10 True Crime Stories That NEED A Netflix Documentary
Your next fiendish binge watch.
The true crime genre has never been bigger, with podcasts and especially documentary series being turned over to every misdeed or injustice imaginable. Some of them are genuinely classy and thoughtful affairs; others are sensationalist slop designed to profit from the ever-popular format. Either way, we lap them up.
Netflix in particular has become one of the biggest purveyors of crime documentary series, from recent stories like Aaron Hernandez to historical incidents like the Yorkshire Ripper and murdered nun Catherine Cesnik. They have even captured the zeitgeist repeatedly with the likes of Making A Murderer and Tiger King, two genuine cultural sensations and watercooler shows.
As such, the streaming platform has an insatiable appetite for more juicy stories, and these 10 would all be ideal subjects for the next big budget doc. From grizzly deaths to national outrages and wild outlaw adventures, we’re pitching Netflix’s next few years of true crime programming right here.
Some are famous tales, some have been covered in other mediums, but each would make a terrific long form series that would get every crime fan hooked and talking.
10. Raoul Moat
A story that captured the attention of the UK back in 2010, the bizarre saga of Raoul Moat managed to pack in so many twists and turns that it feels as though it lasted for far longer than its eight day duration. Most people of a certain age will at least vaguely remember the manhunt and eventual sorry conclusion, but the deeper story packs in a cavalcade of colourful characters and odd occurrences.
Moat was a bouncer, bodybuilder, and ex-con whose boiling anger and latent mental health issues led to a terrifying but engrossing rampage around the north east of England 11 years ago. With the difficulties of life piling up, Moat snapped - he shot his ex partner and her new boyfriend, killing the latter, before shooting a police officer and then going to ground.
The search for Moat was fodder for rolling news broadcasts, even as the story ground to a halt. Famously, former footballer Paul Gasgoine got involved for reasons unknown, until the whole thing came to a sorry end.
Many of the intricacies of Moat’s story have been consigned to history in favour of the flashier, Gazza-led details - a documentary could redress this.
9. The Lindbergh Baby
The kidnapping of Charles Lindbergh jr was at one time the crime, and subsequently the trial, of the century, but nearly 90 years on a great many of the details have been consigned to history. The fascinating and troublesome case would be fantastic fodder for a reflective series, even if the story itself can never truly be solved.
The son of famous aviators Charles and Anne Lindbergh was kidnapped in March of 1932, and following receipt of a ransom note, the child’s body was found two months later. In 1934, Bruno Richard Hauptmann was convicted of the murder, and in 1936 he was executed in New Jersey.
For all manner of reasons, this most public of cases was a hotbed for theorising, gossiping, and amateur sleuths. Hauptmann protested his innocence to the end, and all manner of alternate theories popped up. Some suggested the crime couldn’t have been a one man job, others pointed to the shoddy police work as a reason Hauptmann’s guilt couldn’t be proved conclusively.
As with any case of such prominence, there are crackpot theorists to wade through, but the story itself remains as chilling today as ever.
8. The Freshwater Five
The story was covered this year by a well received and popular Guardian podcast, but it deserves greater exposure still. The story of the Freshwater Five has it all: high drama, unusual twists and turns, and the possibility for genuine societal impact.
The Freshwater Five are a quintet of fishermen who were arrested in 2010 after their small fishing boat was out at sea around the time 250 kilograms of cocaine washed up on the shores of the Isle of Wight. Radar data along with the testimony of two officers on patrol saw the five men imprisoned for significant sentences.
Two are out, but three remain incarcerated, and all five have maintained their innocence throughout. Until recently the case has been under consistent appeal, and while recent efforts to escalate the case didn’t yield results, a much-publicised documentary could - on the basis there’s more to the case than the courts would suggest - make a significant difference.
Either way the verdict falls, this is a fascinating story of either terrible luck or criminal activity gone awry, with a tempestuous oceanic backdrop for added excitement.
7. Mary Bell
There are few tropes in horror more well worn than that of the creepy child. Kiddies are supposed to be the embodiment of innocence, so when a youngster is imbued with the spirit of evil, it can make for chilling fiction. In reality, though, it’s far more shocking than any writer could ever concoct.
Mary Bell was a young girl from a troubled and disrupted background in the north east of England who, by the time she was 11 years old, had strangled and killed two small boys. Bell was known to have a violent temperament, but was entirely neglected by her mother, and in due course the aggressive outbursts escalated to the murder of two three year old boys.
Bell was quickly apprehended, and while diminished responsibility played a part in her sentencing, she still wound up with 12 years’ imprisonment. She actually managed to escape from prison some way into her sentence, but was eventually released in 1980.
Since then Bell has attempted, and seemingly succeeded, to lead a normal life. She has been granted a new identity, and while she collaborated on a memoir of sorts, she unsurprisingly shuns the spotlight. That’s all to say she’d be unlikely to contribute to a doc, but the story’s an incredible one.
6. The Murder Of Jill Dando
The Jill Dando murder remains one of the strangest unsolved crimes in modern British history. A significant chunk of time has passed since the tragic event, and yet we still know absolutely no more about it than we did at the time.
The facts: in April 1999 presenter and journalist Jill Dando was shot dead just before midnight in front of her house in Fulham. An enormous investigation immediately launched, of a scale not seen in Britain for many years. A man named Barry George was arrested and spent eight years in prison, but the somewhat shaky conviction was eventually overturned.
Everything else remains a matter of pure speculation. Theories raged as to why Dando would be targeted for murder, but these were diffuse and mostly unconvincing - some tried to link her professional work as a motive, but she was hardly a controversial figure. Many, many persons of interest were interviewed, none of which went anywhere.
As a mystery it remains truly fascinating in its oddness; as a tragedy it remains baffling, and perhaps worthy of further investigation.
5. The Old Lady Killer
Vice’s exceptional Dark Side Of The Ring series takes a detailed and considered look at some of professional wrestling’s most distressing stories, but even they’d likely find this one tough to swallow. Juana Barraza was a professional luchadore, but is now known better as the murderer of at least 11 and as many as 49 women.
La Dama del Silencio (The Lady of Silence) had an upbringing that was beyond traumatic, abandoned by an alcoholic mother and subjected to horrific sexual abuse from an early age. On her capture, she cited a lingering (and understandable) resentment towards her mother as the reason behind her targeting of elderly women.
The spree of murders took place over eight years, and the story contains many of the usual tropes from real live serial cases - inept policing, red herrings, historic tragedy. And that’s without the professional wrestling sheen to add a layer of intrigue to the whole thing.
Barazza was convicted in 2008 - she copped to just one murder but wound up with a sentence of over 700 years. She remains alive - there are plenty of living sources which would contribute to this fascinating tale.
4. Tokyo Subway Sarin Attack
Leaving aside the truly terrifying nature of this incident, the Tokyo subway sarin attack of 1995 contains many aspects that would make for an engrossing documentary. There’s cult action, horror, terrorism, a fascinating aftermath. It’s a story that still looms large in Japan, but one that isn’t discussed so often in the west.
On March 20th 1995, members of the Aum Shinrikyo cult released toxic sarin gas on three lines of the Tokyo subway. The effects were immediate and catastrophic: 14 people lost their lives, either at the time or in the aftermath, and a further 5,500 were injured, many permanently.
This was a seismic incident for the Japanese people, who maintain the world’s lowest murder rate and haven’t experienced a terrorist attack on this scale before or since. The aftermath was one of great soul searching and reckoning, including a fascinating book by Haruki Murakami.
13 members of the cult were executed in July 2018, but the organisation, now under the name Adelph, still functions, albeit without having attempted anything nearly as audacious since. It’s a wild and terrifying story that deserves to be kept alive.
3. Albert Spaggiari
When it comes to crimes rich in derring-do, particularly gentlemanly heists and prison escapes, no one does it like the French. Mesrine and Papillon are the nation’s headline acts, but high up on France’s list of criminal cult heroes is Albert Spaggiari, a bank robber extraordinaire who even the most strident fans of law and order could hardly fail to admire.
Spaggiari cut his teeth during the Algerian war, where he joined an anti-de Galle quasi-terrorist organisation that saw him serve time. Hardened against the state, on release he began his real criminal career.
His most notable exploit was the robbery of a major bank in Nice. A long term operation, the heist saw Spaggiari and his crew dig an eight meter tunnel up through the sewers and into the bank’s vault. Once in, they managed the most profitable bank robbery to date.
Things slowed down for Spaggiari from there - he was arrested, escaped prison, fled to Argentina, and vanished from the face of the earth. He died mysteriously in 1989, but was a keen enough storyteller and self aggrandiser that there’s plenty of information around which to build a narrative.
2. The Skyjacking Epidemic
In a post-9/11 world, the skyjacking epidemic of the late 50s to early 70s feels truly bizarre. In a bygone era, the capturing of commercial aircraft, often for political purposes, was almost a part of life for flight crews. The most famous story is the mystery of D.B. Cooper, who held up a plane for ransom money before vanishing off the face of the earth.
His story was told recently in an excellent documentary, but a less well remembered story is that of Willie Roger Holder and Catherine Marie Kerkow, who hijacked a domestic flight in 1972 in order to demand, among other things, the release of Angela Davis.
Political skyjackers would frequently seek political asylum in countries with revolutionary leanings such as Cuba. Holder and Kerkow made it all the way to Algeria (still a record distance for hijackers), where they attempted - with mixed results - to assimilate with the resident Black Panthers.
The story is an incredible one, captured magnificently in Brendan Koerner’s “The Skies Belong to Us”, but the sheer wildness of the story would make for great TV content.
1. Norwegian Black Metal
For those not in the know, the Scandinavian black metal scene can seem seriously imposing. Vocalists sing in guttural growls, bands don terrifying occult garb, and subject matter often fixates on violence, Satan, and general gloomy vibes. For those in the know, it’s even worse.
After the relatively peaceful first wave of Norweigan black metal, the second wave came along with an intention to leave its mark. Bands like Mayhem and Burzum were part of a scene that plotted and often carried out the burnings of churches, the charred remains of which would then be proudly featured on their album covers.
The scene boasts murder, suicide, and arson galore. Mayhem guitarist Euronymous was stabbed to death by bandmate Varg Vikernes; drummer Faust murdered a gay man for reasons he attributed not to homophobia, but just general evil.
There are a few books and movies available on the topic, but many are difficult to find outside of Norway. 2018's Lords of Chaos depicts the life and times of Mayhem (with Kieran Culkin as Euronymous), but several members of the group raged at their depiction, and many critics found the film's approach dismissive of the scene. There's an incredible story in there for anyone willing to take it seriously.