15 Greatest American Horror Story Characters

Clowns, ghosts, witches, and more.

Twisty Jaw Clown American Horror Story
FX

Since its introduction in 2011, American Horror Story has grown to become nothing short of a TV phenomenon. Its incredible stories and unique way of bringing largely the same cast back together to tell them has seen its popularity skyrocket.

Initially, the key returning actors were Jessica Lange, Sarah Paulson, and Evan Peters, before the former said goodbye to the show and Paulson and Peters stepped away for 1984. This has allowed the likes of Finn Wittrock, Emma Roberts, and Billy Lourd to expand their character back catalogue.

Every returning actor gets to show off their range throughout American Horror Story, playing often incredibly differing characters, yet making them all feel as real as the last. Evan Peters even had to sit out season nine, because everything he was pouring into his characters was becoming too emotionally taxing for him.

After nine seasons at the time of writing, with more confirmed to be coming in the future, there are plenty of incredible AHS characters to choose from, but there are a certain handful that stand above the rest.

15. Benjamin Richter

Benjamin Richter was the infamous 'Mr. Jingles' at the beginning of American Horror Story: 1984, a man famed around the country for committing the massacre at Camp Redwood and taking his victims' ears as trophies. Only after being locked up for years in an insane asylum was it revealed that he was in fact innocent.

John Carroll Lynch has played many villains throughout the series, and while he is capable of cutting a very intimidating and creepy figure, there is usually something else behind it, some redeeming quality. In this case, the character was portrayed as a loving man, who was bullied and persecuted so harshly, that he ultimately became the monster he was pinned as to start with.

Richter's downward spiral hit rock bottom as he traveled L.A with Richard Ramirez, murdering people in the name of Satan. However, after returning to Camp Redwood, the man known as Mr Jingles was able to reconcile with his mother, and spend eternity with her and his infant brother as ghosts.


14. Mallory

American Horror Story Apocalypse Mallory
FX

Over the last three seasons of American Horror Story, Billie Lourd has established herself as one of the biggest assets the show can boast. Making her debut as Winter Anderson in Cult, she has since portrayed Mallory in Apocalypse, and Montana in 1984. The best of her characters so far is easily her second.

Mallory started season eight as the highly undervalued and disrespected PA for Coco St. Pierre Vanderbilt. Despite the humiliation suffered, this allowed her a ticket into Outpost 3 after the apocalypse occurred, exactly as Cordelia Foxx planned. Mallory was in fact, one of the most powerful witches in the world.

Something of a magical prodigy, the future Supreme of the coven had the ability to perform the tempus infinitum spell, something that allowed her to ultimately go back in time and kill Michael Langdon, retroactively stopping the end of the world before it ever happened.

Such was the power and potential of Mallory that Cordelia, one of the most powerful witches in the world, put her faith in her protégé, and gave her life to allow Mallory's powers to reach their full potential.


13. Myrtle Snow

American Horror Story Apocalypse Myrtle
FX

There is absolutely no shortage of incredible, powerful characters in season three's titular coven of witches. While we will get to many of them later in this list, possibly the most entertaining of the group is Frances Conroy's Myrtle Snow.

The fashion obsessed, incredibly eccentric witch was the head of the Witches' Council and acted as something of a mother figure to Cordelia Foxx in the absence of a good role model. On more than one occasion Myrtle has given her life for the good of the coven, and despite the comedic aspect she brings to the table, has shown herself to be absolutely ruthless when she needs to be.

With Cordelia blinded, Myrtle used a melon baller to take the eyes from two of her colleagues on the council who voted for her to be burnt at the stake. Ironically, for this act, Myrtle demanded Cordelia burn her at the stake. Again.

It's fair to say that the coven would have been much worse off if it hadn't been for the help and guidance of Myrtle Snow.


12. Twisty

American Horror Story Twisty
FX

American Horror Story is loaded with the macabre, the creepy, and the downright weird, from settings, stories, and of course, characters. There are none so creepy however, as one of the greatest aspects from Freak Show, Twisty the Clown.

After spending the first few episodes killing people, kidnapping children and tormenting them in a dilapidated caravan, the audience has no reason to think Twisty is anything more than a demented murderer. Soon after however, we're shown that there is so much more to the character than that.

Yes, he is a ridiculously creepy murderous clown, but his is a story filled with tragedy. Left mentally disabled from being dropped on his head as a baby, he became a clown to put smiles on children's faces. When some other freaks in the circus became jealous, they spread the rumour that Twisty was a child molester. Unable to continue being a clown, he began a spiral into depression and further mental health issues.

After trying to take his own life, Twisty ended up surviving a shotgun blast to the face, but lost his entire jaw. Genuinely not seeing that he was doing anything wrong, he wanted to 'save' the children from their parents and make them love him again.

There are few characters in the show as iconic as Twisty, and John Carroll Lynch should receive any and all praise for bringing him to life.


11. James March

American Horror Story Hotel James Patrick March
FX

Evan Peters, with the exception of 1984, has been ever present throughout American Horror Story. The actor has shown his incredible range and what he is capable of on screen, with one of the most unique characters he has brought to life being James Patrick March.

From playing young and reckless, usually naive characters in the show, Peters jumped into the role of March, the murderous former owner and designer of the Hotel Cortez straight out of the roaring 20's. Based on the real life murderer H.H Holmes, the character used his giant maze of a building to feed his lust for murder.

Despite his more than questionable hobbies and the company he kept, Evan Peters made James March incredibly charismatic and strangely likeable. He is completely unique in the world of American Horror Story, which is quite something given the sheer amount of characters the show has produced.

James March was terrifying enough when he was alive, yet somehow he became far worse after he died.


10. Lana Winters

American Horror Story Asylum Lana Winters
FX

Like Evan Peters, Sarah Paulson has appeared in every season of American Horror Story to date, with the exception of 1984. Though she grew to become one of the biggest names in the show, it didn't start out this way. After playing a supporting role in Murder House, appearing in just three episodes, her first lead role came as Lana Winters in Asylum.

Lana deceived her way into Briarcliff, with the intention of exposing the horrific experiments taking place behind the scenes. The reporter however, found herself in too deep, as she became a patient/inmate of the institute, and just when escape was seemingly on the horizon, she was taken to a place far worse.

There are few characters who have as tragic a story as that of Lana Winters. From having to keep her love life a secret to avoid public persecution, to the horrific ordeal she is put through, including being held hostage by a psychopathic serial killer and seeing the corpse of her girlfriend with her own two eyes, she refused to give in or be intimidated.

Lana is a strong, bad ass character, and the excitement surrounding her return in Roanoke was more than justified.


9. Madison Montgomery

Emma Roberts Emmys American Horror Story Coven 600x300
FX

Madison Montgomery is a complicated character, to say the very least. She is something of American Horror Story's answer to an anti-hero, in that she has helped the coven out on numerous occasions, but usually only if it coincided with her own self interests.

The former movie star is often played as selfish, egotistical, and bratty, but she has been through an unfair amount of tragedy in her life, from being raped at a party to being murdered by Fiona, and a more than unpleasant stay in hell.

Personality traits, petty squabbles, and power struggles aside, Madison has proved herself to be nothing short of an incredibly powerful witch. At one stage she was even thought to be the next Supreme, though this was ultimately not the case. As strong as she was in her first appearance however, it's fair to say that between Coven and Apocalypse, Madison became more well rounded as a witch, and certainly more worthy of Cordelia's trust.

Though she never rose to the rank of Supreme, she was instrumental in taking down Michael Langdon and earning a big win for the coven.


8. Michael Langdon

MICHAEL LANGDON AHS
FX

After much of Murder House was built around the birth of the anti-Christ, Michael Langdon returned in Apocalypse ready to bring the world to its knees. An appearance that was seven years in the making, there was obviously a lot hype surrounding Cody Fern's American Horror Story debut, and it did not disappoint.

It would have been easy to make Michael a ridiculously overpowered warlock hell bent on world domination. While it seemed this way at first, Apocalypse took a deeper look into Tate Langdon and Vivien Harmon's son, and the struggles he found himself facing, woefully unprepared to lead his fanatics into war.

With such pressure for great things on his shoulders as the anti-Christ, Michael found himself unsure of his path, what to do next, and how to live up to everything that was expected of him. Like Madison, he was a complicated character, and while he did become an immensely powerful being, he certainly wasn't gifted it.

Eventually Michael cut a powerful, intimidating figure, and it took the strongest witches and warlocks in the world to the very limits of their power to bring him down.


7. Tate Langdon

Tate Langdon AHS
FX

There wouldn't be an anti-Christ, or an Apocalypse at all if not for Evan Peters' first ever character in American Horror Story, and easily the MVP of Murder House, Tate Langdon. There are few souls as demented, cursed, or broken as that of Tate.

After going on a killing spree through his high school, ending the life of ... people, the teenager was gunned down by police in his bedroom, forcing him to live on forever as a ghost, unable to ever leave the titular house. This would be just the beginning of his suffering.

When Violet moved in, Tate found someone he could connect to more than ever in his young life, and not being able to be with her properly tore him apart.

Though a mass murderer, a part of Tate genuinely thought he was doing something noble for those he killed, allowing them to be free of the horrors of the world. Deep down, Tate is a mess of confusion and fear, that with no true role model or outlet, turned into anger and rage.


6. Dandy Mott

American Horror Story Dandy Mott
FX

Though Twisty the Clown was one the most terrifying antagonists in all of American Horror Story, he wasn't the big bad of Freak Show. That title belongs to Dandy Mott, the character portrayed by Finn Wittrock in his series debut.

Dandy was not a complex villain like Twisty, nor was he tragically misunderstood or wrongfully persecuted. No, instead, Dandy was simply a spoiled brat who had grown up never hearing the word 'no' from his mother, expecting the rest of the world to treat him the same way. Before Freak Show, he had never met a problem he couldn't solve with either money, or a tantrum.

The despicable villain is one of the most hated characters in the history of the show, something that as an antagonist is a credit to Wittrock’s performance. Particularly when you consider he is still able to stand out as a strong villain amongst the likes of Twisty, Dell Toledo, Stanley, and Maggie.

After Twisty's death, it is Dandy that continues his legacy, finding a haunting purpose in torturing the children, blissfully unaware of the true motivation behind the clown's actions. That just sums the villain up a nutshell - completely unaware of everything but his own self-interest.


5. Delphine LaLaurie

American Horror Story Delphine Lalaurie 2
FX

There are vile, hated characters throughout American Horror Story like Michael and Tate Langdon, Bloody Face, and Dandy Mott, but Delphine LaLaurie is not your average villain. Coming from a different time in history, the New Orleans socialite was ruthless, pompous, egotistical, and racist.

There was not a good bone in her body as she was brought to life by Kathy Bates expertly, creating a hateful antagonist beyond any kind of empathy or redemption. It is no surprise she was brought back for four out of the next six seasons.

There are so many dimensions to LaLaurie's arc throughout Coven, the best of which is her dynamic with Queenie. Despite her intolerable views, Queenie still believes she can help Delphine see the error of her ways, and for a while it feels like she may. Ultimately however, she stays the heinous villain she is.

Incredibly, even with a character such as this, the show is still able to bring a certain aspect of comedy to the table. The majority of this comes from the woman out of time angle. From seeing how the world has changed to thinking an antihistamine is a magic potion, Delphine LaLaurie is a surprisingly well-rounded, albeit repulsive character.


4. Sister Jude

Sister Jude American Horror Story Asylum
FX

There is a good reason why Jessica Lange was one of the most important aspects of the earlier seasons of American Horror Story. After portraying Constance Langdon in Murder House, a character that just missed out on her own entry on this list, she played the strict and severe head nun at Briarcliff, Sister Jude.

Constantly battling the demons of her past, Jude throws herself into her work at the institute, handling any obstacle that she comes face to face with, from undercover reporters to power struggles with Dr. Arden. Though this is how she began season two, it is certainly not how she ended it.

There are very few characters, if any at all, that have gone through such a transition as Sister Jude. Her spectacular fall from grace saw her relegated to an inmate at Briarcliff where she ultimately lost her mind. Eventually Jude was saved by Kit, the man she once imprisoned, and became something of a grandmother figure to his children.

It takes a very talented actor to make an audience feel such hatred toward a character, before being filled with utter sorrow and sympathy by the end.


3. The Countess

Lady Gaga Blood Vampire American Horror Story Hotel
FX

While some may have doubted Lady Gaga's foray into the American Horror Story universe, her role as the fashionable and frightening Countess in Hotel didn't disappoint. The owner of the Hotel Cortez, Elizabeth lived over a century due to an ancient blood curse, and used the hotel to cover her vampirism and house her 'blood relatives' - children she stole and infected.

A complex and emotional character hidden beneath a cold and masterful presence, The Countess has known heartbreak in her past, which has helped shaped her outlook on her own life and future. Despite her confidence and the gravitas she brings to every interaction she has, she is in truth a scarred and insecure character.

To the astonishment of some, Lady Gaga absolutely knocked her portrayal of Elizabeth out of the park. She managed to steal every single scene she was in as the unquestioned MVP of the show's fifth season, and Lady Gaga's Golden Globe from 2016 is simply a testament to her performance in Hotel.


2. Kai Anderson

American Horror Story Election Ending
FX

Of all the different stories and seasons within American Horror Story, Cult is quite possibly the scariest. Despite being much more grounded, without ghosts, witches, or vampires, the fear factor for season seven comes from how real it seems. While watching it you can't help but think this could really happen, and one of the most terrifying aspects of it all is Kai Anderson.

Kai isn't immortal like many of the American Horror Story villains, nor is he imbued with supernatural powers. Instead, he adapts to the situation around him, and manipulates his way to positions of power using only his brain and his words.

He is so self-sure of everything he is doing, and so charismatic, it is far too easy for people like Harrison and Ivy to fall in line and follow him to the ends of the earth. Even once inside prison he manages to build a brand new following from the ground up.

Kai Anderson, one of the most dangerous characters in all of American Horror Story, managed to work his way to a position of power, and could have gone even further if not for Beverly turning against him, shooting him in the head.


1. Cordelia Foxx

Cordelia American Horror Story Coven
FX

Of all the incredible, powerful, and down right bad ass characters in all of American Horror Story, none can match Cordelia Foxx. As the daughter of Fiona Goode, the witch was at an immediate disadvantage growing up, but still pushed through adversity, betrayal, and the seven wonders to become one of the most powerful characters in the show.

When we are first introduced to Cordelia in Coven she is not the Supreme, but since her mother is such a poor leader, she has to step up and take charge of the group more often than not anyway.

She is willing to make incredible sacrifices in order to maintain her gift, as evidenced by taking her own eyeballs out with garden sheers! Yet as she grows in power, and ultimately becomes the Supreme, she never loses sight of what is important, and still treats every member of her coven like a daughter. Even Madison.

By the time Apocalypse rolled around, the tender, loving Cordelia, while still that same person, is a force to be reckoned with. Leading her girls into battle against Michael Langdon, and standing up to the warlocks who insist on allowing the anti-Christ to take the seven wonders test, there is no one better suited to be Supreme.

Ultimately, her unselfishness and willingness to sacrifice herself for the good of the coven cement her legacy as the greatest character the show has ever produced.


Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.