10 Worst Simpsons Guest Stars (Who Played Themselves)
Simpsons guest appearances miss a lot more often than they hit these days.
The Simpsons have had many, many guest stars over the years, and increasingly there’s been a lot of criticism aimed at the show’s overuse of them. At their worst, they’re lazy, unfunny and are more concerned with patting themselves on the back for having snagged such big names than they are with actually making a good episode.
Then again, aside from very, very few bright spots (looking at you, Halloween Of Horror), The Simpsons don’t seem all that great at making good episodes at all these days.
The point is, if you’re looking for bad guest stars, The Simpsons has a lot of low decks. Recently, the best of the bunch for a bit of the limelight in the list of best guest stars, but it’s only fair to remember the duds too.
As was the rule previously, only stars who appear as themselves in the show count here. No space for the likes of Sacha Baron Cohen as tour guide Jakob then. When it comes to picking the worst though, you’re definitely not going to be short of options, so some pretty bad appearances might luck out and miss the cut here.
10. U2
U2 appeared in The Simpsons’ 200th episode Trash Of The Titans (they’re on over 650 now, by the way), and was one of the first obnoxiously gratuitous guest roles. Clearly brought on board to celebrate the impressive milestone, the band are woefully misused and overshadow Steve Martin’s Ray Patterson, who’s a much better guest star all around.
Bono gets the starring role of the foursome as per usual, but (again as per usual) he comes off incredibly preachy. His insistence on stopping the show to let Homer talk about garbage management is supposed to be an ironic wink, but comes across as too genuine, and so loses all of its comedy. All his other lines feel too stiff as well.
The other three band members (the Edge, Adam and Larry, though nobody ever remembers the latter two) are a bit better, actually getting some gags and managing to stick the landing. Still, the fuss of getting one of the world’s biggest rock bands only to fumble them so spectacularly is sad to see.
*NSYNC suffer from similar balancing issues in their episode, but to their credit they’re a bit funnier and more natural than U2, so avoid inclusion here.
9. Martha Stewart
Martha Stewart may be the ninth worst guest star in The Simpsons’ history, but she’s only the second worst star in her episode, which should give you some indication of how bad Season 22’s The Fight Before Christmas is. Told in three distinct vignettes a la Treehouse Of Horror, the episode features one segment led by Martha Stewart helping Marge plan creative and cost effective Christmas decorations.
Post financial fraud, Stewart has taken to various TV and movie cameos as herself, trying to scrub her once good name clean again. On the back of this performance though, it’s unclear why she keeps getting booked.
If you have some prior love for Martha Stewart, then there’s definitely potential here. The problem is that very little of what she says is even supposed to be funny. It’s not bad delivery, necessarily, but that she’s largely just going about her usual routine as if it was her own show.
Some things are taken to extremes and while there is some comedy in that, it’s largely all brushed over for more Martha. Bit of an odd episode all around here, with another celebrity still to appear.
8. Justin Bieber
There was a time when hating on Justin Bieber was one of the internet’s most popular pass times. Post Purpose, that’s not as in vogue anymore, though there are still some very vocal opponents to the Canadian star. During the height of his infamy though, The Simpsons decided to offer him a guest spot.
Of course, for all the Justin haters there were plenty of ‘Beliebers’ too, something the show was clearly hoping to cash in on as they hyped up his appearance to the rafters.
The Season 24 finale The Fabulous Faker Boy is messy at best, juggling Homer’s baldness, a Patrick Stewart guest spot, Bart’s piano lessons, Marge giving driving lessons, Bart getting a crush on his tutor and a mother-son storyline revolving around Bart faking his piano skills.
Basically, it’s full as it is, so it’s no wonder Bieber only gets a single line. It’s not that it would necessarily be better for him to have had a bigger part, but as things stand it’s difficult to see what all the fuss was about.
If you hate him, booking him was a disappointment. If you love him, his lack of screen time feels like a let down too.
7. Rupert Murdoch
Honestly, who asked for this?
Rupert Murdoch guest started in Sunday, Cruddy Sunday along with several other unnecessary guest stars, but is far and away the worst. Dolly Parton is superfluous but at least sounds like she’s having fun, while Fred Willard plays a good part as the hapless Wally Kogen. The rest of them though are utterly pointless.
Murdoch isn’t just a bad guest star though, his spot is massively self indulgent. As the owner of News Corp (who own Fox, who own The Simpsons), Murdoch being on the show is utterly transparent vanity. It wouldn’t be so bad if he was in any way funny or likeable, but he’s neither.
All his lines are hammy yells, and he frequently features highly on lists of the least likeable people in media. His networks have tried to monopolise news broadcasts and networks around the globe; wherever you stand on politics, media monopolies are bad news.
The idea that he’d be able to stop the Super Bowl so adoring fans and players would spell his name is laughable, and not in a good way. Worst of a bad bunch in this episode.
6. Alec Baldwin & Kim Basinger
When You Dish Upon A Star is often held up as one of the earliest glimpses into The Simpsons’ mediocre future, coming in Season 10.
It features Homer accidentally crashing through Alec Baldwin and Kim Basinger’s roof and becoming their assistant. Leaving behind the silly reason for them being in town and the fact that they didn’t think to hire an assistant anyway, the episode did have potential. The problem is the plot is poorly paced, the jokes are few and far between and a lot of them are in-gags.
More and more, The Simpsons have been writing for other writers with referential Hollywood humour, like Homer commenting that Jesus had a big staff and still wasn’t that funny. This though is the first sign of that, with Basinger dull, Baldwin wasted and none of the jokes having the usual Simpsons charm.
Ron Howard also features in this episode, but avoids being listed here because he returns on multiple occasions and is always pretty funny. Alec Baldwin also returns, but this time as a manatee trainer in Season 17’s Bonfire Of The Manatees. He’s better there, but not by much.
5. Kid Rock
Kill The Alligator And Run is a frequently criticised episode of The Simpsons, largely because it’s a) terrible and b) came at a time when lots of people were still watching. While Dietrich Bader did a decent job as a poor character, Kid Rock’s guest appearance as himself was much worse.
In the show’s defence, having Kid Rock at a spring break concert at least made sense, unlike some other random walk ons. That’s about all you can say if defence of this though.
‘MY NAME IS KIIIIIID, KID ROCK!’ Kid screams as he opens Bawitdaba, and the energy never goes anywhere from there. His lines are simultaneously yelled and lifeless, and it feels less like he’s playing himself than he is a weird parody.
That would be fine of course (many celebrities have parodied themselves before), but there’s just no jokes. Zero.
To be fair though, playing a character is nothing that new for Kid Rock. Despite his appearances, trailer park motifs and tough attitude, Kid was born in a six acre estate, with his music and image being entirely self styled. A talented musician maybe, but not much of a voice actor.
4. Ronaldo
Ronaldo (Brazilian, not Cristiano) only has a small appearance in The Simpsons, but it’s so terrible that it needs to be included. It wasn’t overhyped like Justin Bieber’s appearance, but in terms of quality, it was even worse.
Not only would it be nonsense for Ronaldo to be at an under eights game, just wandering around in his Real Madrid kit, his delivery is terrible too. In fairness, English isn’t his native language and having played in the Netherlands, Spain and Italy, learning the language wouldn’t have been his first priority.
However, he dubbed himself in his first language of Portuguese, and is apparently just as bad. The fact Homer recognises him from his FIFA Player Of The Year awards rather than his Copa America, Golden Boot, Cup Winner’s Cup wins or league titles is bonkers as well.
Having a sportsman this high also allows for an honorary mention of another thoroughly wooden guest spot from Yao Ming. Again, not a native English speaker, but when the set up for his joke is that he speaks fluently, his delivery’s wooden as a log cabin.
’Quiet kid, I got a good thing going here’ might be the worst delivered line in the show’s history. Kudos, Ming.
3. Lady Gaga
A lot of people probably expected Lady Gaga’s appearance to be top here, but that’s part of the reason why it’s not. Lisa Goes Gaga is such a legendarily bad episode that it’s terrible-ness has been way overhyped.
It’s still very, very bad, but there are a couple of celebrity appearances worse than Lady Gaga’s. Also, while she doesn’t bring her A Star Is Born a-game, a lot of the blame lies with the writers. Gaga’s been accused of phoning it in here, but even then she’s a more convincing character than a lot of their celebrity guests.
There’s just too much time dedicated to Gaga herself, especially for a season finale. The gag where Homer cooks and eats her meat dress is culturally relevant and a little funny, but her strangely eccentric train or kissing and exciting Marge just feel weird.
You can kind of see what they’re going for, but you shouldn’t have to squint this hard.
Her song ‘Lisa Simpson Superstar’ is actually pretty decent, but massively undercut by the depiction of Gaga as a Christ like figure. Lisa might have gone Gaga, but the fans certainly didn’t for this episode.
2. Elon Musk
Elon Musk is one of the internet’s idols right now, and seemingly even baseless accusations that heroic divers in Thailand are paedophiles can’t hurt his good name. If more people knew about his appearance in The Simpsons though, maybe he’d be less popular.
Modern day Simpsons are usually well behind trends; case in point, upcoming Season 31 will see Bart & Homer becoming Instagram influencers. With getting Elon Musk on board for Season 26 though, they were a bit ahead of their time.
While Musk is a bit of an internet cult hero these days, his appearance on the show displayed an utter lack of charisma and charm. Dull and wooden throughout. The Musk Who Fell To Earth is a much worse episode than Lisa Goes Gaga, and is only saved from notoriety due to its blandness.
It’s hardly really a Simpsons episode at all. It’s more of the writers fanboying out over Musk and deciding to dedicate a whole episode to him.
Elon is the star of the show but doesn’t have anywhere near enough comedy presence to carry it, and the Simpsons get supporting roles. A big waste of time.
1. Katy Perry
The only reason Katy Perry’s guest appearance on the show isn’t widely remembered as the bona fide worst ever is because so many people have either forgotten it or swept it under the rug.
In a shameless act of self promotion/‘hey look we got Katy Perry’, the bit drags on with virtually no gags at all and just leaves us looking at Katy Perry and weird puppet versions of the cast. This is, apparently, supposed to pass for comedy.
Yes, it’s a reference to Perry’s Sesame Street bit being cut for her being overly sexy, and the tight latex dress references both that and fits her then trademark fashion choices. But it’s one joke, not done very well, dragged out, and months after the likes of Saturday Night Live did it much better.
It’s also a reference to A Muppet Christmas Carol, but unlike the Michael Caine movie it’s completely devoid of humour. Perry has her usual pretending to be ditzy, always on persona, and three solid minutes of her is way too much. Someone should have told her that even though it’s live action, she had to do more than stand there and look pretty.