10 TV Shows You Were Ready To Hate

How did Game Of Thrones manage to suck us all in AGAIN?!

Rings Of Power
Amazon Studios

It’s a well known reality that TV shows, much like any other creative medium, can often be polarising. Whether it be down to the subject matter, those involved in the project, or unfavourable tales from the set, many productions find that there is a contingent of the audience ready to pour scorn over the material before they’ve had the chance to view the first episode.

Luckily, many of these preconceptions turn out to be false, and shows successfully win even the most sceptical of viewers over thanks to their overall quality. Yet more end up being a battleground of personal taste, where some love and some despise the material dependent on their prerogative. And then, of course, there are the few that thoroughly bomb, with an explosion of poor planning that television fans had seen coming miles off.

Whatever their eventual fate, all these shows certainly garnered their fair share of preemptive hatred prior to their launch. Whether deserved is up to you, but somehow, it seems likely there won’t be further greenlights in at least a few of these titles' futures.

10. Gossip Girl

Gossip Girl
HBO Max

The 2020s are shaping up to be the age of nostalgia. Low rise jeans and skinny scarves can be seen on fashion influencers all over Tiktok, and in the wake of the pandemic’s global uncertainty a majority of us have been settling in with the old, comforting television we know and love. Hence, the huge slate of reboots hitting our screens.

When it was announced, the bringing of iconic young-and-rich escapism fare that is Gossip Girl into the present was confusing at best. The original show only went off the air in 2012, and much of the magic surrounding it stemmed from the cultural climate it was formed in. Considering that none of the original cast would be returning, and that the titular Gossip Girl had been unmasked in the final season, many were mystified as to how HBO intended to revitalise it.

After the new iteration of the show debuted in 2021, those questions weren’t exactly answered. Gossip Girl received muted reviews that praised the cast and improved diversity, but criticised the meaningless drama supposedly driving the plot. With characters that are altogether too nice to dish dirt on, and the reveal that the teens' teachers are the minds behind the gossip blog, the show fell flat with fans of the original who bothered to see it.

Still, it garnered enough positive viewing from the fresh teenage audience who hold no unfavourable comparisons to get a second season, so who are we to sniff at a show that a new generation are having fun with?


9. She-Hulk: Attorney At Law

She Hulk
Disney+

It's safe to say that both the quality and reception of Marvel's slate of Disney+ originals has been... mixed, at best. Some standouts have shone through, but the majority have sadly fallen somewhat flat for all but the most dedicated of fans.

When a series surrounding She-Hulk was announced back in 2019, the response was primarily positive, as the introduction of a beloved female hero to the still overwhelmingly male-dominated MCU seemed a step in the right direction. With Orphan Black’s immensely talented Tatiana Maslany set to portray the superhuman lawyer, it was hoped in spite of the prior less-than-excellent TV offerings that the character’s humour would bring a more light-hearted, comedic tone to the franchise.

Then we all saw the trailer. And, more importantly: the CGI.

When transformed, Maslany’s She-Hulk was a plastic-y-looking, lurid green supermodel that teetered somewhere between uncanny valley and Shrek. Both fans and critics immediately found it unreal and distracting, meaning that much of the expectation prior to release was less about the quality of the narrative or acting, and more about how terrible it was all going to look.

While it remains somewhat egregious compared to the visual effects work of earlier Marvel properties, someone clearly intervened between the trailer and first episode, because the CGI in the show is a degree better than expected. Luckily, the writing and performances were received much more positively, and She-Hulk is generally regarded as a decently fun foray into the MCU’s take on sitcoms. The defence rests!


8. Dexter: New Blood

Dexter: New Blood
Showtime

When Dexter’s original run came to a close in 2013, it's safe to say that it limped, rather than strode, over the finish line. Despite an originally engaging premise of the vigilante serial killer, and a commendable performance from lead Michael C. Hall, the quality of the show invariably declined as it continued. In particular, the sixth and final eighth seasons received highly negative critical reviews, so that by the time the finale rolled around, much of its audience was glad to see the disappointing decline laid to rest.

Many were conflicted, then, when a limited series sequel to the show was announced. Consistent inquiries from fans over the years as to whether Dexter would ever see a continuation to follow the misguided original ending had been taken seriously by Hall and original showrunner, Clyde Phillips, and they sought to bring a narratively separate yet satisfying conclusion to the character’s story.

Dexter: New Blood later premiered on Showtime in 2021, following Dexter years after his faked death under a new, false identity. It received praise for the consistently compelling portrayals and its attempts to revive the show’s bloody magic, and thankfully performed better critically overall compared to the latter seasons of its predecessor, which should seem like a job well done.

However, an almost equally divisive finale saw New Blood once again disappoint many fans - which is ironic, considering such a fate is what the writing team deliberately set out to avoid.


7. Iron Fist

Iron Fist Finn Jones
Netflix

The last and least well received of Marvel’s original Netflix efforts at bringing a television universe into line with their big screen cinematic one, Iron Fist suffered in the public perception from the outset. Undeniably less popular than the comic characters upon which fellow Defenders titles Jessica Jones and Daredevil were based, and without the lead-in to fans of the preexisting shows gifted to Luke Cage, marketing was already starting out on the back foot. However, the show then went on to earn itself significant controversy in one of the worst possible fashions: accusations of cultural appropriation.

With the main character Danny Rand’s powers surrounding martial arts and stemming from traditional Chinese culture and mythology, despite being a white American, it was impossible to escape a rightly perceived orientalist, white saviour narrative. Both fans and multiple high-profile comic writers campaigned for the character to be changed to Asian-American as casting for the show proceeded.

Despite this, distinctly not Asian Game of Thrones alum Finn Jones was ultimately cast in the lead role. People were not pleased, and concerns about the direction of the show soon proved themselves warranted, as both Jones’ performance and the narrative representation of Asian culture in the show were unceremoniously panned.

The series did receive strong viewership despite its poor critical reception and perceived problematic nature, sufficient to secure a second season, but it was later cancelled nonetheless. Here’s hoping Marvel intends to reintroduce Iron Fist to the MCU any time soon that they’ll learn from their mistakes.


6. Avatar: The Last Airbender

Ty Lee Avatar The Last Airbender
Nickelodeon

It’s impossible to pass true judgement on a show that hasn’t yet shown itself to the public, but let's face it: based on the evidence, hopes for Netflix’s live-action Avatar: The Last Airbender adaptation aren’t looking good.

Set in a completely different universe to that of James Cameron’s blue aliens despite the title discrepancy, Avatar is set to be based on the acclaimed animated series of the same name. A show influenced by but not strictly considered anime, it follows a group of pre-teens, several of whom possess element-bending powers, as they help Avatar Aang to develop his own powers and attempt to end the war with the conquering fire nation.

This original series, and its spin off The Legend Of Korra, are beloved by children and adults alike. What is less beloved is its previous live action adaptation. Released in 2010 and directed by the one and only M. Night Shyamalan, The Last Airbender is often considered to be one of the worst films ever made, having butchered the primarily Asian-influenced mythology and cast almost entirely non-Asian actors. The spur this film left in the side of fans endures to this day, and so when it was announced that attempts were being made to convert the premise for live-action again, people were understandably alarmed.

Though hatred towards the upcoming adaptation did briefly turn to hope, thanks to the Netflix production budget, casting, and involvement of the animation’s original creators as showrunners, worries quickly surged again after it was announced the showrunners had departed the project thanks to creative differences and a negative experience with Netflix.

We still want this one to turn out well, truly, but at this point it just doesn’t seem likely.


5. Dahmer – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story

Dahmer Netflix
Netflix

Audiences will always find a fascination with real-life horrors thanks to innate human morbid curiosity. However, the true crime boom of the 2010s has led to a slate of extremely high profile, high budget stories about real life serial killers and, as is the nature with any adaptation of real life events, this inevitably divides critics and consumers alike.

The latest show to brew up this particular storm is Netflix’s Dahmer, which sees horror auteur Ryan Murphy executive produce a dramatisation of real serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer’s life with Evan Peters in the title role. Far from the first screen portrayal of Dahmer, the show nevertheless drew mass publicity and criticism thanks to its perceived sensationalization and glorification of the murderer, with particular ill feeling towards the lack of consent from the families of Dahmer’s victims - all young men and boys, with the majority being from minority ethnic backgrounds - to use their stories.

Despite the negative press, which ballooned further after Netflix applied and then subsequently removed the ‘LGBTQ+’ tag from the show, Dahmer quickly became Netflix’s second most-watched English language series of all time. Critically, it has received mixed reviews, which often praise the performances and self aware nature of the show, but agree that the staging of the narrative land it in exploitative territory.

Whether or not you personally feel that production of the show was justified, the controversy surrounding it is a poignant reminder that when dealing with true stories, the lives of those depicted deserve a level of care and respect that they are not always afforded - especially in true crime.


4. Halo

Halo Tv Series
Paramount Plus

Historically, film and television adaptations of video games have rarely been received well. Storylines that were created with an interactive medium in mind often don’t translate well, the intricacies of gaming culture and narratives are often misunderstood by Hollywood, and the quality of the vast majority of adaptations has been subpar at best. Considering that there has been a shift towards long form television adaptations over films, which arguably suits the typically 10+ hour run-time of games far better, public reception to some of these projects is gradually becoming more positive.

Halo is not one of these. While Paramount+’s series did make some winning choices, such as having the original voice actress for Cortana reprise her role, the initial trailers raised concerns for many long time fans of the iconic franchise. The show was seen as being both too derivative of other sci-fi shows, as well as not an accurate Halo adaptation, and harbouring issues in costuming and production value. If fans don’t think Master Chief looks like Master Chief, you aren’t going to get far.

In reality, reviews of the final product proved much more mixed. Hardcore game and comic fans derided the show’s faithlessness, while critics, more casual fans and newcomers praised the action and performances, but heavily criticised the writing and story. Thankfully, Halo made the explicit choice to be set in an alternate universe from the main games, ensuring their take on the source material doesn’t influence the original canon, so here’s hoping the greenlit second season will fix its mistakes and build itself into a version of Halo that is worthwhile, if different.


3. Resident Evil

Resident Evil Netflix
Netflix

Resident Evil as a franchise is no stranger to Hollywood. Having been introduced to the big screen through a whopping six films starring Mila Jovovich, and recently received a reboot in Resident Evil: Welcome to Raccoon City, it finally received its moment on the small screen in 2022 with a Netflix original television series. Unfortunately, it did so to the joy of very few people.

As with all video game adaptations, the apprehension of pre-existing fans was to be expected, with concerns that the source material would be mishandled. Resident Evil already had a slate of movies under its belt, all of which had been received varying levels of poorly by critics and fans despite being commercially successful. Producing yet another version of the horror title in the hope that it wouldn’t turn out like every dud before it seemed like the very definition of insanity!

This assessment was proven absolutely correct upon release of the series, when viewing audiences tuned in to find a show that maybe, just barely held a faint whiff of the games it was based on. Which would be absolutely fine, no matter what die-hard fans say, if it was actually any good - but it wasn’t. Despite Lance Reddick’s valiant efforts in providing a genuinely commendable performance as key villain Albert Wesker, one man cannot save a show alone, and the middling critical reception combined with extreme fan backlash saw the show cancelled soon after release.


2. The Rings Of Power

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power episode six cliffhanger Galadriel
Amazon Studios

Prior to Peter Jackson’s seminal film series, many believed The Lord Of The Rings to be unfilmable. Sure, the movies were forced to make concessions from the original narrative, but most Tolkien fans came to accept these in the face of an overall wonderful adaptation. Then came The Hobbit films, which contrastingly received extremely mixed reviews, with a sense that the series had sold out. So, by the time Amazon Studios announced its acquisition of the television rights, fan opinion had ended up somewhere back at the beginning again.

A television series based on the appendices of The Lord Of The Rings should have seemed solid in theory, with a sign-off on the project from the Tolkien Estate, proposed involvement of film series director Peter Jackson, and a staggering budget of $1 BILLION thrown behind it. However, the mistakes of The Hobbit had many fans sceptical, and worries only increased as a series of departures, and halts were announced amid production. Jackson was out, with the series legally required to have no connection to the film series; foremost Tolkien scholar Tom Shippey would also no longer be involved. Filming was also halted in New Zealand for an extended period thanks to the Covid-19 pandemic. All in all, despite being the most expensive show ever produced, The Rings Of Power’s prognosis wasn’t looking good.

Whether or not the show felt satisfying or stagnant upon release is largely a matter or personal perspective. While the vast budget was clear in the visual effects and production design, many criticised it as feeling soulless in its characterization and pacing. However, what certainly can be agreed upon is that pouring quite so much money into what is inherently a divisive medium is maybe not the best idea.


1. House Of The Dragon

House of the Dragon
HBO

Few TV shows have betrayed fans quite so spectacularly as Game Of Thrones. Following the almost maliciously bad eighth season, it seemed that the reputation of both the series and its showrunners had been ruined for good. Nothing could bring Game Of Thrones back from the dead, no matter how many Red Priestesses you chuck at it.

HBO disagreed.

A prequel based on author George R. R. Martin’s Fire & Blood received a straight-to-series order in October 2019 despite the overwhelmingly negative public and critical response to the end of its parent series. Fans were filled with either dread, or the smallest inklings of hope, while industry insiders wondered if this was a gamble that would pay off.

While expectations of the show had become more positive by the time of its premiere thanks to the casting of lead actors Matt Smith and Paddy Considine, and entrusting of the material to ‘Battle of the Bastards’ director Miguel Sapochnik as showrunner, it still arrived with a sense of foreboding. Game Of Thrones had burned its audience too badly, and getting it to trust again would be an almighty task. But in a move that all of us are now eternally grateful for, House Of The Dragon actually turned out to be good. As in, seriously bloody excellent.

Record numbers tuned in for the first episode, and thanks to a spot of ingenious viral marketing born of some inspired cast interviews, even more are now turning up to see what all the fuss is about. Damn it, HOTD, you pulled it off. In the immortal words of Olivia Cooke: oh, stunning!


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Writer, gamer, and enjoyer of all things visual. Makes jokes more reliably than headshots.