12 Darkest Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Moments
The darkest tales of the best Star Trek show ever made.
Star Trek is no stranger to dark storylines or moments, every single show has at least one that sticks with them for the rest of their lives. From Picard being tortured and assimilated into the Borg, to Kirk being forced to let the woman he loves die in order to protect history, to plenty of others I'm probably forgetting.
And then you have Deep Space Nine, which can best be described as a series of super dark moments interspersed with Quark shenanigans.
Due to the lack of Roddenberry looking over their shoulder every step of the way for the first time, Deep Space Nine was allowed to broach subjects never allowed before in Star Trek. Not only making it easily the best entry in the franchise so far, but also making it by far the darkest.
This show is unflinchingly willing to hurt and even outright break the characters it made you fall in love with, and we're going to be looking at the darkest, bleakest examples thereof. These are the moments that made Deep Space Nine so freaking hardcore.
12. Kira Learns About Dukat And Her Mother - Wrongs Darker Than Death Or Night
Oh look, it's time to make Kira Nerys miserable! Which is to say that it's a day ending in Y.
On the night of her mother's birthday, Gul Dukat, the man whose last f*ck long ago mysteriously "fell out of a window", calls up Kira and reveals a hot little tidbit about him and her mother. Namely that they slept together. A lot.
Kira obviously calls BS, but she can't be sure, so she uses the orb of time to find out the truth. Kira finally gets to have a real conversation with her long dead mother, and what she learns during that conversation is even worse than she imagined.
Kira's mother didn't just sleep with Dukat, she was his personal comfort woman. And the worst part? She admits to her daughter's face that while initially forced into the arrangement, she ended up enjoying every minute. She gets to live in luxury and never have to worry about where her next meal is, and all she has to do is get Dukat's rocks off? To her that was too good a deal to pass up.
This is one of the most Earth shattering moments for Kira, as every illusion she had about her mother is broken, shot, and left to bleed out on the side of the road.
11. "We're Everywhere" - The Adversary
Plenty of shows like to end certain seasons on dark cliffhangers, but few of them get as harrowing as the last moments of The Adversary.
The 3rd season is where we get our first glimpses of The Dominion, and the season finale is where the crew of DS9 figures out just what they're up against. Throughout the episode, a changeling infiltrator almost tears the entire ship apart by turning the crew against each other, demonstrating how easy it is for just ONE changeling to infiltrate and gum up the works of the federation by making officers kill each other.
Odo manages to bring down the changeling, but the moment that makes it onto this entry is the last message of the changeling to his traitorous brother: we're everywhere.
Those last words being the last moments of the season leave viewers with a haunting realization. The Dominion is already making their move, they know everything about the federation and how to wreak havoc within their ranks, and it may already be too late to stop them.
10. Garak Tortures Odo - The Die Is Cast
If there is any one thing that separates Deep Space Nine from its peers within the franchise, it's that it's nowhere near as optimistic about people as other Trek shows.
Garak is one of the more interesting characters on the show, as everyone kinda KNOWS he used to be a spy, spending his days eeking out a living as a tailor on the promenade, sharing smiles and lunches with Dr Bashir.
But of course, that doesn't mean Garak isn't capable of horrible things. As seen in The Die Is Cast.
Long story short, Garak's old bosses - The Obsidian Order - wish to welcome him back into the fold, which of course means the chance for him to finally return home, something Garak wants more than anything. The catch? He must torture Odo for information on the Dominion. Despite knowing that Odo has already confessed everything he knows so torture would get nothing, Garak's wish to finally return home overrides his morals and he proceeds with the torture.
We get to see Garak turn into a frightened, self loathing person, and the collected, dignified Odo reduced to a shivering, scared child over the course of this episode. This moment gave the audience a much needed reminder that Garak's smile may be genuine, but at the end of it all, he'll choose Cardassia over the federation any day of the week.
9. Benny's Breakdown - Far Beyond The Stars
Star Trek has always been socially conscious and steeped in politics, that's what's always set it apart from its sci-fi contemporaries, especially at the time when the original series came out. And one of the absolute best episodes to bring that socially conscious mindset to the forefront was Far Beyond The Stars.
This episode finds Sisko, for various reasons, transported to another universe where Benjamin Sisko is "Benny", a science fiction author in 1950's America facing the challenges that black creators faced just trying to get their work published. Over the course of the episode, we see him face obstacle after obstacle, all because he's a black man writing a story where a black man is the lead.
Eventually, it all becomes too much for Benny and the man has a breakdown. He's tried so long staying calm for these people, but all that got him was further underfoot. He knows that nothing he says can change things at this point, but what he has to say needed to be be let out, for it had been building up in him all his life. It's a haunting tear down of systemic racism and oppression, made all the more painful by Avery Brooks' being the best leading actor in Star Trek history and turning in a defining performance.
8. Kira Talks With Odo - Things Past
Deep Space Nine is known for many things, but one thing it's definitely accrued acclaim for is its ability to end an episode on the most hurtful note imaginable.
Case in point, the ending to Things Past. In this episode, the crew are telepathically transported back to the past, where the Cardassians owned Deep Space Nine, but Odo was still the chief of security. During this time, they find out one of Odo's darkest secrets, that during this time, he sentenced three innocent people to die.
The end of the episode sees Kira going to talk with Odo, to find out why he would do such a thing. Odo is a hardass, but he's always done the right thing despite orders in the past, so why would he sanction the execution of three innocent citizens? In the end, neither one walks away satisfied, Kira doesn't get her answers, and Odo knows he's lost a lot of trust from one of his dearest friends. All they can do is acknowledge that it happened and try to do better in the future.
Because in the end, that's all we can ever do.
7. The Jem'Hadar Knowingly Walk Into An Ambush - Rocks And Shoals
How far should someone take their code of conduct and honor? Probably not quite as far as the Jem'Hadar do in Rocks And Shoals.
The episode has Sisko and company being trapped on a deserted planet with a bunch of Jem'Hadar and their wounded Vorta. When the Vorta gives himself up as a POW to save his own skin, he informs them of the perfect way to ambush and eliminate their enemies. However, Sisko finds this act of callously sacrificing one's own men to be...well, callous, so he informs the Jem'Hadar of what their Vorta plans. But, due to their code of honor, they choose to walk into the ambush anyway.
The plan goes off without a hitch, leading to one of the most brutally one sided fights in the entire show. Every one of the Jem'Hadar soldiers are killed in the ensuing firefight. The most infuriating part of all of it, though, is just the simple sight of the Vorta gingerly stepping over the corpses of his own men after the fighting is done. What a bastard.
6. O'Brien Is Implanted With 20 Years Of Prison Life - Hard Time
When Miles O'Brien is falsely accused of espionage by the Argrathian government, instead of getting thrown in prison like a caged animal, they decide to try something different. But make no mistake, different doesn't necessarily mean any less cruel.
Their process is simple: instead of making him live 20 years in prison, they simply CONVINCE him that that's what they did by implanting perfect memories of spending 20 years locked away in an Argrathian gulag. As far as Miles knows, he just got out of prison that same day. As you can imagine, the true cruelty comes in when he finds his friends and family not a day older than when he "left", making his already frayed mental state basically fall apart completely.
It's a genuinely harrowing scene as the most obsessively in control character next to Odo turns into a PTSD stricken, barely functional man right before our eyes, to the point where he can barely even be around his own family. And of course, Colm Meaney knocks every second of it out of the damn park.
5. Kira Talks With "Gul Darheel" - Duet
Season 1 of Deep Space Nine, like those of all Star Trek shows, was a bit rough around the edges. Regardless, you'd be hard pressed to find a better mission statement as to what this iteration of the franchise is going to be all about than Duet, and this moment in particular.
Kira has just learned that Deep Space Nine has caught the biggest of big fish, Gul Darheel. Known among Bajorans as The Butcher Of Gallitep, he was a work camp leader who slaughtered thousands of Bajorans during his tenure. Kira goes to talk to this man, and what she finds is even worse than what she already expected. Gul Darheel not only has no remorse, he sees what he did as a service in itself for ridding the universe of as much Bajoran filth as he could.
The talk between these two characters is nothing short of uncomfortable, as Kira has to look pure evil in the eyes and hear it laugh at her attempts to understand it. Which of course makes the ultimate twist about who he truly is all the more haunting.
4. Quark Tears Into Sisko - The Siege Of AR-558
Quark is not what any sane man might call a good person, per say, but he definitely had his moments of giving the crew a much needed slap in the face.
This moment comes from the episode, The Siege Of AR-558, where Sisko and the Defiant crew try to help out the eponymous station, which is under siege from Jem'Hadar, with Quark and Nog caught in the middle. Throughout the entire series, Quark's one truly redeeming quality has been his unconditional love for his nephew. So when the fight turns especially ugly and Nog becomes seriously injured, Quark finds himself overcome with righteous fury.
Quark proceeds to tear into Sisko for jumping so recklessly into a battle like this when he had a god damn CHILD on his ship who would inevitably get hurt. He drags the federation's my way or the highway, gung ho attitude through the mud where it belongs. It's a rather short moment, but it's nothing short of defining for this character. When Quark is calling you out on your BS, you know you've screwed up big time.
3. Jake Watches A Soldier Die - Nor The Battle To The Strong
Everyone is a badass until bullets actually start flying, and no one better embodies this than Jake Sisko.
When Jake and Bashir go to help out an outpost under Klingon siege, Jake - seeing the horrors of true combat for the first time - runs off in fear, leaving Bashir behind. When he takes a break from fleeing, he finds a soldier slowly dying in the dirt. After talking for a bit, Jake finally reveals what he did to the soldier just as he starts actually dying. The soldier spends his last moments chastising the young Jake, telling him that he can't just write off running away and leaving behind a comrade a mere "mistake", and that life doesn't work like that.
This entire episode is basically about the adorable young Jake Sisko being forced to grow up by the ravages of war, having his every illusion of heroism and glory irreparably shattered before our very eyes. And it's all personified in a single moment, where a soldier spends his last moments on this Earth calling Jake out for being a coward.
2. Dukat's Breakdown - Waltz
By season 6, Gul Dukat was not having a fun time.
His empire had been shattered, his mental state had gone off the rails and rolled off a cliff, and his beloved daughter was dead. This is usually around the point where any other show would cut the guy a break because I mean, c'mon. But of course, Deep Space Nine instead said "actually no, he hasn't hit rock bottom QUITE yet, but we'll fix that".
In the best episode of the entire series, Waltz, Sisko and an imprisoned Dukat crash land on a deserted planet, forced to rely on each other to survive. Which Sisko finds increasingly hard as he realizes that he's stuck on an empty planet with a crazy person. Throughout the episode, Dukat slowly goes more and more mad as everything he did to the Bajorans is finally laid out before him. Leading up to a final breakdown where his excuses for everything he did finally disintegrate before our eyes and he admits just how much he truly loathed the Bajorans as a species and how he really should have just killed them all.
For a season or two there, it really looked like Gul Dukat would end up on the side of good. But Deep Space Nine, always the show that made the harder narrative choice, instead reminded its audience that the only good fascist is a dead one.
1. Sisko's Logs - In The Pale Moonlight
What happens when a good man is forced to make genuinely horrible decisions? What happens when there just isn't a "right" way to resolve a conflict? What happens when that good man learns just how good he ISN'T after all? All of these questions are front and center in the darkest moment of Deep Space Nine, In The Pale Moonlight.
The entire episode could make it onto this list, but Sisko's personal logs as he explains and attempts to justify his plan to instigate a conflict between the Romulans and the Dominion stands out in particular. Despite everything the Dominion is doing, and how important it is that they ARE stopped, we see Sisko break every personal code he has, compromise his every moral, and again and again he tries to explain to "us" as well as himself that it was all necessary.
This is by far the best performance by Avery Brooks in this show, as you can see the conflict in his eyes, feel it in his voice. This is a man who knows what this is turning him into, but is utterly powerless to stop it. Or even worse yet, maybe he's totally okay with what he's turning into.
This episode isn't just dark, it's dark in a way every other Star Trek show has been too chicken to be. Sisko isn't being assimilated into the Borg, he isn't being mind controlled, none of that cop out stuff. This is just a good man being exposed to war, and buckling under the moral strain. What else could top a list like this?