10 TV Shows That Were Nothing Like You Expected

S'all good, man.

Better Call Saul
AMC

It takes a lot for a TV show to truly surprise you. Not in the one-off moments like the Red Wedding or episodes like The Fly, but on a much broader level of both premise and execution.

Going into shows such as Friends, Mad Men, or The West Wing, you don't know exactly what's going to happen on an episode-by-episode basis or where certain characters might end up, but there's an expectation as to what the show will be like in terms of storytelling, plotlines, and tone that they typically meet.

It's especially the case now, when the landscape is full of reboots and revivals and series are hyped to death before airing, but there are occasions when you thought you knew what you were getting into, only for it to completely subvert all expectations.

10. Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Season 1
Mutant Enemy

While anyone referring to Buffy the Vampire Slayer now means the TV show unless otherwise stated, it was a different case back in the 90s. Joss Whedon's original attempt at getting the project off the ground didn't go as planned, resulting in a 1992 movie that had little in common with his script and played as a broad comedy.

Five years later, then, when a TV show of the same name debuted, the movie version was still in the cultural consciousness. Anyone expecting similar high school silliness would've been caught off guard, with the series darker, smarter, more action-packed, and on a completely different level quality wise.

However, even The WB's attempts at marketing the series didn't quite nail it: the trailer for the series premiere really overplayed the horror elements, making this look like a cheap slasher movie where everyone would die. In neither the movie nor the trailer was there any of the brilliant Whedon dialogue, pop-culture references, or sense of character that would make the show so beloved to each generation that watches it.


9. Frasier

Frasier Niles
NBC

Cheers is one of the ultimate hangout sitcoms. It was Friends before Friends was Friends, with the exploits and relationships of the patrons of Sam's Bar delighting fans for 11 years. The premise was relatively simple, with the main crux being a bunch of people hanging out in a bar and talking; with little irony or snark but a lot of heart and charm - it wasn't particularly dumb or low-brow, but it certainly had broad comedic appeal.

Imagine, then, how jarring it is to go from that to Frasier. While fans were familiar with the character after his introduction in the third season, with him becoming a mainstay for over 200 episodes, his spin-off show couldn't really be more different.

Rather than a hangout, this time it's mostly just a band of three players - Frasier, his brother Niles, and their dad Martin (neither of whom featured in Cheers) - and the comedy has a decidedly cerebral bent, offering a mix of intellectual wit and high farce that is every bit as winning as Cheers' humour, but absolutely nothing like it all the same.


8. The Office (U.S)

The Office Steve Carell Ricky Gervais
NBC

American versions of British sitcoms rarely go well, and The U.S. Office both proves the rule and serves as an exception to it. Starring Steve Carrell in the David Brent type role, the first season suffered by trying to be almost shot-for-shot, word-for-word the exact same as the U.K version, but hardly any of the humour landed and the characters were completely off. Anyone expecting anything remotely close to Ricky Gervais' hit were to be sorely disappointed, but even more unexpected was its turnaround in Season 2.

From its second season onwards, the show found its true voice: Carell came into his own, the characters were shaped differently, and the romantic relationships began to form. It took some of the U.K version's best elements but twisted them to fit, rather than offering a pale imitation, with Michael Scott more childlike, less mean-spirited, and more purely loveable than David Brent.

It became an absurd satire of the *American* workplace, and a far more sentimental affair than you'd find from Gervais. Which is better is likely to split opinion, but it exceeded all expectations by being so different while still being respectful to the original.


7. The Defenders

Defenders Netflix EW
Netflix/EW

Phase One of the Marvel Cinematic Universe isn't perfect - Iron Man 2 is among the worst MCU offerings, and all of the standalone movies would have sequels that bettered them, despite their qualities. It was all worth it, though, because of the build to The Avengers, and that paid off beyond anyone's wildest dreams.

The Defenders, then, was supposed to be the Netflix Marvel Universe's version of The Avengers: all of the heroes we've been following for the last couple of years finally coming together in a much-anticipated team-up, even if the path there was slightly rocky at times.

But then instead of a true event, it takes three hours for the Defenders to even begin teaming-up, is mostly a bore, and worst of all never gives a good reason for them to be a team in the first place beyond the corporate mandate.


6. Game Of Thrones

Game Of Thrones Ned Stark
HBO

Nowadays Game of Thrones is a pop-culture behemoth that destroys all in its path, whether it be ratings records or Emmy contenders. Back in 2011, though, it was a rather different proposition and, unless you were familiar with George R.R. Martin's novels, it wasn't entirely clear what we could expect from the show.

While HBO suggested something prestige, one of the most common and layman terms description of the show you'd hear is that 'it's like Lord of the Rings, but with sex'.

While very basic similarities between the two do exist, there's little in that descriptor to give credence to just how much of the show is about warring families, nor how important (or gripping) the political machinations would be. The fantasy elements are only just coming to the fore now but, bar the opening and closing scenes of Season 1 (and a sprinkling of magic), they were largely non-existent back then.

The trailers, meanwhile, didn't fully capture just how thrilling and captivating it would be (indeed, the Season 1 trailer really looks a little generic and even a tad dull), the posters made Ned Stark look more like a brooding anti-hero, and everyone except book readers thought Sean Bean was playing the main character.


5. Crazy Ex-Girlfriend

Crazy Ex Girlfriend
The CW

A romantic musical dramedy, with the title Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, airing on The CW network of hot young things and soapy teen dramas, and with a trailer that solely seemed to emphasise the rom-com, ex-girlfriend-wants-her-boyfriend-back elements, Crazy Ex-Girlfriend promises something very different to what it actually is.

While the show does include romance, musical numbers, and comedy, it's also a surprisingly - and increasingly - dark look at mental illness, but also a very considered exploration of it as well.

It also looks at female sexuality from a decidedly female point-of-view, along with themes of parenthood, which combine to make this show as serious and affecting as it is hilarious and full of showtunes.


4. The OA

Netflix The OA Prairie
Netflix

Netflix deliberately kept The OA mysterious in the build-up to releasing the eight-episode first season, but even then it managed to defy any and all expectations. The basic premise was that of a previously blind girl who returns home after being missing for seven years, and has her sight returned.

It was fair to think it'd explore the mystery of what happened to her and how she got her sight, but The OA didn't stop there or do anything in a conventional way. The first episode alone suggested as much, with the opening credits not rolling until the 55-minute mark, telling us this wasn't a normal TV show.

From there we were plunged into stories within stories, alternate dimensions, questions as to the fabric of reality, a school shooting and, at the very heart of the series, what amounts to interpretive dance. It's baffling, beguiling, and unlike anything else around.


3. Gotham

Gotham Season 4
Fox

The elevator pitch of Gotham is that it depicts the titular city before Batman came along, with a focus on Jim Gordon's early days in the Gotham City Police Department.

That made it sound like a plain old procedural set within the Batman world, with a few villains popping up and gradually building to Bruce Wayne's transformation, and early episodes do fit with that brief, especially with the focus on the straight-laced Gordon.

However, no one could have predicted just how completely bats*it crazy this Batman series would become, nor how the true focus would be its villains. With a disregard for Batman canon and instead an onus on doing, well, just about whatever the hell it wants, including resurrections, clones, turning Posin Ivy from a child to an adult, and pretty much everything that happened with Jerome/Jeremiah.


2. Better Call Saul

Better Call Saul Jimmy McGill
AMC

Breaking Bad was a high octane thriller of a show, with a propulsive plot that left you gripped episode after episode. Following up one of the greatest TV shows ever made is no small task, and no one expected Better Call Saul to be as good as Breaking Bad, but they did at least anticipate something similar, although more comedy was promised too.

While Saul does increasingly have some Breaking Bad elements, especially thanks to Mike and now Gus, in terms of the main plot they're worlds apart. Where Breaking Bad was driven by plot and about a million things happened every episode, Saul takes the opposite approach: the drama is largely focused around the gradual descent of Jimmy McGill, and is slow-paced and deliberate, with it often seeming like little is happening in each individual episode (and yet, everything is really happening).

It does have its funny moments, but ultimately it's a more tragic show than Breaking Bad: that told the story of a man corrupted by power and greed; this is simply the sad story of a person who tried to be good, only to repeatedly fail and be told he isn't good enough. Breaking Bad was exciting, but Better Call Saul will break your heart.


1. Twin Peaks: The Return

Twin Peaks The Return Dale Cooper
Showtime

For 25 years, Twin Peaks fans wondered what fate had befallen Agent Dale Cooper. The man of pure goodness and integrity had, at the end of Season 2, seemingly became twinned with the malevolent BOB, but that's where the story was left.

So when Showtime announced a revival of the show, with David Lynch returning as the main creative force, answers were expected. It seemed likely that Cooper would return, and Twin Peaks would be, well, Twin Peaks.

Of course, that underestimated the warped mind of Lynch, who instead of the damn fine coffee and cherry pie town, gave us nightmarish creatures in New York, talking trees, Michael Cera doing a Marlon Brando impression, and a black and white hellscape of such sonically and visually distorting fury it needs to be seen to be believed.

But most of all, he gave us Dougie, played by Kyle MacLachlan but essentially an empty, somewhat childlike vessel, and Bad Cooper, the complete antithesis of the hero we'd known and loved. It was unlike anything else we'd seen from Twin Peaks, and yet by the end completely fit as the missing piece of the jigsaw, and something arguably even better than the original run.

Which other TV shows were nothing like you expected? Let us know down in the comments.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.