12 Worst Time Travel Goofs In The Flash (So Far)

Where we're going, we don't need common sense.

The Flash Time Travel
The CW

The CW’s hit DC comics adaptation The Flash pulled out and waved the time travel card surprisingly early on in its latest run on television.

Although the scarlet speedster’s ability to travel in time has been a part of the character for several decades in the comics, you’d have thought they’d have given the new show a chance to bed in for a year or two before bringing on the hard stuff: like sinking a few beers before ordering a round of shots.

After all, time travel is an absolute b*stard to write without creating plot holes the size of King Shark’s king size toothbrush.

Why is this important? Because all storytelling requires a narrative on friendly terms with its own internal logic. Time travel stories, however, require bulletproof internal logic to succeed, given that they live and die on the consistency of cause and effect.

This is especially true of the story currently being told in The Flash, since not only do the nuts and bolts of the plot hinge on the consequences of messing with cause and effect, but the broader character arc pivots on Barry Allen - the Flash himself - being held accountable for the consequences of messing with cause and effect.

So have they pulled it off? Not remotely. Here are some of the most glaring errors regarding their time travel shenanigans so far: the mistakes, blunders and goofs in the narrative of The Flash that indicate that they don’t really know what they’re doing.

12. They’ve Already Overegged The Pudding

The Flash Supergirl
CBS

Were this a genuine 'many worlds' fiction, there would be no possibility of time travel 'changing history' at all.

If you were to draw a diagram representing the many worlds theory, it’d look a lot like the branches of a tree. Every decision, no matter how small, creates a new branch, which continues onward as a new timeline. Fractal flora, flowering into an infinity of futures.

Time travellers would, theoretically, either skate up and down the branches or find a way to leap from one branch to the other. While doing so, any attempt to change history would simply see them hop onto a new branch: ‘resetting’ history would be a matter of finding the right branch again.

However, the Arrowverse’s version of the DC Multiverse, while sticking to a variation of the infinite parallel worlds theory, clearly also allows for the possibility of travelling in time to change history: after all, that’s half of the arc plots in The Flash to date and the entire premise of Legends Of Tomorrow. The two aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive, but there’s a lot more explanation and exposition required to make them work side by side in the same continuity.

And that’s part of the problem: the CW’s DC superhero universe is now completely dependent on how all of this time travel fiddle faddle hangs together.

On an ongoing basis, with sixty-odd episodes of television a year, the various interrelated creative teams on those three shows now have to reconcile Legends Of Tomorrow’s high concept of protecting the timestream from change and The Flash’s storylines featuring multiple rogue speedsters changing history willy-nilly and the fact that Supergirl takes place in a parallel universe where history has taken a different turn… not to mention the fact that The Flash regularly opens portals to these parallel worlds as well.

It’s only been two years, and already this time travel/multiverse/parallel world set-up is hopelessly confused and incredibly confusing, and bound to become even more so.


11. What Caused These Effects?

The Flash Killer Frost Deathstorm
The CW

Narratives like this love to show subtle and nuanced variations in alternate histories, blindsiding the protagonist and the audience with the fascinating parallel versions of familiar characters. In this world, Cisco’s a villain! Laurel Lance is still alive, and a villain! Caitlin’s got ice powers - and she’s a villain! There but for the grace of god go we!

Okay, maybe not that subtle and nuanced.

In the Flashpoint timeline, Joe is a depressed, drunken screw-up on the verge of losing his job while Caitlin isn’t a virtuoso bio-engineer, but a pediatric ophthalmologist: an eye doctor for kids. Flashpoint Cisco, on the other hand, is still a boy genius, but a power-suited billionaire douchecanoe boy genius.

Why? No one knows for sure. You could explain the butterfly effect in the West family by saying that without having to step up and raise a traumatised Barry, single father Flashpoint Joe descended into depression and alcoholism, and became estranged from his kids and his old friends the Allens.

You could explain it that way… but they don’t, just as they don’t explain why Flashpoint Caitlin and Cisco’s lives were so radically different. At least Joe knew the Allens. How did Nora’s survival change the career trajectories of two total strangers?

Once again, we’re left with ‘oooh, alternate timelines/parallel worlds, they so freaky’ as the default interpretation. It's infuriating when stories like this - which are supposed to be about cause and effect, and the consequences involved - are told without showing the cause of the effect.

That would have involved the show’s writers actually having an explanation for the changes, which they clearly don’t. Like inventing evil versions of heroic characters for the hell of it, it doesn’t actually make sense: it was just done for sh*ts and giggles.


10. They’ve Created Gaping Holes In Continuity

Kid Flash
The CW

Flashpoint Wally claimed he gained his superspeed powers when he was struck by lightning while drag-racing and testing a new nitro formula. It’s the old comic book chemicals and electricity origin story, with no mention of the dark matter that created Our Flash, or any of the Central City metahumans from the original timeline.

In the Flashpoint timeline, Ramon Industries is where S.T.A.R. Labs used to be. The site doesn’t appear damaged, and Flashpoint Cisco himself doesn’t seem to be affected, financially, physically or otherwise, by any city wide catastrophe.

In fact, from all the available evidence there doesn’t appear to have been any Flashpoint version of the dark matter wave in 2014. How did the Rival gain his powers? And what about the other Flashpoint metahumans?

If Ramon Industries wasn’t responsible for the creation of Central City’s metahumans, then how does Flashpoint Cisco already know the Flash’s secret identity, and why did he reluctantly work with Wally and Iris to provide Flashpoint Flash with a friction-proof costume?

Come to that, where is Dr. Harrison Wells and his world-changing research? In the original Flash timeline, Wells was about to start S.T.A.R. Labs before Thawne killed him and stole his life and career. In Flashpoint, Thawne couldn’t have killed Wells. Did someone or something else remove him from the equation?

These are all questions which could have been easily answered, had anyone running this show thought to have them asked. Since no one did ask them, we’re left with huge gaps in Flashpoint’s continuity that make no sense: and ‘making no sense’ is the kiss of death for a time travel storyline.


9. Why Does A Happy Barry Still Waste His Life?

The Flash Nora Henry Allen
The CW

So, in the Flashpoint timeline, Our Barry saves his mother from Eobard Thawne, and his father doesn’t go to prison. That means that Young Barry grows up with both parents, isn’t fostered by Joe West… wait a minute, why does he become a police forensic scientist in this timeline?

The whole point of the Flashpoint timeline is that this Barry grows up to be a happy Barry, unscarred by bereavement and loss. He might have a weird story to tell about the night that an impossible man invaded his home - but without that tragedy to hang it on, why would an incredibly intelligent eleven year old boy devoted to science, whose hero is Dr. Harrison Wells, decide to become a CSI?

In the first Flash timeline, Barry becomes obsessed with paranormal phenomena and with finding evidence that this ‘impossible man’ was there that night. For fourteen years, he’s consumed by it, putting everything else in life on the back burner, because his mother was murdered and his father wrongly convicted of the crime.

Without either of those motivations in play and with no police officer as a de facto father figure, why would Barry become a scientist for the police in the Flashpoint timeline?

As with most of the other changes to the timeline, we’re not given a reason. No cause and effect is established for it within the storyline. We’re just expected to believe that Barry’s ‘supposed’ to be a bottom rung lab monkey, when he’s got parents like Henry and Nora Allen to encourage him to do the great things he’s clearly capable of.


8. What Happened To The Other Barrys? Part 1

The Flash Flash Back
The CW

Back in the first season episode ‘Rogue Time’, when the Flash went back in time a day for his Groundhog Day experience, there should have been two Barry Allens in the past… but there weren’t.

As he breaks through to travel back in time, we see his past self disappear, and then Barry is just suddenly in his place, receiving radio signals from the Cisco of the past as though their conversation was never interrupted.

To make matters worse, Our Barry doesn’t time travel to the present day again - or if he does, he does it the old fashioned way, by living it sixty seconds at a time. The Barry in the past doesn’t come back - he’s just gone.

‘Rogue Time’ never gives us an explanation as to why that is, or how Our Barry is just able to step into the shoes of his suddenly missing past self. It’s not a normal function of time travel in fiction. The closest there is to an explanation is Harry Wells’ theory of the ‘time remnant’: the living echo of a speedster from a now defunct timeline.

Here, however, the time-travelling Barry - Our Barry - simply takes over from the Barry of the past, who vanishes without trace. Why? He belongs in that time. Our Barry is the visitor.

More to the point, in the second season episode ‘Flash Back’ Our Barry travels back to 2014 to persuade Eobard Thawne, masquerading as Harrison Wells, to train him to run fast enough to stop Zoom in his own time.

In that episode, he has to drug his past self to keep him out of the way long enough to impersonate him, so that Thawne doesn’t realise he’s talking to a Flash from the future who knows who he really is.

That’s how this should work: two Flashes, one present day, one strange visitor from the future. Why does it work differently on other occasions?


7. What Happened To The Other Barrys? Part 2

The Flash Doctor Alchemy
The CW

Now let’s look at ‘Flashpoint’, the third season premiere, and the two new timelines created. In both cases, Our Barry travelled back to that fateful night in 2000: first, to stop Thawne and save his mother, and second to try and reset the original timeline by allowing Thawne to kill Nora again.

In both cases, Our Barry travels forward to 2016 again, having changed history, and in both cases, during that intervening sixteen years two other Barry Allens grow up all over again - from 2000 to 2016 - one having the love of two parents, the other not.

However, as soon as the time travelling Barry - Our Barry - returns to 2016, he takes over from them in their lives as though they never existed, while they, presumably, vanish just like his past self in ‘Rogue Time’ did.

The thing is… surely in these situations, Our Barry is the time remnant. He’s changed history to make himself, as he is right now, a memory. He should be vanishing from time like Eobard Thawne did in the season one finale, but the Speed Force is shielding him as it did with Thawne, to avoid creating a paradox.

So why are the ‘real’ Barrys the ones disappearing in favour of Our Barry? Aren’t these real people, with sixteen entirely different years of life lived and hopes and dreams for the future? Why is Barry Allen allowing his other selves to die?

Or is he? I’m hoping against hope that they’re planning on pulling a rabbit out of the hat here: that Barry’s other selves aren’t gone, but are still around waiting to become a plot point… maybe even dressing up in a hooded robe and calling out remnants of metahumans from other timelines.

However, right now this show isn’t doing the work necessary to convince a sleepy toddler that it knows what it’s doing, so I’m not holding my breath.


6. What Makes Flashpoint So Special?

The Flash Barry Jay Garrick
The CW

In Flashpoint, Barry began losing his memories of his life proper the more he used his powers. Is that because he was a time remnant, protected by the Speed Force, and his constant use of his speed wore away at that protection, exposing him to the fate he should have suffered?

That actually makes a little sense, for a change. However, it raises another question… why isn’t it happening here, in this new timeline?

Flashpoint saw Our Barry give up being the Flash for three months while he stalked Iris and hung out with his parents. He barely used his speed until he realised things were beginning to go wrong, and then of course the more he used his speed the faster things fell apart.

Since that’s the case, why isn't Barry worried about the same thing happening all over again in this new timeline? He’s constantly using his speed, whizzing around like an ADHD toddler in his red leather jammies… isn’t he concerned that he’ll start losing it again, like he did in Flashpoint?

If not, why not? What makes the Flashpoint timeline so different from this one? And why is no one raising any of this as an issue?

We’ve got Harrison Wells (two of them, now) Cisco Ramon and Caitlin Snow on hand in S.T.A.R. Labs, all of whom are scientific geniuses in their various fields. Barry himself is supposedly no intellectual or scientific slouch, and he’s already had a visit from Jay Garrick - the Flash of Earth Three, with huge experience in these matters - specifically to warn him about the dangers of timef*cking the world around him.

Of course, the real reason none of these brilliant minds is raising any of these thorny issues is that the team behind The Flash (the TV show) aren’t nearly as smart as the team behind the Flash (the superhero).

Because they don’t understand any part of the temporal shenanigans they’re screwing with, neither does Team Flash… so we have to put up with a TV show that makes no sense, and scientific geniuses who act like morons.


5. Flip It And Reverse It

The Flash Eobard Thawne Reverse-Flash
The CW

When Barry told his friends about the amended timelines, he conveniently left out the part where it wasn’t actually him that ‘restored’ the timeline back from Flashpoint to its current state.

He didn’t mention that it was Eobard Thawne, the Reverse Flash, who did the deed, nor that he’d given his greatest enemy free reign to mess with his life and the lives of his friends: leaving everyone completely unaware that a madman had timef*cked the world.

If anyone understands about the new timeline and the changes that have been inflicted on people, it’s the Reverse Flash: because he caused it. He even tells Barry as much… which kind of implies that he did it deliberately.

Worse, he’s still out there, free to do it again, having travelled forward to 2016 with Our Barry. Did Our Barry carry him there, or has he retained a connection to the Speed Force to allow him to time travel on his own?

The premiere episode of season two of Legends Of Tomorrow reveals that a version of Thawne has resumed meddling in history, joining forces with Damien Darhk in 1942... a man who planned to nuke the world and rule over the ashes. Is that this Thawne, or a different version?

No doubt there’ll be a Flash/Legends crossover later on in the 2016/1017 television season to resolve this. But poor characterisation and unresolved plotlines aren’t necessarily mistakes. What’s the goof?

Well, this timeline saw Eobard Thawne kill Nora Allen and then travel to 2016… so who killed Harrison Wells in 2000 this time?

After all, this current timeline is supposed to have repeated all the larger events of The Flash season one and two: which means that a stranded Reverse Flash is supposed to have killed and impersonated Wells, created S.T.A.R. Labs in his place and used future knowledge to invent the doomed particle accelerator project and create the Flash six years early.

But Thawne wasn’t stranded in 2000 in this timeline, so none of that can have taken place… except it clearly has.


4. The Horrifying Case Of Sara Diggle, Part 1

Arrow Diggle
The CW

One of the biggest changes to the timeline after the Flashpoint fiasco was the removal from history of John Diggle’s daughter with his wife Lyla Michaels.

When Barry runs to Star City to try and talk through the ramifications of his stupidity with Felicity Smoak, he sees a picture of Green Arrow’s best friend holding a little boy, not a little girl - John Diggle Jr.

Thawne’s meddling wiped a beautiful two-year-old girl from existence and replaced her with an entirely new two-year-old boy.

Now, there are two rather massive issues here. The first is a technical one: how has the timef*cking caused a different child to be conceived? Did this new timeline have some knock on effect that caused the Diggles to knock boots on a different night, or for a different zygote to be formed by the same fertilisation event?

If so, then this is a perfect example of the butterfly effect in operation. Sara Diggle is a can of worms: because if this tiny little change affected that tiny little life, born to a family with no connection to the Allens whatsoever, it should have made vast, sweeping changes to the whole world.

Just for a start, surely this can’t be the only conception that’s been affected in that way by the timeline change. There have been about two billion children born since 2000. However it happened: if it’s happened once, it’s got to have happened at least a million other times in those sixteen years of exponentially transformed history.

What about Oliver’s son William, conceived in a casual liaison with a passing acquaintance in 2007? We could - we should - be looking at half a planet full of different children.


3. The Horrifying Case Of Sara Diggle, Part 2

Arrow Sara Diggle
The CW

The second issue is more complicated. Unbelievably, the loss of Sara Diggle is actually played for laughs in the opening scenes of ‘Paradox’, when Our Barry sees the picture and realises what’s happened.

It’s not like Sara has just been gender-swapped. All this timef*cking has erased a toddler from the world, a baby girl that, last season, Diggle murdered his own brother to protect.

You might be thinking “yes, but Diggle will never know what he’s lost” - and you might be right. If Felicity and Barry never tell them, he and Lyla might go through the rest of their lives in blissful ignorance of the loss of their daughter.

But we’ve already had two people, Iris West and Edward Clariss, who’ve somehow realised that their changed timeline wasn’t quite right. I’ve got a two-year-old daughter myself: I’d rate Diggle and Lyla’s connection with little Sara as far deeper than Iris’ feelings for her soulmate and Clariss’ longing for his superpowered ‘Rival’ persona.

Barry may have doomed Diggle and Lyla to forever look at their son and wonder why it is that he doesn’t feel right to them. That’s… horrible, like a kind of existential postpartum depression that never goes away.

Imagine if everyone who suffered a loss as a result of all this meddling felt that way. That’s a vast amount of psychic trauma being inflicted upon the world. Who knows, maybe this is part of the reason why Cisco is so devastated about the death of his brother - because Dante is supposed to be alive. Talking of which...


2. I Don’t Wanna Be Buried In A Pet Sematary

The Flash Paradox Cisco Ramon
The CW

Then there’s the other major change that Barry knows of so far. When Thawne changed the timeline again, the ripple effect caused Cisco’s older brother Dante to be killed in a car accident only a few months before Our Barry returned to the present after making the change.

As with the other changes, we’re given no indication as to why it is that those changes had a knock on effect that caused the car accident. Just as with Sara’s disappearance, there’s no way to blame Our Barry for directly causing Dante’s death.

However, Barry deliberately caused or allowed events to take place which would have a completely unknown and unpredictable effect on the world around him. You couldn’t indict him for murder, or even manslaughter, but it’s fairly clear that, morally speaking, blame can be laid at his feet.

The question is, why hasn’t Cisco, a genuine rocket scientist, figured that out yet? He was distant and angry with Barry, but only because the Barry of that timeline had refused to go back in time and save Dante’s life.

When he does find out about the timeline change, he’s angry all over again because he considers it hypocrisy that Our Barry went back in time to save his mother after his Barry refused to do so for Dante. Our Barry talks it through with him, and the two reconcile… but Cisco doesn’t seem to understand that the new changes to the timeline have directly led to Dante’s death.

Cisco knows that A) this Barry is from another timeline and is winging it with the changes in this one, and B) this Barry was taken aback at him going to counselling. Surely it's not that hard to connect A to B and figure out that Dante wasn't dead until Thawne timef*cked the world? And of course, since Our Barry has told all his friends that he’s responsible for the new timeline, Cisco wouldn’t blame Thawne. He’d blame Barry.

Either way, if Barry thinks Cisco is narked at him now, wait till he finally twigs. It's the difference between being aggrieved that your mate won't lend you money, and being angry because your mate has stolen all your money.


1. Cause And Effect Is A Cascade, Not A Magic Bullet

The Flash Barry
The CW

Even if you presuppose that rational scientific explanations for time travel will take a back seat here to comic book science (and that’s fine: The Flash treats time travel and the Speed Force with a degree of mysticism, just as the comics do, and just as Lost and Doctor Who did on television before it), cause and effect are still vitally important.

This whole storyline is supposedly all about cause and effect. It’s about the ramifications of our decisions, about accepting responsibility for the consequences of our actions. That’s precisely what Jay tries to teach Barry in ‘Paradox’: that rather than trying to fix things, he should be learning to live with the mistakes he’s made.

This article has laid out some of the more glaring issues with that: massive gaps in continuity, missing explanations, wonky exposition and generally a complete disregard for actual cause and effect. Even accepting all of this nonsense on face value, everyone is surprisingly willing to accept the fact that Barry went back in time - in complete disregard of their lives, their safety and their happiness, and unilaterally screwed with the people closest to him.

None of this reflects well on the supposed hero of this show. In Flashpoint, Our Barry spends three months having breakfast with his mother and stalking Flashpoint Iris at the coffee shop. He doesn’t look up his friends to find out whether they’re okay after he rewrote their whole lives ab initio and without permission.

He doesn’t even seem curious as to what’s happened to them: and even when he finds out, he never looks into how it happened. He never tries to figure out what action has brought about this reaction; what cause has created this effect.

But then, Our Barry Allen isn’t actually the real Barry Allen, is he? The whole Flash timeline isn’t the real timeline. Everything we’ve seen, from the opening narration of the very first episode, is an alternate timeline: it’s what happened after the Reverse Flash of the 22nd Century travelled back in time to 2024 to kill the Flash, and both men then travelled back in time to the year 2000, and Henry and Nora Allen’s house.

Nora Allen, Harrison Wells and his wife weren’t supposed to die in the year 2000. Henry Allen wasn’t supposed to be put in prison. Barry Allen wasn’t supposed to become the Flash until 2020, when the real Wells activated the particle accelerator he built without 22nd century knowledge.

We’re told that Flashpoint is a mirage, a fantasy, a timeline that shouldn’t have been; but so is the so-called ‘original’ timeline we’ve been following from the very beginning. Who knows what the other knock on effects have been? Not us... because, despite all protestations to the contrary, cause and effect isn’t something that this show is interested in.


Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.