10 TV Characters That Didn't Deserve The Hate

The Internet's ridiculous disdain for Skyler White makes no damn sense.

January Jones Mad Men
AMC

We simply can't love all TV characters, and sometimes that's absolutely the point - for example, Game of Thrones' villainous twerp Joffrey Baratheon (Jack Gleeson) was conceived to be as detestable as humanly possible, and what a success he was to that end.

But some of the most widely despised characters on our TV screens really aren't deserving of all that bile, no matter that the Internet might tell you otherwise.

Inspired by a fascinating recent Reddit thread on the matter, these 10 TV characters are so pervasively hated by fans for a number of reasons, none of which are really entirely reasonable.

Are these characters faultless saints? Absolutely not, by going by the volcanic reactions to their mere presence in the fandom, you'd assume they've done something truly horrific - more terrible, even, than the actual villain of the show themselves.

But because they had one annoying trait, weren't as fun as the rest of the cast, or made the audience confront some ugly truths about themselves, they're all held with an air of disdain by a colossal chunk of the fanbase to this very day...

10. Janice Litman-Goralnik - Friends

Friends janice
NBC

Perhaps the single most iconic recurring character in Friends is Janice Litman-Goralnik (Maggie Wheeler), Chandler's (Matthew Perry) on-again, off-again girlfriend best remembered for her nasal voice, "New Yoik" accent, and loud, obnoxious laugh.

This isn't to say that Janice isn't grating, because she's clearly the definition of a "small doses" person, but there's also a prevailing under-layer of sadness to her appearances throughout the show that's basically glossed over.

Janice genuinely likes the friends while being basically oblivious to how utterly unbearable they find her, and as a result many of their actions towards her come off as needlessly snide and mean-spirited.

Janice is certainly no saint in her own right - having cheated on Chandler and all - but she was a fun, caring person who actually made one hell of an effort with Chandler's pals.

Plus, she dropped a monumental truth bomb by calling Ross (David Schwimmer) too whiney for her, which alone negates any disdain she's apparently worthy of.


9. Mark Brendanawicz - Parks & Recreation

Parks and Recreation Mark
NBC

As much as Parks and Rec fans love basically the entire main ensemble, there are nevertheless nuclear levels of scorn reserved for Pawnee's city planner Mark Brendanawicz (Paul Schneider), who bailed from the show after its second season.

To this day, fans follow Leslie Knope's (Amy Poehler) lead and dub him "Mark Brendanaquits," and while he was definitely the least-funny member of the core cast, he gets way too much of the blame for the show's first season being, well, a bit of a damp squib.

In an office full of Characters, Mark was a total normie - basically an audience insert straight guy to react to the absurdity unfolding around him.

Mark never fully gelled with the show's other characters, but is still an all-too-convenient lightning rod for Parks and Rec's substantial growing pains during its rather mediocre first season.

As a character he's hardly great, but does he deserve to be saddled with all the ire for how rough Parks and Rec was out of the gate? Absolutely not.


8. Shannon Rutherford - Lost

Lost Shannon
ABC

Without question the most hated character in Lost's first season is Shannon Rutherford (Maggie Grace) - a seemingly vapid, selfish, spoiled young woman who at the time of the show's airing was regularly compared to Paris Hilton.

Part of the problem is that, just as Shannon began to enjoy greater character development and grow as a person, she ended up dead, being accidentally shot by Ana Lucia Cortez (Michelle Rodriguez) at the start of season two.

Following the death of her stepbrother Boone (Ian Somerhalder), Shannon was clearly beginning to become a stronger and less "useless" person, but before she could be fully realised as a team player on the island, she got capped out of nowhere.

Though the Shannon hate has cooled somewhat in recent years, the true tragedy of her character really only fully unveils itself on a repeat viewing.

Instead of bagging on Shannon until the end of time, direct your hated somewhere it actually belongs - to Nikki (Kiele Sanchez) and Paulo (Rodrigo Santoro).


7. Wesley Crusher - Star Trek: The Next Generation

Wesley Crusher Star Trek
Paramount

Star Trek: The Next Generation certainly had some major growing pains in its uneven first season in particular, and one of the major fan gripes was the presence of young acting Ensign Wesley Crusher (Wil Wheaton).

For many, Wesley was a stereotypical child genius character who they felt was cynically shoehorned into the series to make the show more appealing to children.

The number of times he'd suddenly save the day with his unique aptitude quickly left fans tired and irritated, such that they relished when Captain Picard (Patrick Stewart) gave him the iconic dressing-down: "Shut up, Wesley."

And while the writing absolutely did the character no favours at all in the early going - enough to invite accusations he was a "Gary Stu" - he improved leaps and bounds in subsequent seasons when his presence was scaled back and he basically became a regular member of the crew.

Wil Wheaton's performance deserves a lot of the credit here, but for a generation of kids watching Trek, he was indeed an aspirational figure - plucky, determined, and super-smart.

He doesn't give a great first impression, sure, but as the show found its own identity, so too did Wesley, as less of a Gene Roddenberry self-insert and more a relatable, likeable member of the Enterprise crew.


6. Lois Wilkerson - Malcolm In The Middle

Malcolm in the Middle Lois
Fox

If you grew up watching Malcolm in the Middle as a kid, you likely detested the family's perennially angry, ultra-strict mother Lois (Jane Kaczmarek), who is framed as being a joyless foil to the kids and their father Hal (Bryan Cranston).

This is perhaps best embodied by the infamous Family Guy skit where Hal is shown beating Lois to death in order to "free" the kids and himself. Despite the comedic intent, it reflects a very real attitude among viewers that Lois is a void of rage who wishes to suck up every last scrap of possible fun.

In reality, Lois is a brutally overworked woman who simply doesn't get the support she needs from her husband while dealing with a troupe of especially unruly sons.

Lois is just the first of several mothers and wives on this list who were demonised by the fanbase for daring to call the "heroic," typically male characters out on their bulls**t.

Revisiting the series today as an adult, it's clear that Lois loves her family and devotes so much of her time and energy to caring for them, no matter how rarely they seem to appreciate it.

If she's too controlling of Malcolm's (Frankie Muniz) life in particular, it's only in reaction to the abject chaos that's unfolding around her.


5. Betty Draper - Mad Men

Mad Men Betty
AMC

Not that dissimilar to Lois is Mad Men's Betty Draper (January Jones), who despite her once-husband Don's (Jon Hamm) regular philandering, substance abuse, and generally pretty awful parenting, caught the brunt of fans' ire throughout the period drama's run.

Betty is obviously written to be icy and standoffish to a point, but while many fans will simply write her off as childish and sulky, her demeanour is far more complex than simply being a bitchy foil to her whiskey-chugging hubby.

It's important to consider Betty within the context of the time: a woman clearly depressed at her general lack of purpose outside of her place as a homemaker.

She's not the best mother, but in her own way she's a prisoner of her time, and very, very pissed off about it. She's certainly no worse than Don, whose bed-hopping and general absenteeism is so regularly swept under the rug by his cheerleaders.

By the end of Mad Men, with Betty's days numbered by lung cancer, there were those who still couldn't bring themselves to feel even a morsel of sympathy or basic pity for her. For shame.


4. James Hurley - Twin Peaks

Twin Peaks James
NBC

Easily the most widely despised character in Twin Peaks is Laura Palmer's (Cheryl Lee) secret boyfriend James Hurley (James Marshall) - a sulky biker who just can't seem to catch a damn break.

James may be a sad sack, but he's certainly got enough reasons to justify it, given his fraught home life and seeing two of his romantic interests end up dead, as well as later suffering a traumatic head injury in an accident.

James will forever remain a figure of ridicule for fans because of his infamously toe-curling rendition of his song "Just You," and while the writing for the character certainly got worse in the show's second season, he's really a pitch perfect parody of the brooding teenager common in so many American soap operas.

He's nobody's favourite Twin Peaks character, but the hatred his mere name invokes would suggest he'd done something much worse than be a sensitive, good-hearted boy who dared to sing a terrible song.


3. Lisa Kimmel - Six Feet Under

Lisa Kimmel Fisher Six Feet Under
HBO

Six Feet Under's second season introduced Lisa Kimmel (Lili Taylor), Nate's (Peter Krause) old friend who becomes pregnant after they sleep together, and later gives birth to their daughter Maya.

Lisa is then murdered at the end of season three, and for many fans their reaction was simply "good."

Lisa is by far the most divisive character among the show's main cast, with many dismissing her as an excessively needy, insecure, high-maintenance hippie.

But let's rewind a little and consider the facts: even accepting that Lisa is far more into Nate than he is into her, her paranoia over Nate still being in love with his ex Brenda (Rachel Griffiths) was basically entirely justified given that, you know, it was demonstrably true.

Sure, Lisa is at times a deeply difficult person, but is she really worthy of more derision than any of the show's flawed gallery of main characters? Nate isn't exactly a saint - far from it, in fact - and yet seems to get far more leeway from the fanbase.

Some food for thought: Lisa brings out the hate in so many people because she holds up a mirror to the most anxious and insecure parts of ourselves that we don't want to think about. Boom.


2. Skyler White - Breaking Bad

Breaking Bad Skyler
AMC

There's surely no more overhated character in the history of TV than Breaking Bad's Skyler White (Anna Gunn), who was so thoroughly demonised by the show's (predominantly male) fans for basically serving as an obstacle to her husband Walt's (Bryan Cranston) drug kingpin aspirations.

Despite acting in a generally reasonable manner - relatively speaking, at least - Skyler was routinely mocked by fans as a wet blanket or "b*tch" for simply wanting her husband to, you know, not make meth for a living.

It's undeniable that much of the Skyler hate was couched in a general brand of sexism, that the severe, upset woman wasn't letting our "hero" be a badass and build his empire.

That fans so conveniently brushed over Walt's horrendousness while focusing their ire on Skyler is, frankly, ridiculous, something that even the show's creator Vince Gilligan called "troubling."

The vitriol became so volcanic that some ill-intentioned fans even sent threats of harm to actress Anna Gunn, who consequently feared for her safety. All for playing a character who didn't want the bad guy to do bad things.

Skyler was plenty flawed in her own right, but that she's ultimately loathed by orders of magnitude more than any of the show's real villains is outrageous. If you hate Skyler, you're basically telling on yourself.


1. Toby Flenderson - The Office (U.S.)

The Office Toby
NBC

In the case of Toby Flenderson (Paul Lieberstein) from the U.S. version of The Office, the fanbase was effectively manipulated into hating the straight-laced HR rep because Michael Scott (Steve Carell) did.

But really, Toby's only crime is that he's "boring" - that is to say, in an office full of cartoon characters, he's probably the most "real" and tragically relatable person.

Toby's just trying to get through the day without administrative headaches that will make his job harder, and Michael's obnoxious hijinks present an obvious obstacle to this.

Sure, Toby wasn't perfect - touching Pam's (Jenna Fischer) knee wasn't a good look - but he didn't deserve to be the office punching bag. Considering his fraught family life - defined by a divorce and shared custody of his young daughter - fans should've been considerably more sympathetic to him.

Hating Toby was such a wide-spanning meme throughout the show's history that fans in turn abandoned their own humanity and forgot that he's just a poor guy trying to find happiness while facing off against consistent workplace abuse.

Assuming he actually isn't the real Scranton Strangler, of course.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.