10 TV Shows That Were Spoiled By Romantic Couples
Sometimes fools really do fall in love...
Whether people acknowledge it or not, often times one of the most engaging parts of a successful television series is a good love story.
Fans sometimes wait years for their favorite 'ship' to finally get together and, when done right, it can be a great success. But then there are other times. Times when a central romance can be one of, if not the biggest, problems a show has.
Just as a series can benefit from a love story, it can be hurt by one. It doesn't seem to matter whether a pairing is tainted by things like egos, abuse, infidelity, or even incest, there have been many times when a group of writers just can't seem to let go of a bad thing, no matter how loud the viewers might be screaming for it to end.
10. Friends - Rachel Green And Ross Geller
Really, there are a lot of issues with Friends. From unrealistic apartments to bad decisions, there was no shortage of things to critique. But even still, there were enough good stories that people kept coming back. Arguably the show's most famous storyline, and the most problematic, was the relationship between Rachel and Ross.
It started off rather endearing. He was the nerdy kid in high school and she had been his sister's best friend. After reconnecting several years later, he still has feelings for her and she eventually reciprocates.
For all the build-up, when they actually got together it turned into a disaster, particularly on Ross' side. While Rachel wasn't perfect, Ross' belittling and clingy tendencies started to become overwhelming. Him blaming her for his poor choices in the ensuing aftermath didn't help matters. It's not very surprising that retrospectively the popularity of Ross' character has been greatly diminished.
For years after their messy breakup, the storyline still kept coming back to these two for no other apparent reason that just because they were 'Ross and Rachel'. There were a lot of people who were seemingly appalled by the idea that Rachel would get together with Joey in later seasons. Whether that should have happened or not, he actually treated her well and, after a long build-up, the storyline was discarded in a ridiculous fashion. Unlike with Rachel and Ross, whom the writers never let go of, no matter how bad they were for each other.
9. Buffy The Vampire Slayer - Buffy Summers And Angel
Much like the previous entry, this one started off well enough. The plot featuring a vampire and the girl chosen to destroy his kind falling in love quickly became popular. But then the relationship got to be where it was dominated by brooding and angst. Oh, how they wished he weren't a vampire and she weren't the Slayer so they could live a normal life together.
And then in a flashback episode, it was revealed that Angel had been watching Buffy from afar before they actually met. Now, being that he's supposed to be immortal, a big age difference is probably to be expected in just about any relationship he enters into. However, this gave it a feeling of an older man stalking a teenage girl. It's something that a lot of people have found difficult to look past while trying to get engaged with their story.
Eventually Angel became the title character of his own spin-off, and Buffy would go on to fall for another vampire in Spike. Her relationship with him is generally more popular among the fans, though not without its own issues. Angel went on to fall in love with Cordelia, the once shallow cheerleader while on Buffy the Vampire Slayer who became his best friend and closest ally on the spin-off.
8. 7th Heaven - Lucy Camden And Kevin Kinkirk
When 7th Heaven started, Lucy was the middle child who often felt left out and suffered from low self-esteem. As time went on, she grew in confidence, eventually choosing to go into the ministry. While she did do that, she also met Kevin Kinkirk.
When Kevin was introduced, it was during a period of time when the writers seemed bound and determined to marry all of the oldest children off quickly, no matter how absurdly short the amount of time that the potential spouses knew each other.
So, Lucy met Kevin while she was away from home, and in almost a blink of an eye, he had moved across the country to live in Lucy's family's garage - declaring that they were going to get married. He also turned out to be very controlling and have an air of superiority about him. Yes, an air of superiority over the people who were allowing him to live in their garage. His controlling nature also seemed to do some damage to her relatively newfound confidence that so many fans had enjoyed seeing her grow into.
Lucy had had a number of boyfriends before Kevin. Almost immediately before he was introduced, she had been seeing her sister's former boyfriend Robbie (her sister approved). If the writers were so desperate to marry Lucy off, it remains somewhat mind-boggling why they didn't pick one of her former suitors in a more realistic way, rather than abruptly stick her with the unpopular Kevin.
7. Modern Family - Haley Dunphy And Andy Bailey
Haley and Andy may not be a central storyline, or the most controversial, of Modern Family, but they're still a big problem. Haley was from the start presented as the shallow and somewhat simple-minded oldest daughter of Phil and Claire Dunphy. Andy was introduced as the 'manny' working for Haley's grandfather and his wife. He was very annoying, but for some reason, she took to him.
Eventually, they began having an affair behind Andy's fiancée's back. This was while the fiancée was away because she was serving in the military. It eventually turned out that she had been cheating on Andy, too, but they didn't know this at the time. All they were aware of was that they were betraying her while she was serving her country. It doesn't get much lower than that.
Another kicker is that Haley's relationship with Andy was intended to be a signal that she was maturing as an adult. Rather than have her focus on her future without worrying about having or not having a boyfriend, she instead got involved with a man who was already committed to somebody else. To most reasonable people, that probably doesn't qualify as making better life decisions. It's a wasted opportunity to grow her character.
6. Gilmore Girls - Rory Gilmore And Dean Forester/Rory Gilmore And Logan Huntzberger
Rory Gilmore started off as one of the most beloved characters on television; quick-witted and wise beyond her years. Things really started to take a turn for her popularity when she wouldn't let go of her first boyfriend, Dean, after he had married somebody else. After they had begun committing adultery, Rory then lashed out at her mother and made her out to be the villain after she had confronted her about it.
Eventually, her relationship with Dean ended (not before destroying his marriage), but now we have Logan. Basically, Logan was a whiny entitled hypocrite who loved criticizing his wealthy family, but was more than content to live off of their money and do absolutely nothing for a living. What's more, he seemed dedicated to turn the previously driven Rory into a fellow slacker.
The relationship between Rory and Logan would also end after Logan issued an ultimatum - marry him or he breaks up with her. But then in the Netflix revival of the series, Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life, Rory had returned to her cheating ways as she and Logan, by then engaged, were sneaking around.
By the end, a series of morally objectionable and irresponsible choices have seemed to lead to a child being brought into a seriously messed up situation. The path that Rory has taken has been very disappointing to many loyal fans. She seemed destined for greatness. Instead, her story became a series of dysfunctional relationships, zapping much of the show's joy.
5. True Blood - Sookie Stackhouse And Bill Compton
True Blood, the often times unnecessarily graphic television series, was based on the series of books entitled The Southern Vampire Mysteries or the Sookie Stackhouse Series, depending on who you ask. Both the books and their television adaptation started off being centered around the waitress Sookie and a vampire named Bill Compton shortly after the existence of vampires is made public.
In real life, stars Anna Paquin and Stephen Moyer have gone on to get married and have children. And that's sincerely wonderful. But their off-screen chemistry just didn't seem to translate the same way on-screen.
The relationship between Bill and Sookie, though it began interesting, quickly got boring and it became somewhat of a chore to sit though. Throughout the series, the writers kept coming back to the romance between them, even though the series seemed to truck on just fine when they were separated or just friends. Instead of enjoying much of an episode, fans could be left to feel like they had to labor through it.
True Blood's popularity seemed to really take off around the time in the storyline that things started brewing between Sookie and former Viking-turned-vampire sheriff Eric. It's probably not a coincidence.
4. The Big Bang Theory - Leonard Hofstadter And Penny
Even before the show went on its downhill slog in quality and likeability, there was the problem of Leonard and Penny, which has only gotten worse. It was so predictable to begin with. A pretty girl befriends a bunch of nerdy scientists after moving across the hall from two of them - well obviously one of them has to almost immediately fall in love with her.
Years went on of them breaking up and making up. Leonard's self-confidence did seem to grow, which would be a good thing, except that it grew too much. Over time it became clear that he viewed himself as better than Penny and pretty much everyone else on the show.
He became self-centered and seemed to have little if any problem with insulting the woman he supposedly loves, just because she didn't happen to be a genius when it came to science like the others. It was also painfully obvious that the two had just about nothing in common aside from their circle of friends.
And then there was Leonard's piece de resistance - he cheated on her. He also didn't confess to Penny about this until right before getting married. When a couple this unhealthy is supposed to be what keeps a show grounded, it doesn't have much going for it.
3. Game Of Thrones - Jaime Lannister And Cersei Lannister
So, these two are twin brother and sister. Really, the entry could end here and that would be more than enough to justify its inclusion, but I'll go on.
Even if they weren't as closely related by blood as a man and woman can get, their relationship would still be filled with toxicity. For all the bad behavior taking place on the show based on the series of books that began with A Song of Ice and Fire, these two arguably bring out the absolute worst in each other.
That's probably to be expected, given that they each decided to go for their sibling. Even as Jaime became more of honorable man, Cersei would berate him for it, because she liked him better as an awful person.
On the subject of awful people, it was from them that Joffrey came forth, probably one of the most despised characters in television history. Even after the character's death, viewers were met with a hugely controversial sequence between Jaime and Cersei in his tomb.
There's just so much about this couple that's so wrong and the amount of discomfort it can make a viewer feel can really detract from enjoying what can be otherwise quality television.
2. The Flash - Barry Allen And Iris West
It's well-established that Barry Allen (The Flash) and Iris West get married in the comic books. In the most recent television adaptation, Barry had been taken in as a child and raised together with Iris by her father. And it's a really good backstory, but it also essentially makes Barry and Iris brother and sister.
Despite flimsy attempts to play this off on the show, Iris' father has consistently referred to Barry as his son and Barry in turn has often called him his dad, while Iris' brother has identified Barry as his, you probably guessed it, brother. The awkwardness is obvious.
There's also the distinct lack of romantic chemistry between Grant Gustin and Candice Patton, despite both of them playing their parts very well. Romantic scenes between the two tend to feel so forced that it can make you want to grit your teeth.
Another side effect of this relationship is a level of hostility from certain fans. Yes, elephant in the room, there's a change in Iris' ethnicity from the source material. This has led to many cases of fans of the show who don't care for the relationship, usually preferring Barry to be with Caitlin Snow (Killer Frost), to be unjustly labeled as racists, no matter how legitimate their concerns may be.
One can't help but wonder if it's fear of this kind of animosity that has influenced the writers from moving on from this failing storyline. If so, it's time to summon some courage.
1. Gossip Girl - Serena Van Der Woodsen And Dan Humphrey/Blair Waldorf And Chuck Bass
The popular show loosely based on the books about an unseen Internet presence exposing the secrets of New York's wealthy began with featuring the mutual interest between Serena and Dan It started alright, but then their constant break-up make-up routine began to wear thin. And then it got creepy when their parents got married and it turned out that they share a sibling in common. It became even more unbelievable following the infamous twist in the series finale.
And then there's Blair and Chuck, a relationship of epic unhealthiness. So much so that essays have been written about the abusive nature of it. Laced with emotional and mental trauma, there were also instances of physical harm.
Eventually they wed, not because they were finally in a good place together, but so Blair couldn't be made to testify against Chuck in a murder trial. He didn't actually commit murder, but the slimy aspect is still there. (It should be noted that a number of disturbing allegations have been made against Ed Westwick recently. This entry is not to comment on his possible guilt or innocence, but to comment on the television show.)
And when Blair and Dan got together, a pair that supported and took care of each other following an endearing journey going from enemies to becoming best friends and love interests, many rabid 'Chair' shippers made it out like that coupling was the sick one. Such reverence for such toxicity is depressing and really taints the series.
Agree with this list? Which couples do you think spoilt TV shows? Share your thoughts down in the comments.