18 Best TV Episodes Of 2017 (So Far)

Gotta light?

Best TV Episodes 2017
AMC/Showtime/FX/Starz

We're only halfway through 2017, and already trying to keep up with the sheer amount of TV on offer has been a breathless exercise.

The sheer number of shows on offer in the Peak TV is staggering, with serious pros and cons: it means there is, during any given week, likely to be at least one excellent TV series available for you to watch; it also means that, during any given week, there's likely to be at least one excellent TV series you cannot possibly get around to watching.

That in turn makes it harder for individual episodes to shine through. Prestige TV is wrapped up in season-long narratives where the pieces of the puzzle are deliberately withheld, meaning it only fits as part of a whole. Binge-watching, whether it's on Netflix or just an attempt to catch-up on an already finished show, means that instalments blur together faster than you can click 'play next episode'.

It results in some series that, even while having a strong run, might not have a particular standout episode (see: House of Cards, A Series of Unfortunate Events), and of course a few blind spots too (for me, this year, it's Big Little Lies and The Americans). However, it also means that when a specific episode does rise above the noise, it's offering something really great.


18. Hooli-Con - Silicon Valley

Silicon Valley Hooli-Con
HBO

From a narrative point-of-view, Silicon Valley's fourth season wasn't quite as strong as previous ones, with too much repetition of the 'one step forward, two steps back' device. It's a good job, then, that it did at least remain one of the funniest shows on TV, and while the season wasn't as tight as normal, it all came together in the penultimate episode, Hooli-Con.

Taking its name from the convention it's set at, it also serves as a reference to the plot, as Richard plans to piggyback on the Hooli app. One of the reasons this episode is so great is the turning point it marks for Richard and the show: he's no longer the unlucky good guy, but instead begins a dark descent - breaking bad, if you will.

That downfall drives the episode's plot and gives it a sense of excitement, but it's mined superbly for laughs too. Dinesh and Gilfoyle are their excellent sniping selves - and the way the camera focuses on Dinesh when he visits Mia, and learns how dangerous she is, is some great direction - but the real MVP, as he was all season, is Jared.

Zach Woods has long been superb, but this instalment is the best showcase of his comic talents, in particular once he starts to break down at the end. His well natured empathy and attempt to maintain a sense of control lead to some priceless reactions, all culminating in him blowing up in a fit of rage, before the surprising turn of events at the end, with things blowing up again in a rather different sense.


17. Riddle Of The Sphinx - Inside No. 9

Inside No 9 Riddle Of The Sphinx
BBC

Over the course of three series Inside No. 9 - which comes from the dark minds of League of Gentlemen's Steve Pemberton and Reese Shearsmith - has established itself as one of the smartest, most inventive (and criminally under-watched) shows on television.

It really got to show off its genius in Riddle of the Sphinx, a gothic episode played less for comedy than it was a puzzle to be solved. Set in Cambridge, Nina - a young woman - seeks help solving a crossword from the professor who writes them.

It starts off with him teaching her how to solve cryptic clues, before gradually turning into something much deeper and darker. The entire episode was effectively turned into one puzzle, and viewers could only watch along as it was figured out in front of them, desperately scrabbling to pick up the same clues as the characters.

Even at just 30 minutes long it manages to be a complex maze of twists and turns, with numerous hints hidden throughout. It's expertly constructed by Shearsmith and Pemberton, and a dazzlingly clever, complex episode of television.


16. Lian Yu - Arrow

Arrow Deathstroke Oliver
The CW

Arrow Season 5 wasn't the show back to its very best, but it massively improved on the past two years and, in a season all about legacy, got back to doing the basics very well.

That theme, with the battle between Oliver and Prometheus, came to a head in the breathtaking season finale. Arrow almost always nails its final episode of any given year, and this was no exception.

Fittingly, it takes us back to Lian Yu, to end things where it all began. To combat Prometheus' team, which includes Talia al Ghul, Black Siren, and Artemis, Oliver assembles his own: Deathstroke, Nyssa, Malcolm Merlyn, and Captain Boomerang, who together attempt to defeat Adrian Chase and rescue Ollie's friends and family.

It's a thrilling episode, one rich in both the action stakes and character dynamics; everyone gets a moment to shine, with some - such as the storyline with Thea and Malcolm - proving surprisingly touching, and others - like the reunion of Oliver and Slade - just incredibly exciting to watch, with great chemistry exhibited once again by the pair.

The action expertly builds to its dramatic climax, one which wraps a bow on the last five years of the show, and makes the future of the series a lot more exciting than a year before.


15. World Enough And Time - Doctor Who

Doctor Who World Enough And Time
BBC

Series 10 represented the end-of-an-era for Doctor Who: it was the last series with Steven Moffat in charge, and the final run for Peter Capaldi's Twelfth Doctor too. Luckily they managed to bow out on a high note (Christmas Special pending). The finale itself was excellent, but the setup to that was one of the real highpoints of Capaldi's tenure, rivalling the epic Heaven Sent.

It's a bit of a shame that the big returns of this series - the Mondasian Cybermen and, even bigger, John Simm's Master - were revealed ahead of time, but their respective arrivals in this episode still managed to offer up the sort of spectacle worthy of closing out the season.

Trapped on a giant spaceship, we have the delight of Missy trying to play the hero, but it's not long before the darkness encroaches. The episode has everything you could want from Who, an emotional rollercoaster with plenty of shocks, twists, and tinged with jet black humour, it manages to be, at turns, touching, funny, surprising, creepy, and outright horrifying.

Moffat's script is clever - but not too clever for his own good - and the direction of Rachel Talalay is superb (she has really become one of the series' biggest strengths); perfectly paced and gorgeously shot, with some shocking big moments and delightful smaller ones.


14. On The Road - Preacher

Preacher Jesse On The Road
AMC

Preacher's first season (which was mostly good, but had a fair few stumbles) spent all 10 episodes in its small Texas town, a departure from the comics. With Season 2, they're back on track, as the show finally becomes the American road trip fans of the graphic novels know and love.

The premiere, fittingly titled On The Road, does a wonderful job of setting the tone for the rest of the season (which holds up in the following couple of episodes, and hopefully the whole thing).

It's a riotous affair, full of madcap humour, insane violence and gore, and some brilliant character interaction between its three leads. Jesse, Cassidy, and Tulip, after a season of getting to know each other, are even more dynamic this time around, and following the three of them is one hell of a crazy ride.

The juxtaposition of tone helps keep the episode surprising: we kick things off with an incredibly joyride from the police, soundtracked to Come On Eileen; by the end of the instalment, there's a serious Terminator vibe as Jesse and co are stalked by the terrifying villain Saint Of Killers.

It mines its source material for twisted laughs and serious shocks alike, making for an episode that's packed with fun, action, and suspense, and showcases just how great Preacher could well be in Season 2.


13. Kimmy Is A Feminist - Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt

Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Kimmy Is A Feminist
Netflix

The third season of Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt isn't quite as great as the first two, lacking a little in focus, but it more than makes up for it as the show confirms it is the biggest, funniest gatling gun-type sitcom on TV, firing of jokes of every conceivable kind in rapid succession. Its sixth episode, Kimmy Is A Feminist, is the best example of that.

The episode is, admittedly, slightly messy in its attempted commentary on feminism, but that doesn't detract too much from the episode as a whole, which manages to be absurdly funny while also advancing Kimmy's character too.

Kimmy goes to her first college party, where she's approached by a boy offering her a sexual consent form, but it's the comedy in how out-of-place Kimmy is that is great here. She's not a college kid, but because of her time in the bunker she's not fully a part of the adult world either, and this is the episode where she really discovers she's somewhere between the two, in a fashion that is hilarious (when told to 'ghost' Perry, she responds with "Whoooo … get out of my amusement park!”) but also speaks to the poignancy of the character.

The other main strand of the episode is pure laugh-out-loud hilarity, as Jacqueline and Titus work together to stop her from sleeping with Russ' brother. The pair bounce off each other brilliantly, with Titus' attempts at playing a straight man especially a weird joy to watch, and it results in a pure comic farce.


12. Can Josh Take A Leap Of Faith? - Crazy Ex-Girlfriend

Crazy Ex Girlfriend Rebecca Josh
The CW

Crazy Ex-Girlfriend enjoyed a superlative second season, which across its first 12 episodes was funny, tragic, weird, uncomfortable, and brave. It took that mix and throw it all - and then some - into its Season 2 finale, which thankfully didn't attempt to tie too much up, despite the uncertainty of a renewal.

Ending on a wedding, the final hour goes to the places you might expect - and then keeps on going. It's a sublimely crafted instalment of the series, chock-full of surprises, and it'll have you laughing and cringing in equal measure.

There are, of course, some brilliant songs in there, but they only stand to complement the daring and shocking narrative twists and turns the episode manages to navigate. As both Rebecca and Josh search for their true feelings, it becomes at times deeply moving, at others unsettling, and towards the end it becomes really intense.

It manages to pack a ridiculous amount in - the wedding, Trent, White Josh and Darryl, Josh's revelation, the past, present, and future of the show - without ever feeling overstuffed or rushed. Instead it's all perfectly balanced, delivering a funny, touching episode that is the deserved ending to Season 2, and makes Season 3 an absolute necessity.


11. Live Studio Audience - GLOW

GLOW Live Studio Audience
Netflix

GLOW is a weird and wonderful take on the world of women's wrestling, and it's in one of its most wrestling-heavy episodes that everything just perfectly clicks together.

Live Studio Audience sees the ladies putting on their first ever show, which, predictably, doesn't go without a few hiccups. The series has a real strength for finding both comedy and drama in and out of the wrestling ring, and all of that is present here.

Sam is hilarious after his camera gets stolen, but there's also genuine emotion to be found as Carmen - the most purely good character on the show - struggles with her stage-fright, and then by the end and the return of Rhonda's rap, there's a real sense of triumph and empowerment for this group of women.

It has some extremely odd moments, such as a racially-charged tag-team match, that it nonetheless manages to work into the narrative and carry off as a joke and social commentary, while any episode with a very 80s style training montage - soundtracked to Dare by Stan Bush - is a sure-fire winner.


10. The Law Of Non-Contradiction - Fargo

Fargo The Law Of Non-Contradiction
FX

Fargo Season 3 got off to a bit of a slow start, which is often the show's nature, but this year felt slightly stale: like we'd seen it all before. Episode 3 was a much needed shake-up of the typical formula, with the action leaving the fictional town and heading out to Los Angeles.

It was a surprisingly welcome departure, even if the episode was technically a narrative cul-de-sac. We know that it's not actually going to go anywhere, because we have information that Carrie Coon's Gloria doesn't, yet somehow that doesn't have any negative impact on the episode, and it still manages to feel fresh and interesting.

The story can be broken up into three distinct sections, and each are wonderfully put together: there's Coon's investigation into her step-father's murder, and as ever she provides such a believable, human link to the story, and in the end her efforts may not be rewarded, but she takes more conviction to carry on; a great slice of noir-style work focused on the movie industry and the kind of people who inhabit it; and a bizarre-but-gorgeous animated sequence of one of Gloria's step-father's stories, a bold decision that pays off in how delightfully entertaining and whacky it is.

It's got all the mystery and violence you want from Fargo, but succeeds in putting them in a rather different package, and finds some heart at its core too.


9. Thanksgiving - Master Of None

Master Of None Thanksgiving
Netflix

After a very good first season, Master of None moved things up a gear in Season 2, delivering a gorgeous, heartfelt comedy that served as a commentary on everything from race to dating to food. It had a few great episodes, but just about standing out as the best was its Thanksgiving instalment.

Taking place over numerous Thanksgivings from the 90s to present day, it highlights Dev's friendship with Denise, and her trying to come out to her family. We see her realisation as a 12-year-old that she is a lesbian, then coming out (as "Lebanese") to Dev a few years later, right through telling her mother and bringing dates to Thanksgiving (though she has to pretend otherwise).

It's a really quite beautiful story, as the narrative function allows Denise's journey and struggles with her identity and family to really develop and change over the years, something not often afforded to most coming out stories on TV. It still manages to find a lot of laughs in the episode, largely through the extended family, while the central duo of Lena Waithe (Denise) and the powerhouse that is Angela Bassett (her mother Catherine) deliver a much more complex range of emotions around the subject.

It's aided by some dreamy direction and a brilliantly sharp script, giving us one of the year's most heartfelt and downright lovely TV episodes that has authenticity, humanity, humour, and drama.


8. Michael's Gambit - The Good Place

The Good Place
NBC

The Good Place was indeed good right from the off, but it became *great* in its final few episodes, and in particular its season finale.

It's an episode difficult to talk about without spoilers, but the way its constructed makes for a half-hour that is an absolute joy to watch from start to finish. It builds on various threads from throughout the season, piecing together various clues that you may or may not have picked up on, and layers them all together to create a stunningly clever sequence of events that will leave your face a lot like Kristen Bell's in the image above.

The whole cast is on fire in this episode, after a season after gelling together, but what Ted Danson does with his character is particularly surprising and brilliant. There's some incredible chemistry at work here, and the comic timing is perfect. Many shows fail at making a more high-concept sitcom work, but The Good Place always manages to balance that with its character moments, something wholly evident in Michael's Gambit.

It brilliantly caps off Season 1, will have you laughing out loud and genuinely stunned, and you'll be desperate for more immediately.


7. Episode 6 - Catastrophe

Catastrophe Sharon Horgan
Channel 4

With its third season, Catastrophe once again moved up a notch in terms of quality, and positioned itself as arguably the best sitcom on TV - and one of the most hard-hitting.

All that was evident in the Season 3 finale, which took the strands of the season-long arc of Rob's alcoholism to a brutal, harrowing endpoint. It's a moment where it really leaves the comedy behind, instead finding a whole lot of pathos in the storyline.

The relationship between Rob and Sharon is one of TV's best, and it's so beautifully brought together in this episode, which does so many other things right too. The scenes at the funeral are hilarious, and there's a great, wonderfully funny and sharp performance from Carrie Fisher in one of her final on-screen appearances.

It's a superb encapsulation of the show's strengths: its ability to gross you out, the portrayal of a very real, adult relationship with all the warmth and fallouts they contain, to choke you up, and make you laugh and cry in equal measure.


6. Chapter 7 - Legion

Legion Lenny
FX

Until Twin Peaks: The Return rolled around, Noah Hawley's Legion had a strong claim to being the weirdest TV series of the year. A dizzying portrayal of David Haller, superpowers, and mental illness, it rarely made much sense, and didn't always engage viewers.

Chapter 7, though, took everyone that made Legion so great and hurled it at the viewer in a mesh of kaleidoscopic visuals, mutant powers, and silent horror movie homages.

It's here Legion proves it's a really unique beast: we get two versions of David interacting, with a knockout performance from Dan Stevens; a sprinkle of genuine humour from the interactions between Cary and Oliver; a glorious animated sequence that answers some big questions and connects the series firmly to the comics that inspired it; and that black-and-white sequence, set to Bolero and featuring title cards, is one of the most thrilling, terrifying of the year (confirming Aubrey Plaza as its not-so-secret MVP).

There was a big question over where Legion was headed: Chapter 7 not only gave us some satisfactory answers, but did so in the kind of mind-bending style it quickly became known for, and without losing sense of the characters and performances at its heart.


5. Git Gone - American Gods

American Gods Git Gone Laura Moon
Starz

American Gods, Bryan Fuller's lush adaptation of Neil Gaiman's epic novel, looked great in its opening episodes, but it was a bit of a dizzying mess. That's not to say it was bad, but it needed something to ground viewers as the worlds of old Gods and new started colliding.

Enter Laura Moon. The deceased wife of Shadow doesn't feature too prominently in the book, popping up now-and-then, and the biggest and best change Fuller and co-creator Michael Green made to the source material is expanding her role. Shadow is the narrative anchor, albeit one often as confused as we are, but with Git Gone Emily Browning's Laura becomes our emotional tether to the show.

Instead of progressing the story, we instead get to see how her and Shadow met - she worked at a casino he gambled in - and fell in love. Shadow is very much a Neil Gaiman figure, whereas Laura Moon, at least in the way she's adapted, fits more to Fuller's style, and that's clearly to her strength. Git Gone serves as a wonderful character piece, making you care more for both Laura and Shadow, as well as one that is still disturbing, and extremely funny (the bathroom scene with Laura and Audrey is one of the season's most hilarious).

It's the kind of human element that American Gods needed, and does wonders for Laura, Shadow, and the show as a whole.


4. Late - The Handmaid's Tale

The Handmaid's Tale Late Ofglen Alexis Bledel
Hulu

Despite being an adaptation of a novel from 1985, Hulu's take on Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale managed to feel painfully relevant in 2017, and in the process delivered arguably the best brand new series of the year thus far.

While it was pretty faithful to the source material, the TV format offered the chance to expand the scope beyond Offred's point-of-view, and in Late that was used to an horrific end.

Elisabeth Moss shines, as she does throughout its first season, in an agonising hour of television. In flashback form, we get to witness the take over of the United States by Gilead, which happens not with one big bang but in a much quieter and scarier way. In the present, Offred is punished for the 'crime' of not being pregnant. Moss is able to convey so much with just her face, and she does a great job of selling the confusion and then fear of her character, while Yvonne Strahovsk rises to the challenge of channeling a far more menacing side to Serena Joy.

The star of the episode, though, is Alexis Bledel. Not known for giving much range beyond a variation on Rory Gilmore, she excels here in a wordless performance, as unspeakable acts are committed against her. The final moments in particular are among the most technically brilliant, memorable, and downright awful of the year, the sort that will haunt you long past the credits, and one hell of an artistic achievement from Bledel, writer Bruce Miller, and director Reed Morano.


3. Chicanery - Better Call Saul

Better Call Saul Jimmy McGill Chuck Chicanery
AMC

Better Call Saul's third season was its best yet, one that should eviscerate any lingering doubts (not that there should be any) about its place in the Breaking Bad universe. It's centrepiece was episode 5, Chicanery - the series' best yet.

Although the show revolves around two lawyers, it focuses so much on their rivalry - not to mention Jimmy's trickier ways - that this marks the first time it has truly gone into full blown courtroom drama territory, and it utterly nails it.

It's a tense, slow-burning delight to watch this drama methodically unfold, going back-and-forth as Jimmy and Chuck go head-to-head in a battle of brotherly wits, each thinking themselves the likely victor. The true genius of the episode, and the show, is that there is no real winner, and by the time we get the big reveals its a heartwrenching, sombre moment of tragedy for all involved.

With taught direction from Daniel Sackheim you spend almost the entire episode right there in the stifling courtroom, completely gripped even with a lack of action, and it as - as ever - one of the most well shot series on TV. Bob Odenkirk and Michael McKean somehow manage to reach new levels with their respective performances here. McKean in particular is astonishing, bringing so much nuance to Chuck's illness and villainy, with shocking results. The heart of Better Call Saul is the relationship between Jimmy and Chuck, and Chicanery takes a knife straight to it.


2. The Book Of Nora - The Leftovers

The Leftovers Book Of Nora
HBO

The third run of The Leftovers is one of the most powerful and gorgeous seasons of television in recent memory, and it's all perfectly capped off by The Book of Nora, which is its strongest episode (though The Most Powerful Man In The World... ran it very close) and one of the series' very best.

The final season is all about bringing closure, so much so that by the time we reach the finale it doesn't even need to feature most of the characters. It's a stunning achievement - and testament to the work of Damon Lindelof, Tom Perrotta et al - that the final episode can focus almost solely on Nora - introduced as a supporting character - and be so captivating.

After a brief moment at the start between her and Matt, Carrie Coon is largely left to, er, carry the episode. She's done great work on two TV shows this year, but this is her masterpiece, making you feel absolutely everything the character is experiencing. It is, of course, beautifully directed by the great Mimi Leder, especially in its closing moments.

Anyone searching for too many answers should've learned better by this point. Instead what we get is a mediation on life, loss, and ultimately love, with those moments between Kevin and Nora a standout, giving this unique series a touching, satisfying, and incredibly human send-off.


1. Part 8 - Twin Peaks: The Return

Twin Peaks The Return Woodsman
Showtime

At the TCA back in January, Showtime president David Nevin promised us one thing about the new season of Twin Peaks: "It's the pure heroin version of David Lynch." Given what's aired so far, it's almost certain he had Part 8 in mind when he made that claim.

How do you even begin describing this episode? With Twin Peaks: The Return, Lynch has shown zero interest in playing by the TV rulebook; in this episode, though, he tears it up completely and, after asking for a light, sets fire to it.

The 'normal' part of the episode is the creepy opening with BadCoop and the terrifying creatures who come to claim him, so dark you can hardly make out what's going on at times, the viewer left deliberately disturbed and confused.

From there we're plunged into the darkest recesses of Lynch's mind, as his obsession with 50s America takes us right back to its origin: the atomic bomb. The sequence itself could be stock footage (it's CGI), and the rest of the episode is the kind of imagery that will haunt you long past the season's end.

With gorgeous black-and-white cinematography and all manner of freakish characters, it's a visually and sonically dizzying tale of horror that largely stands alone, yet may actually have given some big answers about the series' mythology. It's the most ambitious, avant garde TV episode of at least the year, and perhaps of all time; hauntingly beautiful and entirely unforgettable. Gotta light?

What do you think is the best TV episode of the year so far? Let us know down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.