15 Best American Horror Story Deaths

Violent vampires, murderous magicians, and killer clowns.

American Horror Story Bitchcraft
FX

Since its debut way back in 2011, American Horror Story has created a legacy for itself as one of the most unique shows on TV. The anthology style allows each new season to bring back largely the same excellent cast, with a few new additions each year, while telling a completely different story.

Though they may be a far cry from everything that came before it in terms of narrative and setting, each season still shares the unmistakable American Horror Story style. This all but guarantees fans watching will be shocked, creeped out, and will be subjected to things that make them far less than comfortable.

One such aspect that is synonymous with this style is death. It is a horror story after all, and so every season is filled with characters that simply won't live to see the end.

Whether it's because they are satisfying, shocking, or horrifically gory, there are some death scenes that live longer in the memory than others.

Over ten years, American Horror Story has killed off countless characters, with some of these deaths ultimately becoming iconic moments in the series, and some of the best scenes any horror TV show can offer.

15. Hayden McClaine - Murder House

American Horror Story Murder House Hayden
FX

In the first season of American Horror Story, the narrative wasn't exactly filled with good people. Aside from Vivien and Violet, most other main characters were either cheaters, murderers, or attempted baby thieves. Kate Mara's Hayden McClaine certainly falls within the latter category after scheming with Nora to try and take Vivien's twins.

While she was still alive, she entered into an affair with Ben Harmon knowing full well that he was married, and tried to extort him into supporting her and the child she originally told him she wasn't going to keep.

In a strange twist of fortune for Ben, Hayden wasn't the only one trying to manipulate him. As part of Larry's larger plan to ultimately get the Harmons out of the house, he killed Hayden, forcing Ben to bury the body in his back yard. It was the sheer surprise element of this death that makes it stick in the memory even after all these years.

As she and Ben left the titular house, there was no build up, no suspenseful music, and absolutely no clue as to what was about to happen, just a barrage of shovel hits to the head. One second she was standing, and the next she wasn't.


14. Gabriel - Hotel

American Horror Story Hotel Gabriel
FX

Some deaths are on this list because of the emotional effect killing off a well known character can have. However, there are some characters that barely had any screen time at all, but were able to live long in the memory thanks to the sheer vile nature of their deaths.

One such character is Gabriel, the drug addict played by Max Greenfield who used the Hotel Cortez as a place to feed said addiction. His death is one of the most bizarre in the entire history of American Horror Story.

Hypodermic Sally, one of the many ghosts that lived in the titular hotel, arranged for Gabriel to be visited in his room by the Addiction Demon. The horrifying figure proceeded to rape the character with a sex toy in the shape of a metal cone. It's exactly as awful as it sounds.

He is then sewn into the mattress by Sally, seemingly fluctuating between being alive and dead, before ultimately and definitively dying in a hospital bed. There are some truly harrowing scenes throughout Hotel, and this is up there with the most disturbing of them.


13. Rosie & Mark - Cult

American Horror Story Cult Coffins
FX

Rosie & Mark aren't characters that will likely be recognised immediately by just their names. The two were very much minor characters in Cult, and appeared in just one episode, not even surviving that. While their names may not be memorable, the way that they were killed certainly is.

Rosie suffered from an irrational fear of caskets and of being buried alive. She and her husband attended therapy sessions to address her phobias and how they affected their marriage, and appeared to making strong progress.

However, one night at home the couple were confronted by two caskets. After being forced inside by Kai's clowns, the coffins were sealed shut, leaving Rosie and Mark to suffocate and die, only to be discovered several days later.

Pinpointing one's deepest and darkest fears, honing in on it, and exploiting it to such levels as this is exactly why Kai Anderson is one of American Horror Story's most terrifying villains. There are countless ways he could have killed Rosie and Mark, but he chose the way that would offer them the most amount of pain and suffering.


12. Flora - Murder House

American Horror Story Murder House Afterbirth
FX

Throughout Apocalypse, Michael Langdon played the main antagonist as one of the most powerful beings in the world, all but ending the known world. He breezed through the Seven Wonders like no one before him, and showed powers as befit his title as the Anti-Christ.

This wasn't his first appearance in the series however. As the spawn of Vivian Harmon and the ghost of Tate Langdon, Michael indirectly played a huge role in Murder House before he was even born.

After something of a struggle for who would raise the child, Michael was ultimately taken next door to be raised by Constance. The final scene of the entire season showed a flash forward to Michael as a toddler, and he had already developed a taste for murder.

When Constance returned home from the hair salon, she found a trail of blood from the kitchen up to Michael's room. As she followed it, the tension grew and grew until she saw the nanny, Flora, lying with her throat slit in a pool of her own blood. The creepiest part of the entire scene is Michael, happily smiling and laughing in his rocking chair like any other toddler, covered in the blood of the woman whose life he just took.


11. Serena Belinda - Cult

Serena Belinda American Horror Story
FX

There are deaths on this list that are shocking, others that are completely satisfying, and some that are so disgusting they are genuinely tough to watch. There is meaning behind a lot of these deaths, but Serena Belinda's demise in Cult is one of the most terrifying of all.

There was no strategy to her murder, no subtlety and absolutely no trying to hide it. This was Kai Anderson's affect on his followers in full swing, proving that he could make them do pretty much whatever he wanted, whenever he wanted them to.

As soon as Serena started her news piece at the Animal Adoption Jamboree, a clown could be seen slowly walking towards her, inching closer as she spoke to the camera. Before he reached her, he was joined by two more clowns, one of which drove a knife through her stomach without a care for the fact that it was broad daylight and there was literally a camera capturing everything.

Her cameraman was also ultimately slaughtered by the trio of clowns, as they were both stabbed repeatedly long after drawing their last breath. There is something even more terrifying when a villain shows such little regard for being caught.


10. Myrtle Snow - Coven

American Horror Story Apocalypse Myrtle
FX

Throughout its nine seasons, American Horror Story has introduced some incredible, wonderfully unique characters, but none quite so eccentric and bizarre as the Head of the Witches' Council, Myrtle Snow. Played by Frances Conroy throughout Coven and Apocalypse, Snow has actually died twice during the series, though both times she was ultimately brought back from the grave.

After accusing Fiona Goode of murdering Madison Montgomery and cutting out Spalding's tongue, the then Supreme framed Myrtle for attacking Cordelia, leading to her being burned at the stake. However, it was the second time the character was killed that became an iconic American Horror Story moment.

After being resurrected by Misty Day, Myrtle showed how ruthless she could be, by temporarily paralysing the council members who originally condemned her to death and scooping their eyes out with a melon baller.

Though she did this to give Cordelia her sight back, she still killed two members of the Witches' Council, so she made sure she suffered the consequences. At her own request, Myrtle was once again burned at the stake, this time yelling 'Balenciaga' as the flames engulfed her. Nothing else could have summed up her quirky nature quite like this.


9. Tristan Duffy - Hotel

American Horror Story Hotel Tristan
FX

There were more than a few raised eyebrows when American Horror Story cast Lady Gaga for its fifth season, Hotel, but the eccentric artist absolutely knocked her performance out of the park. She lent Elizabeth, a 112 year old vampire, the kind of glamour that few could have matched.

However, alongside the fashion style of the Countess was a truly terrifying ruthless streak, which she demonstrated on more than one occasion. Arguably the most memorable of these moments came with the demise of Tristan Duffy.

The model had arrived at the Hotel Cortez for a fashion show and soon found himself connected to the Countess. He also fell in love with Liz Taylor, causing complications to say the least. When the two asked if they could be together, Elizabeth saw this as betrayal, the one act she could not stand, and made sure they paid the price.

Mere seconds after telling Liz she could have Tristan, she slit the latter's throat, telling Denis O'Hare's character to bury him. The writers of Hotel, for a split second, tricked viewers into thinking Liz and Tristan would live happily ever after, before snatching it away in the most brutal way possible.


8. R.J. - Cult

American Horror Story Cult RJ
FX

This is the second entry on this list that proves what a heartless, sadistic, and straight up terrifying character Cult's Kai Anderson was. Even if you showed loyalty and obeyed every order without question, you still weren't safe from his wrath.

R.J., cameraman for Beverley Hope, signed up to Kai's cult when his colleague did, and from the moment he joined he was all in. He dressed up as a clown when asked, killed when told to kill, and asked no questions or showed no doubts or misgivings in the process.

However, Kai still saw R.J. as a weak link in the cult, and decided that he needed to go. Of course, this gave the organisation's ringleader the opportunity to test the loyalty of his other disciples, as he instructed them to all play a part in the murder of their colleague and friend.

Like Rosie and Mark, R.J.'s passing wasn't easy or painless, as the murderous clowns all took turns firing a nail from a nail gun into the character's skull. It was awfully tense and tough to watch, but in true American Horror Story style, fans couldn't take their eyes off it.


7. Frat Boy - Coven

American Horror Story Bitchcraft
FX

Shortly after Zoe arrived at Miss Robichaux's Academy, she was taken to a big college party by Madison Montgomery. Pretty much as soon as they arrived, the latter became the target of a group of frat boys whose intention it was to rape her.

Though Kyle was luckily there to stop it, it was still a haunting, traumatic experience for the young witch. As the boys sped away on their bus, Madison used her telekinetic powers to flip the vehicle, killing all but two of them.

Zoe visited the hospital in hopes that one of the survivors was Kyle, but when she found the ringleader of the rapists still alive, she decided to put her curse to good use. Zoe's Black Widow power caused fatal haemorrhages to anyhone she had sex with, so she climbed on top of the hospital bed and killed the man in the best way she knew how.

As she had sex with him, his eyes and nose started to pour blood, and he went into a seizure that ultimately took his life. This was a brutal way to die, but it was one of the most satisfying deaths in the history of the series.


6. Shelley - Asylum

American Horror Story Shelley
Fox

Throughout American Horror Story's second season, there was not one single character that didn't have some sort of traumatic experience while at Briarcliffe Manor. Even those who worked there found themselves either possessed or incarcerated, but few could claim to have had a worse experience than Shelley.

Admitted to the institution as a diagnosed nymphomaniac, Shelley quickly became a victim of the purely evil Dr. Arthur Arden and his reprehensible human experiments.

After finding Shelley trying to escape one night, Dr. Arden's solution to the problem was to amputate her legs at the knees. The Nazi's experiments didn't stop there, as he continued to work on the inmate, leaving her mutilated and unrecognisable by the time she was found.

Her torture ultimately came to an end when the Monsignor visited her in hospital and recognised her. Going against every instinct as a religious man, Timothy Howard took mercy on Shelley and strangled her to death. She was made to suffer at Briarcliffe, and was turned into a monster, leaving the Monsignor no choice but to end her life for her own sake, and with his own Rosary Beads no less.


5. Maggie Esmerelda - Freak Show

Maggie Esmerelda Death American Horror Story Freak Show
FX

Throughout her time on American Horror Story, Emma Roberts has brought several fantastic characters to life, the majority of which are far from virtuous. Madison Montgomery and Serena Belinda were certainly flawed, but arriving in Jupiter with the intention of killing and selling off the bodies of Elsa's freak show makes Maggie Esmerelda the worst of them all.

Even so, the character didn't deserve the death she was ultimately subjected to at the hands, and the saw, of Chester Creb. There are very few people who would.

While trying to get back in the troupe's good books, Maggie offered to be Chester's assistant in his magic act. The plan was for him to 'saw her in half', but after the magician hallucinated and saw Maggie as Lucy, Alice, and Marjorie, he trapped her, not allowing her to escape before the saw ripped through her stomach.

Maggie begged him to stop as he was hurling abuse at her, but he paid no mind, and cut clean through her. The reveal of Maggie's insides spilling to the floor while the delusional Chester tries to put her back together is one of the toughest to watch scenes in Freak Show, which is truly saying something.


4. Twisty - Freak Show

Twisty Jaw Clown American Horror Story
FX

Ever since his introduction to American Horror Story during Freak Show, Twisty the Clown has become one of the most iconic characters in the show's history. There is no one that can match him in terms of how simply creepy and terrifying he is, but his death showed a deeper, more surprising level to him.

The first few scenes in which Twisty appeared showed him as a ruthless murderer, hell bent on kidnapping children and keeping them in his van. Even before he actually did anything wrong, his appearance alone was enough to scare anyone watching.

When Edward Mordrake visited however, the Clown's tragic and heartbreaking past was revealed. Dropped on his head as a child, he was forced out of Jupiter by false rumours of child molestation, sending him into a spiral of desperation and depression, ultimately resulting in a failed suicide attempt that saw him blow his jaw off.

He genuinely never wished the children he took any harm, he just wanted to entertain them like he always did before. Mordrake was so moved by this story, he took Twisty's life and put him out of his misery, inviting him to join his troupe of the dead. This was a solemn and unexpected end to a character that had previously inspired so much dread.


3. Meep - Freak Show

Ben Woolf Meep American Horror Story
FX

Despite putting on shows and entertaining many people, Elsa Mars' Cabinet of Curiosities was mostly hated and persecuted in Jupiter. Labelled freaks, the likes of Jimmy, Bette and Dot could never find a place in the real world, save for with their chosen family within the troupe.

This hatred was demonstrated throughout season four, but never quite so terribly and heart-breakingly as when Meep was sent to prison. After Del framed the show's resident chicken head eater for the murder of a police officer, he was taken away. It was clear that this was dangerous, but the officers who took him away didn't care.

Being locked up in a cell filled with ruthless criminals resulted in the death of poor, innocent Meep. Though this took place off screen, knowing what happened and seeing how his body was dumped on the troupe's yard in such a disrespectful way made this one of the most emotionally charged deaths in the series.

It's almost made worse by not seeing it happen, as it forced audiences to imagine the worst case scenario of the horrors Meep had to endure before he died. This death broke not only Jimmy Darling, but everybody watching as well.


2. Ma Petite - Freak Show

Ma Petite Death American Horror Story Freak Show
FX

There were many troubled souls that found a home in Elsa Mars' Cabinet of Curiosities, and while a lot of them were far from virtuous, there haven't been many American Horror Story characters as innocent as Ma Petite.

The world's smallest human being was one of the first members of the Jupiter troupe of performers, after Elsa traded three cases of Dr. Pepper to keep her in America with her.

Naturally, she was the easiest target for Stanley and Maggie when they arrived looking for human oddities to sell off, and while Emma Roberts' character ultimately couldn't go through with killing Ma Petite, Dell Toldeo's conscious shared no such misgivings.

The travelling strongman agreed to kill the woman for Stanley, which he did by physically squeezing the life out of her. This was an awful way for such a sweet person to meet her end, and was easily one of the most heartbreaking deaths American Horror Story ever put on screen. Thankfully, Dell ultimately got his comeuppance, but this didn't help fans get over what he did any easier.


1. Violet Harmon - Murder House

Violet American Horror Story
FX

The first season of American Horror Story, named for the titular mansion that housed the Harmons and a handful of ghosts, certainly lived up to its name. There were some simply gruesome murders that took place throughout the story, with the likes of Flora's death shocking fans.

Violet Harmon's death however, was a cut above the rest. While other deaths were gory or tough to watch, Ben and Vivian's daughter's was one of the biggest twists of the entire series. No one, neither fans nor Violet herself knew that she had died until a whole four episodes after the fact.

In episode six, with the murder house and everything that came with it proving too much for her, Violet committed suicide in the bath tub. It seemed as though she was saved by Tate however, and she carried on living as normally as she had been, until in episode ten when she found herself unable to leave the house.

American Horror Story took a page out of the Sixth Sense's book, having Violet walk around as a ghost for four episodes without anybody knowing or realising. It was retroactively revealed that her suicide attempt had actually been successful, and that Tate had hidden her body in the basement so that no one would ever find it. Even after eight subsequent seasons, American Horror Story has never been able to match the shock, and brilliance of this moment.


Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.