10 Worst Things Captain Kirk Has Ever Done
You can't boldly go where no man has gone before without treading on a few toes.
Captain, leader, legend – James Tiberius Kirk is one of the most endearing characters in science fiction, if not TV at large. Heroic, individualistic, and with an eye for the ladies, he’s a loveable rogue you can’t help but admire, as well as a great opportunity for William Shatner to shout and mug to his heart’s content.
He’s also, at times, a pretty bad bloke. Whether through selfishness, impetuousness, stubbornness, or good old fashioned dumbness, he has a sizeable CV of wrong doing, and has on more than several occasions steered the crew of the Enterprise into serious trouble simply through his own blunders.
There’s no doubt he sets out to do good, to fulfil the Prime Directive and take his spot as the hero of the galaxy. But when you’re Star Trekking across the universe, it’s only natural you’re going to get distracted once in a while. And when you’re a man with the, shall we say, base desires of J T Kirk, those distractions are liable to get just a little out of hand.
10. Taking Over A Gangster Planet
In season 2 episode “A Piece of the Action”, Kirk, Spock, and Dr McCoy find themselves on what can only be described as a gangster planet. Populated by folks clad in pinstripe suits, clutching tommy guns and talking like James Cagney, the Enterprise crew are baffled at first at this strange new world.
That is until they stumble upon a book about the Chicago mob, on which this planet has apparently built its entire civilisation, which explains that. It’s not long before Kirk and the gang find themselves in the middle of ongoing mob warfare, with rival crews demanding use of Starfleet’s advanced technology. Captured, Kirk thinks quickly, and with the cunning strategy of putting on a fedora manages to infiltrate mob HQ. In due course he has inserted himself as top mafioso, with the technologically impaired gangsters left with no choice but to cough up 40% of their annual takings to the Federation (or be killed, presumably).
Kirk claims that the takings will be put to altruistic use, but any gangster worth his salt can convince himself he’s doing the right thing. One hour in a pinstripe suit and Kirk transforms into Scarface.
9. Flaunting Regulations With No Consequence
James Kirk is a Starfleet careerist - he is frequently depicted as an especially young captain, meaning he has the ear of someone at top command, and has made his way to the rank of Admiral in some instalments. He is also, when it suits him, a rule breaking maverick. Being ambitious is fine, and being a wildcard (who gets results) is fine, too, But when you’re routinely breaking the rules and getting let off every time? That’s just annoying.
He has flown Spock to Vulcan to get lucky, for which he was retroactively given permission. He has taken forbidden trips to dangerous planets, for which he was bumped back down to Captain, which was exactly what he wanted, having grown bored of his Admiral rank. He has back talked and even physically assaulted more federation dignitaries and ambassadors than you can shake a stick at. Still, he is allowed to simply get on with it unabated.
Kirk evidently has friends in high places, and is not afraid to use his influence to keep him in the job. He can act the renegade all he wants, but he’s basically the boss’ son in your office knowing he can act out without consequence.
8. Letting A Mass Murderer On The Enterprise
It seems unfair to use Kirk’s credulity as a stick with which to beat him, but when that trusting streak leads him to invite a mass murderer onto the Enterprise, that can only be a black mark on the record of any spaceship captain.
In “The Conscience of the King”, Kirk’s friend Dr Leighton has the Enterprise investigate actor Anton Karidian, who he suspects is really Kodos, perpetrator of a mass execution which Kirk and the doctor both witnessed. Kirk dismisses his pal’s suspicions, and when Leighton is immediately murdered, Kirk sees no recourse but to ferry Karidian and his troupe to their next destination. It goes on like this: further people Kirk trusts suggest that he looks further into the connection between Karidian and Kodos; Kirk feels this would be a waste of his time.
It transpires that Karidian’s daughter has been offing the witnesses, but all the same, Kirk’s blockheadedness put his staff at risk and almost led to one of the galaxy’s great mass murderers getting away scott free. His refusal to listen can’t have been great for morale, either - a bad day at the office for James T.
7. Ditching His Son
For a serial ladies’ man such as James T Kirk, it was only going to be a matter of time before he sired a child. Unfortunately, rather than creating some kind of weird half-alien creature, he ended up with a boring old human son called David.
David’s mother had essentially cut Kirk out of the boy’s life, on account of his decorated dad’s insatiable wanderlust (and normal lust), not to mention his rampant careerism. Kirk is arguably a wronged party here, but it never seems that he makes much of an effort to get in contact with his estranged son - indeed, his sole heir’s very existence doesn’t play on his mind at all. He eventually manages to win around his understandably unimpressed offspring, and everything goes well for about half a film, before David manages to get himself stabbed dead by a Klingon.
To recap, then: Kirk abandoned his baby, cast him out of his mind for nigh on 30 years, made a cursory effort to get to know him, then allowed his son to get killed in an effort to impress the old man. That’s just bad dadding.
6. Violating The Prime Directive
The guiding principle of Starfleet, it is imperative that you don’t muck about with the natural development of alien cultures. It’s the number one law when it comes to the governing body Kirk has dedicated his life to, so naturally he violates it time and again.
In “The Apple”, the crew find themselves on a veritable paradise of a planet, temperate in climate and rich in resources. The ever-youthful residents of the planet call themselves the “feeders of Vaal”, after the supercomputer which maintains their bodies in return for their constantly supplying it with power-granting minerals. Kirk deems this a form of slavery, with the machine keeping the childlike innocents from learning about various human delights, and in due course he smashes it up.
While he has a point, he has thought very little about what’s going to happen once he has completely altered the way of living of a whole planet. These people previously wanted for nothing, and they’ll now want for everything. Not to worry, though - it’s off on the next adventure for Kirk, and with a warm fuzzy feeling in his tummy after a job well done.
5. Violating The Prime Directive Again
And the violations keep on coming! In season three’s "The Cloud Minders", the gang visit the mining planet Ardana, where the underclasses are forced to dig for precious zenite. When it transpires that the material gives off a brain-muddling toxin, Kirk decides that he is more than qualified to get in the middle of a labour dispute.
The planet is divided into strata, with the snooty Plasus ruling the upper class, and a group of “troglodytes” doing the dirty work. When it becomes clear that the perceived mental inferiority is due to the aforementioned mind baffling gas, Kirk appoints himself union leader, and marches Plasus down into the mines to learn the error of his prejudicial ways. Kirk is on the side of the angels here, it goes without saying, and yet again he goes about it in a clumsy manner. Rather than, say, sparking a serious discussion about Ardana’s class system, his solution is “give the troglodytes gas masks”.
No doubt Kirk is trying to be a comrade here, but he shows himself up again to be a dilettante, sticking his beak in with little thought to the consequences. Once the Enterprise zoomed off on their next adventure, you can bet those miners got it in the neck big time.
4. Starting A War With The Klingons
A successful Starfleet captain must, we imagine, have confidence, but Kirk’s self belief goes beyond gumption to downright belligerent self belief. In season one’s “Errand of Mercy”, Kirk and Spock wind up on a peace loving planet, and Kirk goes out of his way to start a war against the Klingons (making their first appearance), even as the planet’s inhabitants beg him not to. Leadership!
The peace loving citizens of the planet Oragnia insist that Kirk and Spock don’t fight the invading Klingons - Kirk, naturally, concludes that he knows best. No means yes in this instance, and so he starts a guerilla campaign against the iconic foes, which quickly spirals out of control. Kirk no doubt means well, but dismissing the wishes of the folks whose planet you’ve just landed on seems pigheaded and dangerous (notably the episode came out as the Vietnam war reached its zenith).
The episode ends with the revelation that the Organians are in fact highly advanced beings who just didn’t want much to do with Kirk or the Klingons, and quickly end hostilities with their mental powers. Kirk’s reaction to not being allowed to fight any longer, naturally, is to have a sulk.
3. Blundering Into Another War
Why decide you know what’s best for one planet when you can meddle in the affairs of two at once? “A Taste of Armageddon” sees Kirk wade into another conflict, this time between two antagonistic neighbouring worlds, and decide after a few minutes’ observation that they way they’ve been conducting their business for centuries is bang wrong.
The nations of Eminiar VII and Vendikar are at perpetual loggerheads, and vent their frustrations with one another by carrying out incessant simulated combat. After wading into the action, the Enterprise is (virtually) shot down, and the crew are asked to admit (virtual) defeat. Like any bad loser, Kirk decides that the game is at fault. Deciding that the war games are a bad influence on the folks of Eminiar VII and Vendikar, he smashes up their simulators, and delivers a particularly preachy (even for Star Trek) speech on the seriousness of combat and the harm they’re doing through even pretend war.
He may very well have a fair point, but once again, the captain has decided he knows best and that two civilizations’ long standing traditions are bad and dumb and need to stop right now. Christopher Columbus has nothing on big James.
2. Sending Khan Off To Take Over A Planet
One of the most iconic villains in the franchise’s history, Ricardo Montalbán’s Khan is best remembered for the second motion picture, which bears his name. A genetic experiment turned 20th century dictator, Khan escaped earth justice and woke up from a deep freeze in the year 2267.
He comes close to taking over the enterprise, but naturally is bested by Kirk and the crew; the captain and the dictator fight, and eventually Khan is subdued. Taking pity on the man, who must be pretty discombobulated after such a snooze, Kirk drops Khan off on a harsh planet in the outer reaches of the galaxy, where he can have another shot at ruling. We’re told that Khan was a relatively reasonable dictator, but all the same he doesn’t seem like the most balanced of folks, so giving him the challenge of once again seizing control of a world seems pretty shortsighted on the captain’s part. He leaves Khan to his own devices and jets off.
This, of course, comes back to bite him, as Khan pops up some 15 years down the line as - surprise! - the dictator of a planet. An older, wiser Kirk gets the job done this time, but this was a problem very much of his own making.
1. Dooming A Ship Full Of Aliens
Iconic season two instalment “The Trouble with Tribbles” is best remembered for the cuddly creatures who give their name to the episode title. The Enterprise crew come across the fluffballs on a space station, and find them endearing enough that they bring one back to the ship for further research and cuddles.
It quickly transpires that Tribbles reproduce at a prodigious rate, and have a similarly insatiable appetite. Not long after, the grain that the crew have been hired to protect has been devoured by the pests. Some Klingons show up, there’s some tension, and in due course Kirk kills two birds with one stone by sending the antagonistic aliens packing, and beaming a job lot of Tribbles onto the Klingon ship. It’s treated as a jokey ending, but from what we know about Tribbles - they’ll eat you out of house and home, and they multiply like space rabbits - Kirk has doomed two groups of aliens to death by starvation.
A Deep Space Nine episode makes it clear that the Tribbles became a scourge to the Klingons, who spitefully hunted them for many years to come. Inadvertant or otherwise, Kirk has committed space genocide here.