5 Actors Who Regretted Leaving Star Trek

To seek out brave new worlds and career opportunities...

Wesley Crusher Star Trek
CBS Media Ventures

Nobody ever leaves Star Trek, and not just because most cast members are contracted for a minimum of seven seasons! When the contracts are up and the starship sets broken down and put into storage, there's still the global convention circuit.

Not only that, but various Star Trek actors have to contend with eager fans stopping them on the street or waiting for you at stage door. Aside from your Patrick Stewarts, William Shatners and Jeri Ryans there are, however, some less in-demand actors at the autograph tables. Those stars who leave the series before their time, either for story reasons, work commitments or the promise of more interesting opportunities elsewhere.

For actors like Michelle Forbes, who played Ensign Ro, it works out quite well with recurring gigs on shows like 24 or Battlestar: Galactica. Other actors regret missing out on more time on Star Trek, either because the new opportunities weren't as prosperous as they'd hoped or because they miss their friends. This list collects the small number of people who went where no-one had gone before - off the Star Trek set.

5. Will Wheaton

Star Trek The Next Generation Wesley Crusher
CBS Media Ventures

Given the amount of abuse he used to get from fans who hated Wesley Crusher, it's hardly surprising that Wheaton chose to leave Star Trek: The Next Generation in 1990. However, this wasn't why he decided to go, nor was it true that he was written out to appease angry fans.

The reasons for his departure were purely career-focused. Frustrated by the limitations of playing a boy genius, Wheaton was concerned that he'd be typecast. Given how his career panned out - playing himself in The Big Bang Theory, hosting various Star Trek-related chat shows and convention panels - it looks like he ended up doing what he had most feared: recalling his past glories.

Decades since his departure, he is at peace with his decision. Appearing at a 2012 Star Trek convention, Wheaton said "I thought it was a really smart career move. In some ways it was, and in many others, it wasn't." The credits on Wheaton's CV immediately following Star Trek are largely forgettable, and Wheaton regrets how he left "to go out into the world and do my own thing" whilst severing connections with his former castmates.

Thankfully he's made up with the crew of the Enterprise in the intervening years and is eyeing up a cameo on Picard.


4. Lycia Naff

Ensign Gomez Geordi LaForge
Paramount

Lycia Naff was cast in Star Trek: The Next Generation as a potential love interest for Geordi La Forge. The writers had the idea that he and Ensign Sonya Gomez would fall in love with each other over the course of the series. The endgame was to be Geordi making the decision to get potentially life threatening surgery to restore his sight in order to properly see the love of his life.

Unfortunately, given her comedic introduction - spilling cocoa all over Captain Picard - and the writing and direction Naff received, she was seen more as comic relief than love interest. In an interview with the official Star Trek website, the actor stated that she was "super bummed" to be let go.

Since leaving the Enterprise, Naff has had a fairly eclectic career; playing the three-breasted prostitute in Total Recall and as an undercover reporter who broke the Bill Cosby story back in 2014. Whilst disappointed not to play out the intended romantic subplot, her main regret appears to be the film Chopper Chicks in Zombietown, released in the same year as her short-lived role on Star Trek as Gomez.

Naff eventually made a comeback of sorts in the season 2 finale of Lower Decks, with a promotion to Captain Gomez.


3. Jason Isaacs

Star Trek Discovery Lorca
CBS

Jason Isaacs was terrific as Captain Lorca in Discovery's first series. He deftly balanced the macho old-school charm of Kirk with the underlying sense that all was not as it seemed. Of course, an evil Star Trek Captain can only last so long and Lorca was eventually killed off in season one's thirteenth episode, vaporised in a warp reactor.

Isaacs knew of Lorca's fate when he signed up for the role, but it didn't mean that he wasn't gutted to leave the show. Especially when there was a "get out" clause in the form of the Prime Universe Lorca, whose fate is still unknown. Talking to a Star Trek convention in Las Vegas back in 2019, Isaacs discussed the mixed emotions he felt when watching the second season. "I adore all the actors [...] It was odd to see the show and miss my friends."

Isaacs is certainly keen to return to the role of Lorca, playing the Prime counterpart so long as he could "squeeze back into that 8 year old's uniform". If he was to return, it would likely be in the upcoming Pike/Spock spin-off Brave New Worlds given how his Discovery crewmates have ended up 900 years in the future.


2. Terry Farrell

Star Trek Jadzia Dax
CBS Media Ventures

There are many rumours as to why and how exactly Terry Farrell came to leave the role of Jadzia Dax. Some believe she simply chose not to renew her contract in order to accept a role in the Ted Danson sitcom Becker. The truth appears to be more complex than that, however.

Terry Farrell maintains that she left due to issues with producer Rick Berman, whom she later accused of being misogynistic. Farrell says that she requested a reduced episode count on her new contract. Berman denied this request and would then badger her over the phone to make a decision on her future with the show. Berman denies Farrell's account of the negotiations.

Eventually, Farrell told him that they could either write her out or reduce her episode count. So Dax was promptly killed off in the devastating Season 6 finale. In recent years, Farrell has spoken of her heartbreak at leaving the show and of her regret at leaving Dax behind in favour of the less satisfying role of a neurotic chef in Becker.

On the plus side, she also talks of her pride in standing up for herself, noting that if she hadn't done so then she wouldn't have been able to take up the opportunities that were later presented to her.


1. Eddie Murphy

Eddie Murphy Star Trek
Paramount

The Voyage Home is one of the great 1980s fish-out-of-water comedies that also happens to be a terrific Star Trek movie. It was also originally intended to be much funnier. While developing the fourth Star Trek film, Leonard Nimoy was contacted by Paramount head Jeffrey Katzenberg who told him that Eddie Murphy was a huge fan and would "kill" to be in the next movie.

Nimoy had a few meetings with Murphy, pitching him the character of an astrophysicist who comes into contact with Kirk, Spock and the crew. Or, as Murphy put it in a later interview "the jive dude in San Francisco with Spock". Preferring instead to play against type in the role of a Vulcan, Murphy passed on the script and the character was redeveloped into Dr. Gillian Taylor, a love interest for Kirk.

The film that Eddie Murphy did instead was fantasy comedy The Golden Child, which he later called a piece of s**t. Ironically, both films were released on the same day with The Voyage Home being the bigger commercial success, grossing $109 million in the domestic box office v.s. The Golden Child's $79 million. Murphy is said to have later quipped that he should have done the Star Trek movie.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Citizen of the Universe, Film Programmer, Writer, Podcaster, Doctor Who fan and a gentleman to boot. As passionate about Chinese social-realist epics as I am about dumb popcorn movies.