10 TV Villains You Wish Got More Screen Time

Fleeting antagonists we wish stuck around.

Jerome Gotham
FOX

When it comes to television, writers have a long time to build their villains up and give them the development they simply never would have received in a movie.

The overall time spent with a TV villain is key, giving audiences the opportunity to understand what makes them tick, what motivates them and what they're aiming for. It's a crushing disappointment, then, when a promising antagonist is shortchanged, and removed from the narrative long before their time.

Such is the case with the following 10 villains, each of them bursting with potential never quite realised. Whether this was due to poor writing, unfocussed planning, behind-the-scenes headaches, or something altogether more tragic, these big bads should've been around a lot longer than they actually were.

From animated sci-fi series to post-apocalyptic dramas, to revelatory crime epics and fantasy megahits, here are 10 TV villains we really wish had got more screen time. Major spoilers follow.

10. Livia Soprano - The Sopranos

Livia Soprano
HBO

The case of Livia Soprano is a different one to the other antagonists found on this list. There was no bad writing or behind-the-scenes fallouts that ended the family patriarch's run in The Sopranos, but the untimely death of actress Nancy Merchand.

For the first two seasons of David Chase's seminal crime drama, Livia Soprano was the show's overarching villain, a dominating, troubled woman whose very existence caused her mob boss son to suffer panic attacks and admit to needing therapy.

In a much less cruel world, Livia's antagonism and influence would've carried the series through for many more seasons - maybe even to the very end - and audiences would've been graced with Merchand's exceptionally complex performance to boot.

In fact that was the plan, with Livia intended to have a major role in Season 3.

Unfortunately, it was not meant to be, as Merchand tragically died after a battle with lung cancer, and Livia was swiftly written out the show's third season as a result. Her absence is felt throughout the rest of the series.


9. Troy Otto - Fear The Walking Dead

Troy Otto Fear the Walking Dead
AMC

Ask any fan of Fear the Walking Dead, and you'll find the vast majority were instantly taken in by Daniel Sharman and his deceptive portrayal of survivalist Troy Otto.

Appearing only in the show's third season, he was portrayed as the youngest and more dangerously eager son of secretive community founder Jeremiah Otto, a man he constantly tried to prove himself to as a strong and militant leader.

Possessing some sociopathic traits - no thanks to his terrible father - Troy was soon revealed to be the season's true villain, destroying the safe haven his family created and nearly getting most of the other characters killed in the process.

After that, though, there was a compelling change in his development that made it seem as though he'd become a redeemed anti-hero. Just as he started to show promise for bigger things though, series protagonist Madison beat him to death with a hammer, in irritatingly anti-climatic and unearned fashion no less.


8. Jerome Valeska - Gotham

Jerome Gotham Season 4
Fox

Despite being a constant fan favourite scene-stealer, Jerome Valeska never graduated passed recurring guest star on Gotham, turning up mostly in season two but sparingly throughout the rest of the show's messy but wildly entertaining run.

Portrayed by Cameron Monaghan, Jerome was a twisted anarchist and psychopath, based loosely on the Joker but working wonders as his own compelling villain.

More grounded and well developed than his twin Jeremiah, Jerome's was a messy, far too surreal story (he briefly died, only be resurrected, because reasons), but whenever he was around Gotham found a way to feel as dark and menacing as it was always meant to be.

Unfortunately, as a whole, his role on the show ended up feeling somewhat lacking and inconsistent, as if the writers were worried to use him to his fullest potential. If they had, it would've improved the series exponentially.


7. Barriss Offee - Star Wars: The Clone Wars

Barriss Offee Star Wars
Lucasfilm

At first, young padawan Barriss Offee wasn't a villain at all, but an eager Jedi who formed a strong friendship with fellow learner Ahsoka Tano.

After a couple seasons absent from the main story - during which time it was simply assumed she was still a loyal member of the Jedi Order - she returned for one last arc, in which it was revealed she had framed Ahsoka for a terrorist attack and had fallen to the Dark Side after becoming disillusioned with the Jedi way.

This promising bolt from the blue really appears as if from nowhere, and lacks any kind of development or meaning to back it up. It also doesn't really lead anywhere, as she's arrested and never mentioned again (not even by her Master).

Had The Clone Wars decided to give Barriss the development her turn to villainy deserved, her eventual downfall would've been much more compelling and well earned. Tragically, though, it just feels like a rushed-out character assassination.


6. Tuco Salamanca - Breaking Bad

Raymond Cruz Tuco
AMC

The Salamanca family are the Breaking Bad universe's most consistent and troubling villains, first introduced in the debut season thanks to Raymond Cruz's dangerously volatile Tuco.

The first dealer to ever make a deal with Walt White and Jesse Pinkman, Tuco's unhinged, drug-fuelled ways were meant to act as a sharp reminder - both to Walt and Jesse, and the audience - that the show's protagonists were seriously out of their depth.

Murdering without thought, manipulating without care, Tuco stole the show from the off, and seemed poised to be a major player until he was shot dead at the beginning of the second season by DEA agent Hank Schrader.

It's been reported since the show aired that Cruz was in fact meant to be a main character, but the actor found the role far too taxing to pull off, so he begged to be killed. Fair as this may be, it still would've been cool to see Tuco stick around.


5. Francis Wolcott - Deadwood

Francis Wolcott Deadwood
HBO

Played by the greatly underrated Garret Dillahunt, Deadwood's season two antagonist Francis Wolcott was unlike anything the western drama had ever seen.

Whilst the show was known for its eclectic locals and dangerous killers, none quite matched the menace and unpredictable complexity of Wolcott, a sharply-dressed businessman with a delight for killing sex workers whenever the mood struck him.

Thanks in large part to Dillahunt's measured performance and menacingly soft-spoken drawl, Wolcott was able to freeze blood with just a word, but just as he seemed to make a place for himself as a future mainstay, he committed suicide after his vicious employer George Hearst rode into town.

Looking back, Wolcott's death feels a touch too rushed for such an important character departure, and it would've been great to see him stick around as a thorn in Deadwood's side.


4. Sunday - Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Sunday Buffy
Mutant Enemy

All it took for Sunday to make an impression on Buffy the Vampire Slayer audiences was one episode.

Appearing as the main villain of the show's season four premiere, she proves a worthy adversary for the Slayer, and a madly entertaining one thanks to Katherine Towne's hilariously cocksure performance.

As is always the case with the supernatural drama's monsters of the week, though, Sunday doesn't last long, killed at the end of the episode by a battle-ready Buffy, never to be mentioned again.

Given how entertaining and surprisingly complex she proved to be, and how uninspired the main villains of season four ended up being (looking at you, Adam), it wouldn't have been a bad idea for Sunday to stick around as a more long-lasting threat to the Scoobies. Ah, what could've been.


3. Cornell "Cottonmouth" Stokes - Luke Cage

Luke Cage Cornell Cottonmouth Stokes
Netflix

Here's a rule everyone should follow for the rest of time: If you get Mahershalla Ali to play a villain, don't kill him off without giving him the development he deserves.

In Luke Cage, Ali only appears as crime lord Cornell "Cottonmouth" Stokes for the show's first seven episodes, after which he finds himself bludgeoned to death by his bitter cousin Mariah, an admittedly great character who nonetheless serves as a crushing reminder of what the show threw away in Ali.

Given the towering performance of two-time Oscar winner Ali, and Cottonmouth's boundless potential going forward in the MCU, it's truly enraging to remember how and when his time on the show ended.

Honestly, the MCU's Netflix series are all pretty damn great, rarely missing an opportunity to blow audiences away before they were unfairly cancelled, but the loss of Cottonmouth is still their biggest mistake.


2. Daenerys Targaryen - Game Of Thrones

GAME OF THRONES Dany Outfit
HBO

The biggest issue with Game of Thrones' final season lies in its treatment of Daenerys Targaryen, the Mother of Dragons who for eight seasons had slowly but surely made her way to the mainland to claim the Iron Throne.

Whereas the rest of the fantasy epic had been meticulously planned out, slow-burning and compelling, the final season decided to rush to the finish line. Within only a handful of episodes, Dany goes from virtuous queen seeking redemption to angry villain no one can root for.

Her turn to villainy is obvious in hindsight (and, it should be said, brilliant), but even so its execution is painfully upsetting, throwing away years of fan investment and making her final fate feel disappointingly unearned.

Had the writers slowed things down and spent a bit more time building up her downfall, it would have massively improved the entire series, and Game of Thrones wouldn't be remembered today for dropping the ball at the last second.


1. Shane Walsh - The Walking Dead

Rita dexter
Showtime

It's been over a decade, but Shane Walsh from The Walking Dead is still the TV villain we wish we could have seen more of.

Though his fall from grace and death at the hands of former best friend Rick Grimes is incredibly gripping and a major turning point in the series, Shane was such a compelling presence in the drama's early years that subsequent seasons often felt lacking in parts because of his death.

Most of this is down to Jon Bernthal's explosive, multi-layered performance, which effortlessly finds the vulnerabilities within the monster.

Instead of staying faithful to the comics, The Walking Dead would've done well to subvert expectations and keep Shane alive, perhaps to go off on his own journey before returning to the core group a changed man with even more baggage. The potential was endless.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Gotham
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/