5 Reasons Bringing Back The Monty Python Franchise Is A Terrible Idea (And 1 Reason It's Not)

5. It's Not A Full Reunion
Dying with excellent comic timing on the twentieth anniversary of Monty Python's Flying Circus, Graham Chapman was the team's most able straight man (as well as its most able gay man). His innate dignity will be difficult to replace, and although it has been promised he'll be included somehow, surely the best tribute would be the recognition that no reunion can go ahead without him? A hellraiser off-screen, but the image of sobriety on it, Chapman once played Mr Neutron- the most terrifying and dangerous man in the universe- in bouffant wig, yellow pyjamas and pixie boots, and made him seem completely reasonable ("hairdressing is very interesting"). He transformed the utterly surreal into the charmingly mundane. The only real choice to portray King Arthur in Holy Grail and Brian in the Life thereof, Chapman managed to wring pathos from those beaten-down stoics, banging his coconuts together with unexpected- and genuine- gravitas. Chapman could be erratic, but at his best he was the heart and soul of Python, and without him, the reunion will lack not just another doddering geriatric- it will lack its most relatable comic presence.
4. They're Not Funny Anymore
Like all sketch shows, the Flying Circus had its misfires, but when the team were on form not a moment was wasted or a potential set-up squandered. The Pythons were seasoned pros who had served their apprenticeships as gag writers or bit players (apart from Gilliam, who was weird and American). As a group, the rivalries at play between the different writing partnerships (Cleese/Chapman v Jones/Palin v Idle) meant that the best episodes, and the best stretches of their movies, are dense games of comic one-upmanship. When they branched out...results were varied. Gilliam and Jones moved into directing semi-serious films while Palin found success as a dramatic actor and host of a popular series of travel documentaries. Cleese wrote Fawlty Towers, which is a sitcom masterwork, but he also played Basil Fawlty-types to diminishing returns in too many films to mention. Idle, gleefully describing himself as a 'greedy b*****d', appeared in anything with a paycheque, like the multi-Razzie winning 'An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn.' Putting it charitably, a recurring theme with the individual Pythons has been their tendency to avoid projects that require the full range of their comic talents. Naturally they're going to be out of condition as writers and performers, but these shows won't be judged on the quality of their lighting or set design. They'll be judged on the quality of the laughs. And with a collective resume like that, their funniest work is very much behind them.
And now...
No. 3 The Larch.
And now...
2. They're Too old
The surviving Pythons have a combined age of 357, which is perhaps why this reunion was so unexpected. The shows will no doubt be physically strenuous, requiring stamina and concentration- two things the elderly aren't renowned for. Already, there are signs that age and infirmity have taken their toll on the set lists. Asked about the Ministry of Silly Walks, John Cleese said: "That's impossible now because I have an artificial knee and an artificial hip, so there's no chance of that now." Which is a shame, because it's an iconic sketch, as responsible as any for embedding the team in the popular consciousness. A reunion seems pointless when the laughs you can generate are limited by the number of genuine body parts you still possess. There's a deeper issue though, one related to the notion that comedy is a young person's game. Decrepitude acts against spontaneity and surprise, two of the comedian's greatest weapons. In a live show, we expect those things, but if Cleese's statement is anything to go by, there won't be much of either on offer. There's mileage in their geriatric status- references to Tweeting and twerking have been promised- but there's also a strong chance that fans, expecting the Python they remember, will instead be treated to a bunch of shuffling geriatrics struggling to remember their lines. Which could be hilarious in itself, but hardly for the right reasons.
1. They're Only In It For The Money
For many years Python was a decent money-spinner for the group, through VHS then DVD re-issues. It seems, however, that the dead parrot had been comprehensively flogged- promoting the reunion, Michael Palin admitted that 'Python wasn't earning very much'. Which means that the chief motivator for the shows is profit. The group has always assiduously merchandised their work, and they've even been upfront about it, calling one of their records 'The Final Rip-Off'. But with an event like this, it would have been nice if it had been about something more than the need to pay off mortgages and debts. Maybe, say, a celebration of the 45th anniversary of a cultural landmark, or even a reward to the fans who kept the flame alive over the years. As is, the reunion is likely to be no more essential than those VHS and DVD reissues- a hodgepodge of familiar sketches, augmented for reasons of age or death- only vastly more expensive. Of course, this is all guesswork. They might end up pulling off a triumph. It could, after all, be their last chance. As of the present date, however, it's accountancy that makes the world go round, and that doesn't bode well for July.
But!
There are reasons to be doubtful of the reunion, but the fact is this will probably be the last time the Pythons perform together. Even if it is a cash grab and even if they're all well past their prime, there's bound to be a little magic. Their best sketches are exquisitely structured and have survived repetition by legions of Python nerds. Even if Messrs Cleese, Idle, Palin, Gilliam and Jones can have completely forgotten how to wring laughs from those prized set-ups, then...it doesn't matter. In the end, it might be the fans who make these shows, doing what they do best- quoting lines at each other, dressing up as Gumbys and generally making fools of themselves. What does matter is remembering why Python caused all this fuss in the first place. A whole generation has grown up with no significant exposure to Spiny Norman, Dennis Moore, a man with a tape recorder up his nose and gorn. By thrusting their surreal world back into the spotlight, the reunion has already succeeded, reminding us all that they were excrementally runny in the first place. Sorry, I meant exceptionally funny.