10 TV Shows That Should Have Quit When They Were Ahead
It’s always better to go out on a high.
Parting is such sweet sorrow, Juliet tells Romeo in the famous Shakespeare play. While many interpret this to be Juliet speaking of the joyful hope that she’ll see Romeo again the following day, she was actually referring to how satisfying it can be when a long-running TV series bows out at the best possible time in the best possible way.
That means that these 10 shows were definitely not on Juliet’s mind. Either because they overstayed their welcome, meandered on, ruined character arcs or just fluffed the finale, these shows definitely should have quit while they were ahead.
Some shows still haven’t gotten the hint and are still trundling on, but many have already departed in less than ideal circumstances. Even when long-running shows have managed to put together the perfect finale, it doesn’t always salvage the show entirely.
It’s not even that these shows ever became terrible (although some did), but instead that they missed their window. They didn’t age gracefully and in some cases, even damaged the legacy they’d built.
With a certain HBO mega-hit ending in circumstances so controversial, fans have put together a petition to do the last season over completely, poor endings are a very hot topic right now.
Game Of Thrones won’t be here though, as it shouldn’t have quit while it was ahead so much as it should’ve kept going at a much less rushed pace.
10. The Office
Michael Scott simply was The Office. Undoubtedly, there was a lot of talent from likes of Mindy Kaling, Rainn Wilson, John Krasinski, Craig Robinson, BJ Novak, Ellie Kemper, Ed Helms... the list goes on and on of Office cast members who’ve had very successful careers outside of Dunder Mifflin.
The show certainly didn’t fall apart after Steve Carrell left, but then it didn’t really do much of anything. It just existed for two years, propelled along by guest spots from Idris Elba, Catherine Tate, James Spader (and again the list could go on a while). It just didn’t feel like the same show anymore. Nobody would really have minded if Season 7 was the last.
Yes, the ultimate finale is a pretty good one, but even then it’s not really any better than Goodbye, Michael. Even away from what Carell brought, the show warped Ed Helms’ character Andy for no discernible reason, and the love triangle between Pam, Jim and the Boom Mike Guy was never even close to believable.
The Office didn’t really damage its legacy, but it missed the chance to truly go out on a high.
9. The Simpsons
The Simpsons is kind of in a weird spot right now. It still provides pretty watchable television and is good for a few laughs, which is all you expect most cartoons to do.
The Simpsons though is not most cartoons. During its Golden Era, it had a genuine claim of being the greatest tv show of all time. Now though, if you take all 30 seasons into account, recent subpar offerings would disqualify it.
For what it’s worth, the show has recovered slightly from its mid-20s dip, but it’s still held to an impossibly high standard it could never hope to attain, even with the best modern episodes; Barthood, Halloween Of Horror, and Brick Like Me.
Would it be better to have gone out at the top, even though it would have meant 15 to 20 years worth of episodes disappearing?
While it definitely retains some fans and audience pull, The Simpsons has massively overstayed its welcome with the general public. The Simpsons Movie could have been a good place to wrap up, as the show seemed to have plateaued around that point anyway.
Family Guy could probably share this spot with The Simpsons too, although it was arguably less of a classic than The Simpsons ever was, hasn’t been on as long and has never paid as much attention to plot.
8. Pretty Little Liars
Pretty Little Liars was never a good show. However, for a while it was one of the best bad shows going. By the end though, it was just a plain old bad television.
The central plot revolves around a group of four friends who are being taunted by a mysterious ‘A’ in the wake of their classmate’s death. There’s some good schlocky tension and typical teen drama, but the show gets more ridiculous as it goes on.
The classmate returns from the dead, several main characters are ‘A’ (but then they aren’t), a teacher dates two of his high school students and is played off as the good guy while the finale involves a bizarre ‘there was an evil British twin all along!’ reveal.
Just like Alison DiLaurentis, the show then came back from the dead as The Perfectionists, although only Sasha Pieterse and Janel Parrish remain from the core cast.
Keeping the twist that Mona was A until later and bowing out with that would’ve been better, but the show decided to reveal their hand early. After that, it was scrambling, but there were still more chances to save the ending.
The dollhouse episodes were probably peak Pretty Little Liars, but rather than leading to anything impactful, it just sort of fizzled out. Hanna’s PTSD was explored with a real lack of grace and a potentially great finale was wasted.
7. Dexter
Dexter is basically the poster boy for having a terrible finale. It sits at an awful 4.7 on IMDb, just above Game Of Thrones’ at 4.3, ending on an equally sour note.
The final season overall was decent, even if it wound down and unraveled spectacularly at the end. While Game Of Thrones’ issue was being rushed though, Dexter’s biggest flaw was that it didn’t particularly resolve anything at all.
Considering Dexter was a serial killer, you’d figure that the show had to end either in tragedy or with him getting some kind of dark happily ever after. Instead, the final season tries very hard to give him a taped on redemption arc where he recovers his humanity and ceases his desire to kill.
However, the last episode sees him screw this all up in a ball and throw it in the trash.
He decides he is unable to protect his child so just sort of wanders off away from everything. By the way, what exactly is he protecting his child from now? From having a dad around?
Just ending it a season before and giving the real Dexter some closure would’ve been better. Instead, they try to ‘fix’ his character with no justification, then don’t even round off this arc with any logic.
6. That ‘70s Show
That ‘70s Show actually has a pretty good finale which provides a healthy wrap up, some laughs, some tears, and fittingly falls on December 31st, 1979.
However, it doesn’t make up for the last season, which was average in places, terrible in others, and scribbled over character development seemingly for the sake of it.
In Season 7 of the eight season run, both Ashton Kutcher and Topher Grace leave the cast to further their career. Both did go on to success, but then so did Laura Prepon and Mila Kunis who stuck around.
With such a gaping hole in the gang, Josh Meyers was drafted in to play Randy. Rather than give him any sense of personality, the show just asks him to be both Eric and Kelso at once. To be blunt, he fails.
With Kelso gone, the show also neglects to give Jackie any growth, and instead she miraculously falls in love with Fez. Turns out she’s always been in love with him, even when she was clearly in love with Kelso.
The show was scheduled to end after Season 7 when Grace and Kutcher left, and it probably should have. At least it was never as bad as Days Like These or That ‘80s Show.
5. Thirteen Reasons Why
The first season was controversial enough already, but from a purely critical standpoint it was relatively well received.
The fact it seemed to glamorise suicide, didn’t seem to have a handle on the delicate topics it was dealing with and physically showed a girl slitting her wrists in a show intended for a teenage audience are all valid criticisms. However, viewing it in isolation, it was a groundbreaking first season of television, explored places few other shows do and captured the hearts and minds of many.
It drew some unfavourable comparisons to fellow Netflix show BoJack Horseman, but that’s apples and pears. The shows have different themes, narratives and audiences. The fact is, Thirteen Reasons Why could cope with the criticism because it delivered on a narrative front; it could take the slings and arrows.
Season 2 however felt hugely unnecessary, as it just seemed like Season 1 rehashed from a different perspective. The criticisms seemed a lot more fitting as the show cranked up the controversy with no gain on screen.
Season 1's rape scene was difficult to watch but at least made narrative sense, even if the arc wasn’t closed as satisfying as we would like. In Season 2 though, it was more extreme, more gratuitous and much, much less necessary.
Rather than fishing for scandal, the show should’ve went out on a high after their first offering.
4. Heroes
Heroes has one of the best first seasons in television history. Unfortunately, pretty much everything that followed was unwatchable dreck.
That’s perhaps being slightly harsh; the episodes in isolation can provide some decent entertainment. The problem is that after Season 1 there’s no compelling lore, no overarching plot, no thematic links... at least none worth bothering about.
Heroes quickly became a convoluted mess and is one of the biggest casualties of the famous writer’s strike. It had previously been ahead of its time with its gritty, magic realism take on superpowers, sprawling cast and seemingly disparate story linking together in intelligent ways.
Unfortunately, this trend didn’t continue beyond Zachary Quinto’s villainous turn as Sylar in Season 1.
They then decided to bring the show back for Heroes: Reborn five years after cancellation. However, with no Milo Ventimiglia, Hayden Panetiere or Masi Oka, the show’s potential was over before it began.
Much like its parent show, Heroes: Reborn is much less than the sum of its parts. The series has a fairly poor 6.8 on IMDb, while the episodes themselves never dip below 7.4.
3. The X-Files
The X-Files was a phenomenal television show, with a style and attitude which defined the ‘90s. Along with fellow entry here The Simpsons, it was one of the first benefactors of the second Golden Age Of Television.
That said, it definitely ran on just a bit too long. Season 7 could have been the most compelling ending of all time, with Mulder abducted by aliens. It would have caused a huge stir but would’ve been the ideal ending for his arc and the show in general.
In the end though, the abduction was simply a device to get David Duchovny on a shorter contract so they could pay him less. Robert Patrick and in time Annabeth Gish do a competent job beefing up the cast, but ultimately it isn’t The X-Files without Mulder.
It also felt like the show was scrambling from here on out; monster of the week episodes are decent but the overarching story falls apart. That’s before you even get to the fact The X-Files throws two episodes away to give finales to showrunner Chris Carter’s other shows, The Lone Gunmen and Millenium.
It didn’t need those two extra seasons, or the second movie, or the two revival seasons.
2. Scrubs

Scrubs is one of the best sitcoms and best hospital dramas ever made, yet it might well have earned its place in TV hell for its most grievous sin.
The series finale, showing JD meeting all the classic characters and imagining his life with Eliot, Turk, Carla and Dr Cox is one of television’s finest. It wrapped the show up perfectly, had just the right amount of sentimentality and was entirely in keeping with the show’s tone. Sure, Seasons 7 and 8 weren’t as great as the earlier six, but nothing too damaging; certainly not enough to end up here.
Then, in a decision motivated entirely by money, the show came back for a ninth season. There was a new protagonist, new location, most of the main cast were relegated to supporting roles and a heap of new players involved. Worst of all, it lost its identity and plain old wasn’t funny.
There’s been some attempts by fans and the show alike to distance Season 9 from the show’s legacy, labelling it a spin-off (Scrubs: The Interns), but that’s not really fooling anyone. Scrubs had one of best closers ever and they threw it away.
1. The Walking Dead

There once was a time when The Walking Dead and Game Of Thrones were going toe to toe as the best TV show of the decade. Despite both shows featuring here, it’s still very clear that The Walking Dead lost that duel.
Game Of Thrones’ drop in quality was rapid, like the dagger in Dany’s heart. The Walking Dead’s was slower, more insidious, like the virus consuming the titular zombies.
Season 7 & 8 are particularly considered to be low points for the show, though Season 9 did offer some redemption, if you’re still watching.
The main issue though is that there’s a lack of focus. This isn’t Seinfeld; it needs to be about something. Everything builds then fades away and the cycle continues without too many people getting particularly invested in it.
Watching The Walking Dead is unpredictable these days, and not in a good way. You might get a fantastic hour of television, or be made to sit through boring filler. There’s just no way of knowing.
Like Michael Scott and The Office, the show feels like it needs Rick. Without him, it’s not the same show, and they could have ended well before he left if they’d resolved any of their various villains satisfactorily.
There’s been plenty of opportunity for wrap up, but the show has been endlessly marching forward aimlessly, hungry for viewers.
Which other TV shows should've quit while they were ahead? Let us know down in the comments.