10 TV Characters You Forgot Were Recast

We're Team Original Night King over here.

game of thrones night king
HBO

Nowadays, because of streaming, recognising inconsistencies across TV shows is much easier, considering you're watching episodes and seasons back to back.

If a character is recast halfway through a run, it's pretty easy to spot the change in appearance when you've been watching nothing but that show for 5 days in a row.

But back before we binge-watched EVERYTHING we could get our hands on, it wasn't so easy to pick apart plot inconsistencies, set changes and, of course, actor switch-ups.

There are many reasons as to why character may get recast on their show. Maybe the actor manages to snag a more important role on a different series, or maybe beef behind the scenes causes the cast member to be ousted.

Maybe there was no drama at all and everything was all very amiable.

It's not just the lack of streamable content that prevented you from remembering these switches. Blame can also be lifted off of your shoulders because some casting directors managed to outdo themselves with occasionally awesome replacements, bringing actors in that make the role their own.

10. Jason DiLaurentis - Pretty Little Liars

pretty little liars Jason DiLaurentis
ABC

Pretty Little Liars took a while to find its footing. Season one and season two were strikingly different from each other. The tone stayed mostly the same but the drama definitely upped its ante, lots of new characters were brought in to beef up the series, and some of the smaller roles from the pilot season were given much more work to do.

One of the characters that ended up getting a new paint job, was the role of Jason DiLaurentis.

In the pilot series, Jason appeared in two episodes and was played by Parker Bagley. But due to the demand that was being placed on the character for season 2, the showrunners believed they needed a more capable actor to portray the preppy rich boy.

So ousted was Bagley, and Drew Van Acker was brought in due to his more impressive acting credits.

While this was a positive for Van Acker, this move seemed to be the cataclysm for Bagley's career. His last acting credit was from the same year he was replaced on PLL, and he was later arrested for larceny. And it is currently unknown whether or not Bagley has passed, due to various different reporting's online.


9. Mateo Solano Villanueva - Jane The Virgin

Jane the virgin mateo
The CW

When Jane The Virgin decided to do the age-old trope that is the time-jump, the show had to suddenly reconcile this decision with becoming a series that now hires child actors.

Sure, the pilot episode set them up to eventually have to go down this route, considering our main character Jane is artificially inseminated with a rich man's baby. But they could of escaped the child actor paradox if they had avoided moving up the timeline.

Nevertheless, the show's story was pre-planned out, the time-jump was inevitable, and so baby Mateo was subsequently aged to a terrible toddler; played by the adorable Joseph Sanders. Sanders played 4 year old Mateo, and portrayed him for the second half of season 3.

But when season 4 rolled around, Mateo suddenly looked... different. And as Jane The Virgin was always prepared to go meta, our beloved narrator warns us of the fact with a glib comment: "In Novellas, you must be prepared for change, after all".

Sanders was replaced by Elias Janssen, who had already played young Rafael on the show. Although fans were initially miffed by the recasting, Janssen did such a good job that everyone forgot that he hadn't originated the role!


8. The Night King - Game Of Thrones

night king game of thrones
HBO

You really cannot be blamed for not noticing this one.

The Night King was one of the most important villains on Game Of Thrones. He was the terrifying leader of the white walkers, one of the main character's biggest threats throughout the show's run, and the show's signature catchphrase "winter is coming", originates because of him.

The original Night King was played by Richard Brake through season 4 and 5, but was promptly swapped out with Vladimir Furdik in season 6. Furdik was known to Game Of Thrones already, having been one of their resident stunt performers and having played the first white walker that Jon Snow ever killed.

Not much is known about why the recasting took place, there is some lukewarm reporting that states it was due to Brake having "schedule conflicts" but nothing is really set in stone.

Who knows, maybe in a few years a story will come out that reframe the recasting in a more dramatic light. But for now, this one goes down in the history book as a mystery.


7. Jesus Adams Foster - The Fosters

Jesus The Fosters
Freeform

Noah Centineo... the dream of, what seems to be, every tween and teen at the moment. For most non-teens, Centineo appeared to blow up because of his role in the Netflix teen rom-com To All The Boys I've Loved Before. But he actually rose to fame on the drama show The Fosters.

Centineo played the adopted son of the couple and twin brother of Mariana, Jesus. Jesus had ADHD and was a passionate member of his school's wrestling team, until he was caught taking steroids.

Centineo played the character very believably, but you may not remember that he did not originate the role. The role actually went to Jake T. Austin in the beginning; Max from Wizards Of Waverly Place.

Jake was very endearing in the role, but left because his character was going to be severely cut down in season 3. There were whisperings that Austin left because he was tired of playing teenagers, but the actor shut down those rumours online.

But Austin didn't really go on to do much else after that, and people subsequently forget he'd ever appeared on the show. Especially in contrast to Centineo, who is pretty much EVERYWHERE at the moment.


6. Lily Tucker-Pritchett - Modern Family

Modern Family Jay Mitchell Lily
ABC

Adorable Lily Tucker-Pritchett was definitely one of the MVPs of Modern Family. As a baby she was the cutest member of the Tucker-Pritchett-Dunphy clan, when she grew to toddler status, Lily pulled out all the stops to ridicule and sass the older generations. And then, as she grew up to a preteen, her stoic attitude and odd nature became a running gag on the show.

But one thing about Lily that you probably forgot, was that for the first 2 seasons she was played by an entirely different actress than the Lily we all know and love; actually, TWO different actresses. Because before the incredible Aubrey Anderson-Emmons turned Lily into the legend she was, twins Ella and Jaden Hiller portrayed baby Lily.

It's not an unusual occurrence for Hollywood to cast twins in a single role when it comes to children, due to the long hours and demanding workload. What is unusual is the decision to recast the role and give it to a single actress, and for that actress to last for the rest of the show's run.

After all, Anderson-Emmons was only 4 years old when she snagged the role, and proceeded to grow up on the show.


5. Bobby Draper - Mad Men

Mad Men Sally Bobby Draper
AMC

During the run of Mad Men, there were a total of EIGHT different Bobby Drapers.

Four only appeared in one episode, like asleep Bobby in the pilot or "buckethead Bobby" who was in one scene and was made to wear a bucket on his head.

But the one change that we will focus on here is the switch from Jared Gilmore to Mason Vale Cotton. Vale Cotton was the 4th and final Substantial Bobby, and the Bobby that fans remember. But now, he isn't the most famous of The Bobby's.

Fan's of the hit fairy-tale show Once Upon A Time may be familiar with the former Bobby, Jared Gilmore, as he played the adorable lead character Henry in the show. But those fans probably didn't know that Gilmore left Mad Men to star on OUAT.

Perhaps if that opportunity hadn't come around for Gilmore, he would have stayed in the role until Mad Men's finale. But I'd wager that Van Cotton counts his lucky stars that Gilmore left for greener pastures.

At the end of the day, both boys managed to make the big time, and there are definitely no sore losers in this scenario.


4. Aunt Viv - Fresh Prince Of Bel-Air

Fresh prince aunt viv
NBC

Will Smith was at the top of the world, he was the star of the most popular sitcom of the time, he had a budding rapping career and was the crush of so many 90s teens. And with all that success, comes a whole lot of narcissism.

While everything seemed to be going swimmingly on screen, there was drama brewing behind the scenes of The Fresh Prince. Coming into its fourth season, it was announced that the actress Janet Hubert, who played Will's aunt on the show, would be replaced with a new actress: Daphne Maxwell Reid.

From there the drama naturally boiled over. Smith went onto a radio show at the time to slander the actress, which led Hubert to accuse Smith of being the one to get her fired. And that seemed to be the story behind her character's recasting for a very long time.

It wasn't until The Fresh Prince Reunion in 2020, that the two seemingly made up and discussed how BOTH of them played a part in the actress' departure and that, more than anything, the studio's handling of Hubert's pregnancy was what really put the nail in the coffin for her.


3. Kaitlin Cooper - The O.C

kaitlin the oc
Fox

When you think of Kaitlin Cooper from The O.C, you probably picture the rebellious teenager that smoked pot and wore far too much eyeliner, played expertly by Willa Holland. You probably don't associate that name with the portray of Kaitlin as the adorable, horse riding, rich girl; played by Shailene Woodley.

Woodley was arguably quite forgettable in the role, turning up only a few times, and usually just to do the same old thing over and over again. The character was then promptly sent off to boarding school in season 2, and then when she came back she was all grown up and completely different.

It may seem, that the actresses were swapped first and then the storylines were created to better suit Holland. When really, the writers developed the character into a "bad girl" that had "grown up" a lot while away, and then the decision was made to bring in an actress more suitable for that description.

And although Woodley was only a few months younger that Holland, Woodley said "they needed a girl with a body" and that she "was a late bloomer". Which is genuinely gross when you think about it, considering the girls were only 14 at the time.


2. Robin Hood - Once Upon A Time

once upon a time robin hood
ABC

In shows like Once Upon A Time, where so many characters come and go, not a lot of thought is put into casting small, one-episode-arc actors. So, when season 2 came along, a Belle-centric episode saw the introduction of Robin Hood as a prisoner of the merciless Rumpelstiltskin.

The character was only supposed to join the show for that episode and so casting directors didn't see the need to check actor's schedules when casting the show and instead went for a sort-of-well-known-actor instead. They cast Merlin's Tom Ellis as the dashing hero and he played well with the likes of Robert Carlyle.

But when season 3 rolled around they introduced Hood once again. And most viewers, that weren't avid fans of Tom Ellis, nothing really seemed amiss. You see, back when Once was airing, you couldn't stream the show and because it had been a while since Hood's first and very minor appearance, fans understandably didn't notice the switch.

And look, the casting of incredibly handsome Sean Maguire was pretty distracting, not to mention his incredible chemistry with actress Lana Parrilla had fans sold on his casting of Robin Hood, so you can be excused.


1. Reggie Mantle - Riverdale

Reggie riverdale
Netflix

Fans of the Archie Comics were understandably excited when Asian-American actor Ross Butler was cast as beloved character, Reggie Mantle.

The year was 2017 and Butler had landed two coveted roles in two highly anticipated teen shows, Riverdale and 13 Reasons Why. Butler managed to work his schedule expertly, weaving his way through two (admittedly quite similar) characters and learning all his lines.

But when both show were picked up for a second season, Butler had a difficult choice to make. Because, even though he'd managed to pull it off before, Butler did not think he could fit both shows into his blooming acting schedule. And since 13 Reasons Why offered Butler a sweeter deal with more screen time, he obviously leant that way.

So Riverdale had to recast, and while people debated anyone could fill the hunky shoes of one Reggie Mantle, the casting director seemed to get it right the second time round too, some may say they may have even upgraded. Because the world SWOONED over the new Reggie, played by Charles Melton.

Arguably, Melton could be considered the more successful one of the two now, considering Melton has gone on to become a teen rom-com star.


Contributor

Lily thought it was about time she wrote Top Ten lists for people other than herself. She also owes her dog a lot of money so she thought it was about time to pay her dues. There is no tv show she likes that she hasn't seen at least twice.