10 TV Sitcom Characters With Shockingly Dark Backstories
It's not all fun and games in the sitcom world!
Sitcoms! You all know them; you all love them. They are the warm light at the end of the tunnel after a hard day's work, the delightful treat after a tough gym session, and the perfect distraction to chuck on while eating dinner - because no one likes being alone with their thoughts. There's always a time for situational comedies.
Part of what makes the genre such great comfort viewing is the fact that it's just so light. Even when things get emotionally heavy, there's still a sugary sweetness to sitcoms that leaves you with a lovely taste in your mouth. However, within that overly pleasant presentation is a darkness that likes to creep in when you're not looking.
Yes, while sitcoms work hard to make you smile and laugh, there are many times when they throw tragedy and trauma your way. You can see this plainly in the backstories of some characters, as some of the most happy-go-lucky sitcom icons have incredibly dark pasts that counteract their overly bubbly presentations.
These characters take the crown for masking an incredibly tragic and depressing backstory with laughs and giggles.
10. Barney Stinson - How I Met Your Mother
Barney Stinson; the man, the myth, the legend! This suit-wearing, womanising, playbook writing go-getter is a textbook example of how to write a loveable, cool-guy character - even if some of his attitudes towards women are a little dicey. But, there was a time when he wasn't so great, a time before he became legen (wait for it) dary.
You see, Barney's transition into his final form came as a result of a dark past. He had a far from easy childhood, as he never knew his father and was often given misinformation by his mother (she even once told him his dad was Bob Barker, yeah, right). He was also bullied a lot, but the worst was still to come.
The tragedy that made Barney who he was came after he was jilted by his girlfriend, whom he intended to marry and live the rest of his life with. She left him for a rich businessman and even laughed at his attempts to win her back with a song, causing him massive emotional grief, which led him to "suit up".
Barney is hilarious, but underneath that bravado and confident persona is the pain of heartbreak.
9. Twyla Sands - Schitt's Creek
Twyla might not be a member of the Rose family, but she sure does capture the hearts of anyone and everyone watching Schitt's Creek. This loveable, air-headed waitress brings a breath of fresh air to the show and charms you with her upbeat energy, signature food creations and kind personality. But, damn, the girl's got a real screwed-up history.
Part of the character's humour comes from her constantly dropping disturbing family anecdotes without realising quite how tragic they are. She's got a father in prison, a mother who barely knows who she is (and is even involved in a cult), and a cousin who got trampled while performing in Riverdance. Somehow, that's only the tip of the iceberg. Yeah, you thought the Rose family had problems; try the Sands.
Her twisted past isn't even exclusive to family, as she's talked about other issues, such as her friendship with a sex worker, Trixie. Overall, it's clear to see that Twyla didn't have the most conventional upbringing, but you'd never tell from her cheery energy and emotional intelligence. What a role model she is!
8. Annie Edison - Community
Community is an amazing and often underappreciated sitcom that was never shy to delve into darker storylines. That's not just in reference to the likes of The Darkest Timeline or Jeff accidentally killing Pierce's dad (spoilers), as the tragic history of each study group member could land them on this list.
Between Jeff and Abed's neglectful fathers, Pierce's racist upbringing, Troy's performance anxiety, Shirley's failed marriage and Britta's just being Britta, it's safe to say there's a whole bundle of group therapy needed here. Still, the one and only Annie Edison trumps them all with her incredibly traumatic experiences.
Annie was so concerned with academic achievements during High School (mostly thanks to her overbearing mother) that she got addicted to Adderall, had a nervous breakdown and ended up in rehab. As if that wasn't bad enough, this tragic scenario led her to become estranged from her family and cost her a college scholarship.
While everyone's reasons for ending up in Greendale are unfortunate, it's safe to say that Annie's are the hardest, as she was destined to have a bright future but ended up losing it all thanks to addiction. This is a comedy, right?
7. Raymond Holt - Brooklyn Nine-Nine
Each of the characters discussed up until now has suffered because of unfortunate family mishaps, bad relationships or addiction. But, now it's time to delve into something far scarier and more powerful, systematic prejudice - oh god.
Character-wise, Captain Holt is an unbridled delight. He's stoic and almost robotic on the outside, posing a huge contrast to the rest of the cast. However, he's a caring, warm man on the inside. That's what makes it hurt so much whenever you hear about his unjust career struggles.
As a young, gay, Black man, Holt suffered an endless barrage of racial profiling, homophobia, and discrimination, causing him a tonne of difficulty in his career. Of course, the show presents a cautiously optimistic approach to this, as Holt battled proudly against this awfulness to make his way to the top. Still, it's hard to ignore how much unfair difficulty his career path was paved with.
It's true that Holt's lack of emotions is hilarious. But, when you dig a little deeper, it's rather morbid to think that without his cold, calculated personality, he'd never have survived working for the NYPD.
6. Ted Lasso - Ted Lasso
This entry comes with a spoiler alert.
Apple TV's Ted Lasso is a show not many people expected a lot from. The premise is great, but no one could have seen the sheer critical success of the show coming. It's a special kind of comedy that takes you by surprise and even leaves you in tears at times, and leading the charge on that is the beloved titular hero, Ted Lasso himself.
Lasso is the kind of character everyone needs in their life. He's optimistic, thoughtful, caring and an overall positive figure, encouraging growth and self-improvement. Of course, the show made plenty of efforts to hint at hidden darkness within Ted, especially whenever issues of his father came up, and when this was fully revealed, it painted a heartbreaking picture of his childhood.
In season two of the show, it's revealed that Ted's father committed suicide, leaving the unfortunate sixteen-year-old and his mother in a situation that doesn't bear thinking about. This act shaped Ted as a person and somewhat explains why he performs so many acts of kindness.
5. Dr Cox - Scrubs
If you want to talk about characters who stole their shows, then you can't miss the incredible Dr Perry Cox. This character came along and made Scrubs his own, with his abrasive personality, creative insults, high intellect and lack of sentiment turning him into an antisocial champion. Still, it was obvious that his overt bravado was hiding something.
While Dr Cox would want everyone to believe that he's some kind of mentally impenetrable medical genius, he was a person who had a boatload of trauma thanks to his horrifying upbringing. Perry and his sister were raised by a cruel, raging alcoholic of a dad, who would assault and attack them constantly. His mother turned a blind eye to all this, leading Perry to develop a severe issue with forming attachments to people.
In typical Perry Cox fashion, he would joke and quip about his horrifying upbringing all the time, but even within those gags was a noticeable trauma he couldn't escape. This really came to a head in the episode "My New God" when Perry told his sister that he didn't like seeing her because it brought back all the horrid memories.
Dr Cox is a nihilistic and dark character for sure, but even so, this is one hell of a horrifying backstory.
4. Jared Dunn - Silicon Valley
Poor little Jared, this guy just can't seem to catch a break. For starters, his real name is Donald, he just got dubbed Jared by the dastardly billionaire Gavin, and everyone else followed suit. But, once you dig deeper into his life, it's safe to say a new name is a drop in the ocean compared to what he's been through.
The tragic childhood of Donald Dunn is something that unravels throughout the show. He often drops little lines here and there about his past in foster care, and at times it's enough to send shivers up your spine.
As a child, Jared was put through the wringer as he was moved around the foster care system, where he was forced to do chores and was constantly verbally abused. So, he was treated like free labour, never had a loving family, was brought up being told he looked like a "ghost" or worse, and his only friends were a "stuffed bear" made of garbage (Winnie) and an imaginary Harriet Tubman. Yikes!
Of course, things brightened up for him as he became an integral part of the Pied Piper team and found success. But, damn, it was a long road to get there.
3. Kimmy Schmidt - Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt
Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt is a TV show about a woman who was kidnapped at a young age by a madman who locked her (and three other girls) in a bunker and told them the world had ended. Eventually, she and the others broke free and returned to the real world. As you can tell, it was a deep and nuanced drama that rivalled even the likes of Breaking Bad. Oh, wait, it's a comedy? What?!
Yes, this sitcom probably takes the cake for one of the darkest set-ups in comedy, which is highly amusing as it's one of the goofiest and most upbeat shows on the market. It's irreverent, brightly colourful, full of feminist tones and charming to the nth degree. A major part of that is the sheer loveability of Kimmy herself.
Despite her past being so tragic you'd think she was written by Darren Aronofsky, Kimmy is a woman with an infectiously sunny disposition. Being locked up in a bunker would cause most people to fear everything and everyone, but this titular character has an inspiring thirst for life. That solid writing - and the stellar performance from Ellie Kemper - make this delightfully zany series something to behold.
2. Charlie Kelly - It’s Always Sunny
It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia is a brash, vile and downright dirty look at what situational comedy can be, and each character reflects that in their tragic backstories.
Like Community, any member of The Gang could make it here. Mac's got a criminal father, Dee set her roommate on fire, Frank was institutionalised, and Dennis has been a little monster since he was born. Still, it's the incomparable Charlie Kelly who tops them all.
Charlie is easily the most endearing member of The Gang (although that's not saying much). A major part of this stems from how damaged he is, which is no surprise, considering his horrendous upbringing. His mother was - in essence - a sex worker, and while she was very loving, she often left him unsupervised, leading to him finding glue/cleaning products and developing substance abuse issues. It's also heavily implied in his music that he was sexually assaulted by his uncle Jack.
As if all that wasn't enough, his problems go back to before he was even born, as he somehow survived being aborted. Yep, that's the kind of darkness you expect when watching this show.
1. Phoebe Buffay - Friends
Yes, you all knew this was coming, but it really couldn't be anybody else. Phoebe Buffay is the absolute poster child for lively sitcom characters with wildly tragic pasts. There were times when Phoebe's mean-spirited backstory almost seemed too cruel, but she never let that get her down.
This character was part of one of the most iconic sitcom groups of all time, and fans adored her. Phoebe was quirky, unpredictable, hilarious, goofy and downright fun to watch. However, it's no surprise that she had a bit of edge to her, considering the fact that her past made her sound like a Charles Dickens character.
Phoebe's (non-biological) mother committed suicide while she was still young, and with no father figure in her life, she ended up living on the streets. There, she was forced to mug people and experienced a slew of horrifying encounters, any one of which would scar someone for life. She stabbed a cop, was almost murdered by an escaped mental patient, was arrested and even got hepatitis after a pimp spat in her mouth, just to name a few.
If she'd never spoken about her past in the show, then you'd never have guessed any of this, as she was one of the most irreverent cast members.