one of the most shocking, uncomfortable moments in the show€™s history as he tears himself free - literally - from the other corpses and tries to make a frantic escape from the killer. Back in season one we had something as chilling as the Sloth man in the movie Seven - humans buried in the Earth, mushrooms growing from their bodies. Audiences were sick and shocked at the same time when one of the victims woke up. Not to mention the two victims in season one€™s Coquilles kneeling at the foot of their bed, the skin off their backs strung up like angel wings. Biblical imagery transformed into Gothic Horror before our very eyes. The films certainly delved into the macabre but nothing on the scale of the TV series. Week on week we have seen the horrors of humanity unfold before the FBI€™s eyes. Much of it is at Hannibal€™s hands but through the investigations of the first two seasons we have witnessed some truly horrific murders from a multitude of killers. The show has brought a level of horror to television few shows have been able to emulate. You have to wonder what goes through Bryan Fuller and his fellow writer€™s head to conjure these ideas. But they have done Thomas Harris€™s novels justice by expanding the horror that fills the world of Hannibal Lecter.

4. Cinematography That Is An Art Form

We're not just talking about totem poles, angels and people growing out of trees; the tremendous thing about Hannibal is that every shot is an art form. Every angle, every special effect is crafted to perfection. Anyone who knows anything about cinematography - the lightning, camera shot, effects - will appreciate that Hannibal goes far beyond what most shows do to create something that can truly be considered a piece of art. There are two magical scenes in season two that really highlight this. First we have Alana's attempt to provide hypnotherapy to Will while he incarcerated. In Will's mind she draws closer to him to the point that her face and body washes over him like a black sea. It is a stunning piece of imagery. There is also a moment later in the season where Hannibal counsels Will in his office and everything around their faces are absorbed in darkness as the therapy grows more intense and we the audience are drawn in. The movies are much more grounded in realism; Hannibal takes it a step further to deliver something truly unique that matches the madness of Will and Hannibal's world.

3. A Phenomenal Wider Cast

Hannibal might give us Laurence Fishburne€™s best performance in years, but he€™s not the only actor that gives a caliber of performance not consistently matched since the days of The West Wing. From the danger and vulnerability of Kacey Rohl's Abigail Hobbs to the commanding, icy delivery of Cynthia Noxon's Kade Prurnell, we believe in the motivations of every character. There are no two dimensional performances on this show. We recently saw Michael Pitt deliver an outstanding performance as Mason Verger but there are three supporting actors who really stand out since season one. Raúl Esparza has breathed life into the character of Doctor Chilton. Smary, arrogant and ambitious he proved the perfect foil for an incarcerated Will in season two. Eddie Izzard has delivered a larger than life villainous performance as Abel Gideon without ever verging into hammy. Gillian Anderson's ice queen Dr. Bedelia Du Maurier has been simply sensational - easily her best work since The X Files - and it is easy to see why she has been stepped up to be a big player in season three. The movies delivered some brilliant performances from its primary characters but you would be hard pressed to remember some of the supporting cast members. In Hannibal everyone stands out.

2. A Protagonist With Greater Depth

Forget Clarice Starling, Will Graham is the greatest hero in the Hannibal saga. He was the man who worked with Hannibal and caught him, even if it nearly destroyed him as a result. In the movie Hannibal we saw Clarice pushed to her very limits as she found herself on the blurred line between catching and supporting Hannibal. But she has nothing on the Will presented in the show. He went truly into darkness to the point where you believed - but hoped it wasn't true - that Will had joined Hannibal. He killed, he ate human flesh, he let Hannibal control his actions all in an effort to lure him into a trap. What is so interesting about Will is not just the ambiguity around his actions but his method of deducing the actions of a killer by living the experience in his mind. It was one of the most intriguing aspects of the show and the driving force behind Jack Crawford's desire to keep Will on his cases despite the mental pressures it puts on him. Between Jack and Hannibal, Will Graham desire to do good may actually destroy him and that is a fascinating journey to watch. Will Graham is one of the most thought provoking, flawed heroes currently on television. As good as Jodie Foster's (and Julianne Moore's) interpretations of Clarice were, they have nothing on Hugh Dancy's Will.

1. The Greatest Interpretation Of Hannibal

The joy of a TV series as opposed to a film, is its ability to explore its characters in far greater detail. Over the last two years we have seen Mads Mikkelsen develop Hannibal far beyond the character presented in the movies. His role as a renowned psychiatrist, a respected member of high society and gourmet chef: the TV show has delved deep into the man before he was an incarcerated prisoner who provided clues to Will and Clarice from his cell. Mikkelson's Hannibal has shown up the killer in his natural environment in a way the movies never could. Even in the movie Hannibal, he was still hiding from the authorities. In the TV show we've seen what he is like when he can indulge in his tastes, his thrill of working with the FBI, studying other killers like himself. We've even seen a friendship bloom with Will that is far more developed then the distant kinship that arose between Hannibal and Clarice. Not to mention his ability to have a romantic, sexual relationship with Alana. Interestingly too we rarely saw Hannibal commit any act until the blood bath that was the season two finale. Everything had been hinted at up to the point where Hannibal turned on his friends and started a slaughter more brutal than anything seen in the movies. Anthony Hopkins was brilliant and his Hannibal in Silence Of The Lambs was less like the hammier version we saw in Hannibal the movie and closer to the TV version than you might think. In truth, watching Silence again you can see where Mads Mikkelsen has drawn on some of Anthony Hopkins' more nuanced performance. It seemed impossible to beat Anthony Hopkins' interpretation of Hannibal Lecter, but Mads Mikkelsen has done it. There is no greater villain currently on television. Do you agree that Hannibal deserves to be crowned the greatest representation of the story? Share your thoughts below.

Contributor
Contributor

A writer for Whatculture since May 2013, I also write for TheRichest.com and am the TV editor and writer for Thedigitalfix.com . I wrote two plays for the Greater Manchester Horror Fringe in 2013, the first an adaption of Simon Clark's 'Swallowing A Dirty Seed' and my own original sci-fi horror play 'Centurion', which had an 8/10* review from Starburst magazine! (http://www.starburstmagazine.com/reviews/eventsupcoming-genre-events/6960-event-review-centurion) I also wrote an episode for online comedy series Supermarket Matters in 2012. I aim to achieve my goal for writing for television (and get my novels published) but in the meantime I'll continue to write about those TV shows I love! Follow me on Twitter @BazGreenland and like my Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/BazGreenlandWriter