10 TV Characters Cut From Shows (In The Worst Way)

Personal vendettas between writers and actors should never be played out on screen.

Even more so than movies, TV shows are built on their casts. Iconic small-screen characters have carried entire shows into the realm of superstardom, and the ever evolving will-they-won't-they drama of potential romances have captured the attention of audiences over the span of years, maybe even decades in the case of certain shows.

However, while the sense of familiarity and connection to amazing characters that comes with long-form TV storytelling is special, it's not easy to maintain. Whether it's writers running out of ideas or actors getting bored of playing the same character for so long, sometimes characters don't fulfil their potential, or end up disappearing entirely.

Sometimes that's not a bad thing, and it can result in a great send-off for fictional friends and enemies audiences have become attached to, but other times they're unceremoniously cut out, there one episode and gone the next, leaving viewers wondering what the hell happened.


10. Heath - The Walking Dead

The Walking Dead Heath
Gene Page/AMC

The nature of The Walking Dead's world makes characters disappearing for episodes or even seasons at a time an understandable prospect. This is a zombie-apocalypse story where getting from A to B is always a treacherous task, while the huge ensemble cast also means characters can fade into the background without viewers wondering where the hell they are.

That makes it even more remarkable, then, that the writers still completely messed up writing Heath out of the show. A staple of the comics and a major protagonist introduced in Season 5, the Alexandrian was last seen in Season 7 episode 6 while out on a supply run with Tara.

The episode ends with the two separated and the latter making it back to Rick's camp, but Heath's fate is left up in the air. The rule in The Walking Dead is that if you don't see a body, you should never assume someone is dead, but Heath was barely even addressed following this episode, and fans are still wondering where he went when Tara made it back relatively quickly.

The real reason he didn't show up again was that the actor, Corey Hawkins, got another gig starring in 24: Legacy, but even with that over, he's yet to return.


9. Mark Brendanawicz - Parks And Recreation

Parks and Rec
NBC

Parks and Rec has one of the best sitcom casts of all time, boasting an array of great actors all playing lovable, distinct characters.

Well, with the exception of Mark Brendana-quits anyway.

Initially introduced as a too-cool-for-school, will-they-won't-they love interest for Leslie, Mark was set up as the core straight man: handsome, suave, and totally above all the silly shenanigans of working in government.

However, that also made him boring.

In contrast to the rest of the cast - even background characters like Jerry - Mark didn't have much to offer, and Season 2 saw him pushed to the back of storylines.

That season eventually culminated in him leaving the department for another job, which isn't too weird, but what is is that Mark might as well have never existed afterwards. Over the years, Parks and Rec constantly brought back even bit-part characters, referenced them, and made sure they remained a part of the show's heritage right up until the final episode.

Except Mark, who was so boring he vanished into the ether the moment his final episode aired.


8. Detective Lockley - Angel

Angel Kate Lockley
Mutant Enemy Productions

The original idea for Angel was that it was supposed to be a darker version of Buffy, keeping the supernatural action but swapping out the high-school hijinks for grittier detective work. It was closer to a police procedural at first, with Angel literally setting up his own detective headquarters to frame the cases of the week.

To strengthen this relationship and help define it, Detective Kate Lockley was introduced in the second episode. Her relationship with Angel was a huge focus of the first season, but the character was written out mid-way through the second run after a strange suicide plotline, and then was never mentioned again.

Apparently that was never the intention though. For a while, the plan was to bring her back in the third season alongside Daniel Holtz, but due to scheduling conflicts the writers introduced Justine to occupy the same role. Weirder, there were plans to bring her back in later seasons as well, this time as a stripper entertaining Spike.

Neither of those ideas sound all that good, but they would have provided at least an explanation as to what happened to such a pivotal character from the show's foundational years.


7. Daario Naharis - Game Of Thrones

Game Of Thrones Daario
HBO

There have been a tremendous amount of characters and plotlines that were suddenly dropped from Game of Thrones. That's partly down to condensing such dense material for TV, and then running out of dense material and the show's writers not having any idea where the characters they'd previously adapted were supposed to end up.

None of that really explains why Daario Naharis was so unceremoniously dropped after having such an important role in Daenerys' story though. His relationship with Dany was the focal point of her story across seasons three to six, and he was last seen after his love interest finally sailed to Westeros, leaving him in charge of Meereen and the armies she'd liberated up until that point.

That could have been a natural end, but the issue is that Daario's absence lingered over the show long after that. Dany was going to war in the following seasons, and it never occurred to her to call in reinforcements that were waiting over the sea? Not when the Night King raised an army of the dead, and not when she made the final push for the Iron Throne? And he didn't have anything to say about the woman he loved being murdered?

Once Dany jumped into bed with Jon Snow, this former flame might as well have not existed.


6. Rachel - Community

brie larson community
Sony

Rachel debuted in Season 4 of Community, and was played by Brie Larson as a quirky, nerdy girl who enjoys a meet cute with Abed. That run was the year original creator Dan Harmon didn't produce, yet Rachel was a surprising highlight in an otherwise wonky series of episodes, so much so that Harmon decided she needed to stay once he returned.

Consequently she returned for Season 5, with her and Abed starting a genuine romance. Because Brie Larson was an in-demand actor even before she joined the MCU though, her stint on a quirky comedy was always in doubt, and after her run in Season 5 she disappeared from the show entirely, never to be mentioned again.

In a strange move though, the writers didn't even bother mentioning what happened to Rachel, despite having to have known in advance she'd leave eventually.

One minute Abed is in a relationship, and the next minute he's single and has forgotten entirely that he was in one. In Season 6 the character ponders about what happened to her, which almost saves the story with a meta joke, but isn't really enough to not make the sudden change as jarring as it is.


5. Prue - Charmed

Charmed Prue
WB

The entire point of Charmed is that the combined power of the central three sisters - Prue, Phoebe and Piper - is the unifying force that can always overcome any evil. Alone, they're weak, but together they can do anything.

It threw everything into disarray, then, when Prue's actress Shannon Doherty left after the Season 3 finale. Not only would her sudden absence threaten the core of the show regardless, but it couldn't have come at a worse point in the story. The third season ended on a cliffhanger, with Prue and Piper being left for dead after being attacked by the demon Shax, and Phoebe trapped in the underworld, unable to help.

In the jarring start to Season 3 though, it's revealed that cliffhanger was actually solved off screen. Phoebe was randomly rescued from the underworld by Leo and Cole (somehow) and Piper was able to be saved, but it was too late for Prue.

It perhaps couldn't have been handled better bar a total recast, but what was left was a total mess that only makes sense if you know the behind the scenes drama.


4. Elliot - Law And Order: SVU

Law and Order
SVU

Elliot Stabler was one of the core pillars of Law and Order: SVU for twelve whole seasons. He was a big, handsome fella keeping criminals off the street who was so inspirational, he even has a dang good song based on him by The Prettiots.

However, Season 12 was a transitional period for the show, serving as the final year that original showrunner Neal Baer would continue his duties.

Change was afoot, and Stabler's actor, Christopher Meloni, took the chance to also jump ship, which is fair enough after playing the same character for twelve years. However, like Shannen Doherty's exit, the decision to not return for Season 13 didn't do the writers any favours.

That's because Meloni's final episode ended on a cliffhanger, with Stabler being involved in a shootout. Immediately after the finale aired, it was announced negotiations had failed between the actor and network, and the character retired from the world of killers and detectives off screen, before Season 13 started.

It was a clean break, but it was a frustrating anti-climax after so many years viewers had invested into this character, and it coming after such a shocking finale didn't help either.


3. Jo And Ellen - Supernatural

Supernatural Ellen
The CW

Season 2 of Supernatural gave Sam and Dean Winchester something of a home base in the Roadhouse, which was run by an old friend of their father's, Ellen, and her daughter Jo. The two quickly became fan favourites, and were a major part of that season right up to the finale, where they joined the brothers to stop the demon Azazel opening the gates to hell.

They didn't succeed, and the finale ends with the brothers and Ellen and Jo back in the saddle to battle against whatever clawed its way out from the underworld.

However, Ellen and Jo wouldn't be seen again until Season 5, and the show never addressed the absence following the final episode of Season 2. Despite the calvary needing to be called in, the duo barely even get mentioned by Sam and Dean.

Apparently the original plan was to bring them back for a couple of episodes, but when the writers strike curtailed the entire season, those plans fell through, and Ellen's actress turned down the offer to cameo in the season finale.

That doesn't explain why they were absent from Season 4 though where, once again, Sam and Dean needed all the help they could get to stop the actual Devil from returning to Earth.


2. Judy - Family Matters

Judy Winslow Family Matters
ABC

Even if you haven't seen Family Matters you'll have seen the memes that have stemmed from it, or at least seen a video compilation of Urkel's many catchphrases. The most interesting story associated with the show, though, is actually what happened to Judy, the youngest of the Winslow family the show followed the lives of.

Things were smooth sailing for a good few years, but something strange happened in Season 4 when Judy was sent to her room... to never be seen again. In the next episode, not only was Judy never even mentioned, but now the Winslows were said to only have two children instead of three. So, what the hell happened?

Well, nobody really knows. Actress Jaimee Foxworth dropped off the face of the Earth afterwards, and Judy was never mentioned again in the show, and continues to be absent when the cast meet up for anniversaries and celebrations.

Was she abducted by aliens? Is there a Winslow murder mystery the rest of the family are trying to cover up? Did Leo and Cole come in to swoop her away offscreen? We'll never know.


1. Charlie - Two And A Half Men

Two and a half men
CBS

Charlie Sheen famously had a very public breakdown in 2011, coming up with the new catchphrase that he was "not bi-polar" but "bi-winning", while going on primetime TV to take swipes at public figures, including his own boss at the time, creator of Two and a Half Men, Chuck Lorre.

Despite thinking he was invincible, Sheen was axed from the show and replaced with Ashton Kutcher, but the rift between him and Lorre didn't end behind the scenes. Instead, the showrunner made it a point to kill off his character - also called Charlie - in a way that would make a return to the series impossible.

Consequently, Season 9 opens on the revelation that Charlie fell onto the tracks of a metro station, and then popped like a balloon.

This still wasn't enough for Lorre though, and Charlie comes back in the finale (played by a body double) to be killed again. It turns out he wasn't hit by a train, but was kept prisoner in a basement, which he escaped from. When he turns back up at his old house though, he's killed by a falling piano just as he rings the doorbell. Chuck Lorre even appears in the flesh to deliver a final zinger.

I'm not saying Charlie Sheen deserved more, but Two and Half Men fans deserved more than to see their favourite show devolve into a grudge match not once but twice.


Watch Next


Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.