10 Worst Buffy The Vampire Slayer Episodes

Even the best shows aren't perfect, and Buffy the Vampire Slayer is no exception...

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Beer Bad
Fox

It’s not easy to criticise such a beloved show. This fantastical coming-of-age tale excels thanks to the smooth blend of genres, the smart scripts, and the terrific cast of characters.

The four primary personalities – Buffy, Willow, Xander, and Giles – are so entertaining that even some of the weaker episodes hold up all these years later. Add into the mix a whole host of memorable villains, and it’s fair to say that bad episodes of Buffy the Vampire Slayer are a rarity.

However, each season does have several low points which are hard to ignore. Given the strength of the various season arcs, such episodes often fall into the monster-of-the-week category. Whilst most of the villains are fantastic, some of these one-off antagonists fall slightly flat, particularly in the first two seasons. Even the terrific central cast sometimes struggle to make up for a couple of lacklustre adventures.

Having said that, what’s remarkable about many of Buffy’s worst outings is that they remain entertaining. Once you embrace the stupidity of some of these episodes, it’s easy to switch off and enjoy the ride...

10. Inca Mummy Girl (Season 2, Episode 4)

Inca Mummy Girl
Mutant Enemy

Season 2 has a lot going for it. There's a great season arc, plenty of wicked standalone episodes, and the high school setting has that classic Buffy feel. There are, however, some low points, one of which is ‘Inca Mummy Girl’.

It’s pretty intriguing to begin with. There’s a creepy museum, a dead mummy, and plenty of mystery. But things start to get a little ridiculous when an exchange student has the life sucked out of him by an undead mummy.

Xander then becomes romantically involved with the now youthful and attractive-looking mummy. Yet there isn’t much tension because you know their relationship isn’t going to go anywhere. And to make matters worse, the mummy’s guardian keeps cropping up. Far from being dramatic, these moments are laughably stupid.

Still, ‘Inca Mummy Girl’ isn't terrible. It’s pretty entertaining once you accept how ridiculous it is. And the introduction of Oz is a great moment even if the rest of the story is silly.


9. Teacher’s Pet (Season 1, Episode 4)

Buffy Miss French Season One
Mutant Enemy Productions

It’s no secret that Buffy’s opening season is a bit rough. There are only two standout episodes (‘Angel’ and ‘Prophecy Girl’), and the other stories are pretty formulaic compared with the rest of the show.

Indeed, the monster-of-the-week trope is present throughout this season. But the writers keep things interesting by throwing in twists and turns within the parameters of this weekly formula. The problem with ‘Teacher’s Pet’, however, is that it’s too predictable.

The moment Miss French arrives at Sunnydale High, you know she’s the villain. And when she starts her first Biology class by talking about the actions of the giant praying mantis, it’s easy to figure out what’s going to happen. Miss French’s transformation doesn’t hold up well, either – this giant insect is more amusing than scary.

The one strength of this episode is that it starts to explore Xander’s struggles with masculinity. It’s a theme which comes up throughout the show and this episode deserves credit for pioneering this story arc.


8. Him (Season 7, Episode 6)

Buffy Dawn
Mutant Enemy

With the possible exception of Season 6, Buffy’s seventh season is her darkest hour. ‘Him’, on the other hand, is a pretty light-hearted episode. The tone of the story is reminiscent of the earlier seasons due to the school setting and the wacky plot.

Whilst this may seem like a good excuse for some nostalgia, Dawn’s awkward adolescent romance is painful to watch. Sure, it’s meant to be, but it becomes wearisome rather quickly. The cheerleading scene, for instance, might be the most cringeworthy moment in the entire show.

As the episode progresses, other girls start falling for Dawn’s love interest, including Buffy. This leads to plenty of verbal spats between the characters. And though these scenes are entertaining, the tone of the episode feels off compared with the rest of the season.

Still, if you view this episode in isolation, it’s not without merit. Buffy’s attempt to kill the principal is hilarious and the Xander-Spike double act is great to witness as well.


7. Listening To Fear (Season 5, Episode 9)

Buffy Queller
Mutant Enemy

Season 5 is the best season outside of Buffy’s high school years, and as such, ‘Listening to Fear’ is a bit of an outlier.

It starts off okay – the opening section at the hospital with Buffy, Dawn, and Joyce is innocent enough. And the part where Willow and Tara stare at the stars is a great moment. Unfortunately, this tender scene is interrupted by a meteorite burning across the night sky. A Queller Demon then spawns from this meteorite and makes its way to the hospital.

This is when the problems start to arise. For one thing, how on earth does the demon get around without being seen? It doesn’t exactly blend in with the rest of the hospital. And secondly, why did the writers feel the need to bring back Riley’s commando squad? This odd addition to the episode feels completely out of place given the Initiative was one of the worst aspects of the previous season.

Whilst the Queller Demon is terrifying during the closing stages of the episode, this isn’t enough to make up for the rest of the story.


6. Go Fish (Season 2, Episode 20)

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Go Fish
Fox

‘Go Fish’ is a strong contender for the most ridiculous episode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. It feels like a throwback to some of the worst moments from Season 1 and it’s thrown into sharp relief by the terrific two-part finale which comes immediately after.

The story centres around the Sunnydale High swimming coach and his team of swimmers. In order to make the team more athletic, the coach doses them with a unique performance-enhancing drug. Unfortunately, several of the boys are overexposed to the drug and transform into giant fish known as Gill Monsters.

This ludicrous premise is impossible to take seriously. The way to experience this episode is to accept the madness and enjoy watching the gang struggle against a group of giant fish. The adventure is actually quite amusing once you realise the quality of the story is never going to pick up.

Objectively, there’s nothing good about ‘Go Fish’ – the plot is too stupid. But you’d be mad to skip this episode given how hilariously bad it is.


5. Beer Bad (Season 4, Episode 5)

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Beer Bad
Fox

But there’s another Buffy adventure which is even sillier than ‘Go Fish’. The fifth episode of Season 4 sees our central heroine consume way too much alcohol and the consequences are disastrous.

As it turns out, the beer has been tampered with by a mad bar owner who wants revenge on college kids for picking on him over the years. Before long, the students transform into Neanderthals and start roaming around UC Sunnydale. Buffy also feels the effects of the beer and has to save the day despite having the mentality of a cavewoman.

Like ‘Go Fish’, however, you can enjoy this episode once you accept how awful it is. It’s hard not to chuckle at the rampaging cavemen. And it’s also funny to see Buffy whack Parker over the head with a club at the end of the episode.

The central message of the story – don’t drink too much – has no subtlety whatsoever. And ironically enough, you would probably enjoy the episode more if you weren’t sober.


4. Goodbye Iowa (Season 4, Episode 14)

Adam Buffy
Mutant Enemy Productions

'Beer Bad’ isn’t the worst episode in Season 4, though. Due to the lack of humour and the dull plot, ‘Goodbye Iowa’ is the lowest point of Buffy’s fourth season.

The central issue with Season 4 is the overarching storyline and it’s the only season with a subpar Big Bad. There’s just nothing interesting about Adam – he looks freaky, he’s deadly, but there’s not much substance. And given his flat line delivery, his dialogue isn’t memorable, either.

‘Goodbye Iowa’ spends a lot of time with this lacklustre villain. In fact, the entire episode is centred around the Initiative, which means it’s essentially an amalgamation of all the worst aspects of Season 4. There’s too much Riley, too much Adam, and too much of the Initiative.

Spike’s dialogue – as ever – provides some entertainment, but it’s not enough to save the episode on its own. Luckily, the following two-part story gets the season back on track thanks to the return of Faith.


3. Bad Eggs (Season 2, Episode 12)

Bezoar - Buffy the Vampire Slayer - Bad Eggs
Mutant Enemy

‘Bag Eggs’ is the worst part of Buffy’s second season. Whilst ‘Inca Mummy Girl’ and ‘Go Fish’ are silly and entertaining, this episode is boring.

The story starts with a sex-ed class where Mr. Whitmore gives each student an egg in order to teach them that sex leads to responsibility. This alone is pretty strange, but things become weirder when the eggs hatch and insect-like mutants latch onto the back of their respective students.

With a bit of research, Buffy and Xander discover that these creatures are the offspring of a giant Bezoar, which happens to live beneath Sunnydale High. Buffy, of course, kills this creature and things soon get back to normal. It’s a predictable end to a bizarre episode that doesn’t have any replay value whatsoever.

The only mildly amusing scenes are those involving Xander and Cordelia as they continue their secret love affair. But aside from that, this episode isn’t worth bothering with.


2. As You Were (Season 6, Episode 15)

Buffy Riley Finn 16
Mutant Enemy Productions

When Riley left midway through Season 5, no Buffy fan was sorry to see him go. But the writers decided to bring back the Slayer’s most forgettable love interest for ‘As You Were’.

The story bears almost no relevance to the rest of the season – so it wouldn’t do too much harm to simply skip it. The plot centres around Riley’s return to Sunnydale. He asks Buffy to help him hunt down a Suvolte Demon and said demon is possibly the most boring monster in the show. It’s just a noisy, sluggish brute with no dialogue or personality. And after they defeat this forgettable foe, they then have to kill its equally forgettable offspring.

It’s a dull mission, all things considered. There’s just no sense of intrigue or fun. Even Xander and Anya’s comedic personalities fall flat as they spend most of their time bickering about the upcoming wedding.

The one saving grace is the closing lines between Spike and Buffy. It’s a heartfelt moment with superb dialogue that should have been placed at the end of a much better episode.


1. I, Robot…You, Jane (Season 1, Episode 8)

buffy robotjane willow
Mutant Enemy

This episode is Season 1 at its worst. Aside from a couple of amusing scenes, there’s nothing in this episode worthy of merit. It somehow manages to be both ridiculous and dull.

The central issue is that Willow is supposed to be an intelligent young lady, yet she becomes besotted with an online pen pal who’s clearly a creep. As it turns out, Willow’s new ‘boyfriend’ is actually a killer robot-demon from the fifteenth century with horrific dialogue and a laughable costume design.

And to make matters worse, far too much of the episode is spent with characters gazing at computer screens. Once you throw in the electric-shower scene, Dave’s murder, and the ridiculous climax, you’ve got a pretty poor storyline.

At the end of the episode, Willow voices her shame at having been misled so easily, whilst Buffy and Xander point out their own failed attempts at love over the course of the season. It’s a sweet end to the story but it’s not enough to redeem the rest of this atrocious episode.


Buffy The Vampire Slayer Quiz: How Much Do You Know About The Vampires?

Angel tv series
20th Television

1. Where Is Angel’s Tattoo Located?

Contributor

Love to read and write. Have an unhealthy obsession with Harry Potter. Enjoy running up hills.