10 TV Show Scenes With INSANE Implications

These single scenes left so much unsaid and unseen.

Buffy The Vampire Slayer
CBS

The great benefit of TV shows over film is the comparatively gigantic storytelling canvas they're afforded, allowing creatives to tell deeper stories with a huge cast of characters the audience comes to know intimately.

But with such a potentially rich storytelling tapestry across many seasons, shows also have to be very careful with what they show and tell, because putting a single foot wrong can cause the entire house of cards to collapse.

Given that most popular TV shows are gigantic machines powered by a room full of writers, perfect consistency is basically impossible, and sometimes writers bring ideas to the table that end up having wider implications far beyond the immediate.

And that's absolutely the case with these 10 scenes from hit TV series, each of which made some completely wild suggestions despite how abruptly they were brushed off or even flat-out ignored by the show itself.

If you stop and think about what these scenes are saying for even just a minute, it's clear that they would've had a tectonic impact on each show's world and the characters residing within it...

10. The Ageing Pills - Oz

Oz Cyril
HBO

Despite being one of the grittiest and most uncompromisingly bleak depictions of prison life in TV history, HBO's Oz introduced a storyline in its fourth season so ridiculous as to border on sci-fi.

In an attempt to battle overcrowding at Oswald State Correctional Facility, the top brass organise an experiment, whereby inmates with longer sentences can agree to take a drug which accelerates the physical ageing process in exchange for shorter prison sentences.

The storyline proved wildly unpopular with fans, who felt it was too ridiculous and outlandish for a show documenting the realities of incarceration in the United States.

As such, the pill subplot was abruptly dropped by the fifth season, no matter that such a drug's mere existence would've had some serious ramifications in the wider sphere.

First and foremost, a pill capable of rapidly expediting the ageing process would almost certainly end up in the hands of more nefarious parties in the outside world.

But more optimistically, it would also tell us a lot more about the nature of ageing and, as a result, potentially make it easier for anti-ageing drugs to also be developed.

For reasons both good and bad, the ageing pill would've been a huge deal, yet Oz strangely paints it as a relatively ordinary, contained experiment.


9. A Nuke Goes Off In Valencia - 24

24 Jack Bauer
Fox

Though 24 first detonated a nuclear bomb in its second season, in that case it was at least exploded in the remote expanse of the Mojave desert, where it would cause an extremely low number of casualties.

But season six seriously upped the ante - or, depending on your viewpoint, jumped the shark - when a smaller-yield nuke was detonated in the Valencia neighbourhood of Santa Clarita, California, causing the deaths of at least 13,000 people.

Even six seasons into 24, it's a totally shocking moment, and yet the show rather oddly downplayed its impact in the episodes that followed, going out of its way to show Californians going about their day like nuclear fallout isn't a thing.

Consider that the attack's body count was more than four-fold the death toll of 9/11 - not counting those who died later - it would've had a tectonic impact on California, the United States, and really the entire world.

And yet, in both the rest of the season and the show as a whole, it's regarded as a triviality. The wider Los Angeles area would've descended into abject chaos and the incident would've impacted global society and politics for decades.


8. Rhodey Is A Skrull - Secret Invasion

Secret Invasion Rhodey
Disney+

Secret Invasion was a wildly polarising show for many reasons, not least that it revealed that James Rhodes (Don Cheadle) was replaced by a Skrull agent.

When the imposter is killed and the real Rhodey is rescued at the ending of the show, he simply mentions that he was imprisoned by the Skrulls for a "long time."

Naturally this left fans to speculate on precisely how long Rhodey had been a Skrull, while the show's director Ali Selim later insinuated that he was most likely one since Captain America: Civil War.

This revelation caused major discontent among MCU fans because of its most disappointing suggestion, that the Rhodey who was with Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr.) during his final moments in Avengers: Endgame was nothing more than a fake.

Knowing that Rhodey has been an imposter for so long significantly reshapes how audiences will view the events of Civil War and beyond.

Though to the same token, don't be surprised if a future MCU project - most likely Armor Wars - retcons/clarifies that Rhodey wasn't snatched until the events of The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, even if only to appease pissed-off fans.


7. Warp Travel Damages Space - Star Trek: The Next Generation

Star Trek: The Next Generation
Paramount

Maintaining consistency in a fictional universe as sprawling as Star Trek can't be easy, and it gets even tougher when standalone episodes introduce concepts which have major implications for the franchise as a whole.

Case in point, The Next Generation's season seven episode "Force of Nature" has a pair of scientist siblings reveal that warp drive travel is actually damaging the very fabric of space itself.

By the episode's ending, all Federation vessels are limited to a speed of warp five unless in major emergencies, and this message has also been spread to every known species capable of warp travel.

Though the episode was basically a thinly veiled environmentalist commentary, it fundamentally altered warp travel in Star Trek. And yet, save for a few fleeting mentions in TNG's remaining episodes, it's basically been forgotten.

Sure, Star Trek: Voyager introduced a ship with moving warp nacelles which wouldn't cause damage to space, but by and large, Trek's creatives clearly hoped fans would just quietly forget about something that would've changed space travel forever.


6. Greendale's Gas Leak - Community

Community Annie
NBC

After Community's fourth season proved wildly divisive with fans due to the absence of the show's creator Dan Harmon, the fifth season - which saw Harmon return to the fold - offered up a hilarious explanation for the wacky storylines and out-of-character moments throughout the prior season.

In the season five premiere, Annie (Alison Brie) briefly mentions that there was a gas leak at Greendale Community College last year, in turn suggesting that all the absurd behaviour the season prior was due to everyone being mentally impaired by the gas.

Though the audience isn't expected to linger on the line beyond a quick wink-wink laugh, it does nevertheless cause one to consider how an apparently year-long gas leak would've impacted the wider student body at Greendale.

There must've been so many insane, out-of-character things happening to anyone who frequented the establishment, potentially altering people's lives forever as relationships broke down and people made very rash, over-the-top decisions.

Also, prolonged exposure to leaking gas is likely to cause long-term, potentially lifelong neurological and other health issues, so there's that, not to mention the presumed lawsuit that followed.


5. Seven Bundy Goes Missing - Married... With Children

Married With Children Seven
Columbia

Married... with Children's seventh season attempted to change up the show's well-trod formula by introducing a new child character, Seven (Shane Sweet).

Peggy's (Katey Segal) cousins Zemus (Bobcat Goldthwait) and Ida Mae (Linda Blair) leave their son Seven with the Bundy family, who effectively informally adopt him from that point.

But Seven proved wildly unpopular with fans from the get-go, who simply felt that he didn't mesh with the established ensemble cast. And so, near the end of the season, he abruptly leaves, with the D'Arcy family briefly mentioning that he showed up at their house and won't leave.

That's all well and good, but in both seasons eight and nine, a milk carton can be briefly seen with a missing person's photo of Seven, suggesting that he's been kidnapped.

Seven being snatched is horrifying enough, but the fact that the Bundys don't seem even remotely concerned about this is something else altogether. Though clearly intended as more of a goofy Easter egg than anything else, if you stop and think about it, it's crazy.

Basically, it was better for the show to just accept that Seven was missing and nobody cared rather than slogging on with his continued existence no matter how much of an albatross he was around its neck.


4. Walt's Powers - Lost

Lost Walt
ABC

Lost is admittedly a show that left a ton of plot threads dangling when it concluded, but perhaps the most bizarre and meaningful of the lot? Walt (Malcolm David Kelley) having powers.

In the first season episode "Special," it's suggested that Walt possesses the ability to manifest animals from his mind, with both a bird and a polar bear appearing basically out of nowhere.

Fans understandably expected this to have a serious payoff down the line, yet because Walt actor Malcolm David Kelley's appearance changed substantially during production - puberty being a thing and all - he was written out, due to the implausibility of his aging relative to Lost's compressed timeframe.

Beyond season two, Walt returned for just a few episodes, and fans never got to learn much more about his telepathic abilities, despite the initial suggestion that they would have a major impact on the plot.

And more to the point, if Walt is already this powerful at such a young age, what would his skill set look like as an adult in the world?


3. Caitlin Gets Trapped In The Future - Heroes

Heroes Caitlin
NBC

Heroes features one of the most maddeningly unresolved plot points of any TV show ever, when in its second season protagonist Peter Petrelli (Milo Ventimiglia) and his girlfriend Caitlin (Katie Carr) travel to the virus-obliterated post-apocalyptic New York City of the future.

When Peter returns to the present, Caitlin is inadvertently left in this wasteland of a future, and with Peter now unable to access his time-traveling powers, he can't go back to get her.

Though fans understandably assumed that this subplot would be picked up later in the season, the 2007-2008 WGA Writers Strike resulted in a majorly curtailed season two, ensuring that Caitlin's planned rescue never happened.

Instead, given that Peter does eventually prevent the future calamity, it's implied that Caitlin was more than likely erased from existence, as the future she was trapped in would never happen.

It's a horrifying suggestion for Caitlin's fate, and even worse when you consider that Peter doesn't seem particularly bothered about it, nor is she ever mentioned again for the remainder of the series.


2. Buffy Gets The Class Protector Award - Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Fox

Throughout Buffy's run, fans have often commented upon the fact that the residents of Sunnydale must be acutely aware of the supernatural shenanigans haranguing their town, and yet nobody ever talks about it.

But this was quite slyly addressed in the season three episode "The Prom," where Buffy (Sarah Michelle Gellar) wins the Class Protector award, with Sunnydale High's student body writing-in the award to thank her for protecting the school from monsters.

The scene lasts just a few minutes, but makes it clear beyond any doubt that Sunnydale's residents know about the horrors infesting their town, yet seem to have collectively agreed not to discuss it on a daily basis.

It can certainly be interpreted as a form of widespread denial, that everyone knows, at least subconsciously, what's going on in the town, but for the sake of their sanity they opt to put it to the back of their minds.

Sure, it's basically just hand-waving the fact that, in reality, nobody would ever stick around in Sunnydale - no matter how cheap the housing is - but it's certainly a unique odd and fascinating way of doing it.


1. Aidan Dumps Carrie - And Just Like That...

And Just Like That
HBO

Sex and the City's sequel series And Just Like That... kicked off with the sudden death of Carrie's (Sarah Jessica Parker) husband Mr. Big (Chris Noth), and in the recently aired second season, she rekindled her romance with Aidan Shaw (John Corbett) from years prior.

Carrie and Aidan previously broke up after Carrie had an affair with Big, and this baggage looms large over their newly resumed relationship, enough that Aidan won't even go in Carrie's apartment due to the unpleasant memories it invites.

Near the end of the season, Carrie sells said apartment and the pair plans to move into a townhouse to accommodate Aidan's sons, but once the ink has dried, one of Aidan's sons is involved in a DUI accident.

A guilt-riddled Aidan decides he needs to be there for his sons and so breaks things off with Carrie, moving back to Virginia and making a pact with Carrie to pick things up again in five years when his sons are adults.

This outcome was widely criticised by fans as a blatant, lazy attempt to inject more drama into Carrie's life and keep the show going, but it also invited a prominent and strangely believable fan theory, that the whole rekindled relationship was actually a revenge ploy by Aidan.

Whether consciously or not, many have surmised that Aidan teasing Carrie with a happy ending only to pull the rug out and make her wait another five years was basically a means of punishing her for cheating on him in the past.

It's certainly a more compelling implication than the writers simply having no better way to drive a dramatic wedge between them.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.