10 TV Shows Whose Leads Are The Worst Character

Heroes who lived long enough to see themselves become the villain.

Orange Is The New Black Piper Chapman
Netflix

There are many important factors to making a beloved TV show, but chief among them is the main character. While many programmes rely on a deep bench to keep things moving, your lead is the guide who brings people into your fictional world, and the anchor which keeps them invested once they’re there.

Your lead doesn’t need to be likeable - just look at Don Draper, Tony Soprano, or Wendy Byrde - but they must be compelling, and understandable. They’re the glue that often holds the whole series together.

So what happens when your lead character is by far the worst part of the show? Well, it doesn’t necessarily doom the programme to failure; plenty of series have managed to scrape by in spite of a vacuum at its centre. It does, however, create an imbalance, wherein the character you’re spending the most time with is the one you’re least interested in.

To varying degrees, these shows put their worst foot forward, whether their lead was the least interesting part of a successful whole or a dud who could have been removed from proceedings for a more enjoyable experience. When you’re first on the call sheet, the responsibility is massive, and not everyone can live up to that

10. New Girl - Jessica Day

New Girl Jess Day
Fox

Zooey Deschanel was the hook used to bring people into New Girl. The advertising was heavily based around the “adorkable” qualities that she and her character Jessica Day shared, and indeed New Girl’s Jess did seem a natural extension of Deschanel’s persona.

The series, however, quickly evolved beyond the initial episodes’ focus on Jess and her attempts to re-enter the L.A dating scene as a quirky, melodious singleton. The characters with whom she shared the loft - Nick, Schmidt, and Winston, along with best pal Cece - embarked on their own adventures with and without Jess’ involvement.

The issue was that these were without exception more interesting than whatever Jess was doing. She was relegated to the straight woman on her own show, such were the wacky qualities of the other characters and their more comedically gifted actors, particularly the exceptional Max Greenfield.

Jess still works well as an anchor and in no way would you want her removed from the show, but she’s the title character and yet consistently the least important part of the puzzle.


9. Scrubs - J.D.

Scrubs My First Day
NBC

Between this role and Garden State, Zach Braff became the poster child for male leads whose immaturity and neediness were supposed to be entirely likeable traits. He’s less galling in Scrubs than he is in Garden State (mainly because we’re aware he didn’t write himself any scenes in Scrubs in which he kisses Natalie Portman), but still manages to be the most twee and irritating part of a show that could lean towards the twee and irritating.

The main problem with J.D. is how dominant he is in the show. His voiceover is simply relentless, frequently telling rather than showing. We’re also constantly told how great and smart of a doctor he is, while in most contexts he’s presented as an immature manchild with a big ego but fragile self esteem.

Indeed almost the entirety of the original finale is dedicated to the other characters telling J.D., who’s leaving the hospital, just how great he is and how badly they’ll miss him. After nigh on 200 episodes following the guy around, that’s a bitter ending indeed.


8. Gavin & Stacey - Gavin Shipman

Gavin And Smithy Together, Gavin And Stacey
BBC

Gavin & Stacey is one of the most beloved British sitcoms of the 21st century, a warm love story between a guy from Essex and a girl from Wales, whose relationship unfolds over three seasons and a few Christmas specials, encapsulating their highs and lows, from whirlwind romance to domestic travails.

The problem is, no one really watched it for that. It was a sitcom first and foremost, and we were there for the laughs. These were provided by the couple’s best pals Smithy and Nessa, and their families, stacked with ringers like Rob Brydon and Alison Steadman. They weren’t provided by Stacey so much, and they certainly weren’t provided by Gavin.

Poor Matthew Horne was given little to do in the show beyond look exasperated by the latest setback in his fairytale love story, and to react to those around him, particularly the boisterous antics of Smithy. He’s played by James Corden, who co-wrote the show with Ruth Jones as Nessa; unsurprisingly, these two get the lion’s share of the funny stuff.

There’s no show without Gavin, of course, but he’s not the main point of interest for any viewer save, perhaps, Mr and Mrs Horne. Joanna Page, as Stacey, manages to milk a lot more out of similarly meagre material.


7. Angel - Angel

Angel City Of
Fox

The L.A based-Buffy spin-off was intended as a darker and more serious entry into Joss Whedon’s vampire-verse, and accordingly the terse, tortured Angel was the perfect main character. For many years, David Boreanaz was at least solid in the role of the bloodsucker with the soul, determined to find salvation for his years of evil.

We’d be lying if we said he wasn’t a little boring, though. Buffy and Angel alike had casts swimming with fascinating and colourful characters. Angel could boast demons, gang members turned monster hunters, an evil corporation, and a more exciting be-souled vampire among his entourage.

In comparison, the stoic, black-clad lead was a little on the dull side. Boreanaz’s performance was - by design - not the most expressive; meanwhile he wasn’t quite such a relatable lead as Sarah Michelle Gellar’s Buffy (who juggled high school and hellmouths) nor such a vulnerable one (she died twice in seven years).

This didn’t stop Angel from being a compelling and often truly inspired series, but while the title character was a compelling enough lead, the strength of the show was in its world, not its hero.


6. Derek - Derek Noakes

Derek Ricky Gervais
Channel 4

It’s worth noting that Derek is not by any means a great show. In fact, it’s a pretty bad one, filled with one-dimensional characters, recycled gags, and Ricky Gervais’ recent obsession with making trite observations about the nature and importance of kindness. There are good things about it, mainly the work of Kerry Godliman, who’s given more to do here than her thankless role in After Life.

The biggest issue with Derek, though is Derek, the character portrayed by Gervais. Nine years after the fact, it’s amazing that a TV network allowed him to do this. Despite his protestations, it can’t help but feel like he’s doing an impression of a disabled person that ranges from clumsy to downright cruel.

Even giving him the benefit of the doubt in his intentions, Derek is a dire character. Like Forrest Gump before him, his role is to deliver simple truisms that are meant to be profound, but are in fact greetings card-quality observations about being nice to other people.

True to form, Gervais gives himself every line that could be considered a joke, meaning he dominates the screen time. Some people liked it well enough at the time; it has not aged well, and only gets worse.


5. Gilmore Girls - Rory Gilmore

Rory Gilmore
Warner Bros Television

The key to Gilmore Girls’ appeal is the interplay between Lorelai and Rory Gilmore, the titular mother and daughter whose lived-in relationship is one of the best in TV history. They feel like a real family, albeit a uniquely witty one, and Lauren Graham and Alexis Bledel have unsurpassed chemistry in their roles.

The problems come when Rory doesn’t have Lorelai to play off. In such circumstances, she’s an annoying and often downright dislikable character. The bratty teen is never an especially likeable presence on any TV show, and it gets a lot worse when said teen is the lead of your show, and a character you’re supposed to find effortlessly charming.

Yes, Rory has an impressive set of references for her age and can banter with the best of them, but her penchant for a tantrum can be infuriating, generally taking place after she’s been rightly called out for dreadful behaviour. She’s also a child of immense privilege, albeit a generation removed, which puts a knock on any sympathy we might be able to raise for her.

The character isn’t supposed to be heroic, by any means, but the character flaws often mutate into a character who’s simply annoying - not a good look for one of your titular characters.


4. Sons Of Anarchy - Jax Teller

Sons Of Anarchy Jax Teller
FX

Kurt Sutter’s Shakespearean biker gang drama is a deeply flawed show which went on far too long and often lacked the courage to kill off significant characters, but there were many fine elements to it as well. The performances from Ron Perlman, Katey Sagal and more were terrific, and the world of the show was undeniably interesting.

Unfortunately, the show made the decision to centre its narrative around by far the least compelling character on its roster. Jax Teller was an attempt at yet another complex antihero who ended up being anything but complex. He scowled and moped a lot, carried out some brutal violence, exhibited some remorse, and repeated over seven increasingly dull seasons.

We were undoubtedly meant to think Jax was very cool indeed, and no doubt many viewers were inclined to agree. That only goes so far, though, and after you’ve seen him ride his Harley over the California highways once, you’ve basically got the idea.

It didn’t help that actor Charlie Hunnam is, despite his best efforts, not one of the world’s great performer, and when matched with thespian heavyweights and the colourful cast of supporting players, this tough outlaw looked awfully flavourless.


3. Orange Is The New Black - Piper Chapman

Orange is the New Black Piper Chapman
Netflix

Season one of prison drama Orange Is The New Black uses Piper Chapman as the audience surrogate character. Sentenced to a custodial sentence for historical drug crimes, she’s completely out of her depth, a privileged white woman surrounded by people who are, largely, nothing like her.

Over the course of the season and series, we learn more about her fellow inmates, many of whom are underrepresented on TV in the way Piper and actress Taylor Schilling are very much not. With few exceptions, the surrounding characters are more interesting than Piper, with stories more relatable, interesting, and important. It would have been easy enough to take Piper out of the equation to spend more time on the rest of the Litchfield prisoners.

Instead, Piper remains inarguably the main character for the seven season duration. She’s not a bad character by any means - and it should be said that Schilling’s performance is excellent - but the writers can clearly be seen scrambling for more excuses to keep Piper in the limelight, often pushing the credulity of the show as a result.


2. How I Met Your Mother - Ted Mosby

How I Met Your Mother Ted Mosby
CBS

Ted Mosby steers clear of the number one spot by the simple virtue of not turning insufferable for the first few seasons. Ted circa HIMYM seasons 1-3 is a great romcom lead. He’s a swooning romantic, funny and charming, certainly flawed but never truly unpleasant and massively relatable in his quest to find the one.

But as the show wore on, the writers made the lazy decision to highlight all of Ted’s most cartoonishly unpleasant characteristics. He went from a minor know it all to a pretentious lunatic (who for the purposes of a bad joke in one episode could speak fluent Italian). He’s a terrible friend, making a real effort to ruin Barney and Robin’s wedding in the final season and treating the latter terribly for most of the show’s run.

He becomes a character who makes very little sense, with the “story” he’s telling to his kids becoming utterly inappropriate many times over. Actor Josh Radnor does the best he can with the material - indeed without him Ted would be far more unlikable - but the disastrous finale to HIMYM hinges largely on the mangling of its lead character.


1. Dexter - Dexter Morgan

Dexter Morgan
Showtime

For a while, Dexter’s central character was its main selling point. The moral ambiguity of the serial killer who only killed other serial killers was a fascinating puzzle to unlock, and Michael C Hall’s committed, subtle performance was awards catnip.

As the show went on, though, Dexter became his show’s biggest problem. His moral code turned ever foggier as he killed to survive - to keep killing, essentially - rather than to redress some karmic balance in the universe. This reached a head in the final season, whose infamous ending remains one of the worst in TV history.

The showrunners didn’t know how to solve a problem like Dexter. He’d reached a point at which his crimes needed to be answered for; the logical conclusion would be a prison sentence, or death.

Instead, he sailed into a storm, then became a lumberjack. It was so disastrous that the show was rebooted years later. The results were similarly poor.

There’s a great world in there with some quality support and terrific antagonists, but Dexter was an increasingly unworkable character whose writing ultimately spelled the decline and demise of his show.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)