10 TV Finales That Messed With Your Brain

Life On Mars, St Elsewhere and Lost really ended with a WTF...

St Elsewhere Ending
NBC

People become personally invested in shows on TV, far more so than they do movies. TV shows, after all, are experienced in your own home. The characters and the situations they find themselves in are consumed alongside our meals, and we flick on our favourites as comfort food when we’re sad, sick, insomniac or sheltering from outrageous weather.

That’s why we react so strongly to the finales of the shows we watch: even the TV we’re not that passionate about is TV we’ve let into our homes once a week for anything from a few months to half our lives.

But TV finales can be strange, changeable beasts. Usually, they’re pretty predictable. There’s the wrap-up finale, beloved of sitcoms, where the main characters move on, move away, get married or get closure. There’s the resolution finale, where story arcs converge and characters collide for the final time, resolving plot threads and offing antagonists.

And then there’s the WTF finale: the one where they give you the opposite of what anyone sane would expect, breaking your brain, leaving you desperate to discuss it with someone… provided you can pick your jaw up off the floor first.

This article is dedicated to the series finales that made you throw chips and dips at the TV and leap at the internet with the caps lock on. And of course, here be spoilers…

10. Battlestar Galactica - ‘Daybreak’

Battlestar Galactica Ending
SyFy

Critically acclaimed from the beginning, Ronald D. Moore’s grim, ferociously topical update of late seventies Star Wars rip-off Battlestar Galactica felt like a modern classic from the word go.

On the verge of extermination by the artificial intelligences they created, the last of the human race escapes the genocide to search for a new home in the stars. So far, so identical to the high-camp original: but Moore’s version, tightly plotted and light on fluff, debated ideas of politics, revolution, and the nature of the soul. Buck Rogers, it was not.

As the series progressed, it began to change shape, the alluring mystique of the high concept devolving into oblique mysticism positing an Orphic take on spirituality: unless they could break the pattern, humans were doomed to repeat a ‘grievous circle’ of events over thousands of years.

‘Daybreak’, a three part capstone to that elaborate narrative, doubled down on the cod-religious shenanigans, substituting vagueness and a deus ex machina ellipsis for anything resembling closure. The audience felt cheated, and they had been: because no one expected the show they’d been watching for four years to end 150,000 years further in the future... in 21st century New York.


9. Mork And Mindy - ‘Gotta Run’

Mork And Mindy Reunion Ftr
CBS

Famous for starting the career of the legendary Robin Williams, Mork & Mindy spun off the titular alien oddball’s guest spot on fifties nostalgia fest Happy Days to bring US audiences of the late seventies and early eighties the fish-out-of-water adventures of the happy-go-lucky Mork and his long-suffering human bestie Mindy.

By the fourth season, the formula had grown incredibly stale and the writing was on the wall, leading us to the three part climax ‘Gotta Run’ and legitimately the weirdest ever ending to a cheesy multi-camera sitcom.

By now married with a kid, the pair are befriended by Kalnik, another alien who’s also married to an earthling named Tracy, but eventually suspect his true intentions and find he’s there to kill them both. Tracy is revealed to be a bomb (!) and explodes, destroying Mindy’s home and sending them on the run.

To escape the assassin, the family vanish into a time vortex but don’t arrive where they’re supposed to. The final shot is a prehistoric cave painting showing the two of them standing, gazing at the sunset.

Without a season five renewal, that would have been the last anyone saw of the show, so post-cancellation, quick-thinking producers rejigged the broadcast order to have an innocuous, formulaic episode round off the series, never explaining what had happened or how things got back to normal again. Which, of course, made things so much worse.


8. 12 Monkeys - ‘The Beginning’

12 Monkeys
Syfy

Terry Matalas, co-creator and showrunner of Syfy’s brilliantly realised adaptation of Terry Gilliam’s warped time travel tragedy 12 Monkeys, never gave viewers an easy out or a quick fix to figuring out all the convoluted temporal twists going on in his show, and the finale, which he wrote and directed, doesn’t deviate from the established pattern.

Throughout the show, we follow James Cole’s attempts to prevent a worldwide catastrophe caused by the release of a virus by terrorists called the Army Of The Twelve Monkeys. In the finale - entitled, appropriately enough for a series based on paradox and circularity, ‘The Beginning’ - they decide that the only way to unravel all the horrendously complex plot developments and actually save the world is to erase Cole from time itself, producing a complete reset.

And this happens: Cole and the Army never exist, the virus is never released and the world is saved. But then Cole reappears, reunited with his lover Cassie at their old farmhouse home as if nothing has happened. He’d been reinserted into an alternate timeline to live out his life - but as the camera pans away, we see the leaves of a nearby tree turning red, signifying that he’s a temporal anomaly…

As ominous cliffhangers go, Twelve Monkeys is a headf*ck, given the reassuring ‘reset button’ ending we’d just experienced, which - deus ex machina though it may be - was as good a way as any of cutting the Gordian knot of a time travel plot. Cole sacrificed himself to save time itself, right? So why was he saved to place everything and everyone in peril once more?


7. Life On Mars - ‘Life Is A Rock’

Life On Mars Us Cast
ABC

For the purposes of this article, it’s important to note that there are two similar but distinctly different versions of Life On Mars: the original UK version, starring John Simm and Philip Glenister, and the US remake, starring Jason O’Mara and the legendary Harvey Keitel.

Both versions feature modern day police detective Sam Tyler, who is hit by a car and wakes up in 1973 to find himself with a life, an identity and a career with the police of that time period. Both versions see Tyler struggle to come to terms with his situation while contrasting his more modern, enlightened methods of detective work with those of Gene Hunt, his immediate superior, a crass, corrupt old school copper.

The original Life On Mars left that ambiguity in place at the finale, and only actually resolved the mystery in the sequel series, Ashes To Ashes, which saw a new police detective wake up in 1981 with the same supporting cast and the same dilemma. The creators of the US Life On Mars, however, were clearly keen to put a little distance between themselves and their source material, opting for a completely different resolution of the mystery.

Is he mad, in a coma or back in time? Well, no. He’s an astronaut, in hibernation on the first manned mission to Mars, with a computer system that, Matrix style, recreates VR dreams for its sleeping passengers. In one of the most anticlimactic endings to a show in recent memory, it was revealed that it had been a glitch in the program that had led to Tyler’s moonage daydream of a life in 1973.


6. Dinosaurs - ‘Changing Nature’

Dinosaurs Tv
ABC

Rarely does a production team on a family TV show choose to go with such a brain meltingly downbeat finale as the one presented to the audience of puppet sitcom Dinosaurs in July 1994.

You’d think that a show that mined the same family dynamics as the Flintstones and the Simpsons would have ended on a nostalgic note, recapping the gently regressive humour that had helped the show to a full four seasons on a major network.

Instead, ABC doubled down on the often topical themes that Dinosaurs had presented to its audience over the years, introducing a climactic storyline whereby doofus dad Earl initiates a series of events that kill off the world’s plant life and allow poisonous clouds to blot out the sun, bringing on an ice age.

Now, it’s possible that the kids watching the show - who had Dinosaurs merchandise, and had turned Baby Sinclair’s cutesy dialogue into ubiquitous catchphrases - wouldn’t have been aware of the cataclysm that wiped the dinosaurs from the face of the earth - so just to make sure, the writers laid it all out on the table for them.

Earl tries to explain the situation to his kids: to apologise for not looking after the planet that was left in his care, and to admit to them that they no longer had a future because of his shortsightedness. The camera pulls back from the window to reveal the Sinclair home partially buried in ice and snow, and we cut to the weatherman intoning a forecast for “continued snow, darkness and extreme cold. Good night. Goodbye.”

Jesus, that’s cold.


5. Camping - ‘Episode 6’

Camping HBO
HBO

If Camping had simply remained the kind of repellent, fascinating, deeply unpleasant pitch-black comedy that creator, writer and director Julia Davis had made her name with, it would have been bad enough.

The series centres on a camping trip organised around timid doormat Robin’s fiftieth birthday by his overbearing, spiteful wife Fiona. When the rest of the guests arrive - boorish alcoholic Adam, his chirpy partner Kerry and his constantly masturbating teenage son, plus d*ckhead Tom and his party monster girlfriend Fay (played by Davis herself) - the scene is set for the worst weekend away in all recorded history.

The mediocre US adaptation of Camping leaves it there, but Davis - the black widow of British comedy - had more in store for us. Campsite owner Noel (a twitchy, muttering Mark Heap) has a few dark secrets tucked away behind the net curtains of the nearby house, including a mother with an unspecified illness that requires him to hose down several pairs of her enormous, stained underwear every morning.

The final episode veers sharply into horror, with the cast spectacularly trashed on Fay’s cheap ketamine and booze and having horrible sex with one another in various combinations, while Noel - whose mother appears to have literally sh*t herself to death - runs around the dark campsite, naked and aroused.

In escaping from him, Fiona backs her car into Tom, who’s left to the cavorting Noel’s terrifying ministrations. In the morning, everyone leaves with the exception of Tom (who’s nowhere to be seen) and Fay, who wakes on Noel’s sofa to notice dried blood around his fingernails...


4. Lost - ‘The End’

Lost Ending Jack Death
ABC

From the beginning, Lost presented a twin narrative: a present-day storyline featuring the survivors of Oceanic Flight 815 and the mysterious island they crashed upon, and a series of flashbacks intended to reveal more about their backstories and motivations. Around the middle of the series, the show began employing flashforwards instead, radically changing the dynamic of the show and keeping everyone at home on their toes.

Then, in season six, Lost changed the rules yet again, showing us a parallel storyline that this time didn’t seem to be in the past or the future. Featuring the same characters from the present day timeline in what seemed to be some form of alternate universe, the ‘flash-sideways’ narrative kept viewers guessing for months until ‘The End’ finally revealed what was going on... to screams of outrage from viewers.

The ‘flash-sideways’ arc was a form of Limbo, existing outside of time. Every major character in Lost’s history had been brought back together after their various deaths (some during the present day story arc, others years or even decades later) to reconnect with one another and reach some form of closure with their lives, before moving on to whatever was next.

It made sense: Lost was a show about a mysterious island in the same way that Breaking Bad was a show about chemistry. Built around the fundamentals of Lost’s compassionate mysticism and show-don’t-tell style, ‘The End’ was a moving character piece, not an explanation of all of the island’s mysteries.

Those who properly understood Lost loved ‘The End’. Unfortunately, it seemed that plenty of the show’s audience hadn’t been paying attention to the show they were watching.


3. The Prisoner - ‘Fall Out’

The Prisoner
ITV

Just as Lost’s finale doubled down on the themes it had been pursuing all along, so January 1968’s finale to the groundbreaking psychological thriller The Prisoner also danced with the girl it brought to the party, dissecting ideas of collectivism versus individualism while delivering a tense study in surreal existential dread.

Unfortunately, the plot of ‘Fall Out’ - rebellious former spy Number Six has resisted all attempts by Number Two, head of sinister deprogramming camp The Village, to brainwash him and find out why he resigned his post, leading to a last ditch gambit to break our hero’s will - was layered with obscure symbolism and imagery, and no one understood it.

The weird mind games the series had devoted itself to took the next step to proper head*ck territory, and the result is still controversial to this day. Back in early 1968, public pressure to explain the events of the climactic episode was so strong that the series’ lead actor and driving creative Patrick McGoohan was forced to go into hiding.

Is the bizarre ritual Number Six is co-opted into really a ceremony to initiate him into The Village’s secrets, or just another way to mess with his head? Is Number Two really killed by his own superiors and revived, and is he really on Number Six’s side after this? Why is ‘Number One’s face identical to Number Six under that gorilla mask, and do they really escape to return home at the end?

To this day, very few people have managed to get their heads around it.


2. Twin Peaks - ‘Part 18’

Twin Peaks BOB Cooper
ABC

It’s kind of sweet that many people assumed that the long awaited third season of David Lynch’s complex supernatural thriller/small town murder mystery/primetime soap opera would resolve the show’s dangling plot threads in a way that made sense to them. What part of Twin Peaks (or indeed, most of Lynch’s creative output) would make them think that?

True to form, season three - also known as ‘The Return’ - swam deep into the murky, batsh*t crazy end of the Lynch swimming pool, presenting us with more esoteric, arcane symbolism and events obscured by elliptical storytelling. Even the exposition and backstory revelations were heavily layered with hidden meaning.

The result was infinitely watchable for devotees of Lynch’s storytelling style/mania, but utterly incomprehensible for literally everyone else in the world.

How many Agent Cooper doppelgangers were released into the world? Why is BOB now a floating orb? Why is the Arm (formerly The Man From Another Place) now the Evolution Of The Arm? Why… you know what, there are more questions than we have space for here.

The important thing to remember about Twin Peaks is that it will always pose more questions than it answers; it will never provide closure; and it will always be brilliant, audacious, terrifying, groundbreaking television to be experienced, rather than understood.


1. St. Elsewhere - ‘The Last One’

St Elsewhere Ending
NBC

Shaping the television landscape in the 1980s and paving the way for medical dramas like E.R., Chicago Hope and Grey’s Anatomy, St. Elsewhere also boasts the most bizarre series finale of all time: one that divided cast and crew when they were making it and the show’s entire audience when it was broadcast.

In the final minutes, the scene cuts from snow-covered urban teaching hospital St. Eligius - the setting for all 6 seasons and 137 episodes - to a room in an apartment building. Tommy, supposedly the autistic son of Dr. Donald Westphall, one of the show’s central characters, is playing with a snowglobe. His father, a construction worker, comments that he wishes he knew what his son was thinking about… and the camera zooms in to the snowglobe, revealing a perfect replica of the snow-covered St. Eligius inside.

The implication was that the entire show - every character, every storyline - had been the introspective daydream of an imaginative autistic teenager. That was audacious enough, and blew viewers minds when it was first broadcast in 1988.

The thing is, in the last three decades those implications have expanded… because, like many other network TV shows, St. Elsewhere crossed continuities and characters with other shows being broadcast, which in turn crossed over with other shows… all of which were also now revealed to be figments of Tommy’s imagination.

Today, they call it the Tommy Westphall Universe, and it encompasses at least 419 American television shows, including classics like M*A*S*H*, Cheers, Columbo, Friends and Doctor Who, everything in the Criminal Minds, NCIS, CSI and Star Trek franchises, and even modern day TV like 24, Breaking Bad and The Walking Dead.

Now that messes with your brain.


Watch Next


In this post: 
st. elsewhere
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.