While no one can be completely sure if a show will be a complete success or a colossal failure just by looking at a script or having a conversation with a showrunner, there are always those sneaky ones that get away, when an actor decided, or was forced to turn down a role that would later prove to be incredibly well received. Whether it is because of missed connections, scheduling conflicts or just plain lack of interest, the 15 actors and actresses on this list unfortunately just missed a shot to boost their careers to a completely different level. For 15 others however, a stepping stone was reached, audiences reached with adulation and praise, and plenty of money was and still is being made. Before this list begins, it would be smart to point out that some of the actors in this collective are in fact, doing very well for themselves and probably would have been in a similar situation had they taken these roles are not. The characters themselves, however, can still be considered career-making based on what they did for the actor that did end up portraying the role in his or her particular television show.
15. Michael Richards Was Almost Adrian Monk - Monk
An instant hit for critics and audiences alike during its eight year run, many find it strange to think that someone other than Tony Shalhoub could ever have portrayed Adrian Monk. But at one stage, Kramer was almost the lead. The former homicide detective with obsessive compulsive disorder and other phobias became a fan favourite while Michael Richards, best known for his role as Cosmo Kramer on Seinfeld, began his own detective show, The Michael Richards show. Less than two months and just seven aired episodes later, NBC cut its losses and canceled the program due to poor ratings. In Richards' defence, it is understandable that he skipped out on Monk since its premise changed a bit between its initial development with ABC and its eventual haul to the USA Network. This role, however, could have taken the former Seinfeld actor from a supporting man to an A-list star. Picture how much of a difference Richards' career could be today had he followed up Kramer with Adrian Monk just a few years later. As Richards was taking small roles on projects like 2007's underwhelming Bee Movie and not much else, Shalhoub went on to be nominated for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series eight years in a row by the Academy of Television Arts and Sciences winning three Emmys along the way as well as a Golden Globe. The show is still earning big bucks today with reruns airing in more than 60 countries and 17 spin-off novels, the most recent of which, Mr. Monk Goes On Board was released earlier this year. Although Richards has landed on his feet again as a regular on TV Land's new sitcom Kirstie, everybody knows it's a jungle out there.
14. Paul Shaffer Was Almost George Costanza - Seinfeld
If there is just one thing that Paul Shaffer has probably learned since Seinfeld first aired in 1989, it's that if Jerry Seinfeld calls you up, you better make sure you answer. Unfortunately for the longtime band leader on The Late Show with David Letterman, he didn't learn this life lesson until it was too late. While Seinfeld called the former Saturday Night Live musician personally to offer him the role that could have made him a household name without an audition, Shaffer said he was busy with other things at the time and simply forgot to return the comedian's phone call. If that wasn't bad enough, Seinfeld was a guest in David Letterman's show numerous times before Seinfeld ever aired. This could mean that not only was Shaffer to absentminded to answer Seinfeld's phone call, he also failed to talk to the man that shared a stage with him from time to time. This is when Jason Alexander swooped in and charmed us all as "the lord of the idiots," and pretty much made everyone forget that anyone had ever been linked with the role other than him. While Shaffer continues to make music for Letterman's show today, one can only imagine how his and Alexander's careers would have turned around had he just gotten back to Seinfeld.
13. Ray Liotta Was Almost Tony Soprano - The Sopranos
While Ray Liotta seems exactly like the quintessential definition of what Tony Soprano is, the Goodfellas protagonist turned down the role to focus on his movie career - a career, lest we forget that went on to feature roles such as Tuck in 101 Dalmatians II: Patch's London Adventure, Jack in Wild Hogs and Bobby Stevens in CBS' complete failure of a drama, Smith, which lasted only three episodes before it was cut from the airwaves. To add insult to injury, all of these were roles Liotta did take during The Sopranos almost 10 year run. As a result of Liotta passing on the character of a lifetime, the late James Gandolfini jumped in and became the star of one of America's most successful television shows earning himself three Emmy wins, one Golden Globe and numerous other nominations for his portrayal of the street savvy mob boss. Despite his bad judgment, Liotta has been churning out films at a very consistent rate since the late 1980's. Although there are more cameos and direct-to-video releases than he would probably care to admit, films such as 2012's The Place Beyond the Pines and Killing Them Softly, which Gandolfini was also in, have salvaged Liotta's career a bit.
12. Paul Giamatti Was Almost Michael Scott - The Office
Since the American spin-off of The Office premiered in early 2005 on NBC, many rumours have come to light of various actors who were up for different roles on the show but for one reason or another, didn't get the part. To many viewers' surprise, Steve Carell wasn't producers' first choice to play Michael Scott. They instead had their sights set on Paul Giamatti who was fresh off of 2004's Sideways, which had just received an Academy Award for Best Adapted Screenplay along with four other nominations at the 77th annual Oscars. Giamatti was offered the role of Dunder-Mifflin's dysfunctional boss when the show was still in development but ultimately turned it down. While Giamatti probably kicks himself every once in a while for missing out on the show, he has carved out a very successful career nonetheless in both dramas and comedies such as the aforementioned Sideways, American Splendor, The Illusionist and Win Win, and he's set to baffle and delight in equal measure as the most unlikely member of The Amazing Spider-Man 2's rogue's gallery. So he's probably not short a few dollars - but it would have been an issue of boosted profile, rather than monetary gain. Overall, Giamatti denying the role turned out to be a blessing in disguise as it gave former Daily Show correspondent, Steve Carell the chance to blossom in a role that was ultimately perfect for him until he departed after seven seasons to focus on his movie career, which many still think was a mistake in itself.
11. Craig T. Nelson Was Almost Jay Pritchett - Modern Family
Ed O'Neill is one of those actors that seems like he is exactly like the character he plays on TV, but the Modern Family match made in heaven almost never came to fruition as Craig T. Nelson was weighing his offer for the role of Jay Pritchett on the popular comedy mockumentary Modern Family before O'Neill was even considered. In the end Nelson decided ABC wasn't putting enough money on the table and moved on to star in NBC's Parenthood as the level-headed Zeek Braverman which is currently in the middle of its fifth season. Overall, this missed opportunity seems like a win-win for audiences, but it may be viewed as a slight misstep for Nelson as time has unfolded. Although both shows are popular and successful, few shows rival Modern Family at the moment for audience pull (even with a number of controversies attached to it,) which has also started to be syndicated on USA Network. Aside from Parenthood, Nelson has recently starred in films such as The Proposal and Soul Surfer, but he could well have been on the same big money, big profile contract that is likely to tie O'Neill to the show now after its early successes. O'Neill, who has been a part of four Screen Actors Guild Awards for Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble Cast in a Comedy Series as well as numerous other nominations, has stuck to voice work aside from his part as Mr. Pritchett since the show started airing in 2009.
10. Maura Tierney Was Almost Sarah Braverman - Parenthood
Unfortunately for former ER star Maury Tierney, she had to skip out on the part of Sarah Braverman in Parenthood thanks to no fault of her own, so it is perhaps unfair to call her foolish. Tragic would be far more an appropriate definition. After she was diagnosed with breast cancer, the former ER actress had her tumour removed in mid-2009 and her treatment caused scheduling conflicts with the filming of the show. To try and accommodate her leave of absence, executives at NBC pushed the show's production back eight weeks, but in the end, Tierney had to leave the show to focus on her health, before she was replaced by former Gilmore Girls actress Lauren Graham who won Choice TV Parental Unit at the 2010 Teen Choice Awards for her role as Sarah. Tierney returned to her craft in 2010 to work on a stage play called North Atlantic. Since then, the Emmy nominated actress has guest appeared on The Office as Robert California's wife, Susan, and CBS' The Good Wife. As for Graham, she will be appearing in A Friggin' Christmas Miracle later this year, and of course, continues her work as one of the protagonists, Sarah Braverman, on Parenthood, which is currently in its fifth season on NBC.
9. Eric Stoltz For Vic Mackey - The Shield
Eric Stoltz is the personification of the Nearly Man, thanks to his well-publicised association with the role of Marty McFly in the first Back To The Future film, before he was unceremoniously canned. The sad reality of that situation is that most under 25 year olds will be only vaguely aware of him at all, unless you are unlike the average movie and TV viewer who doesn't make a habit out of watching direct-to-video releases. But it could have been so different, even despite the Back To The Future situation, as he had another massive opportunity to cement his profile as more than that guy who made a cameo in Pulp Fiction. He probably could have become a much more popular actor had he just accepted the role of crooked and violent detective Vic Mackey in FX crime-drama The Shield, but instead he turned the role down after FX made him an offer according to a Tweet sent out by show creator Shawn Ryan in 2012. Aside from plenty of little known roles during the time The Shield aired, Stoltz also played the lead on SyFy's spin-off prequel of Battlestar Gallactica, Caprica for less than a year in 2010 before it was cancelled due to low ratings in the middle of the season. The actor who went on to step into Mackey's considerable shoes was of course Michael Chiklis, who won an Emmy Award, a Golden Globe and a Satellite Award and received many other nominations for his work on the show. Along with a consistent film roles and a couple stints on television shows that never ended up lasting too long, Chiklis also played The Thing in the Fantastic Four movies.
8. Katie Holmes Was Almost Buffy - Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Katie Holmes was originally approached to play the high school cheerleader turned undead fighter, Buffy Summers for the now defunct WB Television Network. Instead of acting like she was in high school though, Holmes decided that she would rather attend her senior year of real high school instead. Just a year after the fact, Holmes was cast as another lead in a WB show involving high school, this time as Joey Potter in Dawson's Creek. Holmes essentially gave up the chance to beat monstrous creatures to a bloody pulp for kissing scenes with James Van Der Beek. Some say she won. Most would say she probably didn't. Fortunately for Holmes, she stuck in Hollywood and became a part of projects like Batman Begins, Thank You for Smoking and The Kennedys miniseries, which aired in 2011, but there's no doubt that her profile would have been considerably different now if she had started out in Buffy rather than Dawson's Creek, and she possibly wouldn't be as easily mockable as she tends to be. It can't be forgotten that she was also in Adam Sandler's Jack and Jill though. No one can unsee that. Sarah Michelle Gellar went on to play Buffy for a little over six years and followed her success with a couple of live action Scooby-Doo movies and two films in The Grudge series as well, and though her career isn't exactly hitting heights at the minute, she is still fondly remembered as the greatest vampire slayer ever committed to screen.
7. Michael Keaton Was Almost Jack Shephard - Lost
Picturing Michael Keaton as heartthrob surgeon Dr. Jack Shephard on Lost just feels plain wrong, and luckily, Keaton ended up turning down the role when producer J. J. Abrams informed him that his character would be turned into the shows' protagonist instead of an expendable guest slated to be killed off in the first episode. Keaton didn't want to commit to a full time role and the rest is history. In Keaton's defense, he would be playing the role of a man stranded in the middle of nowhere at 53 years-old, which is a lot less convincing than someone like Fox who was 38 at the time the show began - even if he was Batman. Nonetheless, the role would have made him plenty of cash and forced him back into the spotlight since his gradual fall beginning with 1998's abysmal Jack Frost. He would also have been able to fix his profile after years of perceived abuse, and we could still be seeing regular work from Keaton, rather than wondering how wide a release the admittedly excellent looking Birdman will actually get. In Fox' case, his career appears to be in purgatory at the moment, as he hasn't acted in anything really worth mentioning since the finale of Lost in 2010 - but he can always rely on the fact that casting directors will always easily be able to remember him as the lead in that massive, mend-bending show that pretty much won TV for more than half a decade.
6. Thomas Jane Was Almost Don Draper - Mad Men
Jon Hamm makes a great Don Draper, this much, everybody knows: it's like he was born to play the role.
What a lot of people don't know though is that Thomas Jane, most famous for his roles in The Punisher and The Mist, was originally the one approached to portray the suave businessman on AMC's Mad Men, and that he unthinkably turned it down. Jane's reason for not taking the role was that he didn't want to act in a television show, despite the fact that he then, ironically, went on to play leading man, Ray Drecker in HBO's short lived comedy-drama series, Hung just a couple years later.
Although his career has shaped up to be a decent one with parts in five upcoming projects slated to be released this year, there is little doubt that Jane could have been on par with Jon Hamm's fame if he wasn't so stubborn and just took the role (even if we would have then been robbed of Hamm's superlative performance.)
At least he attempted to learn from his mistakes though.
5. John Hawkes Was Almost The Governor - The Walking Dead
Similar to Thomas Jane's situation, John Hawkes had his doubts about being a series regular on a television show on basic cable, which is what led to him ultimately passing on the goldmine that was The Governor on AMC's The Walking Dead.
"They offered me the role, and I just felt there would be someone else who could do it better," he said in an exclusive interview with MovieWeb in 2010. "There are going to be sponsors. No matter how good the show is, if there are commercials, it's going to be a different show, to me. That's just my personal feeling."
While Hawkes' reasoning for not taking the role actually makes a lot of sense, the Governor will go down as one of the best characters in the history of the show regardless, and has utterly transformed the career of David Morrissey. When all was said and done, Morrissey threw on an eye patch and struck fear into the hearts of everyone that watched him.
Hawkes shouldn't be losing any sleep for his gaff though as he has had large roles in critically acclaimed films such as Winter's Bone, Martha Marcy May Marlene and The Sessions to name a few, but there's nothing quite like turning down the coolest TV villain of the past decade.
4. Whitney Houston Was Almost Sondra Huxtable - The Cosby Show
Whitney Houston took the world by storm from her emergence in the mid-1980's, to her unfortunate death in 2012. While she is known worldwide for her singing voice, it could just as easily have been because of her acting ability as well. In the early 80's, Houston auditioned and was offered the role of Sondra Huxtable in one of the most well-known sitcoms, The Cosby Show. Right before signing on the show, she opted to focus on her music career full time instead of making room for an acting career. "So we gather in this room and there are kids from New York and Los Angeles and they are all signing their contracts, and this girl who we brought from New York said "I can't sign this contract and I said "Why?" She said, "Well, I want to be a singer. I can't be in every show. I have to be in every tour," said Jay Sandrich, director of the first three seasons of the show in an interview with the Daily Mail. Had Houston not become such a stoic figure in the music industry, her risk could have easily been a foolish one, but fortunately for her, she made it big before her tragic fall from grace and untimely death. Perhaps if she'd taken a different career path, her life might have turned out differently, particularly with the grounding influence of Bill Cosby around her.
3. Dana Delaney Was Almost Carrie Bradshaw - Sex And The City
Sarah Jessica Parker has won four Golden Globe Awards, three Screen Actors Guild Awards, and two Emmy Awards for her portrayal of Carrie Bradshaw on HBO's romantic sitcom Sex And The City, and though she is loved by fans, Parker was very close to not even being on the show at all. Dana Delaney, famous for roles like Susan Barnes in Fly Away Home, Sarah Ashby McClure in True Women and Mrs. Beal in Wide Awake was given the role of Carrie by producers but rejected it because she had already been a part of multiple projects involving sex and didn't want to be in something that had sex in the title or had sex as a theme. Seriously. Nowadays, most of Delaney's roles involve voice acting for a variety of cartoons, though she was also a regular on Desperate Housewives for its first three seasons and the star of Body of Proof both of which aired on ABC until the show was canceled in May of last year. While her career has been nothing to be ashamed over, Delaney has to wonder what could have been if she accepted being typecast for a role as popular as Carrie.
2. Matthew Broderick Was Almost Walter White - Breaking Bad
1. And So Was John Cusack
Not only is it hard to imagine someone other than Bryan Cranston playing Walter White on AMC's Breaking Bad, but it is also difficult to accept that both Matthew Broderick and John Cusack were offered and turned down the role of the cancer-suffering science teacher turned crystal meth kingpin. Fortunately for just about everyone, Cranston was the one to get the job and he ran with it, committing one of the greatest performances of the last decade to screen in the process. In his almost six years as Walter White, Cranston earned himself 3 Emmy Awards for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series during Breaking Bad's first three seasons, making him the second person in history to win the award three years in a row along with Bill Cosby for his role in the NBC adventure series I Spy. While both Cusack and Broderick have been just about able to keep their careers from going down the tubes completely, most of their recent work hasn't been too flattering, and nothing at all stands up to what Walter White could have done for them. With films like the critically panned The Raven for Cusack and a few small films that also didn't receive good reviews for Broderick, both could have used the help of one of the most acclaimed characters of all time to shove them back into stardom. When all was said and done, it was they who broke bad, not the show. Did we miss any other actors who infamously turned down career-making TV roles? Share your own picks below.
Hey, I'm Brandon. I love writing and reading and I study journalism, communication studies and business at the University of Rhode Island. My main passions are sports, music, TV, movies and a lot of other things that would take me way too long to write. WhatCulture is a great place for me to express myself so I'm looking to write as much as I can. Thanks for reading my work.