10 Most Unhealthy TV Relationships

Relationships are tough. No much more so than on TV it seems...

Look, relationships are tough for everyone, even fictional television characters. And sometimes, just like in real life, it takes an outside perspective to see a couple that are just not right for one another. There's either underlying psychological issues that make the relationship actively harmful, or something as simple as two people who don't have a ton of chemistry with one another. Most of these pairings are pursuing a romantic relationship, but some are just people who have sexual tension that is unhealthy for one reason or another. Either way, there are some couples on television that should just absolutely not be together -- their toxic relationships make them bring out the worst in one another, and everyone would be so much better off if they just broke it off. Every television show needs a little bit of romance, but some of these people are definitely going about this the wrong way. What's really uncomfortable, though, is that while some of these relationships are unhealthy on purpose, there's a few that are supposed to be genuinely endearing.

10. Wesley/Lilah - Angel

Hey, just because a relationship is unhealthy doesn't mean it isn't engaging and a lot of fun for audiences that are gluttons for punishment. Wesley and Lilah have a very interesting dynamic and tons of chemistry, but ultimately there's too much self-loathing on both sides for this pairing to do anything but implode. Wesley first takes up with Lilah, the gleefully malevolent lawyer from Wolfram and Hart, when he's at his most vulnerable. He mistakenly believed that Angel was going to kill his infant son and sent the boy to a hell dimension, earning the ire of Angel Investigations and getting himself chucked out of the gang. Oh yeah, and his throat gets cut. To say this is a low point for Wesley Wyndham-Price is a bit of an understatement. They both approach the relationship as a way to feel something, but as time goes on it's clear they begin to care for one another. Unfortunately, both characters are far too broken to actually do anything about it.

9. Leonard/Penny - The Big Bang Theory

Leonard and Penny are in one of those sitcom relationships that exists because that's what the showrunners want, rather than something that develops naturally as a result of chemistry. A Ross and Rachel, rather than a Monica and Chandler. The weird thing is, though, that they don't really even seem to like each other that much. They've been on-again off-again for so many seasons, but why? Penny feels inadequate when she's with Leonard because of his high IQ and oh-so-subtle suggestions that she further her education. Leonard is so in awe of her beauty that can become petty and jealous fairly easily. He's also got enough mommy issues to fill an inconveniently large building. It's so obvious to everyone but the characters that Leonard should be with a smart, nurturing woman (maybe an English PhD), and Penny should have a guy with average to slightly above average intelligence and halfway decent social skills. How many awkward breakups and beta tests do they have to go through before they come to terms with the fact that they're just not meant to be together?

8. Helga/Arnold - Hey Arnold

Helga and Arnold are endgame. Let's repeat that. Helga and Arnold are endgame. Helga finally confesses her feelings to Arnold in the Hey Arnold movie, and had the sequel not been cancelled, Arnold would have reciprocated. It gives stalkers everywhere hope. Sure Helga loves him, but she's not just in love with him -- she's obsessed. How else could you possibly describe a nine year old who writes love poetry about a boy in her class and keeps a shrine of him in her closet made out of used bubble gum? That's horrifying. Not only that, she's verbally abusive to him and goes to great lengths to sabotage his relationships with other girls, especially Lilah. It just seems a little too neat and tidy that after everything Helga has put the world through during her infatuation with Arnold, that the two characters should actually end up together. Maybe she does a lot of growing up over the years, and there's genuine attraction there, but like...how is she ever going to tell him how creepily she stalked him when they were kids?

7. Sam/Dean - Supernatural

These two have what is undeniable one of the closest sibling bonds we've ever seen on television, almost so much so that you might even want them to cut the cord a little bit. Branch out, see other people. Sam and Dean give off the vibe that if one of them gets a paper cut, the other can feel it. There's a reason why so many fans write Wincest fan fiction -- there's such an emotional connection there that it could almost be confused with romantic love (if they weren't brothers, that is). They've proven time and time again that they value their own lives far less than they do their brother's, and they've literally died for each other (repeatedly, because this is Supernatural, where everything's made up and the deaths don't matter). While this isn't exactly the recipe for a healthy sibling relationship in real life, on television it creates an engaging dynamic between Sam and Dean that keeps the stakes perpetually high. Each believes that they are nothing without the other, especially Dean, who seems to have been born and bred to protect Sammy at all costs, and if he can't do that he's useless and might as well kill himself. Thanks Dad, for that emotional baggage.

6. Buffy/Angel - Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Sure, Buffy and Angel are supposed to be like the tragic love story of our generation or whatever, but each character was much better when they weren't involved. First of all, the age thing is definitely an issue. Not to put down teenagers or anything, but a 16-year-old is just not mature enough to be in a relationship with a man who has a couple hundred years of experience on her. And what kind of 200+ year old man could find a relationship with a teenager even remotely fulfilling? It's creepy that he falls in love with her while he's stalking her, before she even moves to Sunnydale. Buffy's inconsistent and doesn't really know what she wants. Who can blame her? She's sixteen. But it creates a lot of tension in their relationship. She also struggles to come to terms with what Angel is. She frequently complains about Angel's vampirism, wishing things were different, but not realizing that's a huge part of who he is as a person. Angel doesn't really become a fleshed-out, emotionally complex character until he leaves Buffy and her entire show for Los Angeles. And in turn, Buffy is allowed to grow up and become more self-reliant after that toxic relationship is behind her.

5. Al/Peggy - Married With Children

These two just straight up can't stand each other. There's even an "It's a Wonderful Life" episode when Al sees how much better Peggy is without him, and he chooses to go back to his life because he can't bear the thought of her not being miserable. Al blames her for ruining his life -- he had a promising college football scholarship until he impregnated his girlfriend, married her, broke his leg, and started working at a shoe store. Although the blame clearly falls with both partners, his resentment of both Peggy and his children is present throughout the show. They seem like they actively find ways to irritate one another. Peggy refuses to cook, claiming that she's allergic to fire, despite that fact that she smokes. She refuses to get a job even though Al makes minimum wage at the shoe store, citing laziness as a family tradition. Al's favorite television show is called Psycho Dad, which is a Western that involves a man who kills his wife and children to get revenge for their years of "torment", which is slightly telling in regards to Al's emotional stability. These two need a marriage counselor, stat, before Al decides to emulate his television hero.

4. Norma/Norman - Bates Motel

The relationship between Norman and Norma is completely disturbing. Obviously. Normal mother-son relationships don't normally lead to the son wearing the mother's clothes, killing people, and keeping the mother's skeleton in the basement. A boy's best friend is his mother, and that well may be, but their relationship goes so far beyond best friendship it isn't even funny. There is altogether too much physical contact between Norma and Norman -- she seems to regard her son as a surrogate lover. She's always casually touching him in ways that you would expect towards a boyfriend or a husband. She's totally cool with changing in front of him, and sometimes he peeps on her through the bedroom window while she's dressing. Overall, there is a complete lack of healthy boundaries between them. Them seem oddly codependent, and Norma gets sulky and passive aggressive when he wants to do things with other people. Honestly, this would be an unhealthy relationship even without the incestuous undertones. But as it is, you can't help the shiver that runs down your spine whenever Norman calls Norma "Mother" in that slightly worshipful voice. And when she walks in on him with another girl, well...the less said about that the better.

3. The Doctor/River Song - Doctor Who

Alright, so this entry might be the one that results in a thousand comments insisting that the Doctor and River Song have fantastic chemistry and are a great couple together. And although maybe on the surface, people might be able to see chemistry (although even that's debatable), if you dig any further beyond there, the relationship falls apart pretty quickly. Being with River turns the Doctor from someone who is pacifistic almost to a fault into a man who is turned on by violence. There's something wrong with that picture. River Song isn't so much a character as she is the Doctor's shadow -- through very little fault of her own, everything in her life revolves around this man. She was raised to kill him, she's in prison for the supposed murder of him, her parents are his companions, even her archaeology degree was just a way for her to get closer to him. She's a character with zero agency and nothing really going on her life other than her occasional meetings with this man. And the really sad part is, there's no way for him to ever feel as deeply for her as she does for him. He is her life, but she is just a person in his.

2. Don/Megan - Mad Men

Ironically, the only women with whom Don has a remotely healthy relationship are the ones that he's never slept with. Namely, Anna and Peggy. With Anna, he didn't have to be someone that he's wasn't, and he and Peggy have such a level of respect between the two of them that sex never even enters the conversation. But Megan? She's another story. It starts off so promising, with the adorably fresh relationship with her and his children, after the train wreck of emotional neglect that was the Betty and Don Draper Experience. But then they actually got married, and as soon as the honeymoon was over...well, the honeymoon was over. Don is at least honest with her about his past, which is a step in the right direction. But he really struggles to be supportive in Megan's desire for a career of her own, especially since she wants to be an actress, which means his wife putting herself on display for everyone else instead of just him. It's indicative of the larger generational differences between the two -- Don is of the generation that expects their wives to stay at home and have dinner on the table when they get home from work, and Megan knows that's she's capable of much more than that. Of course, the fact that Don can't seem to stop himself from committing adultery doesn't help matters, and it looks like the writing is on the wall for this couple.

1. Cersei/Jaime - Game Of Thrones

Absolutely nothing about this relationship is kosher. First of all, they're brother and sister -- twins, in fact. Whatever, live and let live, as long as they're not irresponsible enough to conceive children together. Oh wait. What? Three children? That are being passed off as the spawn of Cersei and her late husband, King Robert Baratheon, who she was cheating on with her own brother? That's just not OK. Even if they weren't related, their relationship is suspect. Any couple that will throw a small child out of a window to prevent people from finding out about their illicit love affair is clearly not operating on the same plane of existence as the rest of us. The worst part, though? Jaime grows and changes over the course of the series, after being captured and losing his hand. He becomes a more noble character that is actually likeable if you squint your eyes really hard and accept the presence of moral gray areas. But when Jaime makes his triumphant return to King's Landing, Cersei isn't having any of it. She doesn't like him nice. She's not happy unless their relationship involves every single taboo known to western civilization, and for that reason alone, they top this list.

In this post: 
Mad Men
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.