10 TV Characters Who Went Through Hell To Win (And Died Anyway)
Sometimes you have to go through Hell to come out the other side—and die an episode later...
You hate to see it—a character we’ve grown to love fights through no end of torture, losing friends, minds, and sometimes even limbs to finally claim bitter victory, only to end up offed, often offscreen, to no fanfare an episode later. And we really mean it when we say you hate to see it, to the extent that a lot of viewers never make it to the end of acclaimed shows such as Game of Thrones and Breaking Bad because of sheer frustration with the constant stream of near-misses and brutal defeats which rain down on the ostensible heroes.
Some shows are so unrelentingly bleak that they’re never even given a renewal (sayonara, Low Winter Sun), whilst others assume a shocking death will reignite viewer’s interest instead of leaving them too exhausted to invest further attention (nice try, Dollhouse). But even well-loved shows can sometimes misjudge a character arc badly, leaving us with a list like this.
These are the characters whose stories we followed, desperate for a little light at the end of the tunnel, only to find that after their eventual success their only thanks was an ignoble death thrown in for sheer shock value.
10. Mike - Breaking Bad
Okay,
so including Breaking Bad on this list is a move so obvious it feels like cheating.
The show made a twisted point of ensuring viewers were invested in characters both
heroic and villainous only to off them in underwhelming circumstances every
other week, as if attempting to prove that subversions can be as frustrating as
they are sometimes fun.
Remember the endless journey those two suited assassins made, across various episodes, in pursuit of Heisenberg? Remember how they ended up shot to bits in a Walmart car park without ever getting near him? Textbook Breaking Bad.
However, no character got it in the neck, figuratively and literally, as badly as Mike Ehrmantraut. After three seasons of fraught collaboration with Jesse and Walt, it seemed as if Mike would finally be able to sell his shares in the pair’s meth production operation, give the proceeds to his granddaughter, and escape the whole mess unscathed.
Until
Walt intercepted said cash and pulled a gun on Mike, threatening to off him
unless he named his in-prison associates so Walt could tie up loose ends. Of
course, this being Breaking Bad, it was only after firing that Walt remembered
he could have just quizzed their mutual acquaintance, leaving Mike to plead
that the murderous sad sack leave him to die in peace. Satisfying stuff!
9. Rickon - Game Of Thrones
Ah,
Rickon. Everyone’s least favourite Stark may be the best example in the entire
Game of Thrones universe of a truly pointless death, and for a show as long
running and unforgiving as the HBO megahit, that’s quite an achievement.
At various points in the show’s first six seasons, Rickon graduated from oblivious kid to inept but caring protector of his older brother Bran, to travelling companion and charge of Osha with whom he spends an entire two seasons attempting to reach the Umbers, a house who are (theoretically) loyal to his late father.
He lays low a while, remaining unseen for quite some time—before reappearing in the penultimate episode of season six. It appears the long journey to the Umbers was all for nought, as it merely drove Rickon into the hands of Ramsay Bolton, the show’s worst psycho.
Ramsay drags the youngest Stark out onto the battlefield for an explosive start to the long-awaited Battle of the Bastards—and sends an arrow straight through the poor blighter a few seconds before he would have reached his older half-brother Jon Snow and safety.
Unlike
Jon, his kid brother doesn’t warrant a resurrection, and so his long journey ends
with a PSA teaching all of us the importance of zig zagging when avoiding
projectiles.
8. Bill - True Blood
Remember
the first few seasons of HBO’s sexy answer to Twilight? The R-rated riposte to the
Mormon romance mega-franchise revelled in both explicit sex and gruesome gore,
but at its core was a romantic love story as sweet as anything from the tweenage
phenomenon.
Little-known British thespian Stephen Moyer landed the role of a lifetime in the form of smooth-talking, good-hearted vampire Bill Compton when the show debuted in 2008, braving countless nude scenes and an accent which could have been abominable to become the hero of the campy, Alan Ball-penned horror-cum-soap-opera. That’s not all the series got him, though; Moyer met real-life wife Anna Paquin on-set where she played his love interest, series protagonist Sookie Stackhouse, the eternally beleaguered waitress and occasionally telepathic fairy (no one said the show wasn’t silly).
So with such intense chemistry between its leads, surely the show would end with the pair together despite the endless obstacles—human, vampire, demon, fairy, and otherwise—which came between them. Right?
Sure—or Bill could end up becoming the vampire king, his greatest ambition, and still eventually become infected by an awkward AIDS metaphor, prompting his eventual suicide.
What
a compelling end to a story of two lovers who could overcome anything to be together!
7. Carl - The Walking Dead
Famously
optimistic and cheery The Walking Dead is not, but Frank Darabont’s critically
beloved first season did manage to tread carefully and maintain the balance between
thrills and the grim, realistic nihilistic streak of the source material.
Later seasons? Less so, if the declining viewership and rapidly increasing gore quotient are anything to go by. With the acrimonious departure of Darabont the show became a more sluggish affair, bleaker with each passing season and seemingly committed to offing anyone remotely likeable.
The low point for many viewers was the ultraviolent death of Glen in the opening episode of season seven at the hands of Negan, a shocking spectacle which pushed the boundaries of television violence, as well as the patience of viewers. But the character who made this list is young Carl, the son of and sole source of moral redemption for protagonist Rick Grimes.
After
moving over the years from a cute-but-burdensome kid, to a remorseless survivalist,
to a likeable and relatively well-adjusted young hero, Carl is killed off via
walker bite and subsequent suicide in the most recent season of the megahit,
proving the show’s central thesis is that there’s really no point in trying, is
there?
6. Cooper - Black Mirror ("Playtest")
We’re
getting into the anthology episodes because while these may be one-off stories,
the characters they feature have gone through enough misery for multiple
lifetimes. The poor denizens of the Twilight Zone and in particular The Outer
Limits are infamous for suffering ironic fates that are often far worse than
whatever misdemeanour prompted the misadventure that lead to them, and many were
doomed to cruel hell just for the sheer fun of it.
The contemporary sci fi satire Black Mirror, penned by Charlie Brooker, may be sharper in its condemnation of society and culture than The Outer Limits, but it sure didn’t blunt the edge of the show’s mean sense of humour. Just look at Playtest, wherein a happy-go-lucky slacker played by Channing Tatum’s bromantic foil from 22 Jump Street gets more than he bargained for when he agrees to test out an experimental virtual reality game for a shadowy uber-rich developer.
What follows is a nightmarish odyssey which delves deep into his subconscious as his worst memories and fears come to life in the form of disformed spider monsters, a creaky haunted house, and murderous versions of a former lover. The episode culminates in his scraped-by survival, and ends with him reunited with his ailing mother.
Psyche!
He actually died before the test even began—forgot to turn his phone off, didn’t
he? Very subtle anti-tech subtext there, Charles.
5. Marty - Tales From The Crypt ("Abra Cadaver")
Another
entry and another appearance for the venerable institution of endless character
suffering, the anthology series. There really is no end to the torture writers
can put the one-off stars of anthology episodes through, as the audience know
they won’t be appearing again and therefore can be offed as messily as the
creators feel like without sacrificing narrative momentum.
To this end, this Beau-Bridges-starring instalment of the Crypt Keeper’s unending series of stories (seriously, how many of those comics did he write?) sees a pair of brothers, both surgeons, playing a long-running set of pranks on one another which… get more than a little out of hand, to say the least.
First off there’s the dumb med school prank which gives one brother, Carl, a heart attack—a reaction which you would think might discourage this family from further shenanigans. But alas shenanigans continue unabated, and Carl retaliates years later by drugging his brother, Marty, and pretending to perform an entire autopsy on him whilst he’s alive and awake, but paralyzed.
It’s
a pretty savage prank by any metric, and no doubt Marty would have some years
in therapy ahead of him to undo the Autopsy Room 4-style ordeal he’s been put
through. Er, at least, he would have—if he didn’t promptly have a heart attack,
leading his brother to declare him dead and go through with the real autopsy—while
poor Carl is still conscious and unable to move.
4. Hemlock Grove - Peter
Poor
Peter. Like True Blood before it, Hemlock Grove made a point from its opening episodes
to distinguish itself from the then-dwindling but once massive Twilight
franchise by showcasing an impressive amount of sex and gory, gory violence. This
element was rarely better embodied than in Peter’s pointless sacrifice, which
made for impressive make up effects and little else in storytelling terms.
See, series protagonist Peter realizes before his climactic face off with vargulf Christina that he’s going to have to do more than fight—as the man himself puts it, the price of this turn will be his human face. And it’s a price he pays, with the vargulf version of his murderous nemesis eating his face—after he was kind enough to coat it in bacon grease to coax her (yes, really, it’s that sort of show so just go with it).
And after having his face torn off, the heroic sacrifice pays off, right?
Er…
Kind of, inasmuch as Christina is eventually defeated and Peter does revert to
human form, face thankfully intact, but the manoeuvre still costs him his life
and it isn’t actually enough to stop Christina. Instead she’s offed by Shelley,
who in turn is shot by the sheriff (not the deputy), rendering Peter’s not-inconsiderable
contribution of having his face mauled off pretty much irrelevant.
3. Lt. Blake - M*A*S*H
This
may be the most famous or infamous moment on this list, depending on your perspective,
and it’s one that still holds a place in the annals of television history.
Where many of the entries on here fell victim to melodramatic plot machinations
which aimed for tragedy but fell flat upon execution (we see you, The Walking
Dead and Hemlock Grove), and others aimed for dark comedy in their pointless
demises (shout out to You and Breaking Bad), M*A*S*H had another, more poignant
reason to kill off a character despite their heroic efforts.
For all of its warmth, the television adaptation of Robert Altman’s Korean War-set dramedy is an anti-war text, and one committed to highlighting the pointless brutality and inhumanity of conflict. It’s a metaphor rendered more pointed by the fact that the show aired as the Vietnam war drew to a close, and the criticisms the show makes of American imperialism abroad pretty transparently apply to both conflicts.
All
of which serves to make this death all the more understandable, if no less
devastating. After years of service, Lt. Blake is finally granted an honourable
discharge, prompting him to say his goodbyes to Hawkeye, Radar, and the rest of
the camp as he excitedly calls his wife and family at home. So Blake heads off,
free at last… Until the episode’s iconic closing line reveals that he died when
his plane was shot down over the sea of Japan.
2. American Horror Story - Misty Day
American
Horror Story could quite easily have filled this list alone, given the fact that
the horror anthology show has made a habit of offing every character, major and
minor, fan favourite and most hated, before each season’s closing credits roll.
Executive producer and Glee head honcho Ryan Murphy has a zeal for tossing all
and sundry off their mortal coil once they’ve fulfilled their narrative
usefulness, and no amount of heroism or just straight up bad-ass-ness can insulate
a character from the most unexpected, unwarranted, and straight up demeaning
deaths in the American Horror Story verse.
It’s difficult to pick the most egregious case, but the one which drew the most ire from the Internet will suffice. Misty Day was a deeply likeable character who was utterly tortured for no discernible reason, and the ignominious end of her character arc is inexcusable, particularly in a show where characters played by Emma Roberts frequently go on to survive.
First off poor Misty was burned alive for the crime of being a witch, and not in Salem either—in contemporary America. Luckily she was, as accused, a witch, and as such survived to tell the tale, but she’s nonetheless isolated from the world, only to be buried alive and die of starvation when integrated into the titular coven. But she’s resurrected!
And
ends up in her own personal hell, dissecting a frog on an eternal loop because—she
can’t pass some wizarding test or another?
1. You - Candace
Poor Candace. If ever there were a lesson in not relying on the power of sisterhood, Candace’s brutal fate in You’s second season has to qualify.
The presumed dead ex-girlfriend of the show’s psychotic protagonist, Candace is revealed to have been buried alive after a few cryptic references to her “moving to Italy” once she cheated on former Gossip Girl and current Patrick Bateman wannabe Joe. Unfortunately for him, Candace very much survived as more than just a figure haunting his troubled mind, and she’s out for ambitious revenge against the psycho killer.
Thus begins a season-long game of cat and mouse as Candace digs herself up, digs up the dirt necessary to prove Joe is the dangerous killer she knows him to be, ingratiates herself into his social circle over the course of some months, gets closer to the people he’s close to and finally has enough evidence to bring him to justice. Time to pull the trigger and kill the bastard, right?
Right—or, and hear me out here, why not bring his girlfriend down to the inescapable subterranean lair you’ve got him trapped in and tell her everything? After all, she can’t possibly be as crazy as him, right?
Guess some characters are best left buried, it would appear…