10 TV Mistakes You Can’t Unsee
Upside phones, unexplained wedding rings, and Michael Scott's invisibility...
It happens to the best of shows (and Pretty Little Liars)—every series has its dodgy mistakes, inevitable continuity errors, and momentary mess ups which you can’t help but quirk an eyebrow at. Some of these fumbles may be minor, but sometimes the screw ups are so monumental that you can’t un-see them once they’re pointed out to you—and some are also so obvious that you may not even need them pointed out to you in the first place.
The errant Starbucks cup which showed up in the otherwise medieval milieu of Game of Thrones during its nail-biting final season is probably the most recent case of a TV mistake which millions were dumbfounded by, but there are also plenty of moments which may not be production errors but instead come from the scripting stage—characters who the writers room forgot about vanishing without explanation or unexplainable errors in shows whose period setting makes them easy to fact check.
Some creators laugh them off, some cite creative licence to get a free pass, and some are lucky enough never to have them pointed out, but here are ten television mistakes we couldn’t help noticing and now can’t un-see.
10. Ted’s (Not-So-) Dangerous Date - How I Met Your Mother
A beloved sitcom which managed to spoil its appeal with a disastrous finale, How I Met Your Mother was no stranger to huge mistakes. However, we’ve decided that “the entire finale” was too big a misstep to include on this list, so fans of the Josh Radnor starring series will have to be content with this smaller, stranger screw up featured in one of the shows best episodes.
During a date which serves to prove the show's resident womaniser Barney right about his "crazy eyes" theory, the show's luckless protagonist Ted is shocked when his until-now normal paramour grabs a metal pole and plants it through the windshield of a car which almost bumped into them. Watch closely though—a moment after she smashes the windshield, she takes another swing at what is clearly a miraculously whole and undamaged windshield.
It may be a minor enough screw up, but it’s still one which jars with the viewer upon a rewatch—which is particularly unfortunate given that this’s widely agreed to be one of the shows most critically acclaimed outings.
9. The Origin of BOB - Twin Peaks
Now, this one is better than most TV screw ups, since not only will you never be able to un-see it, in classic David Lynch fashion, it actually manages to be a rare mistake which makes the series it features in more comprehensible and understandable—nifty trick from the Lost Highway helmer.
When crew member Frank Silva accidentally ended up in a shot of screaming Mrs. Palmer as she’s besieged by some (theoretically) unseen force, this set fans speculating as to who the barely glimpsed mystery man in the reflection was. Of course, he was no one—Silva simply hadn’t had time to vacate the room before filming began and was never meant to be visible.
But this happy accident set the show’s creator thinking, and thus Silva was asked to return and embody BOB—the infamously terrifying antagonist of the season.
Initially a fun coincidence, this mistake took on some new significance when the series finale of Twin Peaks revealed, some twenty five years later, that the show’s protagonists had ended up stranded in our reality—a reveal already hinted at by the fact that Silva’s screw up already altered the fabric of the show’s universe years earlier.
What a headf***
8. Early Guns, Late Medical Expertise - Penny Dreadful
Penny Dreadful was never overly concerned with historical accuracy—after all, being a steamy gothic mystery built around the promise of sex and Victorian violence will do that to a show. Nonetheless the series managed by and large to be a bit more believable than the intentionally anachronistic likes of, for example, 2004’s Van Helsing or 2011’s Hansel and Gretel Witch Hunters, a disastrous misfire which diagnoses diabetes a few centuries before the medical establishment caught up.
Speaking of the medical establishment, though, season two’s instalment Verbis Diablo features Sir Malcolm advising a character visiting a cholera sufferer it wear a facemask—despite the fact that this series is set circa 1880, when it was not only accepted science but common knowledge for over thirty years that the disease was contracted from spoiled food rather than fellow sufferers.
Soon in the same episode, the cast make up for their outdated medical views when one of their number wields a Mauser C96 Broomhandle—a gun which wouldn’t become available for purchase until a full five years after the episode was set.
7. Michael Scott, Invisible Man - The Office
None of us want to roast the
beloved US sitcom institution The Office when this NBC behemoth brought us so
many laughs and tears over the years—and also gave us those two post-Steve
Carrell seasons for some reason. But as great as the cult series and its ensemble
cast was, the show did manage to commit one cardinal sin that guaranteed its
inclusion on this list—featuring a glaring screw up in its very first episode.
Yes, way back in 2005, the pilot of The Office featured the first onscreen face-off between Michael Scott and his boss/ on-off love interest the ice queen Jan, and the pair argued spiritedly in his office whilst his employees Jim and Dwight sat outside watching—well, nothing in particular, because numerous wide shots during this scene reveal that Michael’s office is actually empty.
The portions of the episode were presumably filmed separately, which isn’t uncommon practice in shows with such a large cast, but gives the scene a weirdly Beckettian feel we’re pretty sure wasn’t intentional.
6. Dr. Marr's Tricorder Troubles - Star Trek: The Next Generation
Okay, yes, it would have been some easy to pluck low
hanging fruit if we were to pop any of the many mistakes from the original Star
Trek series on this list, particularly when the show was infamous despite its quality
for having numerous unfortunately naff gaffes throughout its run.
But Gorn and his rubber suit belong on a meaner spirited iteration of this list, so instead of mocking some poor production designer’s best efforts, we’re taking the high road and roasting some poor actors for failing to use their imaginary technology correctly.
In this infamous instance, it’s poor Dr. Marr of The Next Generation who is falling under our critical eye for a pivotal emotional scene wherein she informs Data of her dead son whilst out on a mission—and the good doctor must be getting emotional, because that would be the only logical explanation for the fact that she’s clearly holding her tricorder upside down whilst trying to use it in this scene.
5. M*A*S*H To The Future - M*A*S*H
The long running TV adaptation of Robert Altman’s satirical wartime black comedy may have one of the medium’s best finales to date, but like all shows it did drop the ball on occasion when it came to onscreen mistakes. Most of these mess-ups were largely inconsequential, but one flub later in the series managed to skip by set dressers and editors alike and man did it mess up the series chronology as a result.
You see, the show is set during America’s war with Korea, which predates the escalation of their invasion of Vietnam by a decade. So, when a stray magazine in one bunk mentions “The other war in Vietnam”, it’s talking about a war which hasn’t happened yet according to MASH’s timeline, but it make matters worse the show often not so subtly used the Korean War setting as an analogy with the ongoing Vietnam quagmire.
As a result, this headline is talking the same issues the show’s writers tackled—only in doing so it’s revealing that the series is actually taking place in the present, rather than the fifties it’s attempting to pass for
Come on, Alda—Altman would never have let that slip.
4. Waylon Smither’s Changing Colour – The Simpsons
This one is pretty famous, but it’s jarring enough for new viewers that we had to include it here. Yes, Matt Groening’s iconic family sitcom The Simpsons may be the greatest achievement in TV history and amongst the most impressive artistic endeavours of the entire last century (even if you do stop watching after season nine/ ten/ eleven), but even America’s first family aren’t above some simple errors, and when they make a mistake boy is it a big one.
It was years before viewers had it confirmed for them that Mr. Burn’s lackey assistant Waylon Smithers was actually gay, in what was an impressive moment for LGBTQ+ representation in animation. But years earlier, the character had originally been black, rather than the yellow of The Simpsons brood.
It’s hardly an animation error as Groening claims when the beloved likes of Dr. Hibert, Carl, and Lou are all black characters on the same show, but it’s easy enough to chalk this one up to a change in character design early in the series—though it’s still strange to see an unrecognizable iteration of the now well-known figure early on.
3. Phoebe’s Running (Is Caused By Her Microphone) – Friends
Friends has never been too hot with its continuity, as we noted before when we roasted the show for its use of some, er, questionable body doubles—just check out our run down of shoddy body doubles for an Elliot Gould stand-in who looks more like Eugene Levy. Hell, the show even wrote in one of the actor’s mistakes as an iconic moment, when David Schwimmer accidentally called his fictional fiancée Emily “Rachel” and inspired the wedding day bombshell dropped by his character Ross.
But this mistake is particularly galling given that it comes during not only an iconic bit of physical comedy, but it’s unmistakeably centred around the actor you’re meant to be watching. When Phoebe takes Rachel running in the very public environs of Central Park only for her goofy gait to put her long-suffering friend off being seen with her, the joke is meant to leave us laughing at Lisa Kudrow’s ungainly sprint.
But a close look reveals that viewers can clearly see a large, unmissable microphone battery pack protruding from the actor’s back—a textbook error which leaves the scene looking even sillier than intended.
2. Mulder’s Marriage - The X-Files
The slowly smouldering will-they won’t-they chemistry between Gillian Anderson’s straight-laced sceptic Scully and David Duchovny’s more open-minded Mulder kept the mystery of The X-Files alive throughout the series’ now-ten season run (yes, we’re including the revival, feel free to fight in the comments). When the show’s alien-based conspiracy arc fell flat or hit a dead end, at least Mulder and Scully’s on-and-off romantic entanglement was there to keep viewers hooked.
That is, until a season five episode saw Duchovny’s heroic protagonist wearing an inexplicable wedding ring, owing to the fact that the actor had recently gotten married in real life. Eagle-eyed fans immediately noticed and the creators essentially shrugged off the implications of this development, saying—maybe Mulder was married before? Maybe that’s also part of his tragic backstory? Maybe who knows?
Who could have seen a disappointing ending coming from this crew of scribes? It truly beggars belief that the eventual series finale was a widely derided dud.
1. Aria’s Phone - Pretty Little Liars
If there were one rule for TV mistakes it really ought to be that whatever about subsequent instalments, shows should be able to avoid obvious errors for the duration of their pilot episode at least. However, another cardinal rule is don’t include 3oh!3’s hit Don’t Trust Me unless you want to immediately date your show, so Pretty Little Liars was already adept at breaking these rules in its first episode.
Yes, the pilot of this mega-popular teen mystery introduced us to future Fantasy Island star Lucy Hale as Aria, one of four protagonists stalked by the unseen A as penance for some unknown misdemeanour in their murky recent past. And A plagues the kids across all manner of tech, from instant messages on laptops, to anonymous handwritten notes, to their phones—which Aria answers upside down in the first episode, a jarring error which is impossible to un-see once someone points out the flagrantly obvious screw up.
It’s in a close up for God’s sake! And it’s not even a brief shot!