10 TV Shows That Recast Major Characters (For The Better)
Everything worked out for the best.
The simple nature of TV shows, being comprised of massive ensemble casts and often spanning many years of production, often means that recasting is essential for a number of reasons.
Perhaps the original actor wasn't available, maybe there were "creative differences," or it's possible that the showrunners simply wanted to deliver a fresh take on the character.
Whatever the reason, these major TV characters - whether members of the main cast or memorable supporting players - were all recast during their show's run.
While recasting can often result in an awkward period of adjustment for audiences, in the case of these 10 characters, it was absolutely, positively for the better.
These recastings all allowed actors who were ultimately better-suited to the parts to take over, regardless of what the original motivation behind the recast actually was.
Few shows get this lucky when it comes to replacing cast members, of course, but it just goes to show that personnel changes need not be an inherently terrible thing...
10. Frank Constanza - Seinfeld
Outside of Seinfeld's central quartet, Frank Constanza is unquestionably one of the show's most beloved supporting characters, George's (Jason Alexander) interminably awkward, irate father, as played so deliciously by the inimitable Jerry Stiller.
But Stiller wasn't in fact the first actor to play Frank, with the part originally played by John Randolph in his introductory season four episode, "The Handicap Spot."
Randolph's delivery was ultimately far more stiff and serious-minded than Stiller's, to the extent that Larry David actually went back and had Randolph's scenes re-shot with Stiller in 1995 to ensure consistency as the show entered syndication.
You can still check out the full Randolph performance for yourself on streaming releases of the series, but without Stiller's looser, more free-wheeling vision of the character, it's tough to imagine that Frank would've enjoyed such a lengthy recurring tenure throughout the rest of the show.
9. Carol Willick - Friends
Friends introduced Ross' (David Schwimmer) ex-wife Carol in the show's second-ever episode, "The One With The Sonogram At The End," where she was played by Anita Barone.
Yet Barone, who originally auditioned for one of the lead roles, quit the part after just a single appearance because she wanted to pursue other leading parts.
As such, Barone was replaced with Jane Sibbett for Carol's remaining appearances across the series.
It's an especially interesting switch because not only did Sibett bear just a superficial resemblance to Barone at best, but her depiction of the character was also markedly different.
Though we naturally got only a sketch of Carol 1.0 as played by Barone, Sibbett's portrayal was drier and far more sarcastic, and absolutely for the better. But because the switch happened so early in the show's history, many fans didn't even notice.
8. Jimmy Olsen - Lois & Clark: The New Adventures Of Superman
One of the strongest aspects of The New Adventures of Superman was its casting, particularly that of Dean Cain as Superman and Teri Hatcher as Lois Lane.
But by the end of the first season, the showrunners grew concerned that Michael Landes, the actor who played Jimmy Olsen, too closely resembled Cain and strayed too far from the typical goofball depiction of Jimmy from the comics.
And so, Landes was replaced for the show's three remaining seasons by the decidedly more baby-faced Justin Whalin.
But more than that, Whalin's rendition of Jimmy was also significantly different, giving a more aloof performance that felt more in step with what comic book fans expected from the character.
That's not to say that Landes' performance was bad, but simply that he didn't really fit in with the show's tone as well as Whalin, who just totally nailed the part.
7. James Kent - True Blood
Jessica's (Deborah Ann Woll) smouldering vampire boyfriend James Kent was introduced in True Blood's sixth season, as played by the dreamy Luke Grimes.
But ahead of season seven, HBO made the surprise announcement that Grimes had been replaced with Nathan Parsons due to "the creative direction of the character."
Reports then emerged that Grimes may have quit the part due to the character's eventual gay romance with Lafayette (Nelsan Ellis), reports which Grimes himself later denied.
Nevertheless, Parsons was an incredibly effective recast, bearing a strong physical resemblance to Grimes and ultimately just evoking that dishy, mysterious vampire vibe a little more confidently than his predecessor.
Again, Grimes hardly sucked (sorry) in the role, but Parsons totally committed to James' aforementioned arc in the show's final season, and was able to absolutely make the part his own.
6. Becky Conner - Roseanne
There's perhaps no more interesting or creative example of a character being recast than Becky Conner in Roseanne.
The Conner sibling was originally played by Lecy Goranson for the show's first five seasons, after which she quit to attend college and was replaced by eventual Scrubs star Sarah Chalke.
Now, Chalke's performance as Becky wasn't inherently better than Goranson's, but it made the show inherently funnier because the writers decided to milk Becky's change in appearance for every drop it was worth.
Throughout the Chalke years, numerous jokes were made about Becky's "odd" appearance and "absences" for extended periods of time, much to both the audience's and the cast's clear amusement.
Goranson eventually returned to the part in season eight with Chalke still filling it when she wasn't available, until taking the part over in earnest when Goranson quit "for good" before season nine.
But in the recent Roseanne revival, Goranson returned to the part once more, while Chalke was re-introduced as an entirely new character.
There's surely an alternate universe where Goranson simply played the part for the entirety of Roseanne's run, and it clearly wouldn't have been this funny.
For the laughs, the hot potato recast was totally worth it.
5. Kryten - Red Dwarf
What would sci-fi sitcom Red Dwarf be without its legendarily eccentric mechanoid Kryten? The character first appeared in the aptly-titled season two episode "Kryten," where he was played by David Ross.
Kryten didn't return until the start of series three, where he became a main cast member as now played by Robert Llewellyn, due to Ross being unavailable to reprise his role.
And though Kryten's original debut is far from a fan favourite episode, Ross acquits himself well enough, despite the rather naff makeup which, thankfully, was spruced up considerably for Llewellyn's debut in the part.
Llewellyn also changed Kryten's accent and vocal tenor considerably and, over the course of the show's run, transformed Kryten into a beloved sci-fi icon.
Ross clearly had no hard feelings, though, as he returned twice to voice the legendary Talkie Toaster.
4. Meg Griffin - Family Guy
The role of the Griffin family's put-upon daughter Meg is so inexplicably linked with the familiar vocal tones of Mila Kunis that it's easy to forget she was originally played by Party of Five and Mean Girls star Lacey Chabert.
Chabert played Meg for the entirety of season one and select episodes in season two, but ultimately chose to withdraw due to scheduling conflicts with both school and Party of Five.
Kunis eventually stepped in, and comparing the two is just no contest: Chabert's higher vocal register and cutesy delivery is totally steamrolled by Kunis' deeper voice and more obnoxious tone.
Without Kunis superior performance, all that Meg abuse would seem a lot meaner than, well, it already does.
3. Ann Veal - Arrested Development
In Arrested Development, Ann Veal was the hilariously bland girlfriend of George Michael (Michael Cera), serving as the constant butt of jokes revolving around her being a completely beige and forgettable character.
And while Ann was largely played by the brilliant Mae Whitman - who has gone on to enjoy quite the career since - the character was actually originated by another actress, Alessandra Torresani.
Torresani played Ann for a brief scene in the first season's finale "Let 'Em Eat Cake," and despite the appropriately flat monotone of her voice, she was ultimately just a little too cute for the supposedly "plain" young woman who Michael Bluth (Jason Bateman) would constantly forget even existed.
Whitman meanwhile leaned into Ann's homeliness and totally ran with it in her earlier appearances, before eventually becoming a more fleshed-out character with something resembling an actual sense of style later on.
Hilariously, the original plan was reportedly to have Ann played by countless actresses throughout the series, underlining her absolute anonymity among the ensemble, but it ultimately didn't pan out.
2. The Mountain - Game Of Thrones
Gregor "The Mountain" Clegane is the most imposing physical specimens in the entirety of Game of Thrones, but the character was actually recast twice across the series' run.
In season one, Gregor was played by Aussie giant Conan Stevens, but after Stevens headed off to appear in Peter Jackson's The Hobbit movies, he was replaced by Welsh actor Ian Whyte for season two.
Though certainly tall, Whyte's thin frame didn't at all fit the written conception of the character or Stevens' prior portrayal, and so Icelandic strongman Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson ended up taking over from season four onwards.
It goes without saying that Björnsson was given the bulk of the character's narrative meat, but even so, he was by far the most physically imposing of the three actors, and helped make The Mountain one of TV's most feared forces of nature.
1. Alura Zor-El - Supergirl
The role of Supergirl's (Melissa Benoist) mother Alura Zor-El was initially played by Laura Benanti throughout the show's first and second seasons, before The CW announced that Benanti's theatrical commitments prevented her from reprising the role for season three and beyond.
As a result, she was ultimately replaced by Erica Durance, best known to comic book fans for her feisty performance as Lois Lane in the Superman TV series Smallville.
Though Benanti did a decent enough job playing Alura, Durance just brought more charm and personality to the part, to say nothing of the sheer meta joy of the actress playing another iconic live-action DC role.
By comparison, Benanti was occasionally a little flat, while Durance totally knocked the role out of the park.