10 TV Shows Cancelled Before Their Time

What Culture offers this list of ten shows that were cancelled well before their time and deserve a second chance.

The television industry is a cutthroat business. Of the plethora of shows that make it to the air, only a handful survive past their first season and even fewer last long enough to become considered successful. In recent years, however, some shows have been hauled out of mothballs after fan reception has been so great that the networks decided to give them a second chance. For instance, Fox€™s Family Guy was cancelled twice---only to be brought back after achieving record DVD sales and unprecedented popularity on the Cartoon Network€™s Adult Swim. Another animated Fox offering---Futurama---was cancelled by Fox and then revived due to DVD sales, albeit on Comedy Central. Considering that these shows were saved and brought back and that throughout the history of television shows like Star Trek and The X-Files were also saved thanks to fan intervention we€™d like to offer this list of ten shows that were cancelled before their time and deserve a second chance.

10. Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles

Capturing the dark grittiness of James Cameron€™s T2 while ignoring the train wreck that was T3, this show revisited the series€™ original hero - Sarah Connor - in her fight against the machines, protecting her son John who was destined to be the leader of the human resistance in the future war. The show debuted as a mid-season €œfiller€ show in 2008 with only nine episodes in the first season. In spite of this-or perhaps because of it-The Sarah Connor Chronicles immediately gained a fanbase and scored in the top 50 ratings for its time slot with over 10 million viewers. Critical reception was positive and fan reception was favorable which locked in a second season. With a full 22 episodes to produce, a broader, continuing story arc was introduced and more time was spent developing a teenage John€™s humanity, taking him through a series of young adult storylines (read: Teen angst) while simultaneously tackling the issue of cancer. These types of stories are necessary for character development; however, in the case of The Sarah Connor Chronicles the characters were not given a chance to develop. The second season did not fare as well as the first, pulling in only half of the viewers reported for season 1, and the Fox network announced the show would not be renewed for a third season - to the dismay of fans, the show ended on a cliff hanger and left many unresolved plot lines. Cancelled before its time, Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles was a bright spot in the Terminator story and deserves another chance - and fans deserve a resolution to the cliff hanger.

9. Pushing Daisies

Pushing Daisies is a peculiar show and it is the look and feel of it that both made it stand out and perhaps doomed it from the start. The show, chronicling the story of pie maker Ned, who has the ability to bring dead things to life with only a touch; with the caveats of revival longer than one minute results in the death of something else nearby as a form of balance and that if he touches them again they return to death forever - the show was visually stunning and often... er ... touching. In his childhood Ned discovers his powers after his mother dies of an aneurysm and he brings her back to life causing the death of his childhood sweetheart€™s father and ultimately leading to his mother€™s own demise when she gave him a goodnight kiss. Years later, Ned has formed a partnership with a private investigator; using his powers to bring murder victims back to life to identify their killers. The show€™s format duplicated the child like qualities and some of the visual style of a Tim Burton film but it was the romantic story line that really stood out. Ned€™s childhood sweetheart, Charlotte, is a murder victim who he revives and brings into his world kindling a romance. The structure of their relationship was unique in that they are in love but cannot touch - quite a departure from show after show depicting relationships in far more graphic and less emotional ways. Ned and Charlotte€™s relationship showed that love can transcend physicality and be beautiful. This show was wholly unique in every way and was a victim of the 2008 writer€™s strike which cut the first season by more than half. When the creative team returned they opted not to finish the first season and began production on a second season. The second season€™s ratings fell drastically and after 13 episodes the show was cancelled - with many lingering plot lines. Series creator Bryan Fuller has expressed interest in wrapping up the show as a comic book and a graphic novel was in development but has since been put on hiatus due to the loss of a publisher. More recently Fuller has stated that he is €œemboldened by what Starz is doing with Torchwood€ and that he €œwould love to do a Pushing Daisies mini-series for Starz.€ Perhaps there is hope for fans of this diamond in the rough after all.

8. Dead Like Me

Like Pushing Daisies, this show was created by Bryan Fuller and Fuller intended Pushing Daisies as a spin-off to Dead Like Me. Also like Pushing Daisies, Dead Like Me was not given the chance it deserved. Produced for the cable network Showtime, Dead Like Me ran for only two seasons from 2003 to 2004. The show tells the tale of Georgia Lass, struck down in the prime of her life-she had just dropped out of college-by a toilet seat hurtling from an orbiting space station directly onto her head. Immediately after her death, her life ironically begins when she becomes a €œReaper.€ Her task, before passing to the afterlife is to act as a Grim Reaper, collecting the souls of the dead and sending them on their way to the afterlife. Existing somewhere between life and death, Georgia must hold a full time job while collecting the souls of the dead and much of the first season is spent on the difficulties of adjusting to death, a station as a grim reaper and adding the pressures of €œreal life.€ What makes this work, though, is the performance of Ellen Muth in the role of Georgia. Her dry wit and deadpan reactions to her circumstances create the best kind of humor and is somehow relatable to the viewer. We also follow Georgia as she watches her family cope with her death and struggle with her desire to be there for them and the rules she must now abide by. Added to all this is a cast that includes Mandy Patinkin which made the show a surprise winner. The show was doomed early, though, when Bryan Fuller left over creative differences with the network saying that a lack of professionalism made it €œthe worst experience€ of his life and that Showtime cancelled the show due to a €œloss of quality.€ Showtime€™s official stance, however, was that the show€™s ratings did not warrant a third season. Dead Like Me did get a direct to DVD movie in Dead Like Me: Life After Death which served to continue the story and tie up loose ends, but even this entry in the series leaves fans wanting more.

7. Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip

In a departure from his Friends character, Matthew Perry starred in this drama/comedy about a sketch comedy show (think Saturday Night Live) for the NBC network. The show within a show was the most highly anticipated of the 2006-€™07 television season and prompted a bidding war between NBC and CBS for its licensing. Ultimately NBC won and placed the hour long drama in rotation with competing show 30 Rock-a comedy about the same subject. Where Studio 60 focused on the drama and more stress related aspects of running a television show and dealing with the Network and FCC-30 Rock focused on the comedy with star Alec Baldwin saying of 30 Rock, "I'd be stunned if NBC picked up both shows. And ours has the tougher task, as a comedy, because, if it's not funny, that's it." For viewers of Studio 60 it was the storylines dealing with FCC censorship of Afghan war veterans and an actor€™s choice to speak out vocally about religious matters that could damage ratings that drew them in. It was a slice of life in a world that is a curiosity, and an insight into the lives of people watched by millions. Ultimately, the show€™s declining ratings and hefty production costs sealed the show€™s fate and after one season Studio 60 was cancelled-meanwhile, 30 Rock achieved 7 seasons with the 2012-€™13 season being its final outing.

6. Freaks and Geeks

From Leave it to Beaver to Happy Days to the Wonder Years, each generation seems to have a show devoted to the €œcoming of age€ trials of its day. Freaks and Geeks took on the eighties when it sought to tell the story of a group of friends attending William McKinly High School in the 1980-€™81 school year. Everything about this show captured what it is like to be a teenager in high school-the timeless nature of adolescence, of becoming an adult and seeking to fit in-and placed it against the backdrop of the transition of the glam 70s into the excess of the 80s. In following Lindsey Weir and her younger brother Sam, the viewer gets a glimpse into two very specific €œcliques€ in high school. The €œfreaks€ (Lindsey and her friends) being the rebellious slackers who strive to stand out by being different, while doing so in a very uniform way. The €œgeeks€ (Sam and his friends) being the more nerdy, academic, Dungeons and Dragons playing and yes slightly more immature group. More than just a tale of one character growing up, or one family€™s struggles in a tumultuous time, Freaks and Geeks is the story of every teenager struggling to fit in---to find their place in the Social Universe. That is the show€™s charm. It€™s endearing use of the events of the time to paint the picture also offer a nostalgia akin to The Wonder Years-Sam€™s friends playing Dungeons and Dragons, for example, is a great throwback to something that was new in 1980. Lindsey€™s struggle with asking then Vice President Bush a tough question during an assembly is a great illustration of the political climate of the early 80s and the struggle of young people to do what they€™re told or what they feel is right. Basically, Freaks and Geeks was a perfect execution of this type of coming of age story and the reason for its cancellation is infinitely baffling.

5. Survivors

Four years before The Walking Dead presented a rag tag group of Survivors in a dystopia against insurmountable odds (read: Zombies), the BBC showed us a rag tag group of Survivors in a dystopia against insurmountable odds (read: an extinction level plague). Survivors focuses on the lives of people from various walks of life in the aftermath of the €œEuropean Flu€ which has apparently killed 99% of the human population. The story focuses on the matriarch of the group, Abby Grant, and her struggle to find her son Peter. Her determination to find her child is the fuel for her need to maintain her morality and find a new way of life in the dystopia for Peter. What makes Survivors work is the dichotomy of Abby€™s morality and welcoming nature against the lives of other survivors and their secrets. What was truly compelling, however, was the fact that Survivors, unlike The Walking Dead, shows that the real threat to the remainder of humanity is themselves---this darker side may also be what made the show harder to watch. The idea that good people would turn into savages, murderers and lose all sense of right and wrong---regardless of the realism of such events, this idea is challenging to process for some. For the rest of us it was compelling and when combined the season 2 cliffhanger and unresolved plot threads the news of Survivors cancellation prior to a third season was quite disappointing indeed.

4. The Oblongs

Will Ferrell has achieved what few other cast members of Saturday Night Live have-a successful career outside the sketch comedy titan that is SNL. With blockbuster movies like Old School, Elf, Anchorman and most recently The Campaign, Ferrell is a quintessential funnyman and has a nearly universal popularity. Before achieving that he voiced the character of Bob Oblong for thirteen episodes of the animated series, The Oblongs. The show is anything but politically correct and this is the best part of its humor. The Oblongs are a family that lives in a community called the Valley community directly below a higher class community called The Hills. Due to the pollution of the higher class residents above them and radiation exposure from a power plant supplying upper class amenities, the residents of the Valley are all deformed or in some way disabled. While most definitely an adult show, the Oblongs takes the blue collar family dynamic of shows like The Simpsons and Married... with Children a step further by lampooning the more controversial issues facing a middle class, blue collar family. What makes the show funny is also what dooms it, as it takes issues of disability, alcoholism and sexuality and treats them humorously, but it is the kind of humor that is also insensitive. The Oblongs was cancelled after only eight episodes by the WB network but has since seen new life on Cartoon Network€™s Adult Swim, though no information about a revival has been forthcoming since 2010 making new episodes of this series unlikely.

3. The Tick

The Tick has the misfortune of being a misunderstood, mismanaged show that is based on an animated show that is based on a comic. The animated show ran from 1994-€™96 prompting creator Ben Edlund to produce a live action pilot for broadcast on Fox. The Tick is a superhero, sworn to protect a remote bus station from the evil machinations of malfunctioning vending machines and is generally a nuisance to weary travelers. Tricked into moving to €œThe City€ the Tick finds a new domain to defend. The world in which the Tick resides is a hilarious blend of reality and the fantasy of comic books. Patrick Warburton€™s portrayal of the tick is utterly perfect with delivery of such lines as €œJava devil you are now my bitch!€ coming with such sincerity that you€™re not sure if you should laugh out loud at the absurdity or gear up for a battle of epic proportions. Bumbling, inept and accidentally heroic, the Tick is the unsung hero of superhero television shows. After nine episodes it was cancelled by Fox due to climbing production expenses and promotional problems causing the show and its audience to pass like ships in the night. Still, all those involved with the show have expressed love for what they achieved, an audience was found after the show€™s release on DVD and Patrick Warburton himself retains one of the Tick costumes and has expressed interest in returning to the role. Of all the shows on this list, The Tick is perhaps the most likely to be revived.

2. Carnivale

Set during the Dust Bowl and Great Depression, Carnivale tells a classic good vs. evil story blending various elements of Masonic, Gnostic and Christian theologies. Carnivale has an overall story arc that follows two separate stories that are slowly coming together-that of Ben Hawkins who is traveling with a carnival after discovering that he has healing powers; and the story of Brother Justin Crowe, a Methodist preacher who has the power to bend others to his will and show them their sins as visions. The two stories come closer and closer together throughout the 24 episodes of the show€™s two seasons. The second season finale titled €œNew Canaan, CA€ ended on a cliff hanger which prompted the show€™s loyal fan base to send more than 50,000 emails to HBO in a single day, as well as organizing other rescue efforts. HBO cancelled the show based on production costs and the fact that continuing into a third season would have opened up more of the show€™s mythology requiring a larger commitment to tell the story. Show creator Daniel Knauf is hopeful that with a strong fan base HBO will reconsider the cancellation, but explains that he does not want to tie up the loose ends in a three hour movie simply because of the sheer amount of unused story potential. Another nail in the coffin of Carnivale€™s revival is that HBO owns the rights to the show and its characters which means that any transition to another format would require their cooperation. The only cancellation more frustrating for fans than that of Carnivale is our number 1 entry...

1. Firefly

In the 2002-€™03 season there was a show that ran for fourteen episodes, was aired out of production order in different time slots and with very little network support. In spite of these hurdles, Firefly found a loyal fanbase and is arguably the most popular science fiction show since Star Trek. Like Star Trek its experienced a feature film revival in 2005 with the film Serenity, but unlike the senior franchise, Firefly has since passed into memory. The story of the crew of Serenity-a misfit group of smugglers comprised of war veterans, a mercenary, a preacher, a doctor and his sister, a brilliant pilot, a plucky engineer and a courtesan-was short lived but was so memorable that a little simply isn€™t enough. Show creator Joss Whedon has gone on to massive success with Buffy: The Vampire Slayer and more recently with The Avengers but no matter what he€™s promoting, Firefly is the project he€™s most often asked about. Fans want more, and flock to everything that relates to the show whether it is a continuation of the story as a graphic novel or the appearance of Nathan Fillion in his Mal Reynolds guise on his most recent show, Castle. The cast and crew all hold their work on Firefly in very high regard and perhaps the most baffling part of Firefly€™s tale is that everyone seems to want to return but it has yet to happen. At the 2012 San Diego Comic Con, Whedon responded to a fan query with interest in reviving the series as a radio show so there is hope for the Browncoats yet. What do you think of these shows? What other shows were cancelled before their time? Let everyone know about your favorites from the TV graveyard in the comments below.

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A paragon of all things geek, by day Adam repairs computers for kids grades K-12 who go to school online. By night he writes articles about (mostly) Star Trek for What Culture as well as working on several creative projects (http://maddeningmuse.blogspot.com) He lives in Ohio with his Polyamorous life partner and their three children.