10 TV Characters They Couldn't Stop Recasting
The Mountain was played by three different actors, believe it or not.
The nature of TV production is so enormously complex, in many ways considerably more so than a single movie that's simply shot over a period of several months.
The multi-year nature of any hit TV series requires the co-ordination of a massive cast and crew, and so it's simply inevitable that actors have to be recast every now and then.
Perhaps a performer is unable to return due to the ever-precarious scheduling conflicts, or maybe the showrunners simply decided they ultimately weren't a good fit for the character.
Whatever the reason, these TV characters were replaced a frankly silly number of times over the course of their respective series.
In some cases it's clear that the producers didn't think their initial castings through, while in others it's just a fact of Hollywood that actors move on from a role if they've got a better offer elsewhere. That's showbiz.
While in some instances the recasting was evidently for the better, in others it continued to be a huge distraction throughout the rest of the series.
At least in some shows the creatives had the sense to make light of their predicament rather than stubbornly try to ignore it...
10. Judith Grimes - The Walking Dead
Let's kick things off with by far the most ridiculous case of serial recasting in the history of television.
In The Walking Dead, Judith Grimes is the young daughter of the late Lori Grimes (Sarah Wayne Callies) and Shane Walsh (Jon Bernthal).
Because fans have effectively seen Judith grow from a baby into a young girl before their very eyes, the part has been played by numerous actresses - an absurd 18 of them, in fact - across the show's 11 seasons.
This is in part because, as is standard practise for infant characters in TV shows and movies, Judith was played by numerous sets of twins.
This is a classic tactic that allows studios to work around Hollywood's child labour laws that restrict the amount of time a young actor can spend on set.
In season three, Judith was played by Adelaide and Eliza Cornwell, and also Loudyn and Leighton Case, while in season four three different sets of twins ended up taking the part - Tinsley and Anniston Price, Eleora and Elisea DiFranco, and Sophia and Delia Oeland.
Season five saw Judith played by Charlotte and Clara Ward, and then Kiley and Jaelyn Behun, before things finally began to settle down.
Chloe and Sophia Garcia-Frizzi assumed the part from season six to season nine, bar two season eight episodes where Judith was played by Kinsley Isla Dillon.
And most recently, from season nine onwards, Cailey Fleming has played Judith in dozens of episodes. You might recognise Fleming as having also briefly played a young Rey in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker.
If nothing else, the relentless recasting of Judith confirms the huge challenge of including an ever-changing baby or infant character among a series' ensemble cast.
9. Tora Ziyal - Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
Tora Ziyal may have only appeared in nine episodes throughout Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, but the daughter of Gul Dukat and Tora Naprem was still relatively memorable as minor supporting characters go.
Yet due to the half-Cardassian, half-Bajoran character being conceived with extensive makeup, even die-hard fans might've failed to notice that Tora was actually played by three separate actresses.
In her first two appearances in season four, she was played by Cyia Batten, before Tracy Middendorf took over for a single episode later in the season.
For her remaining six episodes throughout the fifth and sixth seasons, however, Tora was played by Melanie Smith.
According to showrunner Ira Steven Behr, the decision to recast Tora twice was inspired by the regular recasting of Felix Leiter in the James Bond franchise.
Behr wanted to "play with the audience's minds," and added that he initially wanted to recast Tora with a different actress in every subsequent appearance.
As it stands Smith is certainly the fan favourite Tora, though she also possesses a huge advantage over her peers by having played the character for two-thirds of her total episodes.
8. Bobby Draper - Mad Men
While not nearly as extreme as The Walking Dead's ceaseless recasting of Judith, Mad Men nevertheless burned through four separate actors for Don Draper's (Jon Hamm) young son Bobby over the course of its seven seasons.
In the show's first season Bobby was played by Maxwell Huckabee for seven episodes, before Aaron Hart took over for the remainder of season one and the entirety of season two, making 15 appearances in total.
Jared S. Gilmore then played Bobby for 19 episodes across seasons three and four, before Mason Vale Cotton finally portrayed Don's son for 33 episodes between seasons five, six, and seven.
Cotton's version of Bobby is really the only one most fans remember much of, honestly, in large because Bobby as written isn't a particularly memorable or compelling character for most of the show's run.
Compared to his far more intriguing sister Sally (Kiernan Shipka), Bobby's basically an afterthought, so they got away with the repeated recasting easily enough.
While it remains a mystery why Huckabee and Hart were replaced, we know that Gilmore departed the role due to winning the much juicier part of Henry Mills on Once Upon a Time.
It gets even better, though: Kiernan Shipka confirmed that, when you count the actor who played Bobby in the pilot and the various doubles who have played Bobby in single scenes, a total of eight different people portrayed him throughout the series.
7. Allison Stark - 'Til Death
Though cult sitcom 'Til Death managed to hold onto most of its central cast for its four-season run, Eddie and Joy Stark's (Brad Garrett and Joely Fisher) adult daughter Allison is the ridiculous, hilarious exception.
Allison was a recurring character who appeared periodically throughout the show, and was first played by the great Krysten Ritter in five episodes across the first two seasons.
Laura Clery then played Allison for six episodes in the latter two seasons, while Lindsey Broad also took over for 10 episodes in season four, and Kate Micucci then played her for her final dozen appearances later that season.
Eventually the writers basically gave up trying to pretend that these very different-looking actresses were the same character and started to have some fun with it, making wink-wink jokes about the recasting. That's a way to do it.
6. Nanette Guzman - Cheers/Frasier
Nanette Guzman, or "Nanny G," is Frasier's (Kelsey Grammer) first wife who is first introduced in a season ten episode of Cheers, where she's memorably played by the inimitable Emma Thompson.
Nanny then resurfaced almost an entire decade later in the ninth season premiere of Frasier, appearing as a young hippie in one of Frasier's memories, this time played by Dina Spybey.
And finally, Nanny showed up once more in Frasier's eleventh and final season, this time played not by a returning Thompson but recast yet again, with the great Laurie Metcalf taking the role.
While Nanny G is ultimately a minor character in the grand scheme of things, the fact that she's nevertheless an important figure in Frasier's past and was played by a future Oscar-winner (Thompson) and future Oscar nominee (Metcalf) is certainly an amusing look.
5. Jedidiah Lawrence - Boy Meets World
Topanga's (Danielle Fishel) parents endured some major personnel changes throughout Boy Meets World's seven seasons - especially Topanga's dad Jedediah.
Peter Tork - best known as the keyboardist and bass guitarist of The Monkees - played Jed for two episodes in the second and third seasons, before the legendary Michael McKean replaced him for a single season six episode, and Mark Harelik then took the reins for three episodes in the seventh and final season.
Additionally, Jed's wife Rhiannon was also recast, having been initially played by Annette O'Toole - opposite her real-life husband McKean, funnily enough - before Marcia Cross took over for season seven.
Now to be fair, Topanga's parents are hardly major characters in the scope of the show's seven seasons and 158 episodes, but it's nevertheless pretty amusing how little effort was made to bring in actors who even faintly resembled the previous Jed.
4. Young Livia Soprano - The Sopranos
Livia Soprano is one of The Sopranos' most unforgettable characters, and also its most frequently recast.
Tony Soprano's (James Gandolfini) cantankerous mother was played by Nancy Marchand for 21 episodes across the show's first two seasons, before the character was written out due to Marchand's real-life death.
But Marchand was ultimately one of just four actresses to play Livia throughout the show's history, even though the character was killed off following Marchand's death.
Laila Robins played a younger Livia in two flashback episodes in the first and third seasons, while Laurie Williams portrayed her in a season five flashback.
And most recently, a younger Livia was finally played by the great Vera Farmiga in the recent Sopranos prequel film The Many Saints of Newark, a role for which Farmiga received considerable acclaim in matching Marchand's memorable mannerisms.
At least in this case the recasting wasn't too distracting given that the new actors were playing the Livia in the past, and in the case of Robins and Williams their parts were relatively minor.
3. Gordon Robinson - Sesame Street
Gordon Robinson was one of Sesame Street's longest-tenured characters, having appeared in the legendary show's very first episode back in 1969, and only being retired from the series in 2016.
Before Sesame Street went on the air, the role of Gordon was played in the pilot episode by Garrett Saunders, an actor whose identity actually remained unknown until 2011 due to the producers losing casting records.
He was only identified when his family discovered the investigation into the original Gordon's identity and stepped forward.
When Sesame Street went on the air, though, the producers decided to replace Saunders due to being dissatisfied with his performance, and so Gordon was played by Matt Robinson for the series' first three seasons.
Hal Miller then took over for seasons four and five, before PBS finally settled on a permanent Gordon by way of Roscoe Orman.
Orman played Gordon from 1974 to 2016, appearing in more than 400 episodes as the beloved character and so easily cementing himself as the Gordon for literally generations of viewers.
Orman was let go after the decision was made to retool Sesame Street, though he continues to represent the franchise at public events.
2. The Mountain - Game Of Thrones
Gregor Clegane - aka The Mountain - is one of Game of Thrones' most memorable villainous characters, though it's easy to forget that he was ultimately played by three different actors across the show's eight seasons.
Initially, Australian actor Conan Stevens portrayed the hulking brute for two episodes in season one, yet scheduling conflicts reportedly made it impossible for him to return in season two, and so he was replaced with Welsh actor Ian Whyte.
Curiously, the Mountain is just one of several characters that Whyte played in the show, having also been a White Walker in the first two seasons, a giant in season three, another giant named Wun Wun in seasons five and six, and finally a giant wight in season eight.
Whyte played the Mountain for three episodes in season two, after which HBO finally settled on a permanent actor to play the part for the rest of the character's tenure.
Icelandic strongman Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson took on the role for 17 episodes across the remaining five seasons, and without question became the definitive iteration of the character.
It helped, of course, that the Mountain was given much more to do in the show's second half, most infamously popping Oberyn Martell's (Pablo Pascal) head like a grape in season four.
Björnsson's massive size and fierce look ensured the character finally lived up fully to his namesake.
1. Cristal - Dynasty
And finally, we have the character of Cristal in the 2017 reboot of the iconic soap opera series Dynasty.
Cristal is an updated version of Krystle Carrington (Linda Evans) from the original series, and in the reboot's first season was played by Nathalie Kelley for 22 episodes.
However, Kelley wasn't asked to return for season two, reportedly due to executives at The CW feeling that she was a poor fit for the part.
But rather than give Cristal a straight-up recast, the decision was made, in true soap opera style, to reveal that Kelley's Cristal was actually an imposter of-sorts.
Rather, "Cristal" was actually a woman named Celia Machado, who the real Cristal allowed to use her name. Celia was then shot dead at the end of season one, paving the way for the legit Cristal to join the cast.
Cristal 2.0 made her debut in season two, now played by Ana Brenda Contreras, who herself departed the role at the end of the season due to "personal reasons." Daniella Alonso then took over playing Cristal for Dynasty's three remaining seasons.
It goes without saying that a show as fundamentally ridiculous as Dynasty can get away with errant recasting far easier than a more serious-minded series, and at least they decided to have a little fun when giving their first Cristal the boot.