10 Times The Walking Dead Traumatised Fans
Sometimes the TV Show steps over the line...
We just cannot avoid The Walking Dead. The comic book series flourished for sixteen years, and the TV show has dominated our screens for a decade, yet The Walking Dead universe still shows no signs of slowing down any time soon.
With spin-off shows Fear The Walking Dead, World Beyond, the Rick Grimes movies, and a Daryl and Carol duo series, the heart of the show is expected to continue for many years even after the final season of the core show concludes in the next year.
The Walking Dead is known for its brutal violence, and there's sure to be many more moments of tense action, heartwarming character relationships, and gut-wrenching deaths and gore as the franchise transitions into its next phase. However, it'll be very hard for the creators to top some moments in the show's history that left an overwhelming feeling of dread among the fans.
By examining all 147 episodes of the original show to date, this list compiles 10 of the biggest shocks, heart wrenching deaths, questionable storylines, and disgusting moments of gore that have traumatised fans over the years.
10. Glenn And His Dumpster
Season 6 Episode 3: "Thank You."
We begin with the most controversial prank in the show's history - Glenn and his dumpster. In the third episode of the sixth season our group stage an elaborate plan to lead a herd of walkers away from town. In the process of fleeing, Glenn gets stuck with Nicholas - the most infuriating and inadequate survivor of a zombie apocalypse.
Glenn and Nicholas get drawn down a dead end alleyway and climb atop a dumpster to avoid the clutches of the surrounding walkers. They're trapped, and there's certainly no plausible way they can survive.
Nicholas, realising this, turns to Glenn and says 'thank you' before shooting himself in the head. The momentum of Nicholas's corpse pushes both him and Glenn into the crowd of walkers. The episode ends on a close up of Glenn's screaming face as his body is ripped apart, resulting in one of the most shocking deaths of a fan favourite character... Or so we thought.
Why is this traumatising? Because we are fooled to believe that Glenn dies a horrifying death. Nicholas actually landed on top of Glenn, and it was his body that got ripped apart. Glenn, magically, was untouched as he managed to crawl underneath the dumpster where he hid overnight.
Fans were devastated by this sudden 'death' of a beloved season one character. It was an unnecessarily deceiving decision by the writers that left fans traumatised for weeks until Glenn's return.
9. Sophia's Fate
Season 2 Episode 7: "Pretty Much Dead Already."
The emotional fate of Sophia is the driving force of the first half of season two. After fleeing the CDC, our group find themselves stuck on a motorway swarmed by walkers. Sophia, Carol's daughter, becomes frightened and runs off into the woods.
The group then seek shelter at Hershel's farm on the other side of the woods while they search for Sophia. However, Hershel has a mysterious barn that he forbids anyone from entering.
After failing to find any clues about Sophia's whereabouts, Rick, Shane and our group become frustrated with Hershel and force open the barn.
Walkers pour out of the barn including Hershel's zombified family. Hershel was keeping them there in the hope that a cure could be found to save them. As the group eliminate the walkers, a zombified Sophia creeps out of the barn.
Why is this traumatising? Because it's the first truly heartbreaking death in the show. So much time was spent on the search for Sophia only for her to have been dead all along and in the barn right next to them.
The death of a child will always be traumatising, but seeing Sophia crawl out of that barn, mixed with Carol's haunting screams, is heartbreaking.
8. Rick's Fake Death
Season 9 Episode 5: "What Comes After."
In the show's biggest moment in the latter seasons, despite promotional content spoiling it, protagonist Rick Grimes made his emotional exit. The episode begins with Rick regaining consciousness after falling off his horse and being stabbed in the side by rubble. He quickly needs to lure away an oncoming herd of walkers and thus begins Rick's farewell.
Rick climbs back onto his horse and leads the walkers away. The episode includes various flashbacks and hallucinations to key Rick moments in the show, allowing the audience to feel nostalgic and emotional towards Rick's impending death. This is the end of an era after all.
Finally, Rick leads the herd towards a bridge, and, with his loved ones watching on, he decides to make the ultimate sacrifice. Rick shoots some dynamite, blowing up the bridge and the walkers, and killing himself in the process.
So why is this traumatising? Because, although the character has left the show, Rick does not actually die. The show fooled the audience once again. After blowing up the bridge, a still breathing Rick is found by Jadis, leader of the Scavengers, who calls in a mysterious helicopter to extract them both.
After leading fans to believe that our protagonist would die through an emotionally traumatising farewell, it turns out that our tears were for nothing.
7. Look At The Flowers
Season 4 Episode 14: "The Grove."
Following the destruction of the prison, Carol and Tyreese are forced to protect baby Judith and sisters, Lizzie and Mika, as they seek shelter in an abandoned farmhouse.
However, Lizzie begins to show disturbing signs of psychopathy as she fails to understand the real danger that walkers pose. Lizzie believes walkers to be her friends as she is seen playing with one in the garden.
To prove her point, Lizzie murders her sister Mika and urges Carol and Tyreese to wait for her to come back as a walker so they can see that she's still the same.
In one of the most emotionally harrowing moments in the entire show, Carol decides that Lizzie can no longer be trusted around people and that, for her own safety, she must be killed.
Carol leads Lizzie to the bottom of the garden and tells her to look at the flowers before Carol shoots her.
Why is this traumatising? Because it's a utterly devastating moment. Carol, having already lost a daughter of her own, is forced to end the life of a confused girl. It's a situation that no person would ever be prepared for and one that has stuck in the memory of Walking Dead fans as the show's saddest moment.
6. Noah's Death
Season 5 Episode 14: "Spend."
Noah's death is perhaps one of the most brutal and violent deaths in the show's history, as it involves a tremendous amount of blood and special effects. We first meet young Noah at the beginning of season 5 in the hospital during Beth's final story-arc. After Beth's death, Noah joins the group and arrives with them in Alexandria.
Noah and Glenn are assigned as supply runners and venture out alongside the infamous Nicholas. Unsurprisingly, the mission goes bad and the three men are forced to run from an overwhelming amount of walkers. Noah's disgusting death occurs as the three men are trapped on opposite sides of a revolving door surrounded by walkers.
Our friend Nicholas selfishly forces his way out the door which lets walkers grab Noah. Noah is then pinned up against the glass door and literally ripped apart in one of the most horrifying scenes, and Glenn, like the viewer, is forced to bear witness.
Why is this traumatising? Because it's an unnecessarily grisly watch. Yes, The Walking Dead is known for its gore and horror, but sometimes not seeing the death is more effective.
If all we saw was Glenn's horrified reaction then that would arguably be just as powerful. Showing Noah's nauseating final moments was a needless flex of the show's muscles, and one that makes you squirm away from the screen in trauma.
5. The Whisperer Border
Season 9 Episode 15: "The Calm Before."
Even this late in the game, The Walking Dead can still be full of twisted surprises. In Season 9, tensions between the four communities and the Whisperers escalate after our group repeatedly ignore Alpha's demand for a separating border. But, when things seem calm for some time, the Kingdom proceeds with its plan to host a celebratory fair. A decision that ultimately backfires.
Alpha sneaks into the fair under a disguise, and, at first, her motives are unclear. The residents of our communities soon notice that several people are missing, and a small group, including Daryl and Carol, go out to search. This soon leads us towards the Whisperer's border where we discover the decapitated heads of the missing residents lined up on spikes.
Why is this traumatising? Because it's an absolutely devastating and harrowing moment. In the comics, we discover the heads of Ezekiel and a pregnant Rosita (which in itself is rather brutal), but in the TV show the biggest reveal is the head of Henry, Carol's adopted son.
The decision to include Henry in this line-up is what creates the most trauma. Carol already suffered the death of her daughter in the second season, and now, when things seemed settled in her life, she is forced to look upon her son's decapitated head. It's an effectively evil decision by the writers.
4. Carl's Death
Season 8 Episode 9: "Honor."
Carl's death is the biggest injustice in the entire show. Carl Grimes, like in the comics, was destined to continue his father's legacy in the years to follow and help establish a new world. He was never meant to die in a cheap fashion for shock factor.
When Carl stumbles across a lonely and helpless Siddiq in the woods he makes the brave decision to help him. As they fight off walkers, Carl is bitten in the abdomen.
Later, as the group hides in the sewers, Carl reveals his wound to Rick and the others. In an emotionally distraught performance, Rick and Carl bid farewell to each other before Carl shoots himself in the head to prevent his reanimation.
Why is this traumatising? Because it's a betrayal of the The Walking Dead's roots and a stab in the back to loyal fans. Carl's death is emotional and heartbreaking and the show never truly regained its footing following this unpopular decision.
This moment is not only traumatising because it's the death of our protagonist's son, but it can also be blamed as a reason for Andrew Lincoln's exit and the original Walking Dead as we know it. The show had moved beyond the Grimes family and this became evidently clear with the decision to kill Carl.
3. Negan And Lucille
Season 7 Episode 1: "The Day Will Come When You Won't Be."
Negan and Lucille, the biggest romance in The Walking Dead. After continuously attacking Savior outposts, the group get their comeuppance as they are held captive by Negan. Negan's introduction is both intimidating and absurd as he threatens to bash in the head of one of our survivors with his beloved baseball bat, Lucille.
In a brutal moment of violence and gore, Negan murders both Abraham and Glenn in front of their loved ones. It's an evil display of power on Negan's behalf, and a disgusting watch as Glenn's eye pops out of its socket and his head turns to mush.
Why is this traumatising? Because it's an absolutely disgusting and chilling watch. It's the biggest, most bloodiest death scene in the entire show and one that leaves a lasting impression.
However, the horrifying deaths that occur are not the sole reason for the trauma, but also the way the writers chose to reveal it to the world. The scene should have occurred in the final moments of the season six finale. Negan chooses an unknown victim before the screen quickly cuts to black.
Eager fans were then forced to wait several months to see who fell victim to Lucille. It was an unwelcome decision which resulted in the season six finale receiving poor reviews, and it unfortunately contributes to this whole moment being a bit too over the top.
2. Hershel's Death
Season 4 Episode 8: "Too Far Gone."
The brutal murder of Hershel Greene is the most sickening and jarring death in the early seasons of the show. A loving mentor figure to the group, Hershel never deserved such an excruciating exit.
In the season four mid-season finale, after having lost his reign and dignity, The Governor takes control of a new group and seeks revenge on the prison. Hershel is captured outside the gates of the prison and used as an example to our group.
With a new army and a tank in tow, The Governor towers over a helpless Hershel as our group watches on. After The Governor ignores Rick's pleas, he hacks away at Hershel's head with a katana, decapitating him.
Why is this traumatising? Because it's such a gut-wrenching death of a beloved character, and one that sets in motion the downfall of the prison.
This whole climatic episode is traumatising as our group's home is destroyed and they are forced to survivor individually out in the wild. But witnessing this vicious assassination of an endearing father has traumatised fans for many years.
1. Rick Bites Joe
Season 4 Episode 16: "A."
We've reached the end of the list, and easily the most disturbing and shocking moment in The Walking Dead. Some honorable mentions include Rick's slaughter of the Terminus Cannibals, Lori's death during childbirth, and Dale's emotional goodbye. Yet nothing quite compares to Rick's brutal act of murder in the season 4 finale.
Following the destruction of the prison, the group are separated and headed towards the false safe haven known as Terminus. Along the way, Rick, Carl, Michonne and Daryl cross paths with the degenerate group known as the Claimers, led by Joe.
Joe holds an unarmed Rick, Michonne and Daryl at gunpoint as the other men of the group harass and threaten to kill Carl. In a fit of pure rage, Rick breaks free and tussles with Joe. Unarmed and defenseless, Joe mocks Rick and asks what he plans to do now. Rick then proceeds to bite Joe and rip out his throat.
Why is this traumatising? Because it's a brutally disgusting shock. It's more uncomfortable to watch than a walker biting a human as that's what we expect. Seeing our protagonist acting like the dead is unnerving, and it's an act of violence that is, frankly, over the top. The line between the living and the dead is blurred and it sets in motion a Rick Grimes that has gone too far.
Watch Next
The Impossible Walking Dead Quiz!