10 TV Storylines Actors REFUSED To Do
Sometimes actors knows best.
The world of TV is so relentlessly fast-paced that the cast and crew often barely have time to breathe, let alone squabble over their character's creative direction moving forward.
After all, in any hit TV series most actors appreciate that they're part of a much bigger machine, and what they feel creatively might not reflect the perspectives of everyone around them.
But at the same time, if an actor is in a position to call out something that rubs them the wrong way or they feel could be harmful for the show's future, then it's certainly smart to pipe up.
And that's precisely what these 10 actors did, ultimately refusing to take part in dubious storylines not merely suggested by writers but in some cases getting dangerously close to actually being shot.
From actors who passionately felt that planned plot lines were totally out of character, to those who weren't comfortable acting out the scenes in question, and those who simply felt the proposed story wasn't good at all, these performers all let their voices be heard.
And for the most part, these shows turned out all the better for these actors not being shy about their feelings...
10. Saul Becomes A Murderer - Better Call Saul
Though Jimmy McGill aka Saul Goodman aka Gene Takavic (Bob Odenkirk) has been responsible for his fair share of death across both Better Call Saul and Breaking Bad, he's never directly killed anyone with his own bare hands.
But that almost happened in the show's sixth and final season, when Gene's true identity is found out by Marion (Carol Burnett), an elderly woman who befriends him.
In the show's penultimate episode "Waterworks," Marion uses a computer to learn that Gene is actually Saul. When Saul realises this, Marion attempts to call the police, prompting him to rip the phone cord out, pull it tight like garotte, and threaten her.
The situation is only diffused when Marion activates her Life Alert alarm, forcing Saul to flee the scene.
However according to Bob Odenkirk himself, writer Vince Gilligan originally had Saul indeed kill Marion at the end of the scene.
But Odenkirk, affronted by the idea of murdering a screen legend of Burnett's caliber, balked and jokingly claimed he even planned to walk if Gilligan didn't change his mind - which, evidently, he did.
9. Davos Crushes On Missandei - Game Of Thrones
Though Game of Thrones' beleaguered cast members ultimately didn't have much say in dictating the direction of the show's underwhelming final season, actor Liam Cunningham - who played fan favourite Ser Davos Seaworth - pushed back hard against one proposed plot for his character.
In the 2020 oral history book "Fire Cannot Kill a Dragon," Cunningham revealed that it was originally intended for Davos to develop romantic feelings for Daenerys Targaryen's (Emilia Clarke) friend and confidante, Missandei (Nathalie Emmanuel).
Cunningham flat-out told the show's creators David Benioff and D. B. Weiss, "I'm not f**king doing it," feeling that beyond the near-three decade age gap between the two actors, it made no sense for Davos to be pining after younger women given the paternal relationship he showed towards several notable young female characters in the series. Cunningham added:
"It's the only thing I ever stood up to them on... The woman is a goddess, but with Davos' history with Lyanna Mormont and Shireen, you can't have him getting the hots for a young woman... I'm not 100 percent sure David wasn't just doing it to annoy me... You're not undoing my hard work engendering the sympathy of the audience to have him be a perv."
Between all this and Davos having a wife and children in Westeros - something the show conveniently forgot in later seasons - it's safe to say that Cunningham was 100% right to veto this icky subplot, which would've just given fans yet another thing to complain about.
8. Elaine Buys A Gun - Seinfeld
Seinfeld had its fair share of provocative plotlines over the years, but one which was nixed during the rehearsal process? Elaine (Julia Louis-Dreyfus) buying a gun.
The season two episode in question, tentatively titled "The Bet," would've seen the gang bet on whether or not Elaine would buy herself a gun for protection.
Most daringly, it was also set to feature a sequence where Elaine points a gun at her head and stomach while referring to John F. Kennedy and William McKinley - two Presidents who were assassinated by being shot in those respective areas.
Staff writer Larry Charles said the episode was intended to probe the uptick in women buying guns in America in the late 1980s/early 1990s.
However, upon reading the script during rehearsals, Louis-Dreyfus refused to film it at all - a sentiment backed by her fellow cast members and even the episode's intended director, Tom Cherones, who said, "Guns are not funny, no matter what you say."
As a result, the episode was scrapped and replaced with "The Phone Message," which Larry David and Jerry Seinfeld had just two days to write.
7. Charlie Comes Back From The Dead (And Then Dies For Real) - Two & A Half Men
Charlie Sheen was fired from hit sitcom Two and a Half Men at the end of its eighth season, at which point his protagonist Charlie Harper was replaced with a new lead - downtrodden billionaire Walden Schmidt (Ashton Kutcher).
The ninth season's first episode also revealed that Charlie was killed in a Paris subway "accident" - heavily implied to have actually been murdered by his obsessive stalker Rose (Melanie Lynskey).
When the show finally wrapped up with its twelfth season a few years later, there was intense speculation about whether or not Sheen would return to bury the hatchet with the show's creator, Chuck Lorre.
And as it turned out, Sheen was indeed invited back to reprise the role of Charlie, in a plot which would've seen him reveal that he was actually still alive. He'd then deliver a meta rant about his drug use and apparent "invincibility" - he's got tiger blood, after all - before being killed for real by a falling piano.
Sheen wasn't interested in Lorre's idea for Charlie's return and swift re-exit, suggesting instead that his comeback be more heart-warming and provide a setup for a spin-off series, The Harpers, starring himself and Jon Cryer.
Lorre was committed to his original idea, though, and so the scene was instead shot with a stand-in, minus the planned rant.
But in an attempt to make it feel a little more even-handed, after Charlie was crushed by a piano, Lorre himself appeared on screen and was flattened in a similar fashion.
Sheen wasn't at all happy that Lorre still went through with the basic idea despite him rejecting it, calling Lorre "immature" and "unevolved."
The series' final moments certainly proved divisive with fans, many of whom decried Lorre for allowing his personal spat with Sheen to define the show's ending.
6. Jim Kisses Cathy - The Office
The first of two aborted storylines on this list which would've driven a wedge between an insanely popular TV couple, we have the planned infidelity subplot involving The Office's Jim (John Krasinski) and Pam (Jenna Fischer).
In the show's eighth season, a temp worker joins Dunder Mifflin's office to cover Pam's maternity leave - an attractive young woman named Cathy Simms (Lindsey Broad) who quickly develops quite the romantic interest in Jim, despite knowing he's married with children.
Though Cathy's attempts to seduce Jim are ultimately firmly rebuffed, creator Greg Daniels initially planned for the pair to share a kiss while away on a work trip in Florida.
The prospect disgusted John Krasinski enough that he even went as far as to refuse to shoot the scene outright, feeling passionately that having Jim cheat would risk obliterating the audience's investment in his and Pam's relationship altogether.
In the book "Welcome to Dunder Mifflin: The Ultimate Oral History of The Office," he said:
"That's the only time I remember putting my foot down... I remember saying things that I never thought I'd say before, like, 'I'm not going to shoot it.' ... My feeling is there is a threshold with which you can push our audience. They are so dedicated. We have shown such great respect to them. But there's a moment where if you push them too far, they'll never come back. And I think that if you show Jim cheating, they'll never come back."
And once again, the actor was right. Having Jim kiss Cathy would've been a devastating, wholly unnecessary betrayal of both Pam and the audience who'd spent eight years watching the pair.
5. Raven Comes Out - Raven's Home
That's So Raven spin-off series Raven's Home of course brought Raven-Symoné back to portray protagonist Raven Baxter, but before the first season began filming, Disney proposed a change in Raven's character which she wasn't too thrilled with.
Raven-Symoné, who is gay in real life, said that Disney wanted to make her character also gay in the revival, something the actress was firmly against and ultimately vetoed.
The reasons for this are complex, with Raven-Symoné evidently being wary of the Raven character being conflated with who she is as a human being. She said:
"The reason I said no wasn't because I wasn't proud of who I was, or I didn't want to represent the LGBTQ+ community in any way... It was because Raven Baxter is Raven Baxter is Raven Baxter. And Raven Baxter is a character that I was proud to play, even if she is straight, cisgender - I don't mind - let her have her moment... If you ever see me in another character, you see Raven Baxter, and that's just what the deal is... And I think the one thing that differentiates me from her is now a lot more."
That's... totally fair enough. Much as it would've been easy for the actress to use this opportunity to bring some strong LGBTQ+ representation to a popular brand, it was personally important for her to draw a delineated line between Raven the character and Raven the real-life person.
4. The Doctor Teams Up With J.K. Rowling - Doctor Who
Per its fantastical nature, Doctor Who is capable of getting away with a lot, and though everybody's favourite doc, David Tennant, certainly seems like he's up for anything, even he felt that showrunner Russell T. Davies' most fan-serving idea was a bit too much.
At one point, Davies extended an invitation to Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling to write an episode of the series, but when she declined due to her ongoing commitments writing the Potter books, Davies had another idea - giving her a role in an episode.
In 2008, Davies came up with the idea for a Christmas Special in which Tennant's Doctor would have to fight his way through witches and wizards in order to reach Rowling, whose written ideas have started to become reality.
But Tennant wasn't a fan of the idea, feeling that it would be less a fun crossover than an outright spoof, and in Davies' own words, "We've got to keep him happy," so the Who/Potter team-up was thrown in the bin.
3. Kato Loses A Fight To Robin - The Green Hornet
The 1960s TV adaptation of The Green Hornet had a few fun crossover events with the '60s Adam West-starring Batman series, which reached a fascinating head when The Green Hornet (Van Williams) and Kato (Bruce Lee) showed up in two episodes of Batman's second season.
The duo were in Gotham City to take down a - wait for it - counterfeit stamp ring, when they crossed paths with Batman (West) and Robin (Burt Ward), leading to a chaotic fight scene in which the quartet both teamed up with and then battled each other.
Originally, Robin was scripted to defeat Kato in one-on-one combat, but Lee, a world-class martial artist, refused to film Kato losing, quite rightly feeling that audiences simply wouldn't buy him getting hosed by the Boy Wonder after seeing him kick so much righteous ass on his own show.
And so, a compromise was met - the fight would end as a tie, even if it's clear to anyone with even barely functioning eyeballs that Kato was about to flatten Robin with those educated feet of his.
2. Chandler Cheats On Monica - Friends
Much has been written about Matthew Perry's iconic performance as Chandler Bing on Friends following his tragic recent passing, and perhaps the most surprising story to emerge is that Perry had to intervene and stop the writers proceeding with a cheating storyline.
In the season five episode "The One in Vegas: Part 1," Chandler was originally written to cheat on Monica (Courteney Cox) with a hotel worker after the pair argued about Mon having lunch with her former lover Richard (Tom Selleck).
According to actress Lisa Cash, who was set to play the hotel worker in question, the scene got far enough that she and Perry had fully rehearsed it - a sequence where she delivers room service to him and they end up sleeping together.
But the day before the scene was to be shot in front of a live studio audience, Perry went to the writers and declared he wouldn't film it, that the audience would never forgive Chandler for being unfaithful.
And so the scene was tossed out, with Cash instead being recast as a flight attendant for a scene with David Schwimmer and Jennifer Aniston.
Just as John Krasinski was totally on the money about Jim and Pam, it's fair to say that Matthew Perry probably knew Chandler better than anyone else, and having him cheat on Monica would've caused the fanbase some serious psychic damage.
1. Jill Dies - Home Improvement
Beloved sitcom Home Improvement came to an end with its eighth season, after Patricia Richardson - who played the wife of protagonist Tim Taylor (Tim Allen) - decided she'd devoted enough years of her career to the show.
Network ABC didn't simply take "no" for an answer, though, offering Richardson an eye-watering $25 million to return, but she held firm and refused.
According to Richardson herself, ABC were so desperate to keep the show going, though, that they then turned to Tim Allen and proposed a ninth season in which Tim was forced to cope with his wife's death. She said:
"So then they went to Tim, and they said 'Let's do it with dead Jill,' And then Tim was like, 'I don't think we can do that.' So then he went out and said 'Well, I think it's time to end Home Improvement.'"
Allen was reportedly offered as much as $50 million for season nine, yet he sensibly knew when enough was enough, and given that his and Richardson's chemistry formed the show's very foundation, it would've been disastrous to continue without her.