10 TV Shows That Should Have Ended After One Season
Short and sweet is sometimes the way to go.
In TV, longevity is the name of the game. The cynical ideal is to create a concept that can run and run, that you can churn out stories for in your sleep, then sit back and watch the money run in.
From a more artistic standpoint, some shows need time to breathe. Better Call Saul, for example, has improved greatly over the years; even the best dramas might take a while to find their feet.
Then there are the shows that start off with a head of steam, looking destined for greatness, only to drop swiftly off a cliff. Maybe they used all their best ideas up in the first season, leaving themselves bereft of inspiration when it comes to the writing process for the next go-round. Maybe they attempt to change speeds for season two with disastrous consequences. At times, the first season is simply so good that any further content only serves to dilute the product.
Whatever the issue, sometimes it’s best to go against the studio’s corporate instincts and quit while you’re ahead. Had these shows thrown in the towel after a single run, their legacies would look a lot different.
10. Westworld
By no means have seasons two and three of Westworld been duds. The world is so well realised, and there are actors of such pedigree, that it would be difficult for the creators to turn the show into an outright stinker.
Things have been rocky ever since that first season, though. It may be more a symptom of the first run’s quality than anything else, because that really was a supremely confident opening for a new show. Most notably, without spoiling anything, there was that twist, one of the most effective in modern drama.
And Jonathan Nolan and Lisa Joy have essentially been chasing that high ever since. The series has only become more complex and oblique since then, often to its detriment. The pacing was always leaning towards the stately, but in season two it got slower still.
The most recent season mixed things up with a new location and characters, but the issues are still there. The show is nigh on perfect visually, but at times it’s not so much fun to watch. The style/substance balance has come out of whack since the end of the first season.
9. Prison Break
The charm of Prison Break’s first season was that it was well aware of how goofy its premise was. It just had everything: wrongful incarceration, a guy with a super detailed tattoo of the prison’s blueprints, escape attempts, blackmail, violence, cliffhangers galore.
Unlike the similarly incident-filled 24, which occasionally took itself quite seriously, Prison Break was more than willing to be nothing more than freewheeling fun. The actors were invested and looked like they were having a great time - it had a lot of charm.
Then, at the end of the first season, they broke out of the prison! That was it, the premise of the show was basically over - there was really nowhere else to go. Only, they kept on going for another four seasons, a special, and a spin off series.
At every opportunity they ramped up the ludicrousness, bringing characters back from the dead, throwing in Navy SEALS and shady conspiracies and all sorts to keep things going, but we’d seen what we wanted to see. They broke out of the prison, as promised. We didn’t need another 60 episodes.
8. Derek
There is a strong argument that Derek shouldn’t have been made at all. Derek, Ricky Gervais’ follow up to the disappointing Life’s Too Short, sees the auteur indulge in two of his worst pastimes - making fun of the less fortunate, and excessive schmaltz. Gervais can claim that the titular character, who he plays, is not supposed to be intellectually challenged all he wants, but as with much of his work there’s a cruelty at the heart of that performance.
Still, there were things to like in the first season of Derek, most notably the performances of Kerry Godliman (underused in the equally schmaltzy but more successful After Life) and long time Gervais punchbag Karl Pilkington. The scenes that don’t revolve around the star’s gurning can be amusing and even heartfelt.
Gervais’ earlier comedy masterpieces The Office and Extras evolved greatly in their sophomore seasons. Derek just doesn’t. It’s the same questionable schtick, only with even more ill earned sentiment, even fewer jokes, and no Pilkington. One season was just about tolerable for the good parts; the second is just more punching down.
7. Glee
It can be easy to forget that, when it first aired, Glee was a genuine cultural phenomenon. A ratings smash and a critical darling (though not without its detractors), Glee was one of the most talked about shows of its era thanks to its bold musical approach and breakout performances from the likes of Jane Lynch.
This is especially easy to forget because Glee became a parody of itself remarkably quickly. It was such a distinctive and particular show that, if you weren’t fully invested, you were likely going to hate, and so when viewers started to grow tired of it, they turned against it in a big way.
Like acapella singing itself, Glee is best served in small doses. Creator Ryan Murphy has a signature style of TV making, bold and brassy, and he has since focussed on shorter seasons that have been roaring successes. Glee’s 22 episode seasons were gruelling to say the least, and we turned off in our droves.
Nowadays it seems a little mad that Glee ever got as big as it did, and that’s solely because they drew it out far longer than they should have done.
6. Stranger Things
Arguably the jewel in the Netflix crown, Stranger Things remains a true pop culture phenomenon. The release of season three was met with great fanfare, and it does huge numbers for the streaming giants. At this point, though, it’s less a TV series than an excuse for the actors to play ‘80s dress up.
The first season took heavy influence from the 1980s resumes of John Carpenter and Stephen Spielberg, but it had its own approach, too, which was refreshing and exciting. More importantly, it was stuffed with content, suspenseful and exciting, bingeworthy TV at its finest.
Like a band experiencing the sophomore slump, it was clear that the Duffer brothers had used up all their best ideas in the first run. Season two had a lot of dead air comparatively, including a huge misfire of an episode set in Chicago that was there to fill time. Season three, to a lesser extent, suffers from the same issue. They lean on ‘80s references and pop hits in lieu of engaging stories.
The tone and vibe of the show is unparalleled - if they took a Fargo approach and transitioned all this to an entirely new set of characters and stories, perhaps that would freshen things up.
5. The O.C
This is not to knock seasons two through four of The O.C, because the SoCal teen drama remained engaging, glossy fun throughout. The characters were so engaging, the majority of the actors so charming, that we’d happily stick with them, no matter how ridiculous things ended up getting.
At the same time, the increasing wildness of the characters and storylines were ultimately a betrayal of what The O.C started out to be. Yes, it was always essentially a soap, with its adolescent characters experiencing the wildest of emotions and the adults behaving no better themselves.
But there was a smartness to Josh Schwartz’ approach that was undercut by the sheer barminess of its later years. It was, ultimately, just about believable - we could empathise with Seth declaring his love at the school fair more than we could with, say, Ryan taking up cage fighting.
Had the series ended on the heart wrenching, melancholic note of season one, it would have been a shocking downer, but a bold move fitting of such a smart teen show.
4. Killing Eve
There is a lot to love about Killing Eve. The lead performances are superb, especially that of Jodie Comer, and it nails the tonal balance better than almost any drama of the past decade. In its first season it was tense and exciting, but always, always fun, which is something so many major shows forget to be.
Season two attempts to freshen things up with a few new antagonists and bringing the series’ lead antagonists/possible lovers together, but it’s clear from early on that a lot of the sparkle had gone. Killing Eve’s hook was the cat and mouse game between Villanelle and Eve - once we’d seen basically all we needed to of that, there was nowhere else to go.
Worse still, the cliffhanger ending of the first season is simply replicated at the conclusion of season two. The issue seemed to be the departure of Phoebe Waller-Bridge, who evidently recognised that the well had run dry and moved on to new things.
Season three has proved divisive, but with the series a commercial success, you’d imagine it’s going nowhere - appropriate, given the storylines are similarly repetitive.
3. Dexter
Dexter has its devotees, and we’re not here to deny that some of the later seasons had decent moments. Season four, in particular, ranks among the show’s best, with John Lithgow doing superb work as the Trinity Killer, a piece of against-type casting that worked phenomenally well.
The shock factor of the show - i.e its raison d’etre - was gone by the time the credits rolled on the season one finale, though. Dexter was built around a gimmick as much as any sci-fi or fantasy schlock you’d care to name - here was a serial killer who killed other serial killers! Once the novelty of that has worn off, the Dexter formula is all too clear to see.
Fans grew tired of the same old, same old in due course, but from the off, the writers had every intention of doing the same thing over and over again. Dexter meets a kindred spirit who he ends up having to murder. Dexter almost gets caught by a colleague, only for them to meet a convenient end.
While Michael C Hall’s stellar performance papered over a lot of the cracks, everyone can agree Dexter went on too long. One would have been plenty.
2. True Detective
The McConaughey/Harrelson led inaugural season of True Detective was, at its heart, a gruesome, philosophical crime drama. We’ve all seen them. But this one felt somehow completely different. Between the genuine star power of the leads, the sheer depravity of the plot, and the time skipping structure that heightened the mystery, this was proper event TV, a must-watch as soon as each episode dropped.
We were so excited for the second instalment - creator Nic Pizzolatto was to scrap what had come before, and embark on a whole new story, with brand new characters. The cast was promising - Vince Vaughn playing against type, Colin Farrell, Rachel McAdams.
To say it was a disappointment is to put things mildly. Vaughn was floundering in the role of a local mobster. Taylor Kitsch wasn’t up to the job as a troubled cop. McAdams and Farrell did their level best, but they had little to work with. The plot was far too confusing, and just not that engaging.
Season three, starring the always great Mahershala Ali, was far better, but sadly the legacy of True Detective is forever damaged. Season one was a hard act to follow, but no one thought they’d miss the mark this badly.
1. Heroes
The first season of Heroes was something genuinely fresh and exciting. Before superhero TV shows were a dime a dozen, Tim Kring’s series felt like huge news for the small screen. It was packed with great characters like Hiro, Sylar, and cheerleader of destiny Claire Bennet. There was a central mystery that only deepened as the season ran on, and an apocalyptic cliffhanger that whet appetites for the next set of episodes.
The wheels came off very quickly indeed. The second season lost all of its momentum, adding some far less interesting new characters and attempting to over complicate things. Despite having half the episodes of the first run, it moved at a glacial pace in comparison. The season was stymied by the US writers’ strike, which explains, but doesn’t excuse, the slip in quality.
While things improved markedly for the last two seasons, especially four, Heroes could never replicate the form of its debut (and did it ever try - a recent reboot was met with wide disinterest). One solitary season, with a suitable dramatic ending, would have cemented its legacy as groundbreaking telly, instead of, ultimately, a disappointment.
Watch Next
Prison Break Quiz: Michael Scofield - True Or False?