20 Flawless TV Character Arcs
The best character development on the small screen.
Without great characters, even the best shows will fail. But what exactly makes a good TV character?
Well, there are plenty of factors, but the main one (at least for the purposes of this discussion) has to be their ability to change with the story, growing from the conflict that surrounds them and enriching the drama they're impacting. If a character fails to grow, a series can't sustain itself.
Most of this comes down to the writing, but large amounts of credit should go the actors, who must bring the script to life and find the depth in their characters and how they're being developed by the action that drives the story.
With that in mind, then, from modern classics such as Better Call Saul and beloved fan favourites like Buffy the Vampire Slayer and The Good Place, here are 20 TV character arcs that are totally, 100% flawless. This article will contain major spoilers for each show mentioned.
20. Tasha "Tasty" Jefferson - Orange Is The New Black
Orange is the New Black was all about growth, as the women it depicted wrestled with the prison system, their pasts and their reputations. Red, Nicky, Crazy Eyes and so many more were granted wonderful and often tragic arcs, but it was Tasty who separated herself from the pack to become the show's most compelling figure.
Introduced as a fierce ball of energy always on-hand to deliver some witty comic relief with best friend Poussey Washington, Tasha Jefferson was always strong and capable, but with Poussey's murder at the hands of an inexperienced guard, she was forced to transform into an activist whilst grief consumed her.
Desperate for change, tired of the racism and corruption that surrounded her, Tasty became a leading figure in season five's riot arc, and given more jail time because of it was finally able to find some slither of peace. It was bleak at times, but Tasty's journey was ultimately one of reliance and hope against the odds.
19. Jax Teller - Sons Of Anarchy
Sons of Anarchy was, to put it mildly, insane, deviating from a studied drama in its first season to a more outlandish, dark and laughably implausible series as it wore on. Through all its highs and lows, though, Jax Teller was always on hand to keep viewers invested.
Initially refusing to enter a life of crime and follow in his deceased father's footsteps, circumstance and tragedy forced Jax to betray his morals and become what he never wanted to be -- a criminal and eventual leader of the Sons of Anarchy club his father helped build.
Purposefully frustrating, Jax's inconsistencies only added to his brilliance, as he struggled to supress his nature. His need to maintain the club whilst keeping his and his friends' souls intact was thrilling and twisty in the best way, and his final fate -- dying just like his father years before -- hammered his arc home beautifully.
18. Maggie Greene - The Walking Dead
As a whole, The Walking Dead had a troubled relationship with its characters, often failing to realise their potential (Beth, Carl, Tyreese) or bungle their development entirely (Morgan, mid-series Carol, Andrea). But when they got it right, they ended up with characters like Maggie Greene.
Rick, Daryl, Michonne, Carol, and Negan may be more obvious picks for this list, but Maggie was often the show's secret weapon, a kind young woman who lost her father, sister and husband to a world she was woefully unprepared for, who used her tragic life to become a hardened survivor and community leader.
Watching her lose Hershel, then Beth and then Glenn, you'd be forgiven for thinking Maggie was doomed to a similar fate, but it never came. Despite all the horror and loss and burgeoning grief, Maggie rose to the challenge at every turn, and was all the more compelling and poignantly transformed for it.
17. Eleven - Stranger Things
So long as they keep finding ways to explore Eleven's growing powers and tangled past, Stranger Things could run forever. Despite ultimately being an ensemble show bursting with compelling characters, it's Eleven who has continuously stood out and stolen the spotlight.
Introduced as a monosyllabic, quietly traumatised young girl with supreme powers, Eleven was always portrayed as a real-life superhero, brave and mighty. As the show has gone on, this hasn't changed, but her heroics have also come with some hefty baggage, as she's confronted young love and her violent past to compelling growth.
Between her relationships with Mike and Hopper and her mysterious origins, which she's willing to confront head-on in order to protect her friends and family, Eleven has been through it all at a very young age, but in the process of being against the world has become all the stronger and more engaging.
16. Prince Zuko - Avatar: The Last Airbender
Look up the definition of "redemption arc," and chances are high you'll find a picture of Prince Zuko from the animated series Avatar: The Last Airbender. Raised as a warrior ordered to capture the Avatar, Zuko's growth from villain to sympathetic hero remains a stunning example of great writing. And on a Nickelodeon show, no less!
Thrown out into the world by a cruel and menacing father, Zuko starts the series as a lost soul with a single-minded purpose, driven by his upbringing and desire to achieve his goals -- no matter the human cost, or the weight it bares down on his soul.
Time works to save him from his path, though, and once he starts empathising with his enemy, Aang, and the victims of his father's wrath, he renounces his evil ways and becomes an ally against tyranny. It's a brilliant, full-circle story, powerfully executed, and a great reminder that there's always hope, for everyone, to change.
15. John "J.D" Dorian - Scrubs
Scrubs welcomed the growth of its many characters, who were thrown into tragic situations without much preparation and forced to deal with calamity and setbacks at every turn. Plenty developed massively -- Dr. Cox, Turk and Carla especially -- but none more so than its main protagonist, John "J.D" Dorian.
A naïve and passionate young doctor who entered Sacred Heart Hospital with high expectations and little understanding of what he was in store for, death and the intimate relationships he formed with his patients and colleagues allowed him to be the best version of himself without sacrificing his affable quirks.
Growing into a strong and capable doctor, able to shake off tragedy without losing his passion for the job, J.D remained a lovable narrator constantly learning from his mistakes and successes. He was funny, odd, charmingly himself, flawed, anxious and intelligent, and watching him grow was the show's great joy.
14. Lydia Martin - Teen Wolf
When we first meet Lydia Martin in MTV's angsty supernatural horror-drama series Teen Wolf, she's on top of the world, thriving as her high school's most popular student and making waves for her party planning and love life. But then her world is turned violently upside down, and her façade crumbles.
You see, like almost everyone in high school, Lydia isn't totally honest about herself, and in carving out her name for herself, she's buried the supremely intelligent, loving woman she really is under a fake persona desperate for acceptance. Bitten by a werewolf and turned into a banshee, she finally comes into her own.
Selfless and brave, Lydia's growth from high school mean girl to world-saving heroine with immeasurable power is the show's best arc, full of heartbreak, sacrifice and plenty of laughs. Teen Wolf was never perfect (though it was very entertaining), but Lydia always was.
13. Ahsoka Tano - The Clone Wars
When The Clone Wars started, it was easy to dismiss it as a silly animated series far removed from the movies that gave it life. After all, it originally aired on Cartoon Network. But it soon proved, from its second season onward, to be far more than a disposable spin-off; it was the show Star Wars had been waiting for.
Dark and violent, The Clone Wars took place before Revenge of the Sith, and followed the clone conflict with intimate detail, in which Anakin Skywalker comes to train and care for a padawan called Ahsoka Tano. It's Ahsoka who stole the show, starting out as brash and inexperienced before growing into a seasoned warrior.
Through Ahsoka, who suffers insurmountable loss and is ultimately betrayed by the very system she fought for, The Clone Wars reached its peaked, as another piece of the franchise's tragic puzzle was unveiled. She was wonderfully entertaining, and the finale hammered her journey home as one of the franchise's best.
12. Ellis Carver - The Wire
Ellis Carver is far from the first character you picture when thinking about The Wire, and yet his development is the richest in a long line of compelling characters. He was always lurking in the background, initially a comic relief and a corrupt cop easy to dislike, but he eventually became so much more.
Originally portrayed as a brutish, immature officer willing to break the rules and push boundaries, Carver was a hot-headed narcotics detective who, after a series of mishaps and personal slips, soon begins to change his ways, striving to become an upstanding and commendable lawman.
Like the bigger personalities of Stringer Bell, Omar Little and Bubbles Cousins, Ellis Carver represented one of The Wire's many key themes; that anyone can change, even if it seems there's no hope for a new beginning. Carver's growth is a testament to the drama's deep-rooted humanism.
11. Chidi Anagonye - The Good Place
The Good Place, at its core, was all about character growth, following its primary characters -- lost soul Eleanor, materialistic socialite Tahani, lovely but dumb Jason, demon Michael and indecisive Chidi -- as they attempted to become better people and earn a place in heaven.
All of these characters went through a beautiful change, but none more so than Chidi Anagonye, the dithering philosophy scholar who started out as a broken man unsure of how to live a good life, and through friendship became the most important person in the world, even help saving it with his ethical views.
An intelligent, loving and hilariously flawed man who meant well but made everyone miserable with his indecision, Chidi's growth from uncertain, uncomfortable sidekick to calm, level-headed hero and romantic lead was one of The Good Place's many great achievements.
10. Starlight - The Boys
The Boys is a show made of Big Personalities. There's the psychotic superhero (no, villain) Homelander, the grizzled hero hunter Billy Butcher, and too many more to list. But arguably the most underappreciated and quietly compelling of them all is surely Annie "Starlight" January, a true hero caught in a horrifying war.
When Starlight first appears in the series, she's an innocent young woman with big dreams of being a hero and helping people. Learning that her dream is really a nightmare and her idols are all soulless monsters, she soon becomes hardened to her life's bleak reality.
One of the show's only real heroines, desperate to do the right thing without caring what it does to her image, Starlight may not be The Boy's biggest personality, but she's certainly its most endearing and transformed. If anyone deserves some kind of peaceful future, it's her.
9. Diane Nguyen - BoJack Horseman
Amongst many other things, BoJack Horseman tackled the idea of personal growth -- whether it's possible, what it takes -- better than most other shows of its era, following its troubled characters as they came face-to-face with their pasts, personal demons, addictions, romantic entanglements and identities.
Introduced as a moderately successful writer hired to ghost-write BoJack's memoirs, Diane Nguyen was always the show's secret weapon, first portrayed as an unwavering professional before quickly becoming the faded star's closest confidant and friend.
As the series progressed, Diane struggled with her career goals, her body image and her relationships, but through it all emerged a much happier, content person than she'd ever been. Hers is a rocky journey, but a stunning and powerful one that goes deep into the shadows of the human condition, and comes out happily ever after.
8. Nora Durst - The Leftovers
Everyone lost someone in the Departure, when 2% of the world's population vanished without a trace, but few more so than Nora Durst, who found herself alone and isolated after losing her husband and young children. Under this loss, though, she doesn't crumble.
It's not smooth sailing. Nora was never the same, constantly shifting between explosive, emotionally trapped and traumatised, tangled in a deep, penetrative grief she never fully escapes but never allows herself to become controlled by. She's broken, but also charming and hopeful enough to break through the tragedy.
In the end, Nora meets the light at the end of the tunnel, finding peace in her family's disappearance and her place in the world after the fact, and watching her come to terms with the Departure -- in the show's revelatory finale, The Book of Nora -- was the masterful show's greatest payoff.
7. Arya Stark - Game Of Thrones
Featuring one of the biggest ensemble casts on TV, it was always going to be hard for one character to break through the rabble as Game of Thrones' best developed star, but Arya Stark's development was so compelling, intimate and crowd-pleasing it has to wear the crown.
The youngest daughter of the doomed Lord Eddard Stark, an outcast who never fit in and lost everything in a barrage of violence and backstabbing, Arya was fierce and strong from a young age, but following the death of her father was forced to become someone new. Someone, it turned out, desperate for revenge.
Driven by vengeance, Arya became the show's most surprising hero, a tried and tested warrior who faced every horror imaginable and still emerged a heroine with few equals. She started the show feuding with the detestable Joffrey, and ended it killing the White Walkers and her many family foes. What a journey.
6. Walter White - Breaking Bad
The greatness of Walter White's development lied not in how much he changed, but in how little. Breaking Bad showrunner Vince Gilligan wanted to "take Mr Chips and turn him into Scarface," but we never really saw Mr Chips. From the off, he was a pathetic, slippery, morally grey man, and he only got worse.
Watching Walt transform from distant family man to drug kingpin was gradual, at once frustrating and amusing. He learned early on that his vast intellect would take him places, and it did, but once he realised his reputation was more important than anything, he became something altogether more terrifying.
In denial about his intentions and blinded by his arrogance, Walter White became more soulless as the series went on, and his metamorphosis came full circle when he finally admitted he was more concerned with his image than the broken family he claimed to love. It's the perfect story.
5. Arabella - I May Destroy You
I May Destroy You does not make for easy viewing, but it is a vital, empowering tale, the focus of which, Arabella, goes through a magnificent arc in just nine 30-minute episodes. She starts at her lowest low, and from there learns to find peace in her darkest moment.
The series follows Arabella as she tries to uncover who sexually assaulted her on a night out with friends. She learns some horrible truths, and in the process must process insurmountable grief stemming from her recent pain, the likes of which many of us do not understand, but too many others tragically do.
In the end, Arabella has a chance to seek revenge on her attacker, but instead pours her grief into her art, finding peace at long last. It's not an easy journey, but it ends in a powerful way that takes a big risk and allows its protagonist to move on. It will stay with you, but be careful watching it.
4. Peggy Olson - Mad Men
Mad Men's Peggy Olson was a true standout in a show dominated by powerful men, a passionate and motivated young woman who, whilst working for the enigmatic Don Draper, quickly proved her worth and soon rose through the ranks to become her former employer's trusted right-hand.
Initially portrayed as innocent and naïve, willing to do anything to fit in even it meant compromising herself, Peggy's growth finds her becoming one of few people capable of seeing through Don's bullsh*t. She was not without her flaws, but they made her that much more human, and able to handle the sexism around her.
By the end of Mad Men's seven seasons, Peggy Olson had been through it all -- failed relationships, backstabs, constant misogyny, blackmail -- and pulled through as its most developed character. Without her, the likes of Don, Pete and Joan wouldn't have been as compelling as they were.
3. Spike - Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Over its run, Buffy the Vampire Slayer prided itself on challenging its characters, who changed on a season-to-season basis based on the horrors they faced and the pain they encountered. Of all the characters, no one changed more than Spike, the vicious vampire who grew into a champion.
First arriving in the show's second season as Buffy's biggest threat to date, Spike was renowned for killing Slayers. He wasn't meant to last, but proved such a hit that he was eventually upgraded to main character status, and given an epic arc for the ages.
Falling in love with Buffy after being rendered helpless by a chip planted in his brain, then fighting to reclaim his lost soul, Spike was a bit of everything at one point of another -- villain, comic relief, romantic lead, sidekick, hero -- and his development from monster to selfless warrior was something truly awesome to behold.
2. Jimmy McGill - Better Call Saul
Jimmy McGill. Saul Goodman. Gene Takovic. Call him what you will, Jimmy was a character so transformative that, after his supporting stint on Breaking Bad, his leading role on Better Call Saul often put the character development of Walter White to shame.
A cocky conman who fell into law and made a name for himself working with career criminals, watching Jimmy become Saul -- his shady alter ego -- was impeccably well written, making a bad man feel deeply tragic and redeemable. Watching him lose his new career and reputation was just as gripping.
Jimmy went through it all, inflicting pain on everyone he knew, getting in over his head at every turn, before finally accepting his wrongs and going to jail in order to save the woman he loved. His arc was so compelling, in fact, that it would be #1 on his list where it not for one (or should I say three) other characters...
1. The Big Three - This Is Us
This Is Us is one of the most emotional and life-affirming shows ever made, and most of its greatest drama came from the three siblings at its centre -- successful actor Kevin, teacher Kate, and businessman Randall -- each of whom go through such loss and hardships it's a wonder their story has a happy ending.
From Kate and her weight and career struggles to Kevin and his troubled career and Randall and his desperate desire to hunt down his birth parents, the Pearson siblings often clashed over their family life, but always came out the other side stronger and closer than ever.
Learning to lean on each other to combat the tragedies surrounding them (the death of their father, the illness of their mother, Kevin's addiction, Randall's identity crises, Kate's destructive secrets), the Big Three went through hell but still found the joy in life's dark spots.
They may have had a tough go of things, but watching them confront the worst of themselves and each other was nothing short of exemplary, and gave them possibly the best TV character arcs of all time.