10 Worst Episodes Of Otherwise Excellent Sci-Fi TV Shows
Every great Sci-Fi series has one or two stinker episodes and these are the worst of them all!
Everyone has their favorite television shows they go back and watch over and over again, but if you’re like most people, there’s an episode you skip while binging. Unfortunately, an amazing series rarely gets it right every single time, and there’s always that one episode the fans just didn’t like.
This is especially true of science fiction series, which tend to go after various themes that can often be divisive among fans. A bad episode in an otherwise great series might offend, or it simply may cover a topic that’s boring to most viewers — whatever it is, it’s no good.
This can happen when a guest writer or director takes the show in a direction the fans don’t like, but in reality, it can be the result of a hundred little things that simply didn’t work. Beloved characters doing something that’s out of character can send fans to the Internet to express their rage — it happens all the time.
This list takes a look at the sci-fi series that are arguably some of the best out there, but they still have that one episode. They can’t all be Emmy Award-winning pieces of perfection, so take this list as a guide of what you can safely skip if you decide to get into one of these otherwise fantastic series.
10. Star Trek: The Next Generation - “Shades Of Gray”
Star Trek: The Next Generation took some time to find its footing. There were some bad episodes early on, which is relatively normal — especially for sci-fi. The second season was mostly strong, but the 22nd episode, "Shades of Gray," is often cited as one of the series' worst.
First and foremost, "Shades of Gray" is a clip show, and viewers rarely enjoy seeing a rehashing of scenes from previous episodes repackaged into something "new." Still, clip shows can be forgiven (sometimes), but not in the case of this episode, as it doesn't even look back on anything particularly interesting.
The plot sees Commander Riker infected with an alien virus, which will kill him in only a few hours. Dr. Pulaski puts him in a machine that will stimulate his neurons, which helps to fight the virus. As he lay inside the machine, he dreams of his past adventures; hence, it's a clip show.
This causes some problems when his mind returns to his passionate endeavors. The virus feeds off those, so Deanna helps him to evoke negative dreams instead. She does this, and it begins to work, so she ups the intensity. More clips roll, and in the end, the virus is defeated.
9. The X-Files - “First Person Shooter”
The X-Files' seventh season bore some decent episodes in the long-running series, but the 13th episode, "First Person Shooter," is widely considered the worst episode of the whole franchise. The episode was written, in part, by William Gibson, the pioneer of cyberpunk, but even his words couldn't make this work.
"First Person Shooter" takes Mulder and Scully into the world of virtual reality, but this was shot and released in 2000, so it's a victim of its era. Other than that, it doesn't have a grasp of the technical jargon most people would have known at the time, making the whole thing feel as if it was out of place and out of time.
The episode revolves around a game called First Person Shooter, which places people inside a virtual world. Inside, there is a female character named Maitreya, who manages to kill players IRL. Through their investigation, Mulder and Scully choose to jump inside the game to take out the character.
They don't do a very good job at it, and by the end, they are about to be killed. The only way they could be saved was to destroy the game, so that's what happens. The game is erased, Scully and Mulder survive, and life goes on.
8. Black Mirror - “Rachel, Jack, And Ashley Too
Black Mirror is an incredibly well-written series, and throughout its 22 episodes, it's been fairly consistent at producing excellent television. That being said, it's not easy to keep it up forever, and the worst episode of the series happens to be the last one aired in its fifth season.
“Rachel, Jack, And Ashley Too" features great acting from the principal players, but the script wasn't up to the standards set early in the series. The episode centers around a 15-year-old girl named Rachel, who receives an Ashley Too robot for her birthday. The robot's personality is derived from a real pop star, played by Miley Cyrus.
The real Ashley O runs afoul of her aunt/manager Catherine, who introduces mood-altering meds into her food. She added too much, and Ashley O slips into a coma. Later, Ashley Too's limiter chip is removed, which leaves it with a perfect digital imprint of the pop star's mind.
Ashley Too and Rachel head to Ashley O's place to euthanize the comatose woman, but after unplugging her, she awakens, as the machines were keeping her in a coma. Ultimately, they crash a concert featuring a holographic "Ashley Eternal," they thwart Catherine's plans, and the day is saved.
7. Doctor Who - “Fear Her”
The new Doctor Who series that began in 2005 has been mostly consistent with its delivery of excellent episodes, but that doesn't mean there aren't a few the fans simply didn't like. The one at the top of those lists is usually "Fear Her," the 11th episode from the second season.
The episode was purchased as a low-budget replacement for a script Stephen Fry wrote that was pushed back. It was designed to be oriented towards children as a lighter episode that would reduce the dark tone that was building up to the season finale.
In the episode, the Tenth Doctor and Rose head to 2012 to watch the Olympic Games, but they stumble across a series of disappearances around a street. Through their investigation, the Doctor learns that a little girl named Chloe has the ability to trap people in drawings, which she derived from an Isolus that has attached itself to her.
Ultimately, she captures the attendees of the Olympic stadium, but the light of the Olympic Flame and the emotion of the crowd attracts the Isolus away from Chloe. The episode has been criticized for its slow pacing and formulaic plot, which seemed out of place in the season.
6. Stargate SG-1 - “Emancipation”
Stargate SG-1 is a great series that lasted for ten seasons and spawned multiple spinoffs to create a relatively large franchise. The series has a stinker or two spread across its 214 episodes, but the one that most fans point to as the worst is "Emancipation" from the first season.
The episode finds the team on the planet Simarka, which Daniel concludes was settled by people taken from the Mongol civilization. This becomes a bit of a problem when Sam is seen by the locals, who don't accept women being anything but utterly subservient to men.
Sam is traded like a commodity, and while she's not willing to let this go without a fight, she ultimately relents to buy time. She's a strong female character, and seeing her treated like that should have gotten the episode's message across, but all it really did was frustrate the fans.
"Emancipation" had a good concept in its take on the issue of women's rights in society, but it was executed poorly. This was especially true, seeing as it is only the fourth episode in the entire series. It might have worked better had the writers pitched this one much later when the series found its footing.
5. Battlestar Galactica - “Black Market”
The rebooted Battlestar Galactica series that premiered in 2003/2004 was widely praised for its dynamic take on the human/Cylon war. The show was filled with heart-racing action scenes and impressive visual effects that still look decent more than a decade after the series concluded.
There were 76 episodes in the series, and while most of them consisted of great scripts and impressive characters, "Black Market" from season two is easily the worst of them all. The episode is centered around Apollo and his interaction with the black market growing throughout the fleet.
He winds up getting involved in a murder investigation, which brings him into contact with Phelan, the man who runs the whole operation. Apollo is captured and threatened, but he is let go, and he doesn't give up on bringing down the black market after he learns it is trafficking in antibiotics and children.
Ultimately, the acting was on par with the rest of the series, but the corny dialogue and weak script ensured "Black Market's" place as the weakest episode in an otherwise outstanding series. Overall, the episode was dull, the action scenes were few and far between, and the events had little impact on the events of the show.
4. Stranger Things - “Chapter Seven: The Lost Sister”
Stranger Things has consistently been critically acclaimed for its nostalgic approach to suspense and horror. The series seemingly came out of nowhere, and it quickly became one of the most popular shows Netflix has ever produced. While the episodes have often been praised, there is one that fans didn't like.
“Chapter Seven: The Lost Sister” came in the second season of the show, and it upends the things people love about the show. Instead of focusing on the interpersonal relationships of the people of Hawkins, Indiana, the episode takes Eleven to Chicago, where she teams up with a low-budget X-Men team.
The group consists of edgy emo teenagers who, like Eleven, all have superpowers they received through the same program. She finds herself surrounded by people who are just like her, and while that could have worked into the larger framework of the series, it didn't have much impact on it at all.
The episode feels like a filler, and the series' creators, the Duffer Brothers, acknowledged that it "annoyed some people." That's putting it lightly. Kathryn VanArendonk of Vulture wrote that the episode has "little to no impact on later events, and Eleven feels like exactly the same person she was before except with a much cooler outfit."
3. Lost - “Stranger In A Strange Land”
Lost was all about hiding information and keeping the audience guessing, which often led to lackluster episodes. There are more than enough people who hated the series finale, but even those folks would find it difficult to offer much praise for "Stranger in a Strange Land" from season three.
The episode was one of the many "fillers" that padded themselves onto the main story, which kept the seasons going for the ordered number of episodes, and it shows. It's not about anything to do with Lost's main underlying plot, and instead, it's all about Jack's tattoos.
Jack certainly needed some character development episodes, and he got them — "Stranger in a Strange Land" simply wasn't one of them. This was during the third season, and the fans wanted to know more about what was going on, and learning about Jack's ink didn't do anything for anybody.
Damon Lindelof once called "Stranger in a Strange Land," "the worst episode we ever produced." There's really not much that can be said about it other than to state it is boring and has absolutely no payoff. If you're binging Lost, you can skip it without missing anything about the overall story.
2. Star Trek - “Spock’s Brain”
Star Trek is an incredibly beloved franchise for millions of people these days, but back in the '60s, the show lost a lot of viewers and was canceled early. There's a lot of nostalgia for the original series, but looking back, it's clear that the series was off its rails by the third season.
"Spock's Brain" opened the third and final season of Star Trek, and it's often chosen as the worst episode of the series. Now, anyone who loves Star Trek from any of the shows or films knows that there's often a suspension of disbelief needed to enjoy the show... but not for "Spock's Brain."
Here's the elevator pitch: an alien woman beams aboard the USS Enterprise and quickly manages to incapacitate the crew. She then surgically removes Spock's brain (without killing him). Captain Kirk and the rest of the crew have only a few hours to find his brain before his body dies.
It's no easy task to suspend disbelief on something that ridiculous, and the episode doesn't have many fans among Trek culture. Even William Shatner himself called it the worst episode, while Leonard Nimoy wrote, "Frankly, during the entire shooting of that episode, I was embarrassed."
1. Star Trek: The Next Generation - “Code Of Honor”
While it may not seem fair to hit Star Trek: The Next Generation twice on this list, the series deserves to take another hit for "Code of Honor," which is widely considered the series' worst episode. The episode was the fourth one produced, and it was terrible.
In the episode, the crew of the Enterprise visit with a delegation of people from the planet Ligon II to obtain a vaccine. When the people beam aboard after an initial meeting, their leader, Lutan, quickly abducts Tasha Yar down to the planet. Captain Picard demands her return, and eventually, the crew beams down to the planet.
The episode deals with women's rights in a society, and just like the fourth episode of Stargate: SG-1, it was way too soon in the series to tackle a complicated theme like women's rights. By the end of the episode, Yar has to fight Lutan's woman to the death, and it's all done in a cheesy and silly manner.
The episode was negatively received when it was aired in 1987, and it has not aged well. It's often brought up as a bad example of a sci-fi show attempting to tackle important issues and has been described as "possibly the worst piece of Star Trek ever made."
Watch Next
The X-Files Quiz: How Well Do You Remember The Sci-Fi Hit?