12 Actors Who Screwed Up Their Big TV Chances By Getting Fired

This list includes multiple references to Charlie Sheen.

We usually think of television actors and actresses as having it good, especially when they land a role on a successful show. Yet, recent years have seen high profile actors fired from their shows after exhibiting bizarre behavior and often crossing the lines of decency. Whatever the cause, these actors and actresses lose the success they worked so hard to obtain and often find it hard to reestablish themselves in Hollywood. And, to make matters worse, their foibles are broadcast in the tabloids for all the world to see, cementing their reputations for years to come. It's happened many, many times over the history of television and it will continue to happen as long as actors and actresses remain imperfect people. These are the top 12 actors and actresses who seriously screwed up a big television gig by being fired. Some of them were fired for personal reasons while others were fired for practical reasons. Yet, what they all have in common is that they were a part of a big-name television show... and blew it.

12. Mackenzie Phillips - One Day At A Time

In the 1970s, Mackenzie Phillips was one of the hottest rising child stars. In 1975, One Day at a Time premiered, and Phillips was cast as the oldest daughter, the boy-crazy Julie Cooper. Like many child stars, though, Phillips went off the deep end. By her own admission, she had started abusing drugs at the age of eleven when her father started supplying her with them, which Phillips claims eventually fueled an incestuous relationship between father and daughter. During the third season of the show in 1977, she was arrested for public drunkenness and possession of cocaine. Phillip's behavior began to spill over to her work on One Day at a Time, where she began to show up to the set late and was even incoherent at some rehearsals. The producers of the show ordered her to take a six week break and seek treatment but, when she continued using drugs, they had enough and, in 1980, Phillips was fired from the show. Amazingly, unlike most of the other stars on this list, Phillips was given a second chance. After two overdoses that nearly proved fatal, Phillips entered a treatment program and seemed to be doing a lot better. She was invited to return to the cast of One Day at a Time in 1981 during the show's seventh season when her character, Julie, had her first baby. By 1982, however, Phillips had resumed abusing drugs and alcohol, and she was fired for good.

11. Grace Lee Whitney - Star Trek

Star Trek has a complicated production history but, by 1966, a permanent cast was in place including actress Grace Lee Whitney, who played Yeoman Janice Rand, James T. Kirk's space-age secretary and potential sexy love interest. But Whitney ultimately only appeared in eight episodes of the show before being fired. Creator Gene Roddenberry claimed Whitney was fired due to budget cutback. Whitney claimed that, as one of three female cast members, one had to be fired and, since the other two were an African-American woman and Roddenberry's wife respectively, she was the natural choice. Whitney has also claimed that she was sexually assaulted by an unnamed executive on the show and that she was fired a few days after the incident. Others have pointed to Whitney's abuse of alcohol and diet pills as factors for her firing. In any case, bitter over being fired from Star Trek, Whitney's alcohol abuse deepened after her departure from Star Trek, but she eventually sought treatment and was invited back to the Star Trek universe for the 1979 film Star Trek: The Motion Picture; the damage to her career had been done, however, and she's never been remembered in the same light as her more famous co-stars. She subsequently appeared in three more of the Star Trek films and an episode of Star Trek: Voyager.

10. Valerie Harper - Valerie

Valerie Harper became famous in the 1970s for her role as Rhoda Morgenstern on The Mary Tyler Moore Show. She was eventually given her own spin-off, Rhoda. Harper decided to return to television in 1986 for the aptly named Valerie, playing Valerie Hogan, the matriarch of a family consisting of three boys and an airline pilot husband. As Valerie began to show some success, Harper became unhappy with her salary. During season one of Rhoda, Harper had staged a walk out on the set over her salary that eventually lead to a raise, so the duo decided to pull a similar stunt during a filming hiatus for the second season of Valerie, stating that, if their demands for a salary raise were not met, they would refuse to return for filming of the third season. What followed was a behind the scenes fight of epic proportions that angered NBC so much they threatened to fire Harper, who believed the threat to be a bluff because no one had ever been fired and replaced in a television show bearing their name. However, that is just what happened. Sandy Duncan was cast to replace Harper and the show was renamed Valerie's Family: The Hogans (eventually being renamed again to The Hogan Family at the beginning of the fourth season in part to keep Harper from suing for use of her name). In the season three premiere, Harper's character was unceremoniously written out with the explanation that she had died in a car accident off-screen.

9. Brett Butler - Grace Under Fire

In 1993, Grace Under Fire premiered, starring Brett Butler as a single, working class mother of three struggling to raise her children post divorce. Behind the scenes, things were not so good. Jon Paul Steuer, who played Butler's oldest son, Quentin, abruptly left the series after the third season. Nothing was ever officially confirmed, but rumors circulated that Steuer's mother pulled him off the show after Butler flashed her breasts at the twelve year old actor. More cast members began leaving the show citing Butler's behavior, and the show started taking a nose dive in the ratings. At the same time, Butler was fighting an addiction to pain medication. Butler entered rehab shortly before the fifth season was due to start production, pushing back the premiere date until November. Once back on set, Butler struggled to remain sober, and morale failed to improve on set due to Butler's continued erratic behavior. Butler relapsed during the holidays and, though the producers of the show wished to continue, ABC had become impatient with Butler's behavior. ABC cancelled Grace Under Fire abruptly that February.

8. Lisa Bonet - A Different World & The Cosby Show

In the 80s, The Cosby Show was the ratings kingpin. It was in the top twenty all eight seasons and held the coveted number one position for five seasons in a row. The producers decided to capitalize on the success with a spin-off, A Different World. Set at the fictional Hillman College, a predominately African-American college, the series followed Denise, the second oldest daughter from The Cosby Show, played by Lisa Bonet. It was a good concept for a spin-off, following Denise and her friends as they adjusted to college life. It wasn't to last for Bonet, though. She committed the despicable crime of getting pregnant, and this didn't sit well with the producers, who wrote out her character at the start of the second season and focused more on the other characters. After her pregnancy, Lisa Bonet was allowed to return to The Cosby Show, but Bonet's attitude deteriorated, especially towards Cosby. Frankly, I can't blame her. I'd be pretty upset if I lost my show for getting pregnant, too. At the end of the seventh season, Cosby had enough and wrote Bonet out for the show's final season.

7. Charlie Sheen - Two And A Half Men

Lest anyone think that it's only female stars who get fired from their shows, I remind you of the well-documented case of Charlie Sheen. Two and a Half Men had been a top twenty program every season it had been on except one, and Sheen was reportedly the highest paid actor on television. But Sheen's behavior off the set began to impact Two and a Half Men's production. In 2011, production of the series went on hiatus after Sheen entered rehab for the third time. The following month, production resumed, but the season's final four episodes were cancelled after Sheen publicly made derogatory remarks about series co-producer Chuck Lorre. In March 2011, Sheen was banned from the set of Two and a Half Men by Warner Brothers Television. Sheen reacted by doing the most sensible possible thing: demanding a fifty percent pay increase, claiming he was underpaid. Warner Brothers responded by dismissing Sheen and replacing him with Ashton Kutcher. Like Valerie Harper, Sheen's character was killed off screen, making any possible return difficult or impossible.

6. Suzanne Somers - Three's Company

In the late 70s, Three's Company was one of the hottest shows on television. John Ritter may have been the star, but Suzanne Somers soon became an overnight success playing the stereotypical dumb blonde Chrissy Snow. Audiences loved Somers, and she was considered the break-out star of the series. Because she wasn't the star, she didn't get paid as much as Ritter. Once her character became popular, Somers says she wanted equal pay with Ritter and other male Hollywood stars of the time. After the fourth season ended in 1980, Somers demanded that her pay be increased from $30,000 an episode to $200,000 an episode. In addition, she demanded ten percent of the show's profits. When the network refused to budge, Somers began missing tapings of Three's Company at the beginning of the fifth season. Jenilee Harrison was brought in to replace Somers as Chrissy's cousin, Cindy, with an explanation that Chrissy was visiting relatives in Fresno. Somers was retained on the show during the fifth season but usually in brief telephone conversations of a minute or less at the end of each episode, all of which were filmed at a different location from the rest of the cast, who were bitter at Somers for disrupting production of the show. Somers was fired at the end of the fifth season and her highly publicized salary dispute prevented her from landing her own series on CBS.

5. Damon Wayans - Saturday Night Live

At the end of its eleventh season, Saturday Night Live had to be completely revamped. Returning show runner Lorne Michaels hired a completely new cast, including a then-unknown Damon Wayans. The season was disastrous, though, as audiences failed to connect with the new cast and NBC was constantly threatening to cancel the failing show. Most critics and viewers consider this to have been the worst season of Saturday Night Live ever and, by the end of the season, every cast member except Jon Lovitz and Dennis Miller had been fired. Wayans,'s firing came about because he was frustrated when he believed producers were ignoring his ideas for sketches. His anger boiled over until, on the March 15, 1986 episode, Wayans had enough. In a sketch title "Mr. Monopoly," Wayans was scripted to play a cop interrogating a suspect when he is interrupted by Mr. Monopoly coming to bail the suspect out. Wayans improvised his character and played him as flamboyant and gay, angering Michaels, who promptly fired Wayans.

4. Dana Plato - Diff'rent Strokes

Dana Plato had a rough career...and life. In 1978, she landed a supporting role on the NBC sitcom Diff'rent Strokes, which soon became a hit. In 1984, she became pregnant by her then-boyfriend. Much like in the case of Lisa Bonet, the producers of Diff'rent Strokes felt that Plato's character being pregnant would not work in the wholesome family show they had created, and Plato was fired and her character written out, although she subsequently made several guest appearances during the final season after the show moved to ABC. Plato's subsequent struggles are well documented. She began abusing alcohol and drugs early in life. After Diff'rent Strokes, she found it difficult to land acting jobs and, desperate for exposure, posed for Playboy in 1989. This backfired and made it even more difficult for her to land acting jobs. Plato divorced her husband but lost custody of their son. She moved to Las Vegas where she struggled with poverty and unemployment. In 1991, she robbed a convenience store, for which she received five years probation. The clerk reportedly called 911 and told the operator, "I've just been robbed by the girl who played Kimberly on Diff'rent Strokes." In 1999, Plato appeared on an episode of The Howard Stern Show, where, despite Stern coming to Plato's defense, several callers insulted Plato and accused her of still being on drugs, which Plato denied. A few days after the interview, Plato committed suicide by taking an overdose of pain killers.

3. Shannen Doherty - Beverly Hills, 90210, Charmed & 90210

Most of the people on this list were fired from one show. But Shannen Doherty has the distinction of being fired from not one, not two, but three shows. Doherty has always been a notoriously difficult actress to work with, causing friction on the set of all three series. She was fired from Beverly Hills, 90210 after the fourth season because of constant bickering. Her work after Beverly Hills, 90210 consisted of a string of made-for-TV movies until she was cast as Prue Halliwell on The WB drama Charmed. Doherty didn't fare any better on Charmed and, just like in Beverly Hills, 90210, there was much conflict on the set. In 2001, Doherty was fired from the show, reportedly after Alyssa Milano threatened to quit unless Doherty was fired. One would think Doherty had learned her lesson, and things seemed to be looking up when, in 2009, she was offered a recurring role on 90210, The CW network's reboot of Beverly Hills, 90210. However, after the first taping, producers learned that Doherty was still difficult to work with. She reported argued with people, ordered changes in scripts, costumes, and props, and generally wanted things her way. The producers decided she wasn't worth the hassle, and fired her after one episode.

2. Janet Hubert-Whitten - The Fresh-Prince Of Bel-Air

When The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air returned for its fourth season in 1993, viewers were surprised to find a new actress playing Aunt Vivian. In fact, Janet Hubert-Whitten, the original Aunt Vivian, had been fired from the show. Hubert-Whitten told TMZ in 2011 that Will Smith was responsible for her being fired. She claimed that Smith was immature and had not grown up, and subsequently Smith had her fired because she wouldn't "kiss his butt." She claimed that his immature attitude lead to on-set altercations and eventually to Smith ordering her to be fired. Smith, on the other hand, claimed that Hubert-Whitten was fired because she had a bad attitude. Though some speculated that Hubert-Whitten's unexpected pregnancy during the third season, which forced writers to script a pregnancy on the show, played a factor in her getting fired, Smith said that he and Hubert-Whitten had trouble working together long before she became pregnant. Whoever was at fault, Smith and Hubert-Whitten have not worked out their differences to this day, and, prior to the death of former co-star James Avery, Hubert-Whitten was the hold-out that prevented a Fresh Prince of Bel-Air reunion.

1. Isaiah Washington - Grey's Anatomy

Isaiah Washington had it good. During the first three seasons of Grey's Anatomy, he was one of the central characters on the show, Dr. Preston Burke. But all was not well on the set of Grey's Anatomy. Washington reportedly had several on-set altercations with co-star T.R. Knight, who is gay. Things came to a head in 2006 when Washington reportedly used an anti-gay slur against Knight on set. And, to make matters worse, Knight used the slur again during an argument with co-star Patrick Dempsey at the 2006 Golden Globe Awards. The fall-out was massive. Washington was denounced by LGBT rights organizations and, after massive controversy in the media, Washington was fired from Grey's Anatomy, proving what your mother always told you: if you don't have anything good to say, you shouldn't say anything at all. To everyone's surprise, though in 2014 Washington guest starred on an episode of Grey's Anatomy commemorating the departure of his former on-screen love interest portrayed by Sandra Oh. Which is... nice? Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.

In this post: 
Charlie Sheen
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Christopher A. Rothbauer is a freelance writer who specializes in nostalgic television and B-movies. His current project is the blog Saved by the Bell...Reviewed!, which reviews every episode of the Saved by the Bell franchise one week at a time. He lives in the southern Indiana suburbs of Louisville, Kentucky.