10 TV Stars Who Controversially Left Their Hit Shows

No prizes for guessing who comes out number 1.

Charlie Sheen Two And A Half Men Some people don€™t know a good thing when they have it. Television is a pretty decent gig, after all - stability, consistent paychecks, mainstream popularity. But despite all this, there will always be actors who make the decision to leave a show right when it€™s at its peak. This has a tendency to outrage fans, who are not only upset that they won€™t get to see their favorite character anymore, but also see that sort of thing as ungrateful. Sometimes they can pull this off without damage to their careers, but television history is full of actors who casually left the best thing that would ever happen to them. As much as people joke about actors having massive egos, a certain amount of self-confidence is a particularly valuable asset in their chosen field -- how else do you suppose they survive having their physical appearances picked apart on a daily basis and dealing with a steady stream of rejection? But the downside of all this comes when an actor feels entitled to all the opportunities, and fools themselves into thinking that the television career they've discarded will still be there when they want it back. Some actors truly are ready to leave their hit shows, and more power to them. But others have a tendency to put the cart before the horse, and that's when they find themselves in trouble.

10. Dan Stevens - Downton Abbey

Almost immediately after Downton Abbey came out, it became a breakaway hit, enthralling audiences on both sides of the pond (especially Americans, who have no landed aristocracy and therefore have a certain romanticized curiosity about the whole thing). And at the heart of all this buzz was the fluffy, on-again off-again relationship between Lady Mary, the aloof daughter of an earl, and Matthew Crawley, the Manchester solicitor who stands to inherit her father's estate and title. They alternately fought and flirted their way through three seasons, until Dan Stevens decided that he didn't want to get stuck playing Matthew Crawley for the rest of his life. Since his original contract was only for three years, he elected not to renew and instead seek out new acting challenges. And so it was that Matthew died abruptly, violently, in a car crash while racing back to inform everyone of his newborn son and heir George. Audiences were crushed at how sudden his departure was, especially coming off the heels of Lady Sybil's death from eclampsia only a few episodes previously.

9. Mandy Patinkin - Criminal Minds

Mandy Patinkin has something of a reputation for not staying on any one show for too long (his present run on Homeland notwithstanding). He'll put in a season or two, but that's usually it. In that regard, Criminal Minds was no different. He starred as Jason Gideon, the stable, fatherly head of the Behavioral Analysis Unit at the FBI, in charge of a crack team of serial killer hunters. The show was an immediate success, bringing a little bit of an edge to the traditional procedural. But good ratings were not enough to keep Patinkin interested, and he left after the second season to be replaced by Joe Mantegna. Under normal circumstances, these types of shows tend to be a little bit like the Supreme Court -- once you're there, you pretty much stick with it until you die. Procedurals are known for their longevity, and most actors are in it for the long haul. So it was a big deal when Mandy Patinkin left after such a comparatively small amount of time. Word is that he really struggled with the dark subject matter of the show, and couldn't face the idea of continuing to film a series about the worst of humanity. We think he knows what he's doing, though -- his career was thriving before he did Criminal Minds, and it's certainly not hurting now.

8. Ashton Kutcher - That 70s Show

Topher Grace may have played the main character on the popular teen comedy That 70s Show, but Ashton Kutcher was undoubtedly its biggest star. The role of the pretty yet oh-so-stupid Michael Kelso turned the young actor into an overnight celebrity. The difference between his level of fame before the show started and after it had been on the air for a couple of years was like night and day. So naturally, it was only a matter of time before the film industry would come calling for America's hottest new heartthrob. For a while, he was able to balance his television commitments with his burgeoning film career, but he couldn't keep that up forever. After That 70s Show's seventh season, shooting conflicts with The Guardian forced him to leave the show that had established him as an actor. Luckily for him, it doesn't seem to have hurt his career very much -- he's been a leading man film star for over a decade and is currently pulling in an extravagant salary for taking Charlie Sheen's place on Two and a Half Men.

7. Shelley Long - Cheers

Shelley Long is pretty much the poster child for leaving a show at its peak and having your career never recover from it. She was one of the original stars of Cheers, where she played Diane Chambers, a highly educated, massively overqualified waitress and love interest of Ted Danson. Long received a tremendous amount of acclaim for her performance, winning several Emmys during her time on the show. But after five seasons, amid major controversy, she left. The unofficial word on the matter is that there was tension on the set, particularly between her and co-star Danson (although both insist that they got along well and any conflict was strictly down to differences in working styles). Long also cited a desire to spend time with her newborn daughter as a major factor in her decision to quit the show, which seems reasonable. But she also must have been convinced that she would face no shortage of film opportunities once she left, which was unfortunately not the case. Her career never again reached the heights of her widely popular tenure on Cheers, and has served as a cautionary tale for actors everywhere.

6. Steve Carell - The Office

For a time, The Office without Steve Carell as Michael Scott was scarcely worth thinking about. The show had shot his career into the stratosphere -- although he was hardly an unknown before The Office came along, it turned him into a household name. And in return, he served as its anchor, the center of The Office universe that everyone else revolved around. How could the show function without the clueless Regional Manager? What would there even be for the other Dunder Mifflin employees to react to with Michael Scott gone? But it couldn't be helped. By the time the seventh season rolled around, Steve Carell had a massively successful film career to attend to, and quite frankly the show just wasn't what it once was. So it seemed as good a time as any for Carell to walk away. And as much as the loss of Michael Scott left a vacuum in the show, his departure forced the writers to be more creative than they have been in quite some time. The scramble to find someone (or several someones) to fill his shoes actually breathed a little bit of life back into The Office, if only for a short while.

5. Chris Eccleston - Doctor Who

The fact that Chris Eccleston left Doctor Who isn't surprising in and of itself. After all, one of the show's most famous tenets basically requires that the lead role be a revolving door of sorts. Fans of Doctor Who will have gotten used to the fact that their cherished actors will leave after a few years, and the character of the Doctor won't disappear, but merely change. When Eccleston signed on, we had just gotten the show back. He was the very first Doctor of the rebooted series in 2005, so we were all sort of expecting him to stick around for a while. At least until it was firmly settled into the BBC lineup. It was a huge shock when he announced that he was leaving the show after only one series of thirteen episodes. We'd barely had a chance to get used to him, and then he was gone. His one year tenure on the show was the shortest of any Doctor, and looking back it really wasn't long enough to fully establish the character. It seems pretty obvious now why he left, though -- he wasn't happy. We doubt that he really knew what he was signing up for before the international phenomenon became a reality. It's also easy to imagine that Eccleston, a serious dramatic actor, might be put off by some of the sillier episodes of the first series and less than keen to commit to another season.

4. Charlie Sheen - Two And A Half Men

Out of all the sudden television departures, Charlie Sheen's exit from Two and a Half Men was by far the most undignified. He had pretty much been playing a slightly less seedy version of himself on the inexplicably popular CBS sitcom, when his behavior started becoming more and more erratic. That's what massive drug use and very likely an undiagnosed mental disorder will do to you. His bizarre actions attracted the media, and when he began publicly insulting Chuck Lorre, his boss and showrunner, the network didn't have much of a choice. He had to go. The most popular character was kicked off a major network's hit show, leaving only the talented but less exciting Jon Cryer and Angus T Jones, stuck somewhere between puberty and adulthood and about to have a meltdown of his own. They weren't exactly subtle about their feelings towards the former star, either. Rather than writing his character off in an ambiguous manner, they chose instead to kill him, giving them no option to bring his character back in case of reconciliation.

3. Richard Coyle - Coupling

Coupling was a success largely because it was able to maintain a careful equilibrium with its ensemble cast. Each character had something to contribute to the whole, and unique styles of humor balanced each other out. You take one of those pieces away and it all collapses like a game of Jenga. Imagine what would have happened if one of the cast members of Friends had left the show three seasons in. It wouldn't work anymore. Well, that's what happened with Coupling. Susan and Steve had a grounded, dry sense of humor, while Patrick and Sally felt more like something you might see on Sex and the City. Jane lived to shock people, but Jeff? Jeff was a wild card. You never quite knew what was going to come out of his mouth. Richard Coyle brought a gleeful mania to the Welshman, and played a big part in the show's success. Three seasons into the show, and Coupling was one of Britain's most popular sitcoms. But then Coyle moved on, and left some pretty big shoes to fill. They tried to replace him with a character named Oliver, but he was a poor excuse for Jeff. As for Coyle, he's still working, although nowhere near the level of celebrity he had attained while on Coupling.

2. Robert Sheehan - Misfits

Robert Sheehan is basically just a giant ball of charisma, and it's an unfortunate truth that people like him don't stay in one place for too long. No matter how good Misfits was, especially during the first couple seasons, it wasn't enough to keep him there long term. His performance as Nathan, an utter knob that we grew to like almost against our better judgment, won him rave reviews from pretty much everyone. He had a magnetic screen presence that was hard to resist, and we knew he was going to be a big star someday. We just wished that we could have gotten another season or two out of him as Nathan. But alas, it was not to be. After the Christmas special at the end of the second season, Nathan and his lovably daft paramour Marnie headed off to Vegas, and that was the end of that. His departure led a mass exodus from the show, with the rest of the original cast leaving only a season or two behind Sheehan, doomed to be replaced by slightly lower quality versions of themselves. Robert Sheehan may not have found a role with as big of an impact as Nathan, but he's been working on progressively larger projects, and who knows what the future will hold?

1. David Caruso - NYPD Blue

If they ever begin handing out awards for the mismanagement of acting careers, David Caruso will be well-positioned. As it is presently, however, the poor thing is rather left out in the cold. Back in the 90s, he was the undisputed star of a little show called NYPD Blue. Perhaps you've heard of it. He received so much attention and acclaim for the popular cop drama that it seemed only natural that he could leverage that into a major film career. Caruso quit the show right when it was at its peak, shocking viewers and making waves within the industry for leaving a show that had been designed as a vehicle for him four episodes into the second season, after not receiving a requested raise. But despite appearing in a couple of well-reviewed films, he was unable to establish himself as a leading man, and his movie career fizzed out surprisingly quickly. Happily, he seems to have learned from his early mistake -- he was cast in a spinoff of the immensely popular CSI (CSI: Miami) in 2002, and stuck with the show for an impressive ten years.

Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.