10 Underrated Current Crime TV Shows You Need To Be Watching

Consider it a felony to miss out on these steller shows.

iZombie CW
The CW

Since the 50s with Dragnet collecting 'just the facts', the crime show has stood as a reliable piece of entertainment for the television department.

The genre has grown in tandem with the evolving medium and reached pinnacle heights with shows like NYPD Blue, The Wire, and Breaking Bad.

There’s no slow-down in quantity or quality at present either; the crime procedural is still the staple of network television with Law & Order and its hundred spin-offs and rip-offs still prevalent. Yet, over in cable and streaming land, stand-outs like Peaky Blinders, Narcos and Mindhunters are receiving their due as cutting-edge serial storytelling.

It's a grand shame, then, that several high-quality shows are being left by the wayside without applause or awards. Of course, it happens in this day-and-age of our ‘Golden Age of Television’ that things get lost in the mix due to mismarketing, an ill-matched network, or not standing out against its competition.

With May's renewal season upcoming - a time where plenty of worthy yet ignore shows get axed - it's time to get educated in these great crime shows that most of you have been missing.

10. The Mechanism

The Mechanism Netflix
Netflix

With Narcos evolving into one of Netflix’s tentpole shows, you would think a follow-up series by the streaming service and a key creative force behind it - director and producer Jose Padilha - would be a much-hyped deal. Yet, the first season of this Brazilian crime thriller quietly came and went internationally, and had a polarising reception at home due to its examination of an ongoing political scandal.

It's the flip-side to Padilha's Elite Squad movies, with those focused on the front-line of the corrupt Brazilian police force. Whilst this looks at the other side of the desk, unveiling the pit of bureaucracy that a police task force has to sift through to get justice.

It's not always an easy show to embrace, as a myriad of exposition and dense relationships are thrown at us with little time to breath. Luckily, it's anchored by a trio of fantastic performances; Selton Mello as the obsessive and broken crusader, Enrique Diaz as the laid-back antagonist, and Caroline Abras as Mello’s persistent successor who walks head-first into a thankless battle.

It can be slow-burn and talky, but due to its connections to a presently-happening drama, it makes for a baffling examination of real-world corruption that rings true and makes for fascinating viewing.


9. Good Behaviour

Good Behaviour
TNT

TNT has been desperately searching for a stand-out show that is worthy of critical plaudits whilst providing enough primal thrills for its audiences. With this melodramatic crime thriller they’ve finally checked those points, but ironically there’s not much of an audience to give it applause.

Based on a pulpy series of books centred on con woman Letty Raines, the stylish and sensually made show plays with several juicy tropes; nail-biting suspense, black comedy, melodrama and of course modern Noir, yet it fascinates most as a character study.

The impressive Michelle Dockery takes on the lead role, a damaged woman who is a hot mess as a human being, yet once the game is on, is an elegant power player - and whose thrill-seeking becomes a healthy substitute to a lifetime of addiction.

The story does stumble at times though, especially with a B-plot that has Dockery seeking redemption with her scorned family. It never really clicks and feels quite pedestrian compared to when it's focused on deliciously dark twist and turns.

Still, it remains a well-made piece of adult storytelling that needs to find an audience before it's yet another cancelled TNT show.


8. IZombie

izombie liv moore body bag
The CW

Despite its ingrained horror tropes sitting front and centre, this recent effort by Rob Thomas (Veronica Mars) has its heart securely on one type of format; the crime procedure show.

In a post-zombie world that has returned to relative normality, Rose McIver’s reformed undead helps the police solves crimes with her significant powers. That usually involves her eating the brain of a wrongfully murdered victim to find vital clues and solve the case.

Certainly, the premise feels like some desperate pitch for a TV writer to keep his job but the combination is a fresh shake-up to this formulaic sub-genre.

It’s hardly the grim and dark show the synopsis suggests. Certainly, when the nastier aspects come into play, it's quick and vicious, but overall this is a colourful, funny and breezy watch with an extremely likeable set of characters filling out its ensemble roster.

The results are a welcome alternative to the usual po-faced and overly serious shenanigans of these types of shows. With sharp dialogue, an enjoyable supporting cast and a refreshing smash-up of genres, it results in the most entertaining crime procedure show currently running - and one that deserves recognition outside its loyal cult following.


7. Hap And Leonard

Hap And Leonard
Sundance

Championed pulp novelist Joe R. Lansdale's, and genre director Jim Mickle made for a great match on the underrated movie Cold In July. The two team up again for a worthy adaption of the author's southern fried crime series.

Skillfully cast as the leads are James Purefoy and Michael K. Williams. The heart of the plot-lines showcases the tight and believable bond between the two - close-knit friends, that grew up like brothers - with them thrown on whatever crazy adventure Lansdale’s source material conjures up.

Enticingly enough, the show reflects the authors’ penchant for switching genres, with the flavours of each season feeling different. The first was a Southern Noir that switched into a bloody exploitation movie, the second a slow-burn murder mystery. Now with season three revving up, it interestingly switches gears into a tense small-town thriller with paranoid undertones.

It boils down to a show every bit as distinct and colourful as its source, as it drips with style, memorable characters and cracking dialogue. Sadly when it comes to mainstream plaudits and nominations this one is highly ignored.

Perhaps the underdog status helps elevate its pulpy cult pedigree - let's just hope there's enough of an audience to justify plenty more seasons coming.


6. The Sinner

The Sinner
USA Network

This murder mystery is yet another police procedure show, but one told in a refreshingly subversive manner; Jessica Biel’s weary mother snaps and murders a man in broad daylight. Now, that’s not a spoiler, it’s the first five minutes in a tale where the ‘how’ doesn’t matter, as much as the ‘why?’.

Bill Pullman’s Detective chips away at Biel’s haphazard psychology to get the bottom of this seemingly open-and-shut case, yet instead ends up cracking open a myriad of dark twists and surprises.

Pullman is solid but this is completely Biel’s show. The actress has been attempting to prove she's more than eye-candy for close to a decade now, with her persistence finally paying off since she is sensational in the role. Playing believably broken and haunted, and without an ounce of ego as she delves into pitch-black places that leave her barren.

It’s the TV equivalent of a good page-turner, and all the more impressive in that it takes a stale and predictable formula and flips it on its head. This stand-alone tale is gearing up for a second season- sans Biel but centred on Pullman - let’s hope they avoid the Broadchurch stumble.

Until then, this is ideal weekend binge-watching material.


5. Ray Donovan

ray donovan
Showtime

Liev Schreiber delivers a career-best performance as Ray Donavan - the troubled alpha of a tough Boston family that has uprooted to LA - his macho persona mask a deeply broken human in a fascinating central arc. Yet, regardless of the name in the title, this show is really about its ensemble.

Paula Malcomson is his hard-as-nails yet affectionate wife, Dash Mihok and Eddie Marsden the weary brothers, but Jon Voight as the conniving yet loveable father steals every moment he’s on screen, in a tour de force performance that stands as peak work. Certainly, the conflict and infighting are intriguing, but the show works best when these eccentric characters come together as a powerful unit.

While the crime elements can feel slightly repetitive as Ray scrambles to sort out that given season's problems, the true strength lies in the character drama and sharp writing. Showrunner Ann Biederman examines the destructive nature of the macho persona, as well as the side-effects of blind loyalty in constantly deep and biting ways.

Season 5 was a true game-changing to the regular dynamic, with a beyond bleak cliffhanger leading to some very interesting places. It's never too late to catch up.


4. Ozark

Ozark 10
Netflix

With this dark crime show, comedy straight-man, Jason Bateman, takes strides to move away from his typecast image. He plays a wealthy accountant given the option of laundering 5 million in drug money within two weeks or have him and his family on the receiving end of a bullet.

Certainly, the premise of the milquetoast male turning to a life of crime feels very Breaking Bad on the page (as is the unconventional casting of its lead). But once you get past the synopsis, comparisons don’t really rear their head, with its muted colour palette and clinical approach to genre tropes, resulting in a much different show from Walter White’s morality tale.

Much of this due to Bateman, not only impressive as the lead but as an integrated creative force as well, with him acting as a producer and director as well. He’s accompanied by a fantastic supporting cast with Julie Garner, as a vicious redneck waif, being the stand-out.

The climax of the season certainly changes things up in shocking ways, with the second season an enticing concept. Ignore the Breaking Bad comparisons and gives this fantastic Netflix show a watch, you’ll be gripped almost immediately.


3. Happy!

Happy Syfy
Syfy

Adaptations of comic legend's Grant Morrison work remain scarce, possibly because his distinct style is exceptionally hard to adapt. Thankfully, grouped with Crank co-director Brian Taylor, he has found the perfect kindred spirit to bring his specific flavour to live-action.

Focused on hitman Nick Sax - hilariously portrayed by Christopher Meloni - a filthy train-wreck of a human being, yet in a twist of fate becomes partnered with his estranged daughter's imaginary friend Happy (voiced cheerfully by Patton Oswald), in a bid to save his child from a chilling death.

Taylor infuses the material with all the pizzazz from his feature efforts in terms of production value, kinetic camerawork and crude attitude. His intricate involvement perfectly intertwines with Morrison’s source material in a faithful expansion of the comic.

Meloni is stellar as well, the criminally underused actor landing an ideal vehicle for his diverse talent, fully taking advantage of his intimidating alpha male presence yet coupling it with his off-the-wall comic timing as well.

The show certainly isn’t for everyone, but those in the mood for a fast and fierce ride with psychedelic visuals, vulgar humour and insanely gory action, this is your fix as its first season rushes by in an exhilarating cinematic blur.


2. Billions

Billions Damian Lewis Paul Giamatti
Showtime

Set in the high-powered world of New York’s hedge fund exchange, it excitingly pits two powerhouse actors - Damien Lewis’ dirty CEO and Paul Giamatti’s crusading District Attorney - in what deliciously boils down to Heat set in the high-powered business world.

Lewis is the working-class kid turned billionaire. While some of his methods are questionable - yet, like most criminals in these types of stories - he carries an admirable sense of honour and morality. He’s a fair man, till provoked, then a frightening dark side is unveiled.

Giamatti is at his scene-chewing best as his counterpart, the ‘cop’ whose obsessive quest to capture his ‘criminal’ will costs him all things he holds dear. His unconventional casting makes for a refreshing subversion of this usually chisel-jawed type of hero, and the results are a fantastic showcase for the hard-working character actor.

It's a high-stakes game of mental chess with razor-sharp dialogue that comes close to out Sorkin-ing Aaron Sorkin, with pulse-pounding dramatic stakes that never let up. So, basically spectacularly made TV for adults.

Still, it's baffling neither lead nor the trio of showrunners have landed worthy plaudits or accolades by now. So, do yourself and get on this quality show while it's still around.


1. Gomorrah

Gomorrah TV
Sky Italia

This Sky Italia production packs a similar power as City Of God did in the early noughts, revealing a frightening existence hidden away in the ghettos of an exotic land. Here, telling the inner workings of a modern crime syndicate inside the Italian city of Naples.

The days of the fat track-suited Mafioso are replaced by a much more chilling reality; the peach-faced youth turned cold-blooded assassin. Its approach is sobering, as there is absolutely zero sense of glamour given to the lifestyle. Gomorrah’s present-day criminals are more like rats, tearing throats out for cheese.

This story structure only helps accent the unpredictable nature of its characters, as every episode is told from a different perspective, and with no one safe from a swift and brutal murder.

Yet, its jarring nature is just as effective with the character arcs, as decent men turn evil, and killers become redeemed, there's a grippingly unrestrained nature to every episode where you're never quite certain what's in store - even from its main cast.

For those turned off by subtitles, it's your loss, this incredible show represents peak work in a golden age of TV; darkly disturbing but infinitely rewarding. Do yourself a favour and start watching - immediately.

Which crime TV shows are you watching? Let us know down in the comments.


In this post: 
Crime iZombie
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

is a working dad by day and a determined gamer by night. He’s paid his dues in both the gaming and film industries, and this year his first feature film as screenwriter, the Polish slasher flick "13 Days Till Summer", played at Fantastic Fest and Sitges Film Festival.