10 Ways American Dad Is Better Than Family Guy

Are you a Smith or a Griffin?

Who would've thought that after shows like Scooby Doo and The Flintstones, the animated world would grant unto us the likes of Family Guy and American Dad?

Two shows that show how depraved the animated form of entertainment can go (unless you're an anime fan...). But does their similarity mean that they're interchangeable? They are the brainchild of one man after all.

Let's go with the notion that both are dissimilar enough to warrant this article you're now reading. Family Guy bears humor that is very much aware of itself, while American Dad is the more subtle of the pair.

It offers far more interesting and less stereotypical characters than Family Guy as well and more inventive use of plot, with story arcs spinning in and around each other on occasion. With that in mind, let€™s take a look at why American Dad is, ultimately, a better televisual feast than Family Guy. Does the quirkiness of the plots match those of Family Guy? Do the Smiths have more depth than their Griffin counterparts? Cue internet rage in the comments section below.

10. Stronger Family Set-up

Compared to Family Guy, the core quintet of characters in American Dad are so different in personality that they balance each other out perfectly €“ the macho-dad, the put-upon-mother, the nerdy-son, the outspoken-daughter, and the alien. Family Guy, on the other hand, sports a lesser sense of variety in its core cast €“ the idiotic dad, the powerful-mother, the dopey-son, the daughter no-one notices, the once-evil-now-watered-down baby and the talking dog. The children in particular in Family Guy rarely step into their own distinctive personas €“ Chris comes across as easily manipulated by his moronic dad, whereas Steve and Stan are so dissimilar, they€™re able to lead near-totally independent lives. After all, when was the last time you saw Chris hang out with a group of friends that he was the leader of?

9. Stronger Family Conflict

This diversity in family personalities very often leads to open conflict within the Smiths, such as the storyline where Hayley elopes with Jeff. Not that there isn€™t conflict to be found in Family Guy, just look at Stewie€™s constant attempts to kill Lois. But while the above example gave way to many a humorous episode in Family Guy€™s early run, there€™s no real logical explanation behind Stewie€™s murderous tendencies. Stewie even forgets his initial purpose for being on the show in the season five opener €˜Stewie Loves Lois€™. The conflict found in American Dad feels more natural, as if it were a real family against each other. Naturally, it€™s not without its exaggeration. €˜Home Wrecker€™ sees Stan and Francine literally split the house in half, each half decorated in their wanted styles. Ultimately, they can€™t bear to be apart from each other, tearing down both a physical and metaphorical wall in order to be together.

8. Stan and Francine Have A Better Marriage Than Peter And Lois

Having that perfect balance in the family set-up results in Stan and Francine sport a better relationship than Peter and Lois. Despite their wholly different lifestyles, one a CIA agent and the other a housewife, they feel far more like equals than Lois and Peter. You have to really ask yourself why Peter and Lois are together. They€™re constantly on different worlds, with Peter€™s mental age of about three meaning that their relationship is less husband/wife, more like son/mother. Consider the spoof murder mystery special, in the scene where Peter and Lois are in the greenhouse. They both comment on the torrential downpour of the weather outside, which leads them to argue over why, after 20 years of marriage, they still do elevator talk. And then consider the episode where Stan and Francine meet a younger couple and attempt to outdo their active, child-less lifestyle by reliving their youth. Stan and Francine essentially try to be the better couple, which is more than Peter and Lois ever do.

7. Less Reliant On Pop Culture

You could make a boxset or two out of the Star Wars/Indiana Jones/Back to the Future references that Family Guy makes. Not that there€™s anything wrong with that, it€™s a sign of an astute team of writers who can merge the old and the new in such a way that the audience understands both the show they€™re watching and the show being parodied. It€™s also the sign of an unfortunate paradox. The more specific Family Guy€™s references to various pop culture events/people, the more it becomes trapped in the time of its making. Being a tea-loving Brit myself, there are a good handful of references in Family Guy that throw me, and I just don€™t get them, a sign of either how specific the show€™s references are, or a sign of how lacking I am in today€™s world. American Dad has its own fair share of pop culture references (even less specific ones to ensure a wider appeal), but it trumps Family Guy here as it doesn€™t rely nearly as heavily on these elements to keep the story together. Instead, the main focus is the quirkiness of the driving plots rather than stopping to make a joke at some musician/politician/sitcom that our kids, who we€™ll most probably force-feed these shows too, simply won€™t get because the people featured in those references would be so far out of their time.

6. No Cutaways

Very rarely in American Dad does the plot stop to allow fights with giant chickens, bursting out into an old musical number, or to immediately explain a joke that€™s already been said. Not that the cutaways in Family Guy aren€™t amusing, but they force the already brief plot of 20-25 minutes to be put on hold while Brian and Stewie show off their dance moves. Additionally, the cutaways in Family Guy can vary wildly in length, suggesting that the longer a cutaway is, the more its being used to fill the gab in a shorter-than-usual script. Examples of this deceptive stretching out of the show are the Conway Twitty performances and that Bowie/Jagger video. American Dad stands away from such devices, instead utilizing the offbeat nature of the characters/plot to provide, at most, a brief pullover to allow some comic relief before roaring back into the plot.

5. Emotional Resonance

A trademark of American Dad is that at least one character experiences some form of epiphany in each episode. Peter from Family Guy also goes through some similar emotions, but in Family Guy, it€™s as if he€™s very much aware of his faults, and yet he still goes through with them every day. In American Dad, the characters work towards their emotions. Their faults are clearly displayed early on, and have a whole episode that uses a bizarre plot as a kind of vessel to carry those characters towards that emotional realisation. Interestingly, that realisation can be seen as only lasting as long as the episode/story itself in which the character has that epiphany. After all, these are only cartoons. Maybe I€™m reading too much into them...

4. Seth MacFarlane's Ego Is Almost Non-Existent

Wouldn€™t we all love to be Seth, creator of not one, but two of the most notorious and best-loved animated comedies of our time (and The Cleveland Show)? Family Guy€™s constant dry wit can wear thin very quickly, and one can€™t help but feel a lot of this comes from Seth€™s hold on the show. He created the thing and voices the three most popular characters. With American Dad, Seth was one of several creators of the show and reins his still marvellous voice-acting skills in via voicing just two characters. They€™re both central characters, but it€™s debatable whether they€™re the best, thanks to the diversity in personalities within the Smith family.

3. Plot Development

A key aspect in the appeal of cartoons is that they remain static. Characters don€™t age and plots may advance throughout one episode, but by next week the situation has reverted back to what it was in last week€™s episode€™s opening moments. American Dad treads away from such aspects, and more so than Family Guy. Both series have shared plots that spread themselves out over several episodes, but American Dad uses a greater shade of subtlety in developing plots than Family Guy does. Think of the storyline where Hayley elopes with Jeff, 100 A.D and Son of Stan. It€™s presented as a pair of regular episode of American Dad, a bizarre yet balanced mix of nutty humour with genuine emotional punch. Now think of Brian & Stewie. Not the characters, but the episode in which Brian and Stewie get locked in a bank vault. It€™s presented as decidedly different from much of the rest of Family Guy€™s output, essentially a two-man play. The fact that Family Guy went to such lengths to ensure a dramatic presentation can be seen as putting it below American Dad in terms of emotional impact. Additionally, after this episode, Family Guy carries on as if nothing had happened. American Dad at least offers tales that spin in and out of each other.

2. Treads Darker Waters

Both American Dad and Family Guy deal with sensitive issues. Drug addiction, family estrangement, death, sex, and alcoholic pet dogs all reign supreme in both shows. But where Family Guy deals with such situations in a sometimes drastic and bombastic light, American Dad somehow manages to pull its own topics off with ease. Perhaps because it€™s a fusion of the emotional maturity that lurks beneath American Dad€™s outer shell with the nuttiness of the show€™s plot and characters that result in storylines such as Stan€™s crack addiction being light-hearted. The show doesn€™t make a massive fuss over such things, when compared to Family Guy. By keeping its head above water, American Dad gives itself the ability to handle darker situations more freely than Family Guy could.

1. Roger

I€™d take Roger over Brian any day. Brian is still a fabulous character, and I know I€™m not alone in thinking that €“ just look at the reaction when he was temporarily killed off. But Brian can wear thin on me. The fact that he€™s a dog who lives like a human doesn€™t have that spark of amusement that it once had. How many women does it take to realize they€™ve slept with a dog? Exactly, no-one seems to bat an eyelid, but it€™s suddenly the worst thing in the world when you sleep with a transsexual. Roger reminds me of Dr. Frank N. Furter of The Rocky Horror Picture Show, maybe not in character similarities, but in how those characters engrain themselves on the viewer. Roger and Frank both dabble in the kind of squalid excess that we would love to take part in ourselves, but we don€™t as that would mean stepping out of line with the norms of society. Ah, so that€™s why Roger€™s an alien! It all makes sense now! Did you agree with this list? Let us know in the comments section below!

Contributor
Contributor

Senior editor for the superhero/comic book hub A Place To Hang Your Cape. BA in Creative Writing and Film Studies from Hull Uni. Currently getting lost in the big wide world of freelance writing. And some other stuff.