20 Greatest Arrowverse Villains

Bad times don't last, but bad guys do.

The Legion Of Doom
TheCW

Every great superhero needs at least one great supervillain. The better the bad guy, the more invested we are in the outcome and the more the story gets its hooks into us.

That’s why a great villain is so important... but what actually makes a great villain? It’s not whether they can beat the good guys, or even come close - plot convention generally requires the antagonist to be taken out in the final act regardless of how awesome they are (or aren’t).

No, it’s some compelling combination of factors: something that intrigues you, makes you keep coming back to see what happens next. They could have a fascinating relationship or dynamic with our hero, or they could have a unique look or power set. Their appeal could lie in the story they’re a part of, or (in the case of villains on the stage or screen) simply in the sheer brilliance of the performance.

The TV shows that make up the Arrowverse have had their fair share of damp squibs and missed opportunities over the last seven years, presenting forgettable takes on classic comic book moustache-twirlers like Ra’s al Ghul, The Thinker and Vandal Savage. But there have been far more dreaded devils than dreadful douchebags in the Arrowverse to date...

20. Mallus

Legends of Tomorrow Mallus
The CW

Initially, Legends Of Tomorrow’s season three did its level best to present primordial demon Mallus as a terrifying harbinger of doom.

Escaped from his prison of centuries, this sinister force of darkness corrupts and possesses more than one person in true Exorcist style while the team desperately try to find a way to put the djinn back in the bottle.

Unfortunately, the climax to his tenure as the show’s Big Bad completely eradicated any menace that had been built up over the preceding seventeen episodes, with the combined Legends using their ersatz Infinity Stones to create a super-Beebo, a blue fluffy toy empowered with the ability to destroy the millennia-old demon.

Mallus would be a lot higher on this list if they hadn’t gone for the Ghostbusters ending and had their supervillain creamed after a WWE-style spotfest with a plushie.


19. Anatoly Knyazev

arrow anatoly knyazev
The CW

For the majority of his time on Arrow, Anatoly Knyazev was like a big brother to Oliver Queen. Not one he spent a huge amount of time with, owing to his membership of (and later leadership of) the Russian mob, but close nonetheless.

David Nykl played the genial Bratva gangster as a charmer with a moral code and a wry sense of humour, a man who’d go a long way to repay a debt or to help a friend. That’s why, when the two of them fell out so dramatically, Anatoly’s transition to impassive, ruthless criminal had such a powerful impact.

Believing himself betrayed by Queen, Knyazev showed why it is that you never cross the Bratva, allying himself with Ricardo ‘The Dragon’ Diaz to gain revenge on his former friend and causing a million Arrow fans across the world to post cryface emojis and NOOOOO memes.

Fortunately, everyone’s favourite KGBeast came to his senses in time to help foil the villain and save the day. But for a good season or so, Anatoly Knyazev was the worst kind of villain: the kind that used to be your best friend.


18. Captain Cold

legends of tomorrow captain cold
The CW

Just as in the comic books that the Flash is drawn from, Captain Cold - Leonard Snart to his friends and parole officer - isn’t much of a supervillain… he’s more of a rogue. Or in this case, Rogue.

The Flash’s Rogues tend to be petty criminals and thieves: cunning bank robbers, larcenists and burglars who use their one gimmick to steal from the rich and give to themselves, and Captain Cold is no exception.

What makes the TV version of Snart such a fantastic bad guy isn’t his eeeeeevil scheming or his position in the narrative as a ruthless, powerful nemesis. No, it’s the pantomime scenery chewing of one Wentworth Miller, whose performance in the role - all sneering sarcasm and moustache-twirling venom, purring like a cartoon cat - made him an instant fan-favourite with the Flash audience from the moment the Captain set foot in Central City.

So much so, in fact, that they chose to make him an antihero, then a genuine hero in Legends Of Tomorrow, where Snart’s brand of snark livened up a very dodgy first season.


17. Lillian Luthor

Lillian Luthor Supergirl
The CW

Lex Luthor’s mother appeared in Supergirl a couple of years before Lex himself, and wasn’t even the central villain of season two. That role fell to Teri Hatcher’s Queen Rhea. However, Brenda Strong stole every scene she was in.

The blueprint for the character was clearly Lex himself, since Lillian shared his scientific brilliance, his cold ruthlessness and his motivating hatred towards extraterrestrials on earth (especially those from Krypton): clearly Supergirl’s showrunners wanted the Lex/Superman dynamic but weren’t at that time allowed to draft Lex himself.

Ersatz Lex or not, Strong proved herself more than up to carving a unique niche for herself in the Arrowverse. You can tell when an actor’s having a lot of fun in a role, and Strong clearly relished getting all the best lines, even when she was sidelined in later seasons.


16. Savitar

The Flash Savitar
The CW

The Flash’s third season nemesis was yet another speed-derived villain threatening Barry Allen’s family. Reverse Flash killed his mother, Zoom killed his father and Savitar murdered (or would murder) his future wife, Iris.

Repetitive, longwinded storytelling aside (season three was not the show’s finest hour), what makes Savitar - the self-styled God Of Speed - such a great villain?

Well, there’s that scary-ass battle armour, which freaked the hell out of Flash fans when Savitar was first revealed in season three’s ‘Shade’.

But it was the second reveal that really put the cat among the pigeons, fourteen episodes later when Barry finally figured out why his archenemy was always one step ahead of them… because he remembered everything that was happening.

Savitar was Barry Allen himself: or rather, an insane time remnant of the Flash from the near future, the victim of a time loop in which he is destined to create himself only to destroy himself, over and over.


15. Deadshot

Arrow Deadshot
The CW

One of DC comics’ most underrated villains, the laconic, amoral hitman Floyd Lawton - aka the world’s greatest marksman Deadshot - didn’t have the greatest of starts in the Arrowverse. The idea that a professional assassin would have tattooed the names of all of his victims on his torso is ludicrous, to say the least.

However, Michael Rowe is a fine actor, rising above that little hiccup to give us a Lawton - conflicted, self-loathing and cynical - as contradictory as the character and his fans deserve.

A sniper of astonishing accuracy, Deadshot was no slouch hand-to-hand either, controlling and subduing the much larger John Diggle in moments.

But it’s the menace that makes him so memorable. Rowe brought a sense of danger and that slightly out-of-control element that all the best iterations of this marvellous villain have had in spades.


14. Reign

Supergirl Reign
The CW

A Kryptonian twist on the classic Jekyll & Hyde trope, Reign is a Worldkiller: a genetically engineered creature enhanced by dark magic and twinned with an innocent personality, Sam Arias, constantly fighting against the malign influence within her.

Essentially a Supergirl made by witches to destroy worlds (how badass does that sound?), Reign pulverises the Girl Of Steel in their first meeting. If anything, she’s stronger than Kara with fewer weaknesses.

As an antagonist, Reign is compelling and powerful, and Odette Annable does her usual sterling job portraying her twin, conflicted halves. She’s got allies, too: not only the witches that created her, but two other Worldkillers, Purity and Pestilence, each almost as powerful as her, making up a trinity of sorts.

She’s a fantastic villain, let down by some questionable storytelling choices. Why take out her two partners so quickly? Why split Sam and Reign in two at the end and remove any dramatic tension built up over the fate of the innocent persona, tied to the evil one? By the season finale, Reign felt more like a missed opportunity.


13. Black Siren

The Flash Laurel Black siren
The CW

Black Canary’s demise towards the end of Arrow’s fourth season didn’t come as much of a shock. The show had been teasing a major death from the beginning of the year, with a flashforward to a mysterious grave, and there were a limited number of likely occupants in the cast.

However, the sheer volume of the public outcry over Laurel Lance’s death seemed to take everyone aback - so when actress Katie Cassidy returned to Arrow as recurring villain Black Siren, her evil Earth 2 take on Laurel Lance, she was an instant hit with the audience at home.

Part of Black Siren’s appeal as a villain lies in that familiar alternate universe schtick: it’s always fun seeing a fan favourite play the bad guy, and the heroic Black Canary’s tragic end threw the murderous Black Siren into even sharper relief.

But honestly, the biggest thing that Black Siren brought to the show was the sight of Cassidy having so much fun vamping it up as the cold, ruthless, femme fatale after years of playing the buttoned-down goodie-two-shoes.

Even the character’s inevitable transition to antihero status by season seven (the Arrowverse can't handle Laurel Lance being completely irredeemable) couldn’t diminish the allure of those snarled putdowns.


12. Dante & The Ninth Circle

Arrow Dante
The CW

Originally set up as the head of Arrow season seven’s terrorist organisation The Ninth Circle, Dante was eventually revealed to be second to the syndicate’s real leader: Emiko Queen, Oliver’s newly-discovered half-sister.

Which is a damned shame, because Dante - played with a wonderfully dark, amused malevolence by former Highlander Adrian Paul - was a breath of fresh air: a sinister puppeteer that even Ricardo Diaz was scared of, physically more than a match for the Green Arrow despite a twenty-year age gap.

Why the Ninth Circle was sidelined remains a mystery. Emiko was just a combination of tired Arrow tropes: a Queen with a dark secret; a female killer with daddy issues; an evil archer as dark mirror to Oliver. And why would a centuries-old secret society that had financed wars and revolutions allow an unstable twenty-something assassin to lead them?

Dante, the Ninth Circle and his lieutenants Beatrice and Virgil are all names taken from the Divine Comedy, the classic poem depicting the circles of Hell, which in turn implies that these were titles or codenames rather than their own names. If that’s the case, we could be seeing a new Dante cropping up in Arrow’s final season. Here’s hoping he’s half as interesting as this one.


11. Dark Arrow

Oliver Queen Earth X Stephen Amell Dark Arrow
The CW

Take audience reactions to Black Siren and double them for the effect that the Dark Arrow - the Nazi overlord of Earth-X - had during the winter 2017 crossover, Crisis On Earth-X.

By now the show’s fans were kind of used to seeing alternate versions of their favourite heroes pulled in from parallel worlds. But to see a twisted doppelganger of the Green Arrow himself, Oliver Queen, as the Fuhrer of a Nazi-dominated Earth-X: that was the icing on the cake.

True, Crisis On Earth-X also brought us the Nazi-alternate of Supergirl - but Overgirl’s just a sadistic might-makes-right type, villainy by numbers, and Melissa Benoist only really offered a little extra sarcasm and bitchiness by way of contrast with her apple-pie girl next door version.

Dark Arrow, on the other hand, is a buff ninja Hitler, played with brilliantly implacable contempt by Stephen Amell as a coldly fascist demagogue with a barely suppressed violent streak. Everything about his performance - body language, tone, phrasing, even posture - suggests an Oliver Queen born and raised to be someone else. Something else.


10. Lex Luthor

Supergirl Lex Luthor
The CW

When Jon Cryer, an actor mostly famous for his award-winning comedy chops, was cast as Lex Luthor for Supergirl’s fourth season, fandom was sceptical. As good as he was in Pretty In Pink or Two And A Half Men, could he really pull it off - become one of the greatest super villains of all time?

Judge for yourself. In only a few episodes, Lex Luthor became one of the Arrowverse’s most compelling, charismatic Big Bads, thanks to Cryer’s astonishing performance and some quality writing. Had it not been for Lex’s brief tenure in the Arrowverse to date, he’d be ranked much higher on this list: the character that Cryer and the writers put together deserves it.

However, Lex is really more Superman’s archenemy, and no one knows of any plans to bring Tyler Hoechlin’s brilliant version of Kal El back to the show any time soon. As it stands, with several Luthors running around National City already (is Lena being set up for a heel turn?), season four may have been the last we’ll see of Alexander Joseph Luthor…


9. Damien Darhk

Arrow Damien Darhk
The CW

Season four of Arrow probably represented the lowest point of the seven seasons to date. It was poorly paced, riddled with plot holes and inconsistencies, and suffered from some of the laziest writing the Arrowverse had ever seen. The flashbacks actively hurt the story, and worse… the whole thing was just boring, seeming to last twice as long as it actually did.

But there was one bright spot in all that dull pointlessness: Neal McDonough and his sneering, gloriously pantomime archvillainy, as former League Of Assassins lieutenant and current Armageddon-baiting sorcerer Damien Darhk.

As mediocre as season four was, McDonough was fantastic: singlehandedly elevating every scene he was in and every episode where he had a significant presence.

For some reason, they felt the need to kill Darhk at the end of the finale, but McDonough was too good to go out like that: time-hopping adventure series Legends Of Tomorrow snapped Darhk up for bad guy duties in seasons two and three.


8. Ricardo ’The Dragon’ Diaz

Arrow Ricardo Diaz
The CW

Season six of Arrow wasn’t nearly as bad as season four - no pointless flashbacks sapping the will to live, far better pacing, but it also suffered from something of the doldrums. It just wasn’t particularly entertaining, week to week.

That wasn’t the fault of veteran actor Kirk Acevedo, however. Famous for the intense ferocity of his performances, Acevedo gave far more to the role than the weaksauce writing deserved. Like McDonough, he elevated every scene he was in, but not through playing the pantomime villain, all theatrical wisecracks and contemptuous sneer.

No, Acevedo’s Dragon was genuinely scary, a powder keg of fury and pent-up violence kept on a leash by an iron will: and despite a lack of superpowers or countless faceless ninja warriors, more than a match for Team Arrow.

Acevedo’s fine work paid off - for the first time since season two, the writer’s room decided not to end the Big Bad's story in the season finale and had Diaz survive to glower another day. It’s a shame they didn’t really seem to know what to do with him in season seven: Diaz deserved better than his final fate.


7. Gorilla Grodd

Gorilla Grodd The Flash
The CW

Faced with dodgy CG realisation and poor storylines, Gorilla Grodd had the potential to be an utter disaster on the small screen - one of the comic book Flash’s greatest and most menacing foes reduced to unintentional comedy.

It’s to the show’s credit that this wasn’t the way Grodd’s CW debut panned out. Instead, they accentuated the positives and hid the negatives: using darkness and the confined surroundings of subway and sewer tunnels to mask the cheapness of the effects required to create off the giant gorilla, while using canny storytelling to play up the villain’s intelligence and formidable psychic gifts alongside his sheer size and animal fury.

The result surprised everyone. Grodd was terrifying, unlike any villain seen in the Arrowverse so far, and an unusually faithful adaptation of the original comic book character.

Subsequent uses of the character didn’t quite live up to his original introduction, a particularly cringeworthy fight with Gorilla City’s king Solovar representing exactly the kind of poor showing fans had originally expected.

Still, for a while Gorilla Grodd exceeded all expectations and brought something genuinely new to the Arrowverse.


6. Zoom

The Flash Barry Zoom
The CW

Season two of The Flash gave us another rival speedster that our hero couldn’t defeat by pegging it alone… the monstrous Zoom.

Plenty of people remember Zoom with less than adoring fondness, given season two’s alarming similarity to the major beats of season one. You had a speedster, from another world masquerading as a mentor figure to Barry Allen out of costume while literally running rings around him in costume: a villain who would be responsible for the murder of one of his parents.

However, taken on his own there was a lot to love. Hunter Zolomon was a serial killer, a warped and twisted psyche who used his superspeed like garden-variety psychopaths used knives. His status as archvillain of Earth 2 allowed him access to some of that world’s most notorious lesser bad guys to bedevil The Flash, which helped pace the season’s arc without

And he was scary. Looking like nothing so much as a hulking, demonic version of the Flash himself, Zoom was a roaring, clawed monstrosity, catching bullets and lightning bolts with devilish ease.

It made perfect sense that after his defeat, he would be resurrected as the macabre Black Flash - the sentient Speed Force’s hitman, sent to assassinate any speedster who dared to abuse time travel.


5. Malcolm Merlyn

Arrow Malcolm Merlyn
The CW

Untrustworthy, cunning and always two steps ahead of everyone else, the Arrowverse’s first ever Big Bad was Malcolm Merlyn, played with Machiavellian glee by the incomparable John Barrowman. A complicated man, Merlyn was a villain who believed himself to be doing the right thing and would stop at nothing to achieve his goals.

As the Dark Archer, Merlyn set the bar for the best kind of villains in the Arrowverse. Charismatic, menacing, ruthless and great with a one-liner, his original sinister scheme played out over the course of Arrow’s first season, culminating in The Undertaking itself: the destruction of The Glades through earthquake in order to force the crime-free regeneration of Starling City, as it was called back then.

All the names were different back then. As the Hood, Oliver was barely able to hold his own against Merlyn who, as Al Sa-Her - the Magician - had been trained by the League Of Assassins.

In later seasons, having been trained by Ra's al Ghul, the Arrow was more than a match for Merlyn. He became more of a secondary antagonist and occasional anti-hero, appearing here and there to liven up every scene he was in until his supposed death at the end of season five.


4. The Legion Of Doom

Legends of Tomorrow Legion of Doom
The CW

In the same broadcast year that he was playing out his final episodes on Arrow, Barrowman was also hamming it up in glorious fashion as one of the major villains on Legends Of Tomorrow’s second season.

How could Merlyn appear in both shows at the same time? Legends Of Tomorrow is about time travel: this version of Merlyn was shanghaied from Star City in 2016, shortly after that time period’s Damian Darhk was killed by the Green Arrow. His partners in crime? None other than Darhk himself… at least, the 1987 version of the character, alongside a version of Eobard Thawne, the Reverse Flash (played by Matt Letscher).

And how does Thawne (who also died, in The Flash’s season one finale) come back? It’s complicated… far too complicated to bother going into. Let’s just say ‘timey-wimey’ and leave it at that: the Arrowverse’s many, many time travel storylines make very little sense.

Whoever came up with the idea of teaming Barrowman, McDonough and Letscher, to say nothing of the characters they play, was a freaking genius. Fusing the best parts of each of the three fantastic villains into one beautifully snarky unit, the Legion Of Doom effortlessly stole every scene they were in, and elevated the second-string show they were in to something eminently watchable just by showing up.


3. Deathstroke

Arrow Slade Wilson Deathstroke
The CW

The TV version of Slade Wilson (or at least, the drug-addled, vengeance-obsessed Wilson from Arrow season two) remains one of the Arrowverse’s most compelling villains, not least because of a career-best performance from Kiwi action veteran Manu Bennett.

Oliver Queen’s former mentor and friend blamed him for the loss of the love of his life, Shado, on the island of Lian Yu five years earlier, and his exposure to an experimental combat drug, mirakuru, had made him stronger, faster and almost impossible to kill.

In every way the Arrow’s physical superior, Deathstroke wanted Queen to suffer as he had suffered, and proceeded to take his life apart before murdering his mother in front of him.

It’s a moment that Arrow, try as it might, could never really match again - and thanks to Deathstroke’s insane, grand guignol schemes and Bennett’s coiled, muscular menace, for a long time season two was the high water mark for Arrow...


2. Prometheus

prometheus arrow villain
The CW

...at least, until season five brought us Prometheus.

Arrow soared back to its former heights with season five, in no small part due to the story created for primary antagonist Simon Morrison, aka Adrian Chase, aka the Throwing Star Killer, aka Prometheus.

Morrison’s father had been one of Oliver Queen’s initial victims; by all accounts a psychopath in the making anyway, Morrison became obsessed with revenge, intending to force Oliver to confront the serial killer in himself.

The amazing Josh Segarra, a veteran of the stage, played the villain with an intense, almost religious mania. All the best villains are convinced they’re right, but Prometheus’ belief reached the point of zealotry.

Mimicking Oliver’s training, costume and early kills and posing as Star City’s district attorney, Prometheus framed Quentin Lance for his own murders, tricked the Green Arrow into killing a police officer and then leaked the resulting cover-up so that Oliver (the mayor at the time) had to publically disown his own alter ego to avoid impeachment.

He convinced Artemis and Black Siren to infiltrate and betray Team Arrow, stabbed his own wife to stop her being used against him and physically and mentally tortured a captive Oliver for a week. Even in death he had the last laugh.

Always ten steps ahead, Prometheus was smarter, more ruthless and more dangerous than any foe Oliver had ever faced.


1. Reverse Flash

The Flash Season 5 Reverse Flash Eobard Thawne Harrison Wells
The CW

The Flash’s first villain set a gold standard that the show has never been able to come close to again.

Eobard Thawne, the so-called Reverse Flash, is the perfect nemesis. He has a love/hate dynamic with the Flash (he travelled back in time to kill him and ended up becoming a father figure to him) alongside a personal vendetta (he killed Barry Allen’s mother when Barry was only a child). He was both a genius (able to masquerade as the founder of S.T.A.R. Labs for years) and a psychopath (he enjoys what he does far, far too much).

All this would be wasted if the character wasn’t played to utter perfection by not one but two fantastic actors. As the original face of the villain, Matt Letscher takes on Thawne at least half the time, all preening, overweening arrogance and hate. As the fake face of Allen’s mentor Harrison Wells, the unstoppable Tom Cavanagh adds a gleeful malevolence to the mix, forever a perverse reminder to our hero of what he’s lost.

Smarter, more experienced and (at least initially) faster than the Flash, Thawne was and still is practically unstoppable, and has proven to be practically unkillable: using and abusing his speedster’s time travel power stunt to cheat death on numerous occasions. You think he’s gone? He’s never gone. Never.


In this post: 
Arrowverse
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.