10 TV Shows That Would Have Been Better Off As Anthologies

With the success of True Detective's first season, which other TV shows might have benefitted from the anthology format?

Anthology-styled series have never been the primary go-to format for mainstream television shows, but with recent innovators like True Detective and American Horror Story proving both a ratings draw and confirming their staying power, it's a good bet that we'll be seeing more and more anthologies on mainstream TV and cable networks in the very near future. Using the anthology format allows for a complete reset of the series each year, and opportunities for new cast members and storylines not as easily afforded by the standard multi-season approach. Looking back, it's tempting to wish that the format had been embraced by some dearly departed shows... and even some that are still around. So here are 10 series that would have benefited from an anthology style approach, starting with...

10. Heroes

Let's kick things off with an easy choice: NBC's Heroes. News recently broke that the show will be returning next year in a revamped format (Heroes: Reborn), and that's sparked speculation that it may become what it should have been in the first place: an anthology series. The show's first season was a revelation: a well-plotted, engaging trip into a comic book universe that expanded with every episode. Eventually, however, the show tripped itself up with an overabundance of characters and numerous unbelievable twists designed to keep them all around. The central premise of the show never wore quite as thin as many of the characters did, though, and as such would work well to carry an anthology-style series. Think about it: Every season, a new dimension of the super-powered generation rising across the world could be explored. From New York to Chicago or LA, from London to Taipei and beyond - the world of Heroes would be nearly inexhaustible, and the shorter storytelling format would ease the struggle of balancing an overflowing roster of characters.

9. Once Upon A Time

Once Upon A Time is a great show, but it does have its issues. Chief among these is its slow shift to reliance on a small core cast of characters - Snow White, Charming, Rumpelstiltskin, and a few others. The show was at its most engaging and interesting when each episode introduced us to a new resident of the town, and the end of each story arc brought them together in unexpected ways. So, then, what if the show were to be presented as an anthology series? Each set of episodes introducing and focusing on a certain number of characters in one of the innumerable fairy tale worlds would help to keep the show fresh, and even draw in new viewers. Admittedly, it's not a foolproof plan. Once: Wonderland stumbled right out of the gate and chances of it sticking around for another season are slim. Yet, that show was treated and marketed more as a spinoff, rather than as its own separate entity. But Anthology seasons of the show, spent reinventing the fairy tales we all know, would have much more longevity. Once: Wonderland, Once: Neverland, Once: The Enchanted Forest... the list is nearly endless, and so are the stories that could be sprung from it.

8. Under The Dome

Based on the novel of the same name by Stephen King, Under The Dome is currently a staple of CBS' summer programming, slated to return for a second season this June. The show started promisingly, but ratings and reviews have steadily declined. The showrunners have stated that they hope for a solid five seasons to tell the complete story, which deviates in several major ways from King's 1,000+ page tome. The discussion here is less about the quality of Under The Dome and more about the choice to adapt it over some of King's other work. Rather than extending and changing one of King's longer books to fit the multi-season arc structure, why not adapt some of his novellas for an ongoing anthology series? For example: Full Dark, No Stars and Four Past Midnight, among others, provide the chance to delve into King's work and present a variety of stories all with the same name recognition attached. Even some of his shorter novels, such as The Girl Who Loved Tom Gordon, are ripe for adaptation in a limited series capacity. With the success of American Horror Story, it's not out of the realm of possibility for another anthology horror series to succeed on cable television or even a mainstream network.

7. The Killing

True Detective seems to have learned an important lesson from a similar precursor, The Killing. Namely, don't drag out what should be a one-season story across multiple years. The Killing began on AMC with enormous positive buzz, and was considered one of the best shows on television for some time during its first season. But then, the show took an enormous gut-punch with the reaction to its first season finale, which failed to resolve the major story arc of the season (the murder of Rosie Larsen). Subsequently, the show received as much, if not more, press for its continuous dance with cancellation and network shuffling than it did for actual content. This might have been a show where the definition of anthology series could be bent somewhat, by keeping some of the major characters around but presenting them with a new season-long case - or it might have succeeded by tying up the Larson storyline entirely, and moving on (as True Detective now is) to an entirely new set of stories and cast members.

6. How I Met Your Mother

Now, I'll be one of the first folks to defend HIMYM as it is - but I also think that the premise could work separate from the current cast of characters. So do the folks at CBS, judging from their pilot order for the Greta Gerwig fronted inversion of the show, How I Met Your Dad. Imagine the show as an anthology series where, rather than subjecting poor Ted Mosby to every relationship in the book, good or bad, we saw different lead characters experience aspects of the current show every season. And what about putting the characters into different settings as well each year? HIMYM is about New York almost as much as it's about the main characters - so imagine a version of the show in Chicago, or Los Angeles, or even a smaller town somewhere in New England or the Midwest? All relationships are different, and presenting the show as a comedy anthology could explore that almost endlessly.

5. Star Wars: The Clone Wars

I'm a massive Star Wars fan, and I'll admit to being excited to see the series expanding to television at first. And yet, it's frustrating to see the series so focused on a story to which we already know the conclusion: the relationship between Anakin Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi. This is especially true since there is so much Expanded Universe material to mine for new stories and characters already Of course, it's easy to understand why the network and showrunners stuck with their tried-and-true characters, especially in a series aimed at a younger audience - but that doesn't mean it isn't a missed opportunity in some ways. Imagine a Star Wars anthology series set during the Clone Wars, with each installment focusing on a different troop of clone soldiers or Jedi Knight(s). The Star Wars universe is vast, and not exploring the numerous possibilities of that universe is disappointing.

4. Glee

Here again is a show where the creative premise could have outlasted the initial cast. What began as a show about a high school glee club has (not always successfully) morphed into a completely different show, following characters to New York and beyond. I'm by no means an avid watcher of the show, but I don't begrudge the folks that are. When I did tune in, it was always for the music. That's why the series would work as an anthology - because the heart of the premise is the musical side of things. A musical show with a rotating cast of actors and voices could accomplish numerous things: not only would it keep the premise fresh, it would also provide avenues for theater actors and actresses to be exposed to a new audience (as Lea Michelle was when the show originally launched).

3. Joan Of Arcadia

Here we've got another show that worked well in its own right, but may have lasted longer and explored its premise even further with an anthology-style approach. Joan of Arcadia aired on CBS back from 2003-2005, and aside from popularising Joan Osborne's music via its theme song, the show told the story of Joan Girardi, a teenager who is visited by God in various guises. What made the show remarkable in terms of its spiritual nature was its ability to explore matters of faith and everyday life in realistic ways, without espousing a particular religion or ideology. Approaching a show like this one as an anthology would open the doors to all sorts of exploration of faith and religion in the world, and a rotating cast of characters would provide the chance to examine a huge variety of traditions, from Christianity to Buddhism, Islam, and beyond.

2. Dollhouse

From the mind of Joss Whedon, Dollhouse was yet another series that fell victim to the machinations of FOX network executives. Forced into a much more serialised, story-of-the-week format than originally planned by the creative team behind it, the show struggled through two thirteen-episode seasons before being cancelled. At the heart of the show were the moral dilemmas created by its central premise: 'dolls', or humans who consented to having their memories artificially implanted and removed, are rented out to various high paying customers. In the mythos of the show, there are numerous dollhouses scattered around the country and the world - which makes it an ideal candidate for an anthology series. Keeping the central premise of the Dollhouse, but shifting to a new locale with each season, would afford the chance for different characters and themes to be explored.

1. The Walking Dead

The Walking Dead is often hailed as one of the best shows on TV - and more often than not, I find myself asking, 'why?' With a hornet's nest of behind the scenes messes and showrunner changes, plus long stretches of lackluster episodes in each season, the series often staggers along as slowly as one of its rotting antagonists. With the show's (understandable) decision to deviate from the comics series in many ways, we might ask if they might have done better to simply set the show in the Walking Dead universe and cease the similarities there. A series where each installment focused on a different group of survivors during the zombie apocalypse might help keep the premise fresh and interesting, avoiding the steady series of ruts the show has found itself in during its run. With a spinoff series set to premiere sometime in the next few years, it's possible we'll see what that could have looked like after all. What do you think? Would these series have worked better as anthologies, or do you prefer them as-is? What other picks do you have for series you'd like to see in an anthology format? Sound off in the comments below!

Contributor
Contributor

Matt is a freelance writer and aspiring TV and film scriptwriter. He has a bizarrely eclectic skillset, and the interests to match. Find more of his work and ramblings over at the Breakwater Industries page on Facebook. He is a regular contributor to WhatCulture.com, and his work has also appeared in the essay collection "Joss Whedon: The Complete Companion", published by Titan Books.