20 Best Buffy The Vampire Slayer Episodes

11. Potential

Sometimes you get the feeling that the writers didn't quite know what to do with Dawn after they were finished with the Key storyline. Now that she's not the object of some awful Hell God to track down and steal, she's pretty much just a typical teenage girl. And that's exactly what this episode tries to come to terms with. There's a spell that they can use to track down potential Slayers, and for a brief shining moment they think that Dawn could be one of them. It would make sense, wouldn't it? She does have the Slayer's blood, after all. With their group of friends (a Slayer, witches, vampires), being normal has to feel pretty bad sometimes. This episode also has one of Xander's greatest moments, when he gets a chance to shine with a speech to Dawn about how special she is as a person, even if she isn't blessed with supernatural powers.

10. Passion

This episode represents the point of no return for Angel. Throughout the second season after Angel loses his soul, there's always this lingering feeling that maybe somehow they'll be able to fix it and bring the nice, defanged version of his character back. That ends here. Jenny Calender, computer teacher/Romani witch, is trying to translate a spell that will restore Angel's soul and as you might imagine, he doesn't take kindly to that. Joss Whedon made a really significant decision in this episode that when Angel kills her, he just snaps her neck and doesn't even drink from her, which hammers home the fact that this is a murder rather than an animalistic killing. And then when he takes her body to Giles's house, setting up an intricately romantic scene only to have Giles discover her body...well, there aren't a whole lot of characters on the show who are more stone cold evil than that. Passion is a darkly brilliant episode from a time when the show was really firing on all cylinders.

9. Helpless

Helpless is one of those episodes that manages to tell a story on two different levels: both the supernatural world that the show normally inhabits, and the real-life issue that it represents. In this instance, it's about Buffy being tested by the Watcher's Council to see if she can function as the Slayer without her powers, but it's also the commentary on the nature of consent and how it ties into the perception of identity. Buffy has something that's very important to who she is taken away from her by a person that she trusts, and she feels not only helpless, as the episode's title suggests, but utterly betrayed. The fact that Giles, who is the only father figure in Buffy's life that matters, is the one who has to stab her in the back makes this such a difficult but important episode.

8. Becoming

Becoming is where it all goes down at the end of season two. Buffy had been dragging her feet about dealing with the whole evil Angel thing, but she can't put it off any longer. He is trying to end the world and suck all of humanity into a demon hellscape, after all. This story sees the unholy alliance of Buffy and Spike working together, which is equal parts horrifying and hilarious. There's also a tremendous amount of action here, with different intertwining story lines that utilize all of the characters remarkably well. Becoming has a handful of different classic moments, especially once Buffy and Angel finally have their long-awaited stand off. It also features several flashback sequences that further explain Angel's character, as well as conclusion that really makes you wonder where the show will be headed in the next season.

7. Nightmares

This episode is from the first season, when the show was still trying to find its footing. Each of the main characters begins to have their nightmares come to life, and the line between the dream world and reality becomes blurred. It provides marvelous insight into the characters that the audience is still getting to know, from the silly "going to school naked" or "being forced to sing in front of people when you don't know the words" dreams that everyone has to nightmares that express deeper psychological fears. Watching Buffy's father tell her that she's the reason that her parents got divorced and that he doesn't get anything out of their weekend visits is incredibly difficult to watch, partly because rather than being firmly rooted in the realm of the supernatural, it feels like something that could be real.

6. Band Candy

It's always a treat when Giles, the patriarch of the Scooby Gang, gets to unwind a little bit. Which is something he certainly does here. In fact, most of the characters (and some of the audience as well) were probably ready for him to get wound back up by the end of the episode. In Band Candy, Ethan Rayne shows back up in town and is ready for some crazy shenanigans, as per usual. His plan involves magical candy that will make regular adults regress to their teenage selves. And as stupid and silly as that might sound, it's actually hilarious. How can you not stare at the screen with a combination of disgust and amusement as Buffy watches her mom and Giles start to get busy on the hood of a cop car? Or when Principal Snyder is desperately trying to be a part of the cool group?

5. Conversations With Dead People

Conversations With Dead People is probably one of the darkest episodes Buffy the Vampire Slayer ever came out with. Each of the main characters is visited by the spirit of someone with whom they share some king of connection...or so they think. Buffy is psychoanalyzed by a recently turned vampire who went to high school with her, Willow has a discussion with Cassie, and Dawn is alone at her house with a violent spirit. Nothing the dead have to say is encouraging in regards to their fight with the First Evil. In fact, Cassie passes along a message supposedly from Tara telling Willow to commit suicide. Which is exactly the moment that gives the game away, because Willow realizes that Tara would never say that to her: it's just the First playing with them. It's a chillingly downbeat episode, one that matches the rest of the seventh season.

4. The Wish

No science fiction or fantasy television show worth its salt is complete without a good alternate universe, and the one featured in The Wish is note-perfect. After Cordelia is scorned by her boyfriend Xander, who cheats on her with Willow, she's not exactly discerning in who she blames for her current despair. In particular, she sees Buffy at fault. If she had never moved to Sunnydale, Cordelia's life would still be all sunshine and flowers. Unfortunately, Cordelia makes the mistake of expressing this opinion in front of a vengeance demon, who immediately transports her to an alternate Sunnydale that exists without Buffy. And it's horrifying, with the town completely overrun by vampires without Buffy to fight them off. It's a classic story of being careful what you wish for, and the climactic scene that features all of the friends facing off against one another is heartbreakingly beautiful.

3. Once More With Feeling

You can say a lot of things about Joss Whedon, but one thing he's known for is his willingness to experiment with the medium of television. An all-singing episode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer? That just sounds ridiculous on the face of it, but at the same time, what better show to attempt such a thing than a fantasy that has no rules about the kind of events that can happen. In the context of the show, it makes perfect sense that Xander would somehow summon a dancing demon that forces everyone to express their emotions through musical numbers. It's immediately clear that a lot of work went into the musical. While not all of the actors on the show were fantastic singers, they all gave it a shot, and some of them were surprisingly talented. After Buffy went for it and the episode was met with mostly positive feedback, you see other shows copying their model and creating their own musical episodes.

2. Hush

Hush is another prime example of Joss Whedon's propensity for experimentation. A lot of people might think that you can't make an entire episode with no dialogue...Whedon just sees it as a challenge. When the Gentlemen come calling (and they're one of the most terrifying, grotesque monsters that look like they came straight out of the spookiest German fairy tale ever), they steal everyone's voices because their only weakness is the sound of the heroine's scream. Without the power of speech, the characters have to find other interesting (and sometimes hilarious) ways of communicating with one another. Every moment of Hush is gripping, and it's the closest to a perfect 45-minute television episode as you're likely to find.

Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.