12 Incredible TV Episodes (That Fans HATED)
Walt's flies, Daenerys' dracarys, gory ordeals, and a lot of contentious finales...
Every once in a while, an episode of a popular show comes out and manages to unite a divided fandom—in hatred.
These episodes are widely reviled by casual viewers, long-time fans, and critics alike, looked down on for taking a story down a completely pointless route or failing to do characters justice during its runtime.
And sometimes, those viewers are wrong.
Yes, sometimes the most hated episodes of critically acclaimed shows are actually secret gems. Sometimes after the dust has settled from their frosty reception, a re-watch proves they’re actually superb instalments rich with charming character work, clever twists and turns, and shocks which, although unexpected, prove to be perfectly placed in retrospect.
Fair warning—no reader is necessarily going to agree with everything included on this list, given how divisive the subject matter is. But nonetheless, here are a dozen superb instalments of TV which viewers unfairly despised upon first encountering them.
12. Stan’s Best Friend - American Dad
More consistently strange than The Orville creator Seth MacFarlane’s earlier animated hit Family Guy, American Dad has since its inception trafficked in some bizarre and surreal stories such as the seventh season instalment Hot Water, a horror musical which kills off the entire cast.
However even this show’s fan base has its limits, and the gruesome blackly comic instalment Stan’s Best Friend proved unpleasantly mean-spirited enough to earn their ire.
Yes, admittedly the choice to repeatedly and violently off an innocent dog was pretty vicious.
But the episode is also far funnier than fans give it credit for, particularly after years of seeing Rick and Morty and Solar Opposites put its minor characters through similarly gross ordeals.
11. Game Of Thrones - The Bells
In another case of a perfect ending being rejected because it wasn’t a happy one, the penultimate instalment of HBO’s consistently controversial megahit Game of Thrones saw one of the show’s primary protagonists Daenerys torch an entire city of innocent civilians in order to secure a strategic victory.
The beautifully realised and deeply devastating instalment featured the best depiction of war’s inherent brutality and depravity in TV history, dwelling on the deaths of innocents and the human cost of this folly in order to strip the moment of any false notions of moral justification or honour.
Of course, it was despised because it revealed that the beautiful blonde leading lady of the show was as morally fallible as literally every other character in the vast cast of the long-running series, but what are you going to do.
10. Made In America - The Sopranos
David Chase’s mob epic The Sopranos granted television a level of critical acclaim previously reserved only for cinema, with the nineties hit elevating the perception of the medium’s potential in the eyes of the public alongside David Lynch’s Twin Peaks.
Filled with complex characters and the sort of layered storytelling which gave rise to later masterpieces such as Breaking Bad, Mad Men, and The Wire, The Sopranos offered the blueprint for prestige TV from its debut until its uncompromising finale, Made In America.
This moving end to a uniquely American crime saga was, of course, despised for ending on an ambiguous cut to black, rather than spoon feeding the audience.
Yes, he died. No, that’s not the point.
9. Home - The X-Files
Iconic nineties sci-fi hit The X-Files was occasionally criticized for being too light in tone and failing to take its conspiracies and monsters of the week seriously—shout out to the underrated Lone Gunmen, killed off for the crime of being too funny (and also maybe sort of predicting 9/11).
However, Home, the most dark and disturbing episode of the show, certainly does not suffer with this problem.
This Hills Have Eyes homage, featuring gory cannibalism and implied incest, was way too much for many viewers. These fans shied away from the intense and grotesque horror odyssey and, although that’s an understandable choice, it still doesn’t excuse the outsized hate thrown at this superb and horrifying episode.
8. A Million Little Fibres - South Park
Given the absurdly quick turnaround that BASEKetball stars Trey Parker and Matt Stone’s adult animated comedy South Park works with, it’s inevitable that the show will occasionally turn in an undercooked instalment.
After all, the show had an episode entitled The Quest for Ratings, which literally mocked the creator’s inability to think of a plot that week.
Which makes it all the stranger that the show’s episode A Million Little Fibres, a pitch perfect parody of the infamous James Frey and his dishonest “autobiography” A Million Little Pieces, is derided by fans—and the series co-creators—despite being a fairly solid satire of the author and TV show host Oprah’s mindless promotion of his obvious grift.
7. Moe Goes From Rag To Riches - The Simpsons
Every once in a while, a long-running series will try something truly strange—and they’ll almost always be lambasted for it by their supposed fans.
Where the more risqué and experimental likes of TBS hit American Dad may be able to pull off stunts like an episode recreating the Pulitzer prize winning play August: Osage County, the venerable institution of The Simpsons is attacked for trying to leapfrog out of its comfort zone.
Case in point: Moe Goes from Rags to Riches, a surreal Jeremy Irons-starring instalment of the show which illustrates the bizarre backstory of the eponymous dishrag doesn’t deserve any of the outsized hate it gets, being far funnier than most of the show’s later season instalments.
6. The Finale - Seinfeld
Starring the eponymous stand up but coming from the minds of Larries Charles and David as well as Seinfeld himself, the nineties hit sitcom Seinfeld reshaped the landscape of TV comedy with its cast of cynical, uncaring “friends” who refused to learn lessons or provide the requisite golden moments expected from the saccharine genre.
Instead, this wildly popular sitcom became a huge success due to its simple, ingenious ethos of “no hugging, no learning”—which of course meant that it lived up to this mindset in a brutal finale which leaves the heroes stranded in jail.
This obvious choice infuriated viewers, for some reason—Maybe they mixed up the show with Friends?
5. That's My Dog - Six Feet Under
American Beauty scribe/ True Blood creator Alan Ball is no stranger to putting his characters through the wringer both emotionally and physically.
However, the infamously intense kidnapping ordeal unexpectedly endured by Michael C Hall’s sensitive and well-meaning protagonist on this dramedy proved far too much for many of the show’s loyal fans.
Despite the show handling the unsettling and upsetting material superbly, it’s easy to see why this one would rub many viewers up the wrong way, given its difficult content and the uneasy psycho-sexual complications suffered by the protagonist as he finds himself fantasising about his captor despite himself.
4. The Finale - Mad Men
There was no way that series creator Matthew Weiner could have hoped to keep Mad Men fans happy with whatever series finale he chose. But it’s nonetheless bizarre that fans despised the show’s cynical, comical denouement, wherein troubled antihero Don Draper appears to come up with Coke’s infamous “I’d Like to Buy the World A Coke” campaign whilst attempting to reach Nirvana.
The scene is a flawless encapsulation of Draper’s flaws and positive attributes, as his media-poisoned mind manages to warp inner peace into further profits, and on a more macro level it’s a perfect example of Draper and co.’s remorseless consumerist mindset wrestling hippie culture’s movement into submission and forcing it to fit America’s prevailing profit-centred ethos.
We said it was a perfect ending, not a happy one.
3. Dancin' Homer - The Simpsons
It’s hard to understand why Simpsons fans despise the early instalment Dancin Homer when the simple story of the family patriarch’s rise to fame as the eponymous sports mascot is a pretty perfect distillation of the show’s early, uneven, but deeply likeable and promising early seasons.
No, the show isn’t working at its mile-a-minute Homer at the Bat pace yet, but without the Gatling gun barrage of constant jokes the emotional beats hit harder and the charming character comedy, such as Homer’s tentative friendship with Burns, works even better.
It’s a quieter and more grounded tone than the show eventually opted for, but this is a pretty great episode nonetheless.
2. The Long Night - Game Of Thrones
The long-awaited face-off between the Night King and our morally grey heroes on Game of Thrones was always bound to be divisive, but many viewers resented the bleak and unbearably tense final season instalment The Long Night for failing to live up to their outsized expectations for the eventual battle.
Despite the episode handling combat even more brutally and engrossingly than earlier less ambitious instalments such as Blackwater, many fans were let down by The Long Night, and revisiting the episode it’s hard to see why.
The dark, violent action sings, the character beats hit their marks, and everything from Jorah’s brutally tragic death to Arya’s victorious killing of series antagonist the Night King is pitch perfect.
1. The Fly - Breaking Bad
One of the most infamous instalments listed here, Fly is a tense, sparse instalment of former X-Files staff writer Vince Gilligan’s megahit Breaking Bad wherein the protagonist, tortured former teacher turned badass meth-dealer Walter White, pursues a lone eponymous bug which has managed to infiltrate his drug-concocting operation.
That’s it.
The entire season three episode focuses solely on Walt’s attempts to catch this persistent bugger, earning the ire of fans and critics alike as many considered the conceit interminably slow and simple.
Of course, it’s a metaphor for Walt’s all-consuming single-minded ambition, the same flaw which will come to be his eventual downfall, but viewers didn’t care about that, and thus this became the first and last time that director Rian Johnson ever infuriated an entire fandom with his subversive direction.