12 Scariest Doctor Who Episodes

all of the best episodes are straight-up scary. There are these elements of body horror, of creeping fear and terror, that are just marvelously scary. And sometimes, something just reaches out and grabs and you yelp and hide behind the sofa. Characters show their true colors in the face of fear, and no one faces fear like the Doctor. He can stare down devils, give directions in the face of creeping evil, and run towards any form of danger no matter how much his survival instincts scream at him to turn around. Nothing scares like Doctor Who, and there is no one quite as brave as the Doctor.

12. Journey To The Center Of The Tardis

Journey To The Centre Of The TARDIS Header This episode may be unpopular, but it's still bloody freaky. The Tardis, a place of safety and comfort, is suddenly full of terrifying charred zombies. The zombies are chasing people around the ship, with no particular motive and no hint of what they're going to do to you if they catch you. What the heck are they? Where are they from? Not knowing makes them scary, which is why Clara again and again demands that the Doctor tell her what they are. He resists, but bits and pieces leak out. He calls one of the monsters "she," he insists that Clara not ask. And when the sensor figures it out, all he can do is apologize. Knowing makes them even more terrifying, as you realize that the menace throughout the episode, the horrific creatures that have been stumbling around, have been Clara, the Doctor, and the one-shot friends the whole time. The monster you've been running from is revealed to be yourself. Pretty spooky, am I right?

11. The Beast Below

Doctor Who Beast Below

Right up until the end twists, this episode is among the scariest pieces of television I've ever seen. Why did the elevator eat a child? What are the freaky three faced clown statues? Why is everyone so sad? Why the heck is the ship without engines, and how can it not be connected to anything? What the heck is happening in this freaky future England? Bit by bit, the secrets are revealed. The amazing thing is that each clue seems to make the sum of the mystery more scary. The masked woman is a queen, one who doesn't know how her ship is flying. Every single man and woman on the ship are privy to a secret that they chose to forget, a secret so terrible that Amy was desperate to keep it from the Doctor. And the freaky clown statues can walk and, if they choose, kill you if you protest. The "space whale" ending was not a good choice. Look how it turned out on Torchwood: they made the best of it on Doctor Who. But right up until the whale thing, it was creepy as heck.

10. Asylum Of The Daleks

Doctor Who Clara There's nothing scary about a creature made from kitchen implements. Until it starts to become a real, physical, imminent threat. That was the genius in Moffat's new twist on the Daleks: they weren't just crazy thingys that yelled "exterminate," they had a concept of beauty that we would call "hatred," they had humans as slaves and pets, and they had technology that could steal our souls. The final reveal that Oswin Oswald has been, all along, a Dalek, is astonishing because it is both completely unexpected and totally predictable. The episode has been full of little hints: where did the milk come from? "Eggs" at the beginning of "exterminate," wooden planks to keep out Daleks who are "getting in at night," and the conversion of the other humans. All of this is pointing at the terrible truth, but Oswin believes it so we do too. Plus, there were reanimated skeletons blundering about, and a guy who says "I died outside" with a suddenly flat affect. That was freaky...

9. The Angels Take Manhattan

the angels take manhattan No, this one wasn't as good as Blink. But it was still very cool. The angels didn't move unless we looked at them--the cardinal sin of the Byzantium episode--and they even had babies, babies which could blow out your lights. Manhattan lent itself well to a lovely creepy vibe, full of suspicious statues and looming apartment blocks. The angel's farm was frightening too, and had a fantastic sense of foreboding to it. Imagine walking into a building you've never seen before and finding your name written on a door. Finding yourself inside. and then being sent back in time, knowing forever that that was your fate. Then we realize that this is, according to what the Doctor says, fated to happen to Rory. We know that this is Amy and Rory's last episode, so the possibility that one or both of them will be stuck here is very real. Also, the angel baby blowing out the match? So. Spooky. I'm gonna need more words for "scary..."

8. The Empty Child

The-empty-child Are you my mummy? It asks the same question again and again. It calls phones that aren't phones, turns on electronics, begs to be let in with the voice of a child. When it's around, radios play, empty tapes keep running, and typewriters move themselves. It follows you around everywhere you go, if you're poor Nancy. Not only does this little monster haunt Nancy and the other characters, it can also make you like it. It can hollow you out, give you injuries that are terrifyingly specific. It takes your face away from you, and makes you an automoton. It's done this to hundreds of people. And soon it will do this to everyone on earth. But the scariest bit of the episode is in the hospital, when Doctor Constantine knocks his cane on a bin and every man and woman leaps upwards. They're all dead, but they haven't died. They're just empty, asking for their mummies. It's one of those things that gets scarier the more you think about it, and that's saying quite a lot.

7. Midnight

d10-10b-c459

We never did find out what this thing was. It came in, and it stole a voice. It never had a shape, just a pair of terrifying eyes that seemed to bore through your skull. It came from a planet where no life known to people of the future could survive. It lived in light so dangerous it could reduce anything to dust. The planet was beautiful, filled with diamonds sparkling in the deadly sunlight. And the life that inhabited it came and immediately began to kill. Began to take minds, bodies, and voices from other people. All it ever had was their voices. That's it. But it managed to manipulate them, play on their fears, until a group of ordinary people proved capable of murdering and innocent man. With just a voice, it did that. And who doesn't love a good creepy couplet: We must not look at goblin men we must not buy their fruits who knows upon what soil they fed their hungry thirsty roots

6. Silence In The Library/Forest Of The Dead

doctor who forest of the dead This is another monster we never actually got to see, the unspellable Vashtanarada. Not every shadow, but any shadow. "Not everyone comes back out of the dark." They're on every planet, including this one. They can strip bones in seconds. Add to that the macabre nature of their communication--the souls and skeletons of dead people--and you've got a cocktail of horror, as the Doctor, River, and assorted company are chased around a library full of dead faces. Every basic question was answered by ghosts. In that library, even the computers were full of dead people. In the end, the Vashtanarada were just animals, just creatures swarming in their forests. That didn't make them less scary, or the damage they caused less real. But even they feared the Doctor, and that's why they were defeated. They were scary, and they were defeated, and it's over. Unless...have you got two shadows?

5. The Family Of Blood

family of blood

The family are spooky. They talk freaky, they take over people's bodies, they have an army of scarecrows. They murder indiscriminately, they will stop at nothing to get our hero--our hero who is helpless, his mind and his ability to fight gone. They alone are enough to keep any child up all night. But what's really scary about this episode isn't the monsters. It's the Doctor. He is responsible for all the deaths that occur in this episode. He came there "on a whim," and innocent men women and children died. The end of this one always gives me chills, as the Doctor's punishments for the family are laid out. The sister in the mirror, who if you look you can see in every mirror, moving in the background. The mother falling forever into a dying star. The father eternally wrapped in chains. And the son, standing as a scarecrow over the fields of England. All of them, left like that, forever, by the Doctor. "We wanted to live forever."

4. The Girl In The Fireplace

girl in the fireplace Clockwork is spooky, when you think about it. It's the most basic form of software, in a way: mechanics that work on their own, without interference, imitating something like life. So it's no surprise that a clockwork person turns out really frightening. The French court mock-up makes it even worse. When you think about it, the effect should be to make them less scary: clown masks under wigs and coattails are not exactly intimidating when worn by anyone else--the opposite, in fact. But it makes them more scary, as the whirr and spin with empty eye-holes. Every character but the Doctor is cornered by these things, and their stiff movents and black eyes are ridiculously creepy. They speak in jerks, without moving their lips--you know there's nothing under that mask that is anything like a face. And I must say, the moment when the Doctor is almost grabbed by one under the bed makes me yelp every time.

3. The Doctor's Wife

Doctor Who The Doctors Wife This one is Neil Gaiman, so it's full of scary moments. The overall concept seems like it could be carried out without scares, but the episode is full of spooky, creepy, chilling moments that make everything so much more awesome. My personal favorite is the reveal of the "patchwork people," which is such a freakishly logical thought, their internal organs and their limbs removed and patched back together. There's also the Ood that leads Amy on into tentacles, the increasingly aging and scary Rory, the House's takeover of the Tardis, and plenty more scattered here and there. The lights can be turned off within Amy's mind. The planet that is smaller on the inside does not like you, and will kill you for pure pleasure. And it can take over the safest place on the show, make it into a house of horrors: the Tardis itself. Sorry Mr. Gaiman, but this one was way scarier than "Nightmare in Silver."

2. The Waters Of Mars

waters of mars

Again, this is fear of takeover by an alien entity. Again, the eyes are important. There the resemblance to other episodes ends, as this piece of glorious originality goes wild. Mars is supposed to be a dead planet, with nothing left alive. The men and women who came here came because of how rough Earth got. And now they may not be alone. Now, there is something else on this planet, something that doesn't like them, something that wants to get to Earth. Stopping it means death, death which if you're lucky will occur before it gets you. On top of that, the sheer physicality of these monsters is brilliant and terrifying. The twitching limbs of the men and women being taken over, the danger of a single drop of water, the cracked lips and damaged eyes of the people who've been reanimated...It's all enough for a batch of nightmares, and a bit of therapy.

1. Blink

This one had to be number one. I mean, come on. This episode is so scary it's positively traumatizing, it's worthy of being called child abuse with that end monologue, it's the best Doctor Who episode ever. The uncanny wanders around everywhere. The villains are exactly what they're not supposed to be--always still, personality-less--but they somehow are always scary. They are frozen, yet somehow they can follow Sally. For some reason, the Doctor told her to beware of them. Then we discover that they are only evil, can only get you, if you stop looking at them. And as we all know, once you start worrying about not blinking you'll be desperate to blink. The moment when the teeth are revealed, when we realize that the statue is reaching for Sally, when we realize what the angels do to you if they even touch you... It's all enough to haunt you, even without the paranoia monologue at the end. And the best and scariest part of the episode is one you only notice on re-watch: the angels never move when we look at them. There are plenty of moments when all the characters are looking elsewhere, but the camera is still on the angels so they can't move because we are holding them frozen in time. When one of them reaches for Sally, she doesn't see it, and it only stops because we see it. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm going to curl up with my teddy bear and watch something soothing. Like Winnie the Pooh. Or maybe Madeline. Or, I know, Coraline--that's not scary, is it? It's for kids, after all!

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Rebecca Kulik lives in Iowa, reads an obsence amount, watches way too much television, and occasionally studies for her BA in History. Come by her personal pop culture blog at tyrannyofthepetticoat.wordpress.com and her reading blog at journalofimaginarypeople.wordpress.com.