10 Things We Learned From Twin Peaks: The Return Part 6

"What kind of world are we living in, where people can behave like this?"

Spike Twin Peaks
Showtime

It Is Happening Still: When are we going to get to the Fireworks Factory of a living, breathing, restored Special Agent Dale Cooper?

Milhouse Van Houten's classic whine has become shorthand for the impatience experienced when confronted with a challenging work. It was a problem shared by Sopranos creator David Chase, who seemed to delight in wilfully subverting his audience's expectation of a traditional crime saga by dragging out the domestic troubles of Soprano's other, biological, perceived more mundane family. Chase's frustrations with his audience became apparent onscreen, even if they were subtextual and unintended.

The continued Dougie Jones arc has triggered eye rolls from a portion of the fanbase who just want to see an Agent Cooper with the cognitive ability to give himself a present. David Lynch and Mark Frost are giving their audience the gift of Cooper; it's just tightly wrapped, enclosed in a Russian doll. They are both conveying the threat of the Black Lodge to inform the necessary dramatic heft and rewarding those enamoured with the beloved protagonist by parceling out his idiosyncrasies at a narcotising pace. In a show set between two worlds, we are getting the best of both.

"The beauty is in the doing," David Lynch once remarked of his creative process. Those taking in his art would do well to receive it in kind.

10. The Dougie Jones Arc Is Showing Signs Of Wrapping Up

CooperPart 6
Showtime

"Don't die," ran the episode description, the pattern of which, thus far, is extracted from the dialogue.

Phillip Gerard materialised in the living room of Dougie Jones to deliver that message. "You need to wake up," he intoned gravely. "Don't die. Don't die. Don't die." Dale Cooper barely heeded the warning because he remains in a catatonic state. Those unable to reconcile the character - and specifically, the way in which the outside world reacts to him - were assuaged when he was dropped off at his home by a security guard. He was concerned with Dougie's mental state, at which point Janey-E was finally moved to arrange medical treatment. The incongruity of the character is dissipating in parallel with the character itself, slowly subsumed by Agent Cooper.

In the meantime, more signs of Cooper's reemergence into the world became apparent. Cooper felt distant echoes of his past life when mesmerised by the security guard's badge. He also played a childish game with Dougie's young son and used his inherent, dormant deduction skills to identify the cooked case files of Tom Sizemore's Anthony Sinclair.

Lost amid the Fireworks Factory impatience experienced by some is how crucial this arc is to both the dramatic heft and powerful mythology of the show. What would it say about the Black Lodge, if one could recover from it with a degree of ease?


9. We Know That Diane Is Real, And Who Is Playing Her

Diane Twin Peaks
Showtime

The decision made by David Lynch and Mark Frost not to reveal Diane - Agent Cooper's trusted confidant - during the original series led many to speculate that she didn't actually exist - that she was a manifestation of his quirky internal monologue. That theory, however, didn't explain how Diane managed to send him earplugs in the mail. Cooper had his affectations, but he wasn't a lunatic.

We now know for certain that Diane is real, and that favoured Lynch muse and acting powerhouse Laura Dern is playing her. Her appearance was brief, but indelible. In any other director's hands, you might fairly accuse the scene of dragging out the plot for the sole purpose of entrapping viewers. This was teased at the climax of Part 4, unmentioned in Part 5, and here, teased yet again.

In Lynch's, it was handled exquisitely; Gordon Cole, hilariously, sent Albert Rosenfield out in the pouring rain to track her down while he enjoyed a glass of Bordeaux, safely ensconced from the rain. Albert, soaked, was so infuriated he resented that "motherf*cker" Gene Kelly's ability to dance in it. Two charming character moments propped up what was essentially a minor reveal.

Diane's hair is...unusual - pristine and glossy, a bright white bob cut with surgical precision. The style and the colour evoked both the name and visage of BOB and his old vessel, Leland Palmer.

You shudder to think why Diane stares at the bottom of a glass every night.


8. We Know Of A New Villain

Red Peaks 6
Showtime

Balthazar Getty's Red was introduced in the final scene of the premiere. Though his distant interaction with Shelly was unassuming and thus difficult to gauge, it was played with just enough finger-cocking menace to convey danger.

In Part 6, we learned that he is trouble; he is the puppet master orchestrating the movements of despicable thug Richard Horne, and it is suggested his is a more otherworldly power than the grotesque psychopathy of his underling. Red flipped a coin which both spun in the air for an impossible amount of time and replicated in Horne's mouth. The scene was typically interpretative; like near everything else in The Return thus far, it was unclear whether Red's magic is a continuation of the mythology introduced by the Tremonds in the original series, or a hallucination experienced by Horne, his mind altered by what might have been misunderstood by Frank Truman as "Chinese designer drugs" in Part 4. The "sparkle" of which Red spoke is something he might conjure, as well as distribute.

It is expert casting by Lynch. The word for Getty is eccentric; a trait magnified by his character, with his ludicrous obsession with his own hands. On the surface, it was farcical, but in trademark Lynch fashion, the exaggerated posturing was undercut with a demoniac threat.

"Remember this, kid: I will saw your head open and eat your brains if you f*ck me over," he said. The least graphic word in that impossibly violent threat might yet prove the most important.


7. Richard Horne Is Worse Than We Could Have Thought

Richard Horne Part 6
Showtime

We were told to expect something far darker than even the original series, one reading of which is a harrowing account of systematic incestuous abuse. In Part 6's standout sequence, we were jolted out of any remaining notion of the amber-hued comfort of the original series when Richard Horne drove a truck through and instantly killed a young child, literally driven to fury by Red's condescension.

It was an upsetting gut punch of a scene, sold with histrionic grief with lingering reaction shots by the cast of extras. Horne, directed with an odd sympathy - or at least infantilisation - by Lynch during the aforementioned scene with Red, was concerned only with his being caught by the rotund schoolteacher introduced in the Double R earlier. He is a terrible human being, if in fact he meets that biological classification.

The circulating theory that Horne is the b*stard child of Audrey and Cooper's doppelgänger has strong elements of fan fiction, but the similarities between the characters - conspicuous and perhaps crucial, given the series' overarching theme of duality - lend it some credence.

The use of the word "kid" in Red's magic show evoked another link, as did Horne's characterisation; like Cooper, he is evidently an abnormal man child struggling to bridge the chasm to adulthood.


6. Carl Rodd Now Goes Places

Carl Rodd
Showtime

Carl Rodd was introduced in Fire Walk With Me - the almost comically lazy Fat Trout Trailer Park caretaker unmoved by the prospect of physically moving anywhere ("that's just more sh*t I gotta do now!").

He is reintroduced in Part 6. It is a new Carl. We learn that he visits the town of Twin Peaks daily, "damn near" by the minute. He seems far less oppressed by the Black Lodge forces he was heavily alluded to have been haunted by all those years ago. "I've been smoking for seventy-five years - every f*ckin' day," he laughs. He seems to revel in the fact that he has cheated death and that he is ever closer to it.

Why Rodd chooses to enter the town is suggested before and after the centrepiece sequence. His psychic connection with the Lodge was expanded upon in The Secret History of Twin Peaks, in which it is confirmed that he disappeared in the woods as a young boy. As he takes a seat on a park bench, he is drawn to a rustling in the trees, his eyes cast upwards in a weary glance.

He has a premonition or instinct of the young boy's accident, following him to the scene of his demise. It is also suggested that the Black Lodge engineered it; the boy's soul ascends to and is trapped within the power lines erected above. That is another continuation of the mythology developed in Fire Walk With Me. Rodd, like Cooper, has the ability to see the electrical machinations of the Lodge unfolding in the material world.

Is he gifted, or is he damned?


5. The Female Characters Are Developing Agency

Janey E Part 6
Showtime

Naomi Watts' Janey-E Jones character has attracted as much curiosity as criticism thus far for her inability (or unwillingness) to recognise that something is deeply wrong with her husband.

In Part 6, Lynch and Frost add layers to the oblivious housewife. Her failure to grasp situations around her is not limited to her husband, which indirectly lends that storyline more credibility. In a scene in which she half pays off Dougie's gambling debts to two henchmen, she cannot comprehend the concept of a vig - but her doltishness ("people were playing games, he made a bet where he lost $20,000?") is charming here, where previously it was something of a narrative convenience. She also tells the two men off in a fierce, bizarre maternal way - "I suggest you take a good, hard look at yourselves because I never want to see either of you again!"

Where Janey-E revealed a hitherto unseen grit, Doris Truman revealed the root of her compulsive nagging: her son committed suicide in the not too distant past. Suddenly, the character evolved from caricature.

We've seen beautiful, naked murder victims, girls in trouble, women of impossible glamour - now, Lynch is expanding on his characterisation of women by layering them with moxy and pathos.


4. We Know Of ANOTHER New Villain

Spike Twin Peaks
Showtime

We pay a brief visit to the haunted Duncan Todd in Part 6.

A red square slowly materialised on his computer screen, which triggered anxiety within him. It is a coded message, which he received by opening a safe in his office. From it, he uncovered an envelope which was then delivered to a man named Ike 'The Spike' Stadtler, who removed the contents - pictures of Lorraine and Dougie Jones. Stadtler then pinned both of them with an icepick in an on-the-nose moment of foreshadowing.

The implication is that Phillip Jeffries was displeased with Lorraine's inability to get the hit job done. That implication was made clear when we next revisited the Spike; e set upon Lorraine and stabbed her to death, spraying blood all over her and eviscerating her guts with a guttural, primal roar. His job was altogether more thorough than Lorraine's; he spotted a witness and murdered her offscreen.

Lynch is one of few filmmakers with the ability to wrench laughs out of such gruesome material; as the Spike reemerged, he looked down despondently at his broken weapon of choice. His response at the temerity of this woman, whose ripped-apart ribcage mangled the icepick beyond use, was an almost gentle "Oh no" - as if he were a toddler, and not a feral assassin.


3. A General Note On Quality

Agent Cooper Part 6
Showtime

"Anemic platitudes," is how one commenter described these articles.

In a way, it's hard not to see their point. Twin Peaks: The Return invites such lavish critique because it is almost uniformly brilliant. It is a sensory smorgasbord, a complex numerological and narrative puzzle, a sprawling mass of mystery that visually links coffee cups to insurance documents to chevron-patterned floors of brain-melting netherworlds. This isn't a mere masterwork from the world's preeminent visual artist. There seems to be meaning in every choice of prop.

Kyle Maclachlan's performance demands this sort of enthusiasm because there is not one emotion the man hasn't yet evoked. We are not even halfway through the series.

The narrative continues to lurch at a lethargic pace, which has the effect of hypnotising the viewer - it is its own eternally spinning coin, subverting expectations at literally every turn. Last week, it was thought Doris Truman's introduction was a genre staple of a more regressive time. This week, her affectations were revealed as a coping mechanism for one of the most unimaginable of tragedies. Candy Clark has been re-contextualised from shrew to figure of heart-wrenching sympathy. Even when it's bad, it seems The Return will eventually come good.

Criticisms of this new Twin Peaks as some bloated, arbitrary mishmash of unrelated scenes are dispelled when one considers that this revelation occurred on the same episode in which another young life is cruelly taken. Thematic echoes are everywhere. If this all comes together as beautifully as the individual components are being constructed, this might be the greatest television show ever made.

There's a platitude for you.


2. The Episode Description Probably Doesn't Refer To Deputy Chad...

Deputy Chad Part 6
Showtime

...which is a shame.

It's ghoulish to wish death even on a fictional character - but what an (intentionally) despicable man he is.

Chad epitomises the changes experienced by the titular town in the intervenin quarter century. Whereas, in 1989, all arms of local law enforcement were respectful of the Log Lady, Chad is both skeptical and dismissive, laughing off her intuition by comparing her log to a pine cone. He is a sneering, awful avatar for the cynicism of the modern world. His presence is a reminder that Twin Peaks is no longer the "heaven" once described by Agent Cooper.

"I sure wouldn't take that kind of sh*t off her," he snorted, as Doris tore Frank another new one. Her henpecking was then explained. Her son committed suicide after the effects of post-traumatic stress disorder grew too much. This failed to move him. "He couldn't take being a soldier!" he mock-cried.

In a new world of villains - supernatural, psychotic, unfathomably wealthy - the worst might be Chad, for his unrelenting awfulness of an all-too human stripe. In Part 5, Cooper mimicked the outstretched gun of the bronze statue erected in his office complex. Again, it probably isn't foreshadowing Chad's demise.

Which is a shame.


1. We Know What's Missing

Hawk Part 6
Showtime

"Something is missing," warned the Log Lady to Hawk during the series premiere. "How you will find it has something to do with your heritage."

We now know (or can reasonably infer) what is missing; the torn out pages from Laura Palmer's diary, which have somehow wormed their way between a door in the stalls (manufactured by 'Nez Pearce') of the men's room of the Twin Peaks Sheriff's Department. Hawk dropped a buffalo nickel next to a toilet, at which point he noticed a fixture was missing. It was then that he ripped it apart and recovered what appeared to be yellowed, faded diary pages.

In Fire Walk With Me, Annie Blackburn advises Laura Palmer that "the good Dale is in the Black Lodge. Write it in your diary." We can now infer that Hawk will soon learn what the FBI already half-knows: that the real agent Cooper did not disappear. What's also interesting is that Annie was retconned in Mark Frost's The Secret History Of Twin Peaks tie-in novel. Lana Milford, not Annie, was apparently crowned Miss Twin Peaks on the eve of Cooper's entrance into the Lodge. The parentage of Norma Jennings was altered to further erase her out of existence. One thing was made clear by this week's cliffhanger: if we are going to learn how Annie is, we will learn it soon.

As Hawk finally unravels his clue, so too might the viewer; the aforementioned scene with Carl Rodd alluded to there being a "Linda" - a wheelchair-bound war veteran - residing in the New Fat Trout Trailer Park.

We have a Linda. We have a Richard. How (or if) this folds into Cooper's narrative is an as-yet unanswerable mystery.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!